r/DebateReligion • • 2d ago

Meta Meta-Thread 11/16

3 Upvotes

This is a weekly thread for feedback on the new rules and general state of the sub.

What are your thoughts? How are we doing? What's working? What isn't?

Let us know.

And a friendly reminder to report bad content.

If you see something, say something.

This thread is posted every Monday. You may also be interested in our weekly Simple Questions thread (posted every Wednesday) or General Discussion thread (posted every Friday).


r/DebateReligion • • 20h ago

Simple Questions 11/18

1 Upvotes

Have you ever wondered what Christians believe about the Trinity? Are you curious about Judaism and the Talmud but don't know who to ask? Everything from the Cosmological argument to the Koran can be asked here.

This is not a debate thread. You can discuss answers or questions but debate is not the goal. Ask a question, get an answer, and discuss that answer. That is all.

The goal is to increase our collective knowledge and help those seeking answers but not debate. If you want to debate; Start a new thread.

The subreddit rules are still in effect.

This thread is posted every Wednesday. You may also be interested in our weekly Meta-Thread (posted every Monday) or General Discussion thread (posted every Friday).


r/DebateReligion • • 8h ago

Islam Allah Gave Muhammad the Sexual Stamina of 30 Men

44 Upvotes

Allah gave Muhammad the sexual stamina of 30 men, allowing him to sleep with all nine wives in one night.

Out of all the supernatural powers Allah could have given humanity’s final prophet, he chose to give him a legendary bedroom performance.

Forget changing the world. Apparently the priority was changing the bedsheets.

“The Prophet (ﷺ) used to pass by (have sexual relation with) all his wives in one night, and at that time he had nine wives.”

Sahih al-Bukhari 5215

“Anas bin Malik said, "The Prophet (ﷺ) used to visit all his wives in a round, during the day and night and they were eleven in number." I asked Anas, "Had the Prophet (ﷺ) the strength for it?" Anas replied, "We used to say that the Prophet (ﷺ) was given the strength of thirty (men)." And Sa`id said on the authority of Qatada that Anas had told him about nine wives only (not eleven).”

Sahih al-Bukhari 268

Was divine intervention really just a supernatural Viagra subscription?


r/DebateReligion • • 12h ago

Other To have faith in a religion, you don’t necessarily have faith in any specific evidence. You have faith in complete strangers’ interpretations of what they believed was evidence.

42 Upvotes

It’s a simple fact that no one alive can personally attest to the individual character, motivations, or intellectual capabilities of the people who recorded major works of scripture. We have no way of knowing whether these individuals were capable of accurately identifying, evaluating, interpreting, or recording the evidence they used as the basis for their writings.

We have no direct knowledge of the actual nature of the events or interactions that these scriptures were based on, because we cannot independently observe, examine, or test the original evidence for ourselves.

Ultimately, the people responsible for religious theology, scripture, and tradition are complete strangers to us. Their original evidence is inaccessible, and their interpretations cannot be independently verified by anyone alive today.

So, what we are ultimately placing our faith in isn't the original evidence itself, but the reliability, competence, and honesty of people we don’t know and have no way of personally evaluating.


r/DebateReligion • • 1h ago

Christianity Even if Jesus rose from the dead, the resurrection can’t interpret itself

• Upvotes

So I’m setting aside whether the resurrection actually happened, but for the sake of argument, let’s fully grant it: Jesus was crucified and genuinely rose from the dead, and his followers encountered him alive afterwards.

My question is what we can reasonably conclude from that event alone.

It seems to me there’s a ladder of claims here, and each one needs its own justification. I’ve ordered them roughly by how much additional interpretation each requires, though that ordering is a judgment call:

  1. God acted in history
  2. God vindicated Jesus
  3. Jesus is the Messiah
  4. Jesus is divine
  5. His death was an atoning sacrifice
  6. Salvation comes exclusively through him

If the resurrection did happen, we’d have strong reason to think God acted (especially given its Jewish religious context), and I can see how that supports the first few claims. But I don’t see how it automatically establishes the rest. Claims 4 to 6 concern why it happened and what it accomplished, rather than simply whether it happened. Even if we accept that God raised Jesus, how do we establish what God intended by it?

The strongest Christian response, as I understand it:

Christians generally don’t argue “resurrection, therefore Trinity.” The argument is that the resurrection is God’s endorsement of Jesus’ own claims: that he had the authority to forgive sins, described his death as a ransom and predicted his own vindication.

On this view, the meaning wasn’t simply imposed later by Paul or the early Church. It was already present in Jesus’ own teachings, and the resurrection confirmed it. N.T. Wright makes a version of this argument.

I think that’s a reasonable response, but it raises another question:

How confidently can we establish what Jesus actually claimed about himself?

The Gospels were written by followers of the early Christian movement, decades after the events they describe. That doesn’t make them unreliable, and scholars do have criteria for sifting authentic material, such as embarrassment and dissimilarity. But we’re still relying on sources shaped by the very theological interpretations we’re trying to evaluate.

If we use those accounts to figure out what Jesus claimed and then use those claims to explain what the resurrection meant, how do we distinguish Jesus’ original teachings from the interpretations of his followers? And are the criteria strong enough to carry that much weight?

This is where I suspect the real disagreement lies so I’d be especially interested in the best case for reliability here.

The Jewish context is also interesting. Second Temple Judaism already had beliefs about resurrection, though they weren’t uniform. The more familiar expectation was a general resurrection associated with God’s final restoration of the world. An individual being raised ahead of that general resurrection wasn’t the usual expectation. The earliest Christians therefore had to explain how Jesus’ resurrection fitted into their existing beliefs. Paul’s description of Jesus as the “first fruits” in 1 Corinthians 15 seems to be part of that explanation.

