Butterfly Transformation (Shinobu)
Reference 1: Butterfly Breaks Cocoon
Reference 2: Infinity Castle Mission Report
Reference 3: Insect Hashira, Kochou Shinobu
Reference 4: Mount Natagumo Mission Report
Before Kanae’s death, we know that Shinobu had always looked up to her. We know this as, when she dies, she tries to mimic Kanae’s emotional manners rather than her usual serious, and rigid self.
She also takes over as the head of the butterfly mansion, and takes over as Hashira. Even though she isn’t another flower pillar, she still took over from where Kanae left off. In Mount Natagumo, we see Shinobu leave the Spider Sister alive while she has a conversation with her, despite her already established resentment of demons. This is a resemblance of Kanae’s personality, rather than Shinobu’s actual personality.
She then fought to the death properly, and then was consumed in full by Douma. This poison sealed Douma’s fate, however the speed at which it worked was quickened by Kanao and Inosuke tiring him out.
All of this together can bring us to the conclusion that
- Shinobu feels inferior to Kanae, and wanted to be someone that she was not. Even without being able to behead demons, and without being given a body on par with someone like Gyomei’s, or even Kanae herself, she still wanted to fight Douma to the death.
2.The wisteria poison that she had taken in before the fight was incase she died, not with a guarantee that she is going to die, she was not going to take any chances with the Demon that made her throw away her entire built facade.
When Kanae dies, she goes against Shinobu’s wishes of “avenging” her, and instead wants her to grow old. She wants her to leave the demon slayer corps, and “obtain happiness like any normal girl would.” Shinobu believes that Kanae’s last words would’ve been that she couldn’t defeat Douma, yet from the start of the fight she wanted to fight him to the death. Later, we can see what we assume to be Shinobu’s subconscious, representing herself as Kanae in relation to Shinobu trying to mimic everything about Kanae prior, convincing herself to fight as “Insect Hashira, Shinobu Kocho”
This is Real Shinobu and Facade Shinobu talking to each other. Kanae did not believe any of what this Kanae is telling her, Kanae specifically didn’t want Shinobu to try and avenge her.
She proceeds to envision a way to win, by driving poison through Douma’s neck, and then later states
"Even if we're weak and can't cut off demon heads, if we defeat one demon, we can save dozens of people. And if we can defeat an Upper Rank Kizuki, we can save hundreds. It isn't about whether we can or cannot do. There are things we have to do."
Here, Shinobu rejects limitations through what is “possible” and “impossible” through her less able body, and breaks through her limitations by pushing Douma to a near death state. She declares this as something she needs to do, to make sure that those like Kanao can live on rather than repeating the death cycle. We know this since Shinobu didn’t want Kanao to do the same wisteria ingesting plan, so Shinobu’s wishes for Kanao were more or less identical to Kanae’s wishes for Shinobu.
TDLR the butterfly started as a cocoon and broke out by the end, blossoming into a butterfly. Her narrative is not related to the poison that she gave Douma through her consumption, nor does it present her bad hand as something that limits her and it doesn’t present her as weak. She didn’t sacrifice herself, she fought to the death.
The Eternal Paradise Faith (Douma)
Reference 1: Can’t feel Joy and Anger - human emotions are just a dream
Reference 2: Douma’s Final Moment
Reference 3: Conquest Confirmation Report
Ever since Douma was a human, he never had the ability to feel any human emotions. Even when both his parents passed in sequence, he showed no genuine sorrow towards them, and only wondered about the smell of blood in the air.
When he was groomed to become the leader of the faith, he couldn’t comprehend why everyone had beliefs and views of things that couldn’t be proven directly to him, which can also correlate to why he can’t comprehend emotions, since they are drawn from beliefs and views rather than direct responses to certain triggers.
He constantly asked his followers about why things were, rather than if things were or weren’t, showing his inability to comprehend, rather than his ability to know. He then tries to understand these human qualities, like when he tries to seduce Nakime and Akaza to comprehend “love”.
Even after he became a demon, this still stayed true, and Kanao’s sarcastic callout of his inability to feel emotions struck him, and made him lose composure.
Even though these emotions can be triggered, he is unable to comprehend how, why or what is happening, as emotions are a completely foreign concept to him. We can see this in his death, where he asks Shinobu if he is feeling love. The ability to love is evoked, but he can not comprehend what it means to love, or why he is loving, and is strictly an “in the moment” reaction rather than something he wants to do.
Douma’s view of “saving” someone is to eat them in full, so they can live the rest of their life happily alongside him. This is a direct product of his constant praise during childhood, as a “special child who could hear the voice of the gods.”, where Douma inherits all of the views that are told to him, rather than being able to figure things out on his own.
TDLR No he isn’t playing around or holding back in order to feel joy, he doesn’t know how joy is evoked, or what joy actually is or means. He only knows what he has been told, as his childhood was limited by being born into the faith and treated as the leader.