r/DnD • u/TheVoiceOfSnakeEyes • 14h ago
Misc Is 50 too old for 5e?
As a kid, I was really into Dungeons and Dragons (what they now call BECMI), and later on our group switched to 2nd edition AD&D, and that's what I played all the way up until 2005. I totally skipped 3rd and 4th edition, and by the time 5th edition rolled around, all my local gaming stores had closed, and all my friends had moved on to other things. I've really missed playing D&D, and during the pandemic I tried to get back into 2e with an online group, but they spent more time arguing about rules interpretations than actually playing, so that didn't work out. A couple years ago, I was invited to join a semi-local (60 miles away) 5e group, but I had a tough time adjusting to the age gap between me and everyone else, and I was the only one who didn't show up in pajamas with an emotional support plushie (I am not joking, it was weird), and they spent most of the time either playing on their iPhones or making pop culture references, there was very little actual gameplay. I ended up not going back, because gas is expensive, and it wasn't any fun.
I'm wondering if the train has simply sailed for me. I've made a few attempts to sit down and learn the rules for 5e, but I never read very far before shaking my head and saying, "this isn't even the same game anymore." After watching web shows like Dimension 20 and Critical Role and not being anywhere near as entertained as apparently everyone else watching it, I worry I'm the problem, and that maybe I'm just too out of touch with...whatever the D&D culture is now. I certainly feel self-conscious about the idea of trying to play with people young enough to be my grandkids, and apparently people my own age are too busy yelling at clouds to enjoy D&D today.
Anyway, I'm considering picking up some 5e books, but I'm not sure whether to get the ones that are currently in print, or the ones from 2014. I know the new ones are divisive (one asshat told me not to get them because there's a picture of an elf in a wheelchair, and that was his only reasoning), but there's no sense in getting those if no one is actually using them. Is there even a consensus? Or is everyone arguing about that as well? 5e is so alien to me at the moment, I probably wouldn't know the difference, but I would hate to buy books and then suddenly, "Preorder the 6th Edition Core Rulebooks Now!" I mean, that's precisely why we never switched to 3rd edition, because that was just as predatory back then as it would be today.
TL:DR: I miss playing D&D, but my experience with 5th edition has not been great.