So while the Jewish context helps us understand why the resurrection was interpreted in certain ways, it also suggests that its theological meaning was being worked out by the earliest Christians.

There are two objections I want to anticipate:

“If we grant the resurrection, doesn’t that make theism and divine revelation considerably more likely?”

Cool, but even if we accept divine intervention, that doesn’t establish incarnation, atonement or salvation exclusively through Jesus. Those are additional claims that still need to be justified.

“High Christology developed very early. It wasn’t something invented centuries later.”

Sure thing. Paul’s letters already contain remarkably developed beliefs about Jesus, and Philippians 2 is widely thought to preserve an even earlier, pre-Pauline tradition.

I’m not claiming that belief in Jesus’ divinity gradually appeared centuries after his death nor if Paul simply invented it. But being early doesn’t make an interpretation correct. Neither does being widespread or accepted by the apostles. Those things may give us reasons to take an interpretation seriously, but they don’t establish its truth. And I’d apply that same standard to sceptical interpretations.

So where does that leave us? I don’t think any of this demonstrates that Christianity is false. My point is that the resurrection, even if established beyond reasonable doubt, wouldn’t by itself establish the theological framework built around it. Indeed, Christianity itself has never settled on a single explanation of how the atonement works. That alone suggests the significance of Jesus’ death isn’t as straightforward as the event itself. The resurrection may be necessary to Christianity’s central claims, but I don’t think it’s sufficient to establish all of them.

So I ask:

Even if we grant that Jesus genuinely rose from the dead, what establishes that Christianity’s explanation of why he rose is correct?

And how do we distinguish between what the resurrection actually demonstrates and what its earliest followers believed it meant?


r/DebateReligion • • 3h ago

Abrahamic Yahweh and Baal Hadad could be the same entity

5 Upvotes

Not theological evolution or merging of deities, but rather a single, real metaphysical being known in two distinct ways.

True, there is the account of Elijah on Mount Carmel; however, while “Baal”—par excellence—refers to Hadad, the term “Baal” is simply a title that was applied to many gods. The Bible itself indicates that Yahweh was, at times, referred to as Baal. Consequently, the rival “Baal” might not be Hadad, but someone else entirely.


r/DebateReligion • • 17h ago

Islam Debunking Christianity doesn't make Islam any more true

34 Upvotes

Something I’ve noticed in discussions with some Muslim apologists is the tendency to treat criticism of Christianity as though it somehow strengthens the case for Islam.

I submit:

Demonstrating that Christianity is false does not, by itself, provide evidence that Islam is true.

This is a false dichotomy. Christianity and Islam aren’t the only two possible explanations for religious history. Both could be mistaken or the evidence could support conclusions neither religion fully accommodates. These are two separate claims, each requiring its own justification.

Let’s consider some of the usual arguments. That the Gospels were corrupted. That the Trinity was developed later. That Paul distorted Jesus’ original message. That the crucifixion accounts are unreliable.

Let’s grant all of those arguments for a minute and assume Christianity is completely wrong.

None of those conclusions establishes that Muhammad received divine revelations, or that the Quran originated from God, or that Islam represents the final and correct revelation. Simply disproving one belief doesn’t automatically validate another.

The same logic runs in reverse, of course. A Christian can’t point to problems in Islam and call it a vindication of Christianity. I’m applying one standard to both.

Now, the most serious Muslim response isn’t “Christianity is false, therefore Islam is true.” It’s that the Quran makes specific claims about what Jesus taught and what happened to earlier scriptures, and that if the historical evidence lines up with those claims, that counts as positive evidence. And that’s a fair point in principle: consistency with a hypothesis can raise its probability if the hypothesis predicted the evidence and its rivals didn’t.

But that’s where it falls down. Corruption narratives are cheap and nearly unfalsifiable. Any textual variation, doctrinal development or historical dispute can be filed under “distortion” after the fact. And the same evidence is just as well predicted by ordinary historical development, with no divine involvement at all. A claim that fits everything predicts nothing. Appealing to the Quran to establish that it identified those distortions also simply assumes the very authority that needs to be demonstrated.

There’s another problem, and I think it’s the bigger one.

Islam makes specific claims about Jesus that contradict the earliest Christian traditions, and it makes them roughly 600 years after the events, with no demonstrated independent source. A correction offered that late needs more justification than the texts it claims to correct, not less. Distance in time doesn’t earn a source authority. If anything, it’s the reverse of how we normally weigh historical claims.

So even if we completely remove Christianity from the equation, the central question remains unchanged:

What positive evidence establishes that Islam is divinely revealed, rather than being another religion making claims about divine revelation?


r/DebateReligion • • 11h ago

Islam Humans have no free will, yet you still believe so. Your idea of fate is faulty

9 Upvotes

In the Quran, it is mentioned that god gave people the will to choose (believe or disbelieve for example) and mentioned how this life is just a test. Yet, God also mentions that he wrote the destiny of all creation before creating it and knows the events that will happen throughout time !

So, how can you already know the results of a test and still call it a test ?

Also, if God already wrote what action we’ll take, no matter how “free” it may be to us, we will 100% do those actions and will never deviate from what he has willed. And thus, we’re really just free puppets. Evil men were evil because god wills it and he will punish them for that which is CRUEL.


r/DebateReligion • • 17h ago

Abrahamic God cannot think, decide, or be free.

17 Upvotes

God can't think freely as we do. Neither can He make free decisions like us, because He has no free-will.

He's own nature only allows him to execute what's 'best'. Therefore he lacks total sovereignty over Himself. it’s a being tied by its own attributes.

Omniscience isn’t a superpower, it’s a trap. Because God knows everything He is completely incapable of thinking, making decisions or having any sovereignty over His own actions.

Here is the logical breakdown of why:

  1. Thinking and making choices is for beings who don't know everything.

We think because we lack information. Thinking is a process: you start by not knowing something, you connect the dots and you figure it out.

