r/DMAcademy • • 4d ago

Mega Player Problem Megathread

2 Upvotes

This thread is for DMs who have an out-of-game problem with a PLAYER (not a CHARACTER) to ask for help and opinions. Any player-related issues are welcome to be discussed, but do remember that we're DMs, not counselors.

Off-topic comments including rules questions and player character questions do not go here and will be removed. This is not a place for players to ask questions.


r/DMAcademy • • 4d ago

"First Time DM" and Short Questions Megathread

19 Upvotes

Most of the posts at DMA are discussions of some issue within the context of a person's campaign or DMing more generally. But, sometimes a DM has a question that is very small and doesn't really require an extensive discussion so much as it requires one good answer. In other cases, the question has been asked so many times that having the sub rehash the discussion over and over is not very useful for subscribers. Sometimes the answer to a short question is very long or the answer is also short but very important.

Short questions can look like this:

  • Where do you find good maps?
  • Can multi-classed Warlocks use Warlock slots for non-Warlock spells?
  • Help - how do I prep a one-shot for tomorrow!?
  • First time DM, any tips?

Many short questions (and especially First Time DM inquiries) can be answered with a quick browse through the DMAcademy wiki, which has an extensive list of resources as well as some tips for new DMs to get started.


r/DMAcademy • • 5h ago

Need Advice: Other Character secret

33 Upvotes

Im starting a new campaign soon, the players are going to be playing as pirates, hunting treasures and travelling from island to island.

I asked all of my players to send me their character backstory as well as a character secret. I have a lot of new Players and one of them told me that their character cant swim and he's really ashamed of it. I'm not sure if that is a good idea in this pirate themed campaign, because obviously they will be on a boat most of the time. On the other hand I don't wanna be like "Ahm actually that won't work" because he was really proud of his idea and also i think it could lead to some funny moments. It would have to be a secret that gets revealed really early on in the campaign, but if he's fine with it i don't think thats a problem.

Also, if I allow it, i'm not really sure about the rules - how does it work if the character wants to learn how to swim? how about drowning?


r/DMAcademy • • 4h ago

Need Advice: Other How Would You Define a Dungeon?

12 Upvotes

Hi y'all,

I'm having a Session 0 this weekend with two brand new players, and another player who has only played three or four sessions of LMOP and doesn't want to play it again (sigh).

I've done a lot of research on campaigns and I've picked some collections (for the commitaphobe in the group) and some overarching stories I think I can run. I'm going to give a little rundown of each and let the players collectively choose which sounds right for them before we start character creation.

The main points I want to hit for each are:

- Dungeons, Dragons or both

- Roleplay heavy, Combat based, or a mixture

- Short or long campaign

- Sandbox or linear

The Dragon part is easy: you fight a Dragon; but how would you describe a dungeon? I was thinking something along the lines of combat, puzzles, traps, and enemies, but that feels incomplete.

TLDR: How would you define a dungeon for brand new players?

Thanks!


r/DMAcademy • • 5h ago

Need Advice: Rules & Mechanics Quest Rewards

5 Upvotes

Hey y’all, ever have a sticky finger rogue that’s always trying to steal things from quest givers? I need some ideas of why my quest givers do not have the loot on them at that moment and how they can give it to them. I’d say a safe in a house somewhere but knowing my two rogue players, they’ll just wanna find the house instead of doing the quest which just leads to weird and troublesome issues in my games despite me cracking down on it.

Any thoughts?


r/DMAcademy • • 7h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Is my Archmage encounter too swingy for 5th level players?

5 Upvotes

I wrote a final encounter for a one-shot I’ve run for family twice designed for 5th level players and I’d like to be able to run it more but I’m unsure now if the fight should be better balanced based on things I’ve learned and if so how, welcoming suggestions while making the plot still work!

The Archmage is using 3 weather crystals (30hp each) and his 8th level spell slot for control weather to change the local environment and freeze it. He wishes to raise a dragon and has hatched 1-3 eggs depending on how quickly the party get there. He will fight and attempt to kill the party, protect the dragons and flee with at least one only if he is close to death or the party destroys the weather crystals. If all dragons die, he will also flee. The white dragon wyrmlings are weak with 15hp and will only attack if they are attacked.

