It’s been about a year since I started what I call “active deconstruction.” And ever since then, I’ve been keeping a journal documenting what it’s been like. 1 year later, I wanted to share what it was like for me, especially for those who may just be starting their journey and have no clue what the future looks like.
The story starts before a year ago though. I grew up in an evangelical Baptist church and I truly believed. I was never scared of Hell because the love of Jesus sounded so good to me that that’s the only reason I “got saved” around the age of seven. I attended the weekly kids program, and eventually transitioned into the youth group. Around that time, the first major doubts started forming.
I was raised as a young earth creationist, and truly believed that evolution and the big bang were deceptions to drive people away from God. But then I started learning more about earth science and biology from science teachers who cared very much about sharing the truth. And I had to wonder why the evidence for these things was so immediately strong when it was supposed to be a lie. But I just brushed it aside. I thought that surely God would reveal the answer to me someday.
I attended an evangelical university, and that’s where my faith became the strongest it had ever been. I wanted to devote my life to sharing with others the knowledge that had set me free. And so I wanted to learn more. I wanted to defend my faith, just like Paul implored Timothy. I wanted to have a defense for every argument that could be thrown my way. And yet, in my final theology class of senior year, the first major crack appeared. “Wait. How did we even determine canonicity? Who has the authority to make that call, decades after the texts have been written?” This was a huge concern to me. I actually told one of my close friends that I felt “primed for deconstruction,” whatever that was supposed to mean. But I was graduating soon, and I didn’t want this line of thinking to destroy my moment of victory, so again, I ignored it.
After I graduated, I began working at a small evangelical ministry, and that’s where I saw ridiculous behaviors in my “faithful” coworkers that really rubbed me the wrong way. How could they be so devoted to Donald Trump when he’s so blatantly evil? How could they react this way to the death of Charlie Kirk, as if he were a martyr and a paragon of the Christian faith? Or even the one coworker who told me I needed to stop believing in space because the Bible says space isn’t real. And I saw all of these things and I realized that they reached their conclusions in the same way I reached mine. And if their thinking was so flawed, I had to wonder how flawed my thinking might’ve been. And so it was then, a year ago, that I finally snapped and started looking for answers.
I texted my parents about my concerns and about my drive away from evangelicalism. I wanted my family and friends to know about all of this so that they could catch me if I were to ever drift too far (I often regret this decision, but it was the best decision I could think of at the time). I then watched a video from a man I had been seeing in my suggested feed a few times. Dan McClellan. It was a video on Steven L. Anderson and then another that spoke about all the things in the Bible Christians conveniently brush aside. After that, I discovered Bart Ehrman and Wes Huff. Religion for Breakfast and Ready to Harvest.
And then the big day came when I watched Rhett McLaughlin’s story of deconstruction. I knew about this episode of their podcast. Most of my classmates and my parents knew. And we knew to stay away from this man. Somehow, this man who had fallen away from the faith was worth less than people who never had it in the first place. But today was different. I was open to hearing what he had to say. And, to my shock, everything he said made sense. Why does it make sense when he’s supposedly lying?
That’s when I began my journal. The first entry is a lot of scattered thoughts. It begins with “117 billion people throughout history, and only a small percentage of them were ever given the chance to accept Salvation.” An insight into how unfair the system of salvation I had been presented with seemed to be. “If the Bible is true, I ought to be able to research anything in and around it and find it unshakable. I’m sick of hearing that there are dangerous topics to stay away from because it might make me fall away.” I had been told many times to “be careful” when researching other beliefs? Why should I? If I already believe the truth, then what danger is there in researching lies?
I then transcribed a passionate prayer to God, pleading with him to show me the answers: “God if you are real, I think you’re perfectly capable of leading me to the correct answer…if Christianity is real, then I have an eternity to live for right here and now and I have to make decisions that impact my eternity. If it’s not real, then I’m wasting time when I could be doing other things in this limited time I have...it’s either eternal or limited and both of those are equally important and I won’t be told otherwise and I’m gonna find answers and God if you are real, I pray that you would be involved in the search for answers. I won’t take it from anybody else.”
A bulk of this prayer seems to be a callout of Pascal’s Wager, which is the idea that Christians have nothing to lose if they end up being wrong. I, of course, think that’s wrong. They have their only flicker of consciousness to lose, and then the choices they get to make within it.