An omniscient God already has every answer at all times. He can never have an idea, a realization or a thought process because there is nothing left for Him to figure out. His mind is completely frozen in a state of knowing."

  1. You can’t "evaluate". Look at "possible outcomes" if you already know

Some defenders of theism argue: "Gods omniscience is like a compass; He sees all possible outcomes and simply chooses which one to actualize."

This doesn't hold up under scrutiny:

First an omniscient being doesn't need to "look at outcomes" or "weigh options" because He already knows the exact outcome.

Second you cannot genuinely "evaluate" options if you already know what you are going to do. Evaluation requires uncertainty—a period of not knowing which path is best. If you already possess the answer eternally you aren't choosing; you are just executing a fixed script.

  1. Not even sovereign over Himself

Because God knows every choice, He will ever make before He "makes" them He cannot do otherwise. If He could change His mind His previous knowledge would be false (which is impossible for an omniscient being).

This means God has zero freedom or sovereignty over His mind. He is locked into a path forced to follow a future that was already eternally set by His own knowledge.

Conclusion / Question for theists:

If God’s omniscience strips Him of the ability to wonder, evaluate, change His mind or make a choice, isn't He essentially a prisoner of His own attribute?

How can an entity, with zero freedom of thought be considered a sovereign choosing God? He simply isn't.


r/DebateReligion • • 14h ago

Islam Muslims are Paulines, who dont give any credit to him

11 Upvotes

Muslims worship the God of Abraham which was a local and ethnic god of a rather marginal small nation nobody cared about. Yahweh was no Apollo or Marduk.

So this minor god suddenly went through the equivalent of a cosmic inflation in its influence through christianity and by the time islam came about Mediterranean world had forgotten Apollo and Marduk completely

The thing is, before Christianity the worship of Yahweh was limited unless you convert fully by circumcision. But scripture itself was even more limited because Yahweh himself had no interest in the larger gentile world, except to occasionally set them on a course of conquest to punish his own people, his people with whom he had a covenant with.

The covenant means a binding treaty instigated in this case by the stronger party, in this case Yahweh, and is probably the one of its kind in antiquity as a core feature of a theological tradition.

What Paul contributed and was opposed by James is to argue, from scriptures, that God is making a new covenant through the death and resurrection of Christ, and this new covenant is not limited by ethnicity

Therefore now gentiles are God’s people as well, as they are, regardless of circumcision or ancestry. As long as they participate in the salvation by Christ

This removal of ethnic boundaries from Yahweh’s covenant with people is revolutionary for that particular tradition and served as the greatest catalyst in its worldwide adoption

Now when islam came about, it was already a world where Christianity had made it normal that being one of God’s people required faith and ethnicity or circumcised wasnt part of the equation

So islam takes that as a given and operates on that ground, carving up its own territory and competing with Christianity for the souls of men.

All the while not a single reference to Paul, what he accomplished, and what even covenants even are in the history of biblical theology.

Because Paul was so successful in his revolution that it all became normal and faded in the background, people taking them for granted without noticing it.

So a major world religion born in that matrix, took full advantage of the conceptual space it provided, and yet paid not a single credit to its brilliant creator, Paul. And today its followers are speaking ill of the greatest theologian of all time.


r/DebateReligion • • 1d ago

Christianity The Bible is more explicit in condemning homosexuality than it is slavery

59 Upvotes

The Bible explicitly calls homosexuality an abomination and prescribes the death penalty for same-sex acts (Leviticus 18:22 and 20:13). Yet the same Bible contains laws regulating slavery, permits the ownership of foreign slaves as property, and provides instructions for taking women captive during war.

Why is there such an explicit and severe condemnation of homosexuality, but no comparable blanket prohibition against owning another human being? Can anyone point me to a verse where God explicitly calls owning another human being or taking a woman captive for sexual purposes an “abomination”, the way that Leviticus 18:22 describes male same-sex intercourse?


r/DebateReligion • • 16h ago

Abrahamic If evolution is continuous, the moment God assigned the "first soul" had to be entirely arbitrary

6 Upvotes

The evolutionary question about the soul really boils down to where God would draw a clear line. When you try to combine evolution with traditional religious beliefs, you run into a big problem. Theology doesn't just struggle to answer this - it can’t find a logical answer within its own rules.

The main issue is the idea of the first human, like a hypothetical Adam. Scientifically, humans didn’t suddenly appear. Evolution is a slow, continuous process over millions of years. From ancient primates to modern humans, it’s a seamless chain where each generation differs only slightly from the last. There is no sharp moment when an animal suddenly became a human.

But Abrahamic religions see this in black and white. It’s like a switch that’s either on or off. You either have an immortal soul or you don’t. You are either morally responsible for your actions or you’re just an animal driven by instinct. After death, you either go to heaven or hell, or you cease to exist. There’s no in-between where you’re partway a soul or only partly judged.

This creates a logical deadlock. Evolution is a smooth spectrum, but divine judgment needs a clear division between “human” and “animal.” So when exactly did God make that cut?

Say we pick a random day 230,423 years ago. That’s the day a creature becomes the first true human. God gives this individual an immortal soul, reason, and eternal moral responsibility. But what about the parents or siblings born just a few years earlier? Biologically and mentally, they’re almost identical. They feel pain, care for their kids, and fear the dark just like the “first human.” Yet according to this logic, the parents remain soulless animals who simply stop existing after death, while their child suddenly becomes responsible for eternity.

Why would that cosmic line happen exactly then? Why not a year later or a thousand years earlier? Any point on the timeline feels random, unfair, and bureaucratic.