Spell list and slots:

3 1st level: mage armor, magic missile, shield

3 2nd level: mirror image, misty step

3 3rd level: counterspell, lightning bolt, fly

2 4th level left (uses hallucinatory terrain to hide cave) stoneskin, fire shield

1 5th level: cone of cold

1 6th level: globe of invulnerability

1 7th level (reserved to teleport out)

0 8th level (spent on control weather)

1 9th level (reserved for time stop to escape)

If he hears the party approach he initiates battle with a cone of cold to hit everyone as they come through an entrance. The players may have attained things that grant advantage on the save or resistance to cold so probably won’t all go down but this is where I know it can be swingy depending on rolls and then afterwards I’ve generally heard players have the advantage because of action economy but I’m hoping it can still be a fun fight if the mage plays defensively with their spell options.


r/DMAcademy • • 14h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures My players just gave a Thayan Necromancer an Amulet of the Planes

15 Upvotes

So during a recent encounter with a Red Wizard necromancer, my players traded an amulet of the planes that they'd stolen from a druid in exchange for the wizard looking into a way to break a curse that was places on a friend of the party.

I intend for the wizard to keep her promise, it's the fun of lawful evil characters, but I still want this decision to come back to bite the PCs in some way. What are some cool planar shenanigans she could get up to?


r/DMAcademy • • 2m ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures One shot for bros

• Upvotes

A group of friends have shown interest in playing DnD and they wanted to try a one shot, they are your typical meat head, ex American football players, beer drinking bros.
So I’m looking for something fun with action and opportunity for some ridiculous role play (they were already joking about “seducing” the bad guy).


r/DMAcademy • • 4h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Absent player: seeking advice for running a "filler" session

2 Upvotes

As the title suggests, one player has bailed the day before our scheduled session. They play the party’s cleric; the other three players are a rogue, a barbarian, and a monk. They are a level 1 party playing in the Forgotten Realms—specifically, in the forest of Cormanthor, along the Moonsea Ride.

The main quest involves investigating a missing caravan. In the original plan, they might have reached the site of the disappearance during this session, but given the circumstances, I’ve decided to run a "filler" session instead—one that I can use to drop a few subtle hints about themes that will appear later on.

The session will last about 3 hours. I’d love to hear any ideas you might have! In the meantime, here’s the outline I’m leaning toward:

On the road, the party encounters an elderly man in tattered clothing, covered in fresh wounds. He begs for help to rescue his daughter, who has been kidnapped by—well, I still need to choose enemies suitable for a 3-character, level 1 party. Since the absent player’s character is a cleric with proficiency in Medicine, I’ll have that character stay behind to tend to the wounded man, while the others head off to rescue the girl.

As for the reward, I’m thinking of rolling on the random treasure tables in the DMG to determine what the players will earn from this short adventure.

P.S. The main plot involves a band of orcs that has been hijacking caravans in the Cormanthor forest using Thayan magic items. The area also features drow, Cult of the Dragon members near the ruins of Myth Drannor, and a rival orc tribe that despises the group currently hijacking the caravans.


r/DMAcademy • • 1h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Need help with multi-classed players

• Upvotes

Hi all,

So I recently had a situation where a multiclass warlock/bard was trying to grab a young dragon that was polymorphed. He didnt have enough movement to get to it without dashing so he sent his pixie ahead 15 feet, used one of his attacks to have the pixie grab the dragon that was now a frog, then had it come 15 feet back to drop it in his bag of holding. His argument is that the pixie used its reaction to grapple the frog, then its regular action to drop it in the bag. This feels a little hinky so wanted to run it by other DMs.

Id also love advice on how to deal with a player that can use polymorph and has a familiar ready to run in and essentially one shot any creature before anyone else can react.

EDIT: I should clarify that the player has pact of the chain which allows his familliar to use its reaction as an attack.


r/DMAcademy • • 20h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Should i have foreshadowed that the party made the worst decision?

