Hi everyone!
I’m a teacher at an international elementary school in South Korea, where I teach debate to third-grade students who are English-language learners.
I want to mention upfront that I have no formal background or experience in debate myself. I was unexpectedly assigned to teach it, so I’ve essentially been learning as I go, researching, developing the curriculum, and trying my best to teach my students something I’m still learning myself.
My students just completed their second debate ever, on the topic of whether fast-food restaurants should stop giving plastic toys with children’s meals.
It was a challenging topic for their age, and several students missed quite a few lessons throughout the unit. Considering all of that, I was genuinely proud of how they performed.
However, I received some feedback suggesting that their delivery was weak and that their overall performance wasn’t as strong as our first graders’ debate. For context, I did not teach the first-grade students. They have a different teacher, so the two groups were not taught by the same person.
I’m hoping to get an unbiased opinion from people who have experience with competitive debate, coaching, or judging.
I’d especially appreciate feedback on what would be reasonable to expect from third-grade English-language learners participating in only their second debate.
I also have a recording of a first-grade debate that I’d love to have evaluated for comparison, keeping in mind the students’ different ages, topics, and experience levels.
I’m not looking for anyone to tell me my students were amazing just to make me feel better. I genuinely want constructive, honest feedback so I can improve how I teach debate and better support my students.
Would anyone with debate experience be willing to help? I can discuss sharing the recordings privately. Thank you so much!