So how do people who accept both evolution and a binary afterlife actually reconcile this? At what point in our evolutionary history did hominids cross the threshold into having a soul - and how could that line be anything other than completely arbitrary?


r/DebateReligion • • 20h ago

Christianity The Christian God is Not All-Loving

17 Upvotes

The Bible contradicts the notion that the Christian God is all-loving. Here's the premise:

1) If God is all-loving towards everyone, then God should not endorse sexual acts where there is a non-consenting individual.

2) God is all-loving towards everyone.

3) Therefore, God should not endorse sexual acts where there is a non-consenting individual.

The Bible says otherwise.

In 2 Samuel 12:11-12 NIV

11"This is what the Lord says: ‘Out of your own household I am going to bring calamity on you. Before your very eyes I will take your wives and give them to one who is close to you, and he will sleep with your wives in broad daylight. 12 You did it in secret, but I will do this thing in broad daylight before all Israel.’”

In 2 Samuel 16:21-22 NIV

21Ahithophel answered, “Sleep with your father’s concubines whom he left to take care of the palace. Then all Israel will hear that you have made yourself obnoxious to your father, and the hands of everyone with you will be more resolute.” 22 So they pitched a tent for Absalom on the roof, and he slept with his father’s concubines in the sight of all Israel.

So Nathan, a prophet speaking on behalf of God, tells David that the Lord is going to punish him by giving his wives over to an individual, who ends up being his own son. That individual is then going to publicly have sex with David's wives for all of Israel to see. The text explicitly attributes the orchestration of this punishment to God when it says "I will take your wives and give them to one who is close to you, and he will sleep with your wives in broad daylight". The wives are being used as instruments of punishment for David's wrongdoing, despite being non-consenting individuals themselves. This is a direct contradiction to the claim that God is all-loving toward everyone.


r/DebateReligion • • 12h ago

Islam Does the "Satanic Verses" incident (Al-Gharaniq) and Quran 22:52 fit with prophetic infallibility

1 Upvotes

I came across the Incident of the Gharaniq (often called the Satanic Verses) and I honestly find it hard to wrap my head around how this fits with standard Islamic theology. I want to hear how people view this.

Most Muslims today have never even heard of it or they immediately call it a fake anti-Islam lie, even though it comes straight from Islam's own earliest, most respected historians like Al-Tabari and Ibn Ishaq.

If you haven't read the story in the early seerah and tafsir books, it goes like this:

Back in Mecca when the Muslims were being heavily persecuted and boycotted, Muhammad was reciting Surah An-Najm (Chapter 53) in front of the Meccan leaders. Right after mentioning the three pagan goddesses al-Lat, al-'Uzza and Manat (53:19-20), Satan allegedly slipped two lines onto Muhammad's tongue praising them as exalted cranes whose intercession is hoped for.

The pagan Meccans were thrilled because they thought Muhammad finally accepted their gods, so everyone prostrated together at the end of the recitation. The craziest part to me is that Muhammad didn't even notice anything was wrong in the moment. He went about his day until angel jibril (Gabriel) supposedly came down later, told him Satan hijacked his tongue and replaced those lines with the verses we have today (53:21-23).

And it's not just in the history books, there is literally an ayah in the Quran backing it up. Surah Al-Hajj (22:52) says that whenever a prophet recited, Satan threw something into his recitation and then Allah had to cancel what Satan threw in. (Modern English translations quietly change the Arabic word "tamanna" from "recited" to "desired" so people don't connect the dots).

I'd genuinely love to hear how Muslims defend this, because to me the logic completely falls apart:

First, where was God during the live recitation? If Allah is all-powerful and actively protecting the Quran from corruption, how did Satan manage to hijack the broadcast mid-sentence without God stopping him? Why did it take hours or days to send angel jibril down to fix it?
Second, I already know the standard apologist response is "the chains of narration are weak." Okay, even if you throw out the chains, who on earth would make this up? No Muslim would invent a story making the Prophet look like he compromised with paganism and got tricked by Satan and no enemy could trick Al-Tabari, Ibn Ishaq and even Ibn Taymiyyah into believing it.

To me, it reads way more like Muhammad tried to make a political compromise to stop the persecution in Mecca, realized afterward it ruined his whole monotheistic message and had to walk it back.


r/DebateReligion • • 20h ago

Abrahamic Eternal afterlife is another state of death.

3 Upvotes

This is sort of a continuation of an argument I made in a recent post.

In that post, a quick tl;dr of my argument is that Heaven effectively flattens any iota of humanity to ensure that everyone feels infinite bliss.

I wanted to make this post to further emphasize that I am not arguing that Heaven is inherently immoral. Heaven could in fact be the ultimate utilitarian good. Heaven could be genuine infinite, pure bliss. It only comes at the opportunity cost of the annihilation of humanity as a whole

I wanted to further expand my argument that eternal Heaven, (or Hell), does NOT "bring you back from the dead". It is not the opposite of death.

Here, I want to argue that afterlife is death. it is just another state of death. If we take the premises of my linked post, Heaven or Hell completely liquidates anyone who enters the gate. I'm arguing that Heaven (or Hell) must have everyone effectively and functionally dead in a human sense.

If physical death is the annihilation of consciousness into nothingness, then then eternal static existence, whether infinite bliss or infinite torment, is the annihilation of consciousness into stasis. In both cases, the dynamic, evolving, relational human subject ceases to exist. In both cases, the "humans" that were once there are no longer, in any sense of the word, alive. For to be alive is to have a changing state of consciousness

Analogously, in thermodynamics, the ultimate death of the universe is heat death. A state of maximum entropy where energy is distributed with total, uniform perfection. Nothing happens, nothing changes, and no work can be done because there is no difference in temperature anywhere.

Heaven is psychological heat death. When every desire is permanently saturated and every emotional gradient is flattened into uniform, unbreakable bliss, consciousness itself stalls. There is no growth, and no movement of the soul. You aren't living anymore, you are just fossilized as an eternal lobotomite.

