r/Dogtraining • u/queen-of-quartz • 4h ago
help Should I even try to introduce my dogs to my parents dogs or is this just a nightmare waiting to happen?
I am quitting my job soon and when I do my husband and I (he works remote) are going to go visit my parents for about 4 weeks to help with my brother’s new baby (he lives next door). Normally our visits are short and we fly, but since this visit is going to be pretty long we are driving and of course bringing the dogs. I would like to hang out with our dogs in their house and ideally stay in their house but I am pretty apprehensive. Here’s the dog breakdown:
My dogs:
- 2.5 year old Rottweiler x Bulldog/Redbone Coonhound mix Mina, who will have just finished chemotherapy when we go to stay. Nina is very friendly with humans, and decent with dogs although she can get over excited. She is 80lbs.
- 9 year old pit mix Merle. He is great with humans but aloof with dogs. He doesn’t like being approached by them and is defensive. But if they ignore him he ignores them. When I first got him and took him to dog parks he did okay until the age of 2, then didn’t like it anymore. He started to do this thing where he’d flip on his back and then when a dog approached to smell his belly he’d leap up and snarl at them like a sneak attack. He has mellowed out though a lot now that he’s older. It only took a few days for him to adjust when we got Mina last summer. He is 60lbs.
My parents dogs:
- Teddy, a 6year old doodle who is highly energetic, maybe 50lbs. Friendly with people and dogs.
- Rudy, a 6 year old not doodle but some sort of poodle mix, I’m not sure. Maybe with shepherd? HIGHLY neurotic. Vets have told my mom he is the most neurotic dog they’ve ever seen. He was even on Prozac for a while but my mom took him off of it. Friendly with people. Maybe 40lbs.
- Rain, a 4 year old French bulldog recently rescued from a puppy mill. She was a breeder and is pretty sweet although has some behavior problems from life in a cage such as eating poop. She also antagonizes the other dogs a bit. Around 30lbs.
When Rain was introduced Teddy and Rudy started to fight, as my parents had to wait to get her spayed. It got pretty vicious a few times to the point Teddy needed stitches.
My brothers dog:
My brother lives next door and he has a 7 year old doodle named Lacey, she is 70lbs and the sweetest teddy bear girl you can imagine. Totally chill. Rides on planes no problem, never barks or has accidents. She could be the dog that visits children in a hospital. My brother frequently opens the gate between their houses and lets Lacey run over there, so really my parents house is a pack of 4 dogs although on paper they only have three. Lacey will often go over and eat dinner at my parents house, and my brother is often going on weekend trips or partying so Lacey is at my parents house all the time.
The situation:
So, my brother has driven to my place twice last year, and stayed for 2 weeks each time. He brought Lacey and Lacey and Mina loved each other! Merle would ignore Lacey, raise lip if she got close but the three of them could walk together fine, hike off leash fine, and eat next to each other no problems. By the end of the two weeks each time Merle would start really warming up and they would be closer every day, even cuddling together a few times briefly by the end. But when he saw her the second time he did not remember her, and the process had to start all over again. When he met her the second time he actually nipped her leg (no skin