28 Upvotes

So the party (3 people, an elementalist beastmaster, demonologist and dreamwalker) had been spending a few months in a Farmstead (is more like a farmer settlement rather than a farmstead with one family). In those months they discovered a plot of shapeshifters and found multiple inhabitants that were possessed by demons. They saved the village, made connections, developed survival and economic skills.

And then a demon invasion started to the far north of the village, and the team had three clear options; Go north and help a god fend of the invasion, Go west and help protect the villagers that are fleeing towards the nearest walled settlements. Or go east and dip.

Because they chose to go north and help the Goddess fend of the invasion (which was a week's journey) they arrive to find the Goddess having an easy time not letting demons pass through a portal. And the goddess asks them what they do there, they were asked to protect the villagers. Their reasoning was; we can protect the villagers if we avoid the demons from reaching the village. Only for them to be send back, and find that the fleeing villagers were captured and used for a ritual to open another demon gate. They pretty much find the entire town slaughtered.

Now, the moment itself was very impactful. But afterwards, they told me i didn't give enough hints about them making a wrong decision. Even though i dropped hints of another ritual being prepared all over the town, they just didn't connect the dots.

should i have given more hints? Should i have nudged them a little bit? Should I have laid out the results of their choices more clearly?

don't get me wrong, they enjoy the campaign, and they kept playing and even told me that it was the first time there were real stakes, and started playing more carefully. But the gnawing feeling that i should have told them a little bit more sticks with me.

edit: after reading some reactions it seems clear i wasn't clear about something; I re-read my post now and was unclear in one thing; the goddess had already said "she got it" and already send a messenger. They decided they would go north because they couldn't contact her anymore (as she was in continuous battle).

They had seen her in battle before, and even though they witnessed something awe-inspiring, they were told that she was holding back so they wouldn't get hurt in her defense. I thought i had set it up pretty clearly that even though she was a physical being, she deserved the title of Goddess.

second edit: The main opponent of the campaign is a group of shapeshifters, so i would think that paying attention to the acting of the DM would be important, as that is how i give the hints without making it too obvious.


r/DMAcademy • • 3h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Need recs a good high-level dungeon

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone! My players have decided they want to get a secret audience with the king and have snuck into a dungeon beneath the castle to fight and sneak their way up. The king is being manipulated by a society of evil wizards (of course) so there could be all kinds of nasty stuff up in there.

The party is all level 9 and very inventive and haven’t been tested in a fight in a while, so I’d love to give them a good classic dungeon with traps and monsters, maybe a puzzle or two, that I can modify to fit. Thanks in advance for any suggestions. I was planning on writing something myself but between the kids and work my free time is slim.


r/DMAcademy • • 17h ago

Need Advice: Rules & Mechanics A spell that can create coal.

10 Upvotes

Hi, I’m going to be running my first one shot and wanted it to be themed on a runaway steam train. The engine would run with water and coal for fuel and obviously we have the create water spell to explain for constantly producing water. But I’m stuck on the coal, as I can’t imagine something like fabricate or creation spells to be able to continuously produce it.

If anyone has any suggestions that would be appreciated!

EDIT - Sorry probably should’ve added this in the OG post, the overproduction of coal is the reason the train goes haywire and starts going too fast (think Speed the Movie) and eventually I want to have the final boss of the one shot to be a monster formed of this coal at the engine of the train. I have the idea set down for the campaign but scratching my head over a spell - if not might have to homebrew


r/DMAcademy • • 21h ago

Need Advice: Worldbuilding At what point am I imposing my will on my players?

17 Upvotes

Hey everyone! First time DM here! (Actually first time DnD player at all) I had a question for the more experienced out there.

Some backstory, a small group of friends and I discussed interest in getting into DnD even though none of us have played before. Me being the most knowledgeable of the game (I went through a big DnD phase during COVID, just didn’t have the friends to play it with) I agreed to DM our first campaign. Here’s my issue: our campaign doesn’t start for a month or so to give me some prep time, I plan on trying to get them to make their characters sooner rather than later. However, I’ve already have a good idea for the general story. They’ll be starting off in a town that’s mostly human/halfing with small percentages of dwarves/elves/etc. But now that I’m thinking about it, there are some choices they could make during character creation that wouldn’t work with my story. For example, say they all decided they wanted to play Dragonborn. In my story, most of the Dragonborn have been called to their homeland due to a civil war, and having a group of them in this human settlement just wouldn’t make sense. I could work in one Dragonborn, maybe even two. But then I’m A: Imposing my wants onto their characters backgrounds B: Basically telling the party that only a couple of them get to play the race they want.