This also applies to Hell. Real human suffering has narrative arc, adaptation, numbness, or eventual collapse. Infinite torture strips away the capacity to process, learn, or change, reducing the person to a single, never-ending screaming corpse.

If a person walks through the pearly gates and has their capacity for grief, empathy, doubt, and change overwritten so they can function in a static eternity, then they are dead, and got replaced by an automaton.


r/DebateReligion • • 20h ago

Islam Scholars Are Not Infallible: Stop Treating Ancient Opinions as Divine Revelation

2 Upvotes

Abu Hanifa said:

"This is our opinion, and it is the best we have been able to arrive at. Whoever comes with something better than it is more entitled to be correct."

Ahmad ibn Hanbal said:

"Do not blindly follow me, nor Malik, nor al-Shafi'i, nor al-Awza'i, nor al-Thawri. Take from where they took."

Malik ibn Anas said:

"I am only a human being. I make mistakes and get things right. Examine my opinions: whatever agrees with the Book and the Sunnah, take it, and whatever does not agree with the Book and the Sunnah, leave it."

Al-Shafi'i said:

"O Abu Ishaq, do not blindly follow me in everything I say. Examine it for yourself, for this is a matter of religion."

So stop using this nonsensical argument that ancient commentators said this or that, or that scholars supposedly agreed on something, as though their opinions were infallible.

They themselves acknowledged that they could be wrong and explicitly advised people capable of reasoning to examine their opinions rather than follow them blindly.

If they make a claim that has no sound evidence from the Qur'an or authentic Sunnah, then it is their own opinion, not divine revelation.

For example, consider this statement:

"If a man marries a woman knowing that she is enslaved, then any child born to them is also enslaved to her master, by the agreement of the four imams."

— Ibn Taymiyyah, Majmu' al-Fatawa (31/376).

This is nonsense. Where is the Qur'anic evidence? Where is the authentic hadith establishing this?

There is no explicit Qur'anic or authentic hadith evidence for such a ruling. They simply arrived at this conclusion within the assumptions and social framework of their historical and cultural context.

An opinion does not become divine truth simply because an ancient scholar held it, several scholars agreed with it, or it was later presented as a consensus.

Respect scholars, but do not turn their opinions into revelation. The ultimate authority is evidence, not the status or antiquity of the person making the claim.


r/DebateReligion • • 1d ago

Islam Islam’s test cannot be fair when everyone starts with a different exam paper

15 Upvotes

I have some points about Islam, God, and the concept of Heaven and Hell that I genuinely want to understand.

  1. If Allah created the entire universe, which is unimaginably huge, it is strange that Islam seems to focus mainly on Earth and human beings. It is unclear where the possibility of intelligent life on other planets fits into this.

  2. People born in isolated tribes, like indigenous communities in the Amazon, have never heard of Islam, Allah, or the Quran. Some follow their own traditions or practise idol worship. If they go to Hell simply because they were born without knowing Islam, that is unfair.

  3. If Allah already knows everything, including our future decisions and final destination, there is no clear need for Him to test us. A test has no clear purpose if the result is already known.

  4. If a baby is born and dies within an hour and goes to Jannah, there seems to be no reason it was sent to Earth at all, since Allah already knew it would die so soon. It could have been sent directly to Jannah. It is also unclear whether that baby will grow up in Paradise or remain a baby forever.

  5. Islamic descriptions of Jannah are very human-centred. Rivers, gardens, food, drinks, Hoors, and physical pleasures are all things humans desire on Earth. Paradise is described through things we already understand. It is also unclear whether humans will grow older in Jannah or remain at a fixed age.

  6. Considering how enormous the universe is, almost the entire discussion of creation, religion, judgment, Heaven, and Hell is centred around humans on Earth. It is unclear where other intelligent civilizations, if they exist, fit into this.

I'm not making these points to disrespect Islam or anyone's beliefs. I genuinely want logical explanations rather than answers like "Allah knows best."

My main point: If Allah is perfectly just, then people being born into such different circumstances, with completely different levels of knowledge and opportunities, and then being judged, is not a fair test for everyone.


r/DebateReligion • • 23h ago

Christianity The Prophecy of Matthew 24:14

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone, my question relates to the prophecy put fourth by Matthew 24:14 in the New Testament. For those unfamiliar with the verse, it is from a supposed teaching from Jesus to his disciples discussing the fall of the Second Temple. The verse of interest (from the NIV Bible) reads as follows:

And this gospel of the kingdom will be preached in the whole world as a testimony to all nations, and then the end will come.

Now, to myself, and maybe other, this verse reads pretty clear and I understand it in the way that if the gospel is announced and taught to all of those in the world, the end times begin and we supposedly see the second coming of Jesus.

My question therefore is, do you truly believe that if every person in the world heard about Christianity, this event would occur. Followed of course by judgement and the subsequent punishment of non-believers.

My follow up question is then, if you do believer this and if there were some sort of way today we could have everyone in the world, maybe sitting in front of a screen or something along those lines, hear such message of Christianity, would you want for that to occur (I know we have the issue of how this could happen with unconnected tribes etc, but in this case, imagine it could hypothetically happen)? Would you truly want for this to happen right now, knowing people close to you don't believe? This could be anyone to your parents/children, uncles/aunties, grandparents, best friends. Would you want such an event to take place?

Interested to hear people's thoughts.


r/DebateReligion • • 8h ago

Christianity Experiencing God without knowing God

0 Upvotes

I've taken content from some of my other posts and turned it into a debate. I frequently get feedback that my posts are long tangents that don't have any debatable content, so I've done my best to fix that. In full transparency don't expect to convince anyone, I just love hearing the sound of my own voice, especially on topics of philosophy and theology. However, I think this is going to be the post I share to my friend's blog instead of posting "the godless: the smartest people in the room," which was unnecessarily rude of a post, so your feedback on this post is important to me, as I want it to be as good of a post as possible.