I also wrote down 5 statements that I wanted to be very clear to anyone who would potentially read it. In my mind, I would share this documentation with my friends and family someday to make a case for my deconstruction. “I don’t want to fall away,” “I came to these questions after learning more about theology and church history, not after hearing the culture tell me I’m wrong,” “I want to pursue the truth that authenticates what I’m asked to believe,” “Answers are out there, and there isn’t a gap that wild faith needs to fill,” and “If I were to deconstruct, it certainly wouldn’t be because it’s the culturally hip thing to do. You think I want my entire worldview to uproot?” I think it’s clear now that I had all of these apologetic reasons for why Christians deconstruct rattling around my head and I was battling with my evangelical programming. I was realizing that these reasons didn’t hold water, at least not with me.
I still had one ace up my sleeve though that could potentially reverse all this and I could go back to my normal life and worldview. I emailed my theology professor. The same one who taught my class where everything started to truly unravel. He was a biblical scholar, so I was certain that he could answer the numerous questions I had. To make a long story short, he didn’t. “Just got off the phone with [professor]. I’m disappointed…I’m disappointed because it felt to me that the linchpin of the conversation was “at some point, you need to have faith.” And then that statement informed the rest of the arguments he was making. I feel as though there is no logical or reasonable entry point into faith if that’s the case. If you have to assume faith to believe the arguments you make in order to have faith, how am I meant to start having faith in the first place? I don’t believe I can just convince myself to believe.” Looking back, most of his arguments boiled down to “We don’t believe that so it’s wrong.” It also didn’t help that at the very end of the conversation, he told me that I was probably having doubts because of my porn usage and that I should get that sin out of my life before anything else.
“You see, I’ve had this [porn] issue for 13 years and I have heard time and time again that Jesus is the answer. Well if I was truly believing the whole time, then I ought to be out of this by now by that logic…Did I truly not believe?…Or have I truly believed and yet the saving grace has not come to me in this life? And then that makes me wonder what belief actually is…What if, on a surface level, I felt that I’ve been secured the entire time when in fact my soul has been condemned the whole time? And how many millions of Christians are also in this same spot?”
And so things continued. And the following months sucked. There’s no other way to put it. I had a crisis of worldview, and the problem is when it’s something this big and with consequences on the scope of eternity, it’s the only thing you can think of. It’s the only thing I was allowed to think of. How could I not? “I just don’t want to think about this anymore. But with other things I don’t want to think about, I can afford to not do it for at least a little bit. I can’t do that with this. Not when it’s literally eternal life or death at any moment. So I don’t want to keep thinking about it, but I must, and so I’m exhausted. There are a lot of things I can just pretend aren’t problems, and while probably irresponsible to do so, it probably isn’t the biggest thing ever. But this is.” I was scared of Hell for the first time in my life and I had no idea what to do about it. In the following months, this was the only topic on my mind at all hours of the day. It was exhausting. It was horrifying.
Very soon after beginning this process, I looked to other denominations. Surely they would have the answers. I came across Episcopalianism. It seemed like they didn’t make an idol out of certainty like evangelicals do. Maybe I could find comfort here. It was around this same time that I had my first major conversation with a friend from my university. It was a normal phone call until I told them that I was having a crisis of faith. They started crying. But I explained myself. At this point, I was determined I would still land within Christianity, and they were willing to accept even the “heretical” denominations like Catholicism as long as I was one of the “good ones.” Laying everything out and talking with someone about it for once brought some comfort instead of battling it alone in my mind, regardless of whether the person agreed with me or not.
Something else peculiar was happening throughout all this. I could feel my thought processes changing. At first, I would create two views in my head when faced with a problem. The old Christian view, and the new agnostic view. It hurt because I had two opposing views in my head fighting for control. But then a month or so later, I noticed that feeling had faded, and those two views felt more like one view. An amalgam of both that appeared instantly. It wasn’t just two opposing views that I had to pick from anymore. They were both simultaneously my one genuine belief.
“So I find myself in a strange spot of both being critical, but now also placing faith in Jesus despite critical examination because I am willing to have faith that the less plausible outcome is true in this instance.”
Something that seems to have really bothered me was the claim that people who deconstruct or support anything opposed to evangelicalism are simply lying.