My main concern is player freedom and them having a good time. But I also don’t want to have to completely rework the story if they make choices during character creation thag don’t complement it. I don’t think there are many choices they could make that would affect my story in such a way, but based off the horror stories I’ve heard from other DMs I wouldn’t be shocked if they manage to make said choices. Sorry for the rant I guess I’m just not sure if it’s appropriate for me to ask my players if we could workshop their backstories together if need be. Am I already wrong for having a story prepped out without knowing their characters? Expert DMs please help me.


r/DMAcademy • • 13h ago

Need Advice: Worldbuilding What are some unique NPCs and locations that a party might find in a city that is the industrial and military center of a region that wouldn’t be found in the cultural capital?

3 Upvotes

My world has two major cities on this continent, and I want to differentiate them in meaningful ways for the party, so aside from the obviously military-related politics institutions, what might one find in that type of city?


r/DMAcademy • • 8h ago

Need Advice: Worldbuilding How Much Do I Reveal?

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I wanted to get advice on how I should handle the reveal of my bbeg for my homebrew campaign. To make a long story short the party has been investigating and thwarting the plans of a shadowy organization that is attempting to overthrow the guild they are members of. So far I've kept the leader of the organization a mystery only calling him "the director" but intend to reveal him in the distant future. His identity will be a huge twist in of itself, but I also am including a twist that he is the father of one of the PCs(per their backstory). When he is revealed, do I reveal the familial connection in the first encounter or save it for later so I can let that moment breathe? Either option would work for me I'm just not sure which would be the most cohesive.


r/DMAcademy • • 17h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Players unable to (easily) communicate to npc, need some ideas to fix this situation

3 Upvotes

My players befriended a spider, this spider will become important later down the road, my issue is that only one of the players have speak with animals as spell and he out of character has told me he is planning on using it every time they encounter the spider. I don't really want him to burn a spell slot every single time, but I also don't really know how to make it so he doesn't have to. I do want them to keep being friends with the spider and everything cuz I am planning on having it betray them later on. We are currently playing a bunch of oneshots and will start lost mines of padelver in a few weeks, I wanted to connected the random oneshots with the campaign, which is why I introduced the spider to them.

Does anyone have any ideas on how to go about this situation?

ETA: I got adviced against having the spider itself betray them and rather have the bad guy switching the spider to avoid having players never trusting npc's again and I will be making it into a being switched scenario


r/DMAcademy • • 1d ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures What's the final moment of your campaign?

22 Upvotes

I'm about to have the last session of a 2-year campaign, and I'm wondering what the final moment should be.

As I currently have it planned, after the party defeats the BBEG, they celebrate with their friends, then the Queen gives each of them a reward from a grateful kingdom.

And then I'm not sure what to do. It seems pretty anticlimactic to have the Queen give out the last individual reward, and then I say, "Okay, that's it. Campaign's over."

I feel like I need some final button, scene, or moment to be the ultimate conclusion of the campaign.

What are some final moments you've used at the end of a campaign that you thought worked well?


r/DMAcademy • • 12h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Glyph of warding, suggestion, and magic mouth?

1 Upvotes

Hi all. I'm trying to figure out an obstacle for my party and wonder about rules interactions with these spells.

If someone casts glyph of warding, and uses it to cast the spell suggestion, they would be unable to suggest actions without being present to be heard and understood. Would magic mouth be a possible work around for that? If they set up magic mouth to go off when the glyph is triggered?

Thanks.


r/DMAcademy • • 20h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Skull Lord

4 Upvotes

I have a 5.5 WotC adventure I’m running on Friday that features two death knights. Instead, I plan to swap one out for a skull lord for some variety. The party will have 5-6 level 13 pcs. The skull lord will have 6 flaming skeleton friends.