This should be my best post ever so far. If you think this post is garbage, then consider everything I have to post in the future garbage too, because I can't write any better than what you're about to read.

I believe God is like an abstraction, possibly not an abstraction verbatim, but in the sense that God is difficult and in some ways impossible to understand. The social construction of religion is how I believe that I communicate and interpret God. Belief in God and that Jesus communicates with me through the process of religious social construction is a faith belief of mine. Many religious texts call for this definition of faith, 2:b(1): “firm belief in something for which there is no proof.”

Knowledge is “information, understanding, or skill that you get from experience or education.” Faith can lead to interpretation and opinion, but it cannot lead to knowledge, therefore I believe one can interpret God, but not know God.

Edit: God is epistemologically as valid as other spiritual claims, like fairies. However, in my view, God is more philosophically significant to me, and the concept of God brings me contentment, which is why I personally use faith to believe in God and why I don't use faith to believe in things like fairies.

Therefore, I don’t know if there is a God or not, and I certainly don’t know that Jesus Christ is the correct interpretation of God. Which is why I believe on fatih in my interpretation of God, though unlike some other theists, I do not believe my faith leads me to knowledge. I probably am wrong at least partially about my interpretation of God, and it's why my views on God are fluid. To illustrate, I used to believe in natural moral laws, but now I don’t anymore.

One may say that professing to not know if there is a God is an agnostic atheist position. However, agnostic atheists do not believe in God on faith, and I believe in God on faith. Furthermore, some theists will claim to know God, but you and I will likely agree that strong conviction doesn't equate to knowledge. So I think all theists believe in God, rather than know God.

Which leads me to my first argument.

P1: Faith should only be applied to the spiritual world, it should not be applied as a mechanism to the material world or to (arguably) non-material rational concepts, like mathematics.

P2: The spiritual world cannot be empirically tested or demonstrated in any way, unlike the material world and (arguably) non-material rational concepts, like mathematics.

Conclusion: Faith should only be applied to the spiritual world.

Which leads me to my second argument.

P1: Faith doesn’t override morality.

P2: Invoking faith doesn’t justify one holding immoral beliefs.

Conclusion: It is wrong for one to hold immoral beliefs, and invoking faith doesn’t change that.

Which leads me to my final argument.

P1: One can experience something without knowing what that something is, and faith is a way to do that.

P2: One can attempt to interpret that something, even if that something is not testable in any empirical way.

Conclusion: One can experience and believe in what they interpret to be God without knowing God.

Edit to add,

If you only believe in what can be empirically tested or demonstrated, then you shouldn't have faith in anything. At least not faith as defined in my post. I am willing to take a leap of faith when it comes to what I believe is the spiritual world, and if this is not something you are willing to do, then you will find no value in faith.


r/DebateReligion • • 1d ago

Hinduism The doctrine of karma and reincarnation lacks logical coherence and evidence, and is inherently unfair

5 Upvotes

Thesis: The Hindu concept of karma, reincarnation, and moksha is not supported by any reliable evidence, and it faces serious logical problems: circular reasoning, no explanation for the first birth, no clear purpose for the cycle, and an unfair system of justice without memory.

I’m not here to disrespect anyone’s religion or beliefs. I’m presenting why I find this theory unconvincing, and I’d especially like Hindus who believe in karma and reincarnation to challenge my reasoning directly.

1. The common argument for karma is circular

The usual justification for karma is something like: “If someone is born poor, suffers, or faces difficulties, it’s because of their past-life karma.” But this argument assumes karma is true without first establishing it. You cannot use a theory to prove itself. Suffering in this life is not evidence of past-life actions unless karma has already been shown to exist independently.

2. The cycle has no logical starting point

If every birth is the result of karma from a previous life, then the very first birth of a soul becomes a problem. Before its first birth, the soul had no previous life, so it could not have had any previous-life karma. So what caused it to enter a physical body in the first place?

The only way out seems to be claiming that souls have existed eternally. But that claim itself needs justification, and I have not seen actual reasoning for it beyond assertion.

3. If moksha is the ultimate goal, the existence of the cycle makes no sense

If the ultimate purpose of life is to attain moksha and escape the cycle of birth and death, then the existence of this cycle is hard to explain. An all-knowing and compassionate God would be creating souls that enter a world of suffering, make mistakes, accumulate karma, take countless births, and then struggle to achieve liberation.

If liberation is the final destination anyway, creating this entire process seems pointless at best, and cruel at worst.

4. Karma without memory is an unfair system of justice

This is my biggest concern. According to this belief, I am experiencing the consequences of actions from previous lives, but I have absolutely no memory of those lives. I cannot learn from mistakes I cannot remember making.

Also, if I am born into a family or society where nobody believes in God, Hinduism, reincarnation, or moksha, I will naturally grow up with different beliefs because of my environment and upbringing. Holding me responsible for not following a spiritual path I was never even exposed to is not fair.

In effect, it’s like being punished for breaking rules you don’t remember, in a previous existence you cannot verify, under a system nobody can conclusively demonstrate. That does not look like justice.

5. There is no reliable evidence for reincarnation

I am not aware of any reliable, independently verifiable evidence that consciousness or a soul survives death and enters another body. I am also not aware of any scientifically established facts showing a connection between someone’s present-life circumstances and their alleged past-life actions.

Some people share stories about remembering previous lives, but personal stories do not establish that reincarnation is actually happening. Personal experiences and religious scriptures alone are not sufficient evidence for a claim about a universal law.

Conclusion

If karma is a universal law, there should be some logical reasoning or evidence behind it. Based on the points above, I don’t think the theory currently meets that standard.