““It’s because you don’t want to be held responsible for your sin.” “You never really believed in the first place.” “At some point you just have to have faith.” Excuse me? Who are you to say these things you can’t possibly know? And yet, maybe there’s a point there. Maybe I’ve never known what true faith looks like, and maybe sin has a deeper subconscious hold on my mind than I thought. But then, what is true faith?…This is something I’ve heard all my life. Scientists are just throwing crap at the wall, anything to avoid belief in God. Critical scholars are making things up to disprove univocality so that they don’t have to believe in it. When I asked [professor] about the authorship of the Pauline letters, he essentially told me that the evidence that these scholars present is biased because they have an agenda to disprove the Bible. Seriously? Right, the scholars who have devoted their life to the study of the Bible actually hate it and don’t like it and are spending their lives being haters to disprove it. And yet, I hear so many talk about their love of the Bible. Seems to me that the notion that these scholars have an anti-biblical agenda is just another straw man.“
It was right after the New Year that I watched Wake Up Dead Man (great movie, if you haven’t already seen it). There were two moments in the movie that stood out to me. One was when Father Jud was speaking to Benoit Blanc about the nature of faith. “It’s storytelling. You’re right. I guess the question is do these stories convince us of a lie? Or do they resonate with something deep inside us that’s profoundly true? That we can’t express any other way… except storytelling?” Storytelling is super important to me, and I know it has been super important to humanity for our entire history. Perhaps Christianity contains truth in the storytelling and not in the literal letter of the word.
The other quote that stood out to me was from the skeptical Simone. “And I say, good. Expose it all. Wicks was a con man. Miracles and supernatural power of God bullshit. I really believed. I still wanna believe. How sick is that?” It felt like exactly where I was at. Why am I still chasing down these beliefs when I’ve seen so many of them exposed as lies and distortions? Why did I still want to believe when it would be simpler to just let it go and move on? I still don’t know the answer to that one.
About mid-January was when I had a big realization that would change the course of my journey. “I wrote at the very beginning of this that I’m writing all of this down so that people will know that I’m not doing this as an excuse to sin, or to follow the culture. I’m writing this to show that I did at one point “believe” and that I did do the research. I’m writing this so that there is only one explanation for leaving evangelicalism, which is that it just doesn’t make logical sense. And yet, it’s pointless. No matter what I do or say or study, I’ll always be in the wrong. I can cover all known bases, and they’ll just invent a new one because there’s no possible way they can be in the wrong. I’ve seen so many stories from people on various degrees of deconstruction…All of them have repeated the same sentiment. “I didn’t do this just because I wanted to sin.” And I have to wonder if it’s any coincidence that we all repeat the same phrase, and make the same defense. I have to wonder if we were all indoctrinated into the same traumatic system that makes us live in fear…if people like me and if people like Rhett McLauglin “never really believed,” you had better take a good look at your own faith and be extremely concerned. If our dedication and love for the church and devotion to the words of the Bible weren’t really belief, then there’s a whole lot of “Christians” that are damned because that’s apparently not enough to be considered “belief.”” I mean it’s all spelled out right there. I realized that my effort to form an airtight argument to present to my evangelical friends and family was for naught. I was taught to evangelize, and I was still doing it from the other side. The problem is you can’t logic someone out of something they didn’t logic themselves into. And it was around this time that I started deconstructing for me and not for the arguments I could present.
And yet, I was still very very afraid. Here is an entry from a day that I was close to accepting that I was an agnostic. “I sit here in my office, close to a panic attack, crying silently. I feel so close to the edge. But what if I’m wrong? The idea of eternal torment may seem unfair, it may seem logically implausible, it may seem made up and man-made, but what if it isn’t? Is that why I’ve stuck around?…I feel very afraid and I feel very alone.”
But funnily enough, the very next entry documents the beginning of what pulled me out of that fear: I started talking to people more. “I brought this up to my local friends while at lunch yesterday. It’s the first time I’ve ever brought this up to a non-evangelical crowd. And I felt affirmed. I also felt adrift. My eyes were opened to just how varied worldviews can be when not stuck to a single dogmatic view that says you must adhere to it. And something one of them told me stood out to me. “Do you think there is a shore to land on?” He would submit that the person set adrift is not ever meant to meaningfully find a shore to land on. Life is finding enjoyment whilst on the waters instead of finding comfort on land. Do I believe that? I don’t know.”
Shortly after that, I found myself both praying and also saying out loud in private that I didn’t believe in the resurrection of Jesus. That’s where I was at the time. “I think I’m a hopeful agnostic at the moment. I just simply find myself unconvinced of the claims of Christianity. And yet, I want it to be true, which pushes me even further to be unconvinced. Christians will say that the only reason to be an atheist or agnostic or any other thing is because you don’t want to be accountable to God. The very fact that I want all of it to be true proves that false, and feeds back into me being unconvinced.” It was both horrifying and relieving to admit to myself what I believed instead of clawing for something I didn’t, desperately praying for it to be true. And yet, I also wrote this in the same entry, “And yet, what if I’m wrong? What if despite everything, despite all logic and honesty and reason, I’m still wrong? Part of me is disgusted that I have been trained to not trust my own thoughts, but another part of me is concerned that it could be true. It’s a supernatural claim, and maybe, despite all of the evidence against it, it is still somehow magically true.“ I still find myself struggling with the idea of it being magically true. I found myself praying one night “God, if you’re real, you’ve been suspiciously quiet.”
