1. The Fundamental Ethical Problem
Eternal conscious torment (ECT) presents a fundamental ethical problem when considered in relation to an all-loving, omnipotent, and omniscient creator.
Preventing unnecessary suffering is central to ethics. While certain forms of suffering may be justified through their potential contribution to greater goods, eternal torment offers no possibility of eventual healing, restoration, growth, or flourishing for the individual. It therefore stands in direct conflict with fundamental values such as compassion, love, joy, peace, and flourishing.
Appeals to concepts such as justice, retribution, or divine authority do not independently resolve this problem. These concepts require ethical reasoning and justification.
2. The Free Will Defence
2.1 The Creator's Responsibility
An all-powerful creator is responsible for the conditions of the reality they create, including:
- The nature and dispositions of individuals.
- The circumstances in which their agency operates.
- The possibilities and limitations of the created reality.
- The consequences arising from the interaction between these factors.
Free will does not remove this responsibility. Choices emerge from an individual's nature and the conditions within which they exercise agency. These factors are not independent of the creator's design.
Consequently, appealing to free will does not establish why an all-loving creator would permit a reality in which individuals can ultimately experience eternal torment.
2.2 Meaningful Freedom Does Not Require Destructive Possibilities
The free will defence often assumes that meaningful agency requires unrestricted access to destructive possibilities. However, this assumption requires independent justification.
Choice is not unconditionally valuable, and unrestricted possibility is not a prerequisite for meaningful freedom.
Limiting destructive possibilities does not necessarily compromise meaningful agency, just as establishing the conditions for love does not constitute forcing someone to reciprocate it.
The burden is therefore on the defender of ECT to demonstrate precisely what meaningful value would be lost by preventing eternally destructive outcomes.
3. An Alternative Conception of Reality: Flourishing as Its Foundation
Consider an alternative conception of reality fundamentally constituted by flourishing.
Under this framework, individuals retain meaningful agency, but the possibilities available to them are consistent with the foundational principles of reality. This does not require choices to be predetermined, but rather that agency operates through a nature aligned with flourishing.
Heaven would represent the fulfilment of value in reality design.
3.1 Restrictions and Constitution Are Not Coercion
Every reality has constitutive features that determine the capacities, limitations, and nature of its inhabitants. The existence of such properties does not, by itself, constitute coercion.
A reality in which destructive possibilities are restricted preserves meaningful agency, or fulfills it as "meaningful" relates to value principles. The distinction is between forcing individuals to make particular choices and creating a reality whose conditions are fundamentally compatible with flourishing.
3.2 Secondary Theological Framework: Communion With God as intrinsic
Although this is not a regular implication, a secondary theological possibility is to understand communion with God as the necessary condition for ultimate flourishing.
If individuals are created for communion with God, the distinction between God's nature and the deepest nature of the soul need not be absolute. God could instead be understood as the ontological foundation of reality and existence.
Under this conception, alignment with the divine need not constitute submission to an entirely external authority, but rather the fulfilment of agency within a reality fundamentally grounded in flourishing.
Another further consideration is that creation exists by, and for its source, with souls as individuations of that source.
4. The Burden of Ethical Justification
Regardless of which theological framework is adopted, an important ethical question remains:
What meaningful value would be lost by creating a reality in which everyone ultimately flourishes?
To justify ECT, its proponents would need to demonstrate:
- Precisely what meaningful value is lost by preventing eternal destructive outcomes.
- Why that value outweighs the fundamental goods of love, compassion, peace, and flourishing.
- Why eternal suffering would be necessary to preserve that value.
- Why no alternative reality could preserve that value without requiring eternal suffering or annihilation.
Simply asserting that unrestricted freedom is valuable does not establish that the possibility of eternal destruction is necessary for meaningful agency.
The possibility of creating a reality that preserves meaningful freedom without eternal torment challenges the assumption that ECT is necessary.
5. Goodness, Justice, and Divine Authority
Defining God as good within a particular theological value system does not independently establish that God is ethically good.
Goodness is evaluated within a value system, but that system itself must be examined for its coherence with fundamental ethical principles.
Similarly, appealing to retribution or divine justice does not resolve the problem unless the underlying principles can be ethically justified.
The question is not simply whether ECT can be classified as just within a particular theological framework, but whether that conception of justice can be defended through coherent ethical reasoning.
As expressed in A Walk in the Physical:
The true justice is that all are loved and accepted, and that all are healed. Only the ego wishes less than that for someone else.
6. CCEA
I propose CCEA (Coherent Central Ethics Approximation) as a framework for intersubjective ethical evaluation.
The framework consists of three components:
- Coherent: Ethical principles should be mutually compatible, and internally consistent, with centrality dictating the compatibility.
- Central Ethics: Principles central to intersubjective value judgement.
- Approximation: Ethical evaluation is a matter of degree.
I am not claiming that CCEA possesses ultimate moral jurisdiction or that everyone must adopt it. Rather, it provides a framework for examining ethical claims, identifying inconsistencies, and encouraging discernment.
7. Applying CCEA to Eternal Torment
The absence of a sufficient ethical justification is particularly significant when considering an all-loving creator with the capacity to establish alternative conditions of existence.
Within this framework, certain disvalues may be justified under particular circumstances. However, ECT is not justified within the central ethical standpoint because its consequences are fundamentally incompatible with the values of compassion, love, and flourishing.
I consider CCEA a useful framework for evaluating the ethics of hell intersubjectively, while remaining open to refinement and further discussion.