My position: I am not a completely convinced atheist. I am open to the possibility that God or some higher intelligence exists, though not necessarily in the way religious scriptures describe him. I’m open to changing my view if I find convincing reasons.

So I’d like Hindus who believe in karma and reincarnation to respond to these points directly with philosophical reasoning, not with “You won’t understand unless you have faith” or “Our scriptures say so.” Let’s have a respectful debate.


r/DebateReligion • • 1d ago

Abrahamic Faith based on fear of punishment is not genuine faith.

31 Upvotes

If someone believes in God primarily because they fear eternal punishment, their belief is motivated by fear rather than genuine spiritual conviction.

Some Christians argue that "fear of God" means respect or reverence. However, this does not resolve the contradiction when eternal punishment is also presented as a consequence of disbelief.

Respect and fear of punishment are not the same thing.

I argue that genuine faith should arise from freely formed conviction, not coercion or threats.

How can faith be considered freely chosen if rejecting it is believed to result in eternal suffering?


r/DebateReligion • • 1d ago

Christianity Before we even argue about whether Christianity is true, look at the stack of unproven assumptions it needs just to make sense.

49 Upvotes

​For the story to work, you have to buy into an invisible moral rulebook that makes "sin" a cosmic crime, an invisible soul that needs saving, miracles that break the laws of nature, and the idea that ancient stories count as proof while testing God today is off limits.

​Each of those guesses props up the next. Without the rulebook, there's no sin; without the soul, there's nothing to save.

​So the real debate isn't about ancient history. It's why we should accept a whole chain of invisible premises on faith just to make the story hold together. Science assumes nothing it can't, at the very least, test.


r/DebateReligion • • 1d ago

Other I think of best possible replacement of religion

3 Upvotes

Hey folks, I would like to start by saying that I respect every faith and understand how sacred religion is to most people. Whenever I get the chance, I like studying different religions and their histories, trying to understand how they work and the human emotions attached to them!

I guess I'm still too young to understand all of this, but I've always been curious about one thing: What could be the best possible replacement for religion?

Obviously, we can't simply say scientific temperament, because by replacement I mean something that can offer the same sense of hope, moral guidance and belonging that religion provides. I think these are some of the biggest reasons why religion has such a strong place in human societies

I firmly believe humanity needs something that carries the same essence but appeals to everyone. Something that doesn't divide people into believers and non-believers, but instead brings every single human being together and makes us see ourselves as one mankind

Has anyone ever thought about this? I'd genuinely love to hear your opinions and perspectives

And again, I mean no disrespect to anyone's faith or sentiments.


r/DebateReligion • • 15h ago

Islam Paul didnt corrupt Jesus’ original message

0 Upvotes

Paul didnt corrupt Jesus’ original message because Gospel Jesus is entirely fictional and so is the so called original message

Paul, Peter and James were talking about the celestial Jesus who was incarnated, died and rose in lower heaven. There was no Galilean preacher Jesus. So there is no such thing as “Jesus’ teachings” at all except as direct revelations to the apostles

We can see evidence of that in Paul’s writings where he quotes only the old testament and never Jesus except for the commandment for the Eucharist and the one about divorce both of which seems to be a private revelation Paul himself received.

The gospels were constructed with Paul and other apostles already established as teachers of the church and what “Jesus says” in the gospels are actually derived from Paul, Peter and James and the Didache as well

Here are some examples. Lets begin with Paul:

“Love must be sincere. Hate what is evil; cling to what is good. Be devoted to one another in love. Honor one another above yourselves. Never be lacking in zeal, but keep your spiritual fervor, serving the Lord. Be joyful in hope, patient in affliction, faithful in prayer. Share with the Lord’s people who are in need. Practice hospitality. Bless those who persecute you; bless and do not curse. Rejoice with those who rejoice; mourn with those who mourn. Live in harmony with one another. Do not be proud, but be willing to associate with people of low position. Do not be conceited. Do not repay anyone evil for evil. Be careful to do what is right in the eyes of everyone. If it is possible, as far as it depends on you, live at peace with everyone. Do not take revenge, my dear friends, but leave room for God’s wrath, for it is written: “It is mine to avenge; I will repay,” says the Lord. On the contrary: “If your enemy is hungry, feed him; if he is thirsty, give him something to drink. In doing this, you will heap burning coals on his head.” Do not be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good.”
‭‭Romans‬ ‭12‬:‭9‬-‭21‬ ‭NIV‬‬

You would think that’s Jesus’ teachings about praying for your enemies and turning the other cheek. But no it is from Paul and he refers to Deut 32 and Prov. 25 as the source of his own interpretation

Also in 1st Peter we get:

“Finally, all of you, be like-minded, be sympathetic, love one another, be compassionate and humble. Do not repay evil with evil or insult with insult. On the contrary, repay evil with blessing, because to this you were called so that you may inherit a blessing. For, “Whoever would love life and see good days must keep their tongue from evil and their lips from deceitful speech. They must turn from evil and do good; they must seek peace and pursue it. For the eyes of the Lord are on the righteous and his ears are attentive to their prayer, but the face of the Lord is against those who do evil.””
‭‭1 Peter‬ ‭3‬:‭8‬-‭12‬ ‭NIV‬‬

Peter is quoting Psalm 34 and not Jesus. Why quote a Psalm when you can just quote “Jesus’ teachings”? Simple answer is that there was no such thing

And even in James we get:

“But the wisdom that comes from heaven is first of all pure; then peace-loving, considerate, submissive, full of mercy and good fruit, impartial and sincere. Peacemakers who sow in peace reap a harvest of righteousness.”
‭‭James‬ ‭3‬:‭17‬-‭18‬ ‭NIV‬‬

Why not bolster his case by reminding his readers of the memorable line from Jesus Sermon on the Mount?

How about this one:

“There is only one Lawgiver and Judge, the one who is able to save and destroy. But you—who are you to judge your neighbor?”
‭‭James‬ ‭4‬:‭12‬ ‭NIV‬‬

Again a perfect opportunity to strengthen the advice by quoting Jesus missed. And yet another:

“Above all, my brothers and sisters, do not swear—not by heaven or by earth or by anything else. All you need to say is a simple “Yes” or “No.” Otherwise you will be condemned.”
‭‭James‬ ‭5‬:‭12‬ ‭NIV‬‬

I am pretty certain that Jesus has an almost verbatim teaching. Why wouldnt James give credit to Jesus here? It can only bolster the authority of his advice and his own authority as well as a conveyor of Jesus’ teachings. Why not do that?

Look at what Peter has to say here. This man supposedly was the closest disciple of Jesus until his last moment. He must have witnessed the crucifixion. Even from a distance. But here when it comes to talking about it he draws a blank and gives us Isaiah 53:

“But how is it to your credit if you receive a beating for doing wrong and endure it? But if you suffer for doing good and you endure it, this is commendable before God. To this you were called, because Christ suffered for you, leaving you an example, that you should follow in his steps. “He committed no sin, and no deceit was found in his mouth.” When they hurled their insults at him, he did not retaliate; when he suffered, he made no threats. Instead, he entrusted himself to him who judges justly. “He himself bore our sins” in his body on the cross, so that we might die to sins and live for righteousness; “by his wounds you have been healed.” For “you were like sheep going astray,” but now you have returned to the Shepherd and Overseer of your souls.”
‭‭1 Peter‬ ‭2‬:‭20‬-‭25‬ ‭NIV‬‬

Here is another instance where Paul somehow teaches something we later find in the gospels credited to Jesus:

“Now, brothers and sisters, about times and dates we do not need to write to you, for you know very well that the day of the Lord will come like a thief in the night. While people are saying, “Peace and safety,” destruction will come on them suddenly, as labor pains on a pregnant woman, and they will not escape. But you, brothers and sisters, are not in darkness so that this day should surprise you like a thief. You are all children of the light and children of the day. We do not belong to the night or to the darkness. So then, let us not be like others, who are asleep, but let us be awake and sober.”
‭‭1 Thessalonians‬ ‭5‬:‭1‬-‭6‬ ‭NIV‬‬

And again an opportunity to quote Jesus missed:

“Make sure that nobody pays back wrong for wrong, but always strive to do what is good for each other and for everyone else.”
‭‭1 Thessalonians‬ ‭5‬:‭15‬ ‭NIV‬‬

Quoting Jesus as source can only help because it makes the advice authoritative and by extension it adds authority to the one giving advice. So why miss the opportunity?

And here:

“Brothers and sisters, think of what you were when you were called. Not many of you were wise by human standards; not many were influential; not many were of noble birth. But God chose the foolish things of the world to shame the wise; God chose the weak things of the world to shame the strong. God chose the lowly things of this world and the despised things—and the things that are not—to nullify the things that are, so that no one may boast before him.”
‭‭1 Corinthians‬ ‭1‬:‭26‬-‭29‬ ‭NIV‬‬

Seems like a perfectly good opportunity to quote Jesus saying the first shall be the last. And again missed

Thats some of the reasons


r/DebateReligion • • 1d ago

Abrahamic Heaven flattens any shred of humanity to fulfill its promise

10 Upvotes

This is a quite trodden path, though I feel the need to reiterate this argument. Traditionally, Heaven promises an eternal life of a constant state of bliss.

My argument is that the only way to fulfill this promise is to shred every person of their humanity, and essentially turn them into automata.

I'm not arguing that heaven cannot logically be all-good in some sense.

But how can there be any shred of humanity left? A mother who lost her son in hell does not feel grief, pain, trauma. A mother cannot remain a mother in any recognizable human sense if she is incapable of feeling the absence or pain of her child. If her grief is wiped clean, then the person who loved that child has effectively died at the pearly gates.

You have free will yet you're only attached to God, and God only for all eternity.

You cannot feel anything else, since it inherently allows the break of bliss.

Constant, eternal happiness sounds more like another excruciating death, except it never ends. Its constant torture.

No human is what they were, and nothing resembling humanity can ever be left. Attachment, even "healthy" attachment cannot exist.

The things that make up our psychological identity, our scars, our hard-won resilience through trauma, our stubborn loyalty to specific people, our capacity for empathy. These are things that make us up. I don't think it's an unreasonable claim

Strip all that away. Even if the person remembers it, strip all the effect it has on us. Strip empathy, loyalty, trauma, scars. You cannot have them since they risk breaking bliss. You are left with a mannequin that wears the face of someone. That's what heaven promises.

To force the human mind into a permanent state of high-intensity bliss without any emotional range is its own form of psychological torture. It is a removal of the dynamic, breathing spirit in favor of a permanent, unthinking echo chamber.

Heaven promises that if you were to look down at the damned, even ones you love, be tormented forever and ever and ever, you'd feel nothing. This is a total erasure of empathy.

If eternity requires us to throw everything resembling a risk of pain and sit in a state of unfeeling, uniform perfection, then humanity as a whole is crushed. We would functionally be identical to a robot I have programmed to continuously gaze up at me, and feel eternal bliss.

It doesn't matter if our will is "perfected". It doesn't matter if our constant gaze to God in heaven is a genuinely free choice that is logically impossible to counteract. It doesn't matter if its analogous to a starving man always looking at a feast. The outcome is identical, we'll have zero counterfactuals, zero subjectivity, zero loss, zero love, and zero human condition. For a gazillion years, then another gazillion years, then a gazillion to the power of a gazillion years, and we wouldn't even be started by then.

Heaven is nothing but spiritual lobotomy en masse.