And very soon after, I discovered this subreddit. And that was something that has had a lasting impact on my journey. I am so thankful for everyone here who has shared their story and supported me in mine. Fighting this battle in your own head is incredibly lonely and frightening, but being here has shown me that none of us are alone in this difficult process. I don’t find it at all shocking that the frequency of my journal entries slows down after I come across this subreddit. At the same time, I also learned that some of my new friends were also deconstructed and I found that some of my old ones were in the same boat now, too afraid to say anything. What started pulling me out of the existential dread was seeking out others who understood and could offer their thoughts and comfort. If you haven’t found people to have honest discussion with about this yet, I’d encourage you to do so if you can find a safe way to do it.
It’s not to say that all of my troubles ended there. Things got easier to manage, but the difficulties still persisted. I’ve had death anxiety for many years. I was always able to rest in the comfort of Heaven whenever I started to spiral, but I didn’t have that anymore. “It is in my greatest fears that He becomes real to me. I’ve been having panic attacks about death for a few years now. Most of the time, they’re late at night, attacking on the edge of sleep. Sometimes, I fear the edge of life and death, sometimes I fear Hell, sometimes I fear the nothingness. Sometimes I fear that, regardless of what it actually is, I won’t be satisfied with my life. I had an episode like that tonight. And maybe I’m just having an overall ebb back to faith, but the heavy breathing and sweat and overwhelming fear showed me the divine tonight. The peace that comes from it. Maybe it’s a foolish peace, but it’s enough for me. The question has been, are the claims about Jesus true enough for me. And if Jesus can save me from the bondage to my fears, then he is true enough for me.“
Something I should note is that I have experienced this ebb and flow to my faith. It’s not as chaotic as it was at the beginning, but some days I would find myself rejecting the idea of God altogether and other days I’d feel even more evangelical than I was before. This has gotten more stable and has centered around my “hopeful agnostic” label over time, but here was certainly a moment where I found that I needed to believe in God to stop myself from spiraling even further into immense dread and panic.
The journal entries continue to get less frequent as I start pouring myself into other creative work. I begin living my life as much as I can again without chaining myself to dread. I’ve taken a look at mysticism but not much has come of that. I feel fairly stabilized these days. Last month I wrote this:
“If you were to ask me where I’m at lately, I’d have to say that I’m just not. I don’t really know what that means either. If you asked me if I believe in God and Christianity, it’s just a general “meh, I don’t really care that much.” I can’t say I don’t believe, but I’m also not spending every waking hour on it either. I feel “normal” for the lack of a better word. I just feel like I’m living.”
It feels like the space Christianity used to occupy in my head is just blank now. Not that I don’t believe it, it just isn’t there. Imagine what your opinions on Sabrina Carpenter were before you had even heard of her. That’s what it feels like. It’s just nothing. I still care very much about my spirituality, but I’m also trying to live for what feels like the first time. I’m trying to make opportunities myself instead of waiting on a miracle to happen. My depression and self-hatred have greatly decreased. The world seems so much more colorful than it was before. And the biggest thing that I’ve taken away from this whole experience is that I am going to live in the present, because it is the only certain thing we have.
There are still a few things I can see coming that I don’t know if I’m quite prepared for. I still haven’t told my family. I think they suspect something is going on based on the amount of passive aggression I’ve received from some of them, but that’s all still a barrier I’ve yet to cross. I also haven’t engaged in a romantic relationship since this happened. I had quite a few relationships as an evangelical, but now I feel like I’ll have to rebuild a lot of my framework next time I’m in one. And that goes back to the family thing because, sure, there’s people in my life I’d love to pursue more with, but then that would surely lead to my family questioning things, and I’m not sure I’m ready for that. But no matter what happens, I’m sure I will be okay as long as those who truly love me stick around.
There is a lot I didn’t cover in this recap. I wrote a lot on the theology of Hell and evolutionary biology and critical Bible scholarship and my general frustrations with evangelical Christians in my journal but chose not to include those conversations here. If you have questions for me, I’d love to answer them. If you have advice for me and/or for others, please leave that behind as well. I’m so grateful for this community and it has done so much for me. I’d love it if this could help at least one person in return.
To sum up this whole journey, I’ll end on this quote from Rhett McLaughlin: “I was told it was true because it was reasonable. When I found out it wasn’t reasonable, I concluded that it wasn’t true.”