Do you have thoughts on the Skull Lord? I have the Monsters of the Multiverse version, which seems 5.5 adjacent, but would you change it in any way? Am I correct that there is no 5.5 version of this monster? Should I upgrade the quality of the undead it summons to account for the CR downgrade from the death knight? Any other advice?

I’ve read the The Monsters Know What They’re Doing entry, but it seems like it’s for an obsolete stat block. Still, the general strategy seems sound.


r/DMAcademy • • 1d ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Are ”an innumerable amount of rats” a threat to a party of lvl 10’s?

160 Upvotes

Like the title says, I’m reworking an old one shot I had for a much lower leveled party where rats are the main theme. However now I’m struggling to see how any amount of rats really pose a risk to a party of level tens. How can I keep the rats while making them enough of a threat that the party would likely try to avoid them?


r/DMAcademy • • 14h ago

Need Advice: Rules & Mechanics Question regarding trade goods in the DMG (5.5e)

1 Upvotes

The 2024 DMG lists a bunch of items to be used as rewards instead of just money, saying that the party can sell these items for their respective value. For example, 1 pound of ginger is worth 1 GP, and 1 square yard of cotton cloth is worth 5 SP.

But the PHB says that items can be sold for half their value in GP (round down). So, what is the ruling on the price of trade goods?

If 1 pound of ginger is worth 1 GP, then selling that pound of ginger should only yield 5 SP, since you can only sell items for half their value. But if the selling price of ginger is 1 GP, then that means buying ginger costs 2 GP.

Which is it?


r/DMAcademy • • 1d ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Help Building A Monster - A Shambling Corpse That Gets Stronger

4 Upvotes

For an upcoming encounter, I had a particular idea. Essentially, imagine a corpse reanimated by a dark god, its body held together by a massive tangle of writhing metal wires. When the corpse is damaged, the body breaks apart, and the metal wires burst out, attacking folks around it, on top of what the corpse still attempts to do.

I want a monster like this to attack my party, which's a group of six level 8s. I'm not against giving this monster backup to help it defeat the party, since it'd otherwise be 1 against 6. For backup, ideally I'd want them to invoke ideas of body horror.

Any suggestions on how to build this creature?


r/DMAcademy • • 1d ago

Need Advice: Other Feels like i have a hard time "Keeping Focused" as a DM

15 Upvotes

I know its sacrilege to say this but one thing I really envy about live play DMs is their ability to maintain focus and well.. let scenes play out with poking their nose in it.

I often feel like when I DM I lose focus of the core timeline, and too easily throw away the game flow for a joke.

Such as leaving character as a NPC to join in a joke the player said, or speak above the table. It's often in excitement and joy but I cant help to feel the game would run smoother and MUCH more consistently if I could keep focus on the scenes and maintain better NPC consistency across sessions...

I dont want my party to feel like a person they met a week ago suddenly changed drastically the next session because me as the DM struggles to recapture that NPC


r/DMAcademy • • 1d ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Advice on what to use as a set piece?

5 Upvotes

Hey y'all, I'm prepping for my party to eventually find and raid the evil cult who is hiding in a secret part of the withering wood. I have loose ideas, but what I'm lost on is inspiration or what the hideout of the evil cult even is.

Some bits of context first. The evil cult escaped from what was basically an elf Aztec empire that worshipped the sun, and after a big civil war the cult was led by a fanatic of the princess who wanted to be as radiant as she was (princess was secretly a demigod). They fled using tunnels that spanned across the ocean and into a foreign land, finding themselves in a deep part of the withering wood. The withering wood is a forest that is constantly in a state of decay, but is abundant in spirits who are invisible to the naked eye. The cult has a magic ritual dagger that when used to carve a creature's heart out of their body, can grant the consumer a trait or ability of the original creature. There's more to this but it's not necessary.

The ideas I want there are that the cult leader is some form of chimera who had quite a few hearts, and acts as the final boss and there would be some sort of menagerie or prison for creatures they've captured and plan on eventually sacrificing.

I had a thought of a wooden pyramid, but I'm not really sure how practical that would be for a dungeon/hideout. What are other things I could do, and what's the best?