r/Divination • u/VarianMedris • 20h ago
Questions and Discussions Why I Refuse To Read On "What He's Thinking" (Especially With The Transits We’re Moving Into Right Now)
Spend 5 minutes in any divination space and you’ll see the exact same questions on repeat: What are their intentions? Does my ex still miss me? What is my crush secretly feeling right now?
With the Sun in Scorpio squaring Mars and Jupiter right now, it’s no surprise people are hyper-fixated on hidden motives and power dynamics. Uncertainty hurts, and it’s tempting to treat tarot or scrying like a psychic wiretap to bypass the vulnerability of actually talking to someone—or accepting that they walked away.
Personally, I have a firm boundary against third-party "mind-reading" questions. Here is why I don't think reading on "him/her/them" is ethical, healthy, or actually helpful for the person sitting across from me:
1. It’s an ethical boundary (Consent & Scope)
Every reader has to bring their own moral compass to the table. If you don't have a code of ethics as a practitioner, you're just running a spiritual "gossip column". Reading into the private thoughts, feelings, or plans of someone who isn't in the room—and didn't consent to being read—crosses a line. My job is to read the energy of the person who actually booked the session, not spy on someone else.
2. It feeds into anxious attachments and mental loops instead of resolving them
As we head into Sagittarius season this weekend and a Gemini Full Moon conjunct Uranus next week, the collective energy is shifting away from Scorpio’s obsession and straight toward blunt truth and breaking out of overthinking. When someone is spiraling over an ex, partner, or situationship, telling them that "she's conflicted" or "he's thinking about you" doesn't bring them peace. It keeps them trapped in a passive waiting game and hands their emotional stability over to someone else's mood swings and decisions.
3. Redirecting the energy isn't "judging"—it's doing the job
There’s a common pushback that readers shouldn't steer the session and should just answer whatever is asked. I strongly disagree. Especially with Mars moving into practical Virgo next week, the work is about discernment and cleaning up our own side of the street. Part of being a responsible practitioner is knowing how to reframe a dead-end question so the querent actually walks away with direction instead of more obsession.
Instead of asking "What is he going to do?", I redirect the focus back to the querent:
- What do you actually need from a connection right now?
- What is this dynamic triggering in you?
- What is your next best move to protect your peace?
That isn't lecturing someone or acting like a therapist. It’s keeping the reading anchored in the only thing the querent actually has control over: themselves.
For the readers here: Where do you draw the line with third-party relationship questions? Do you take them as-is, or do you reframe them back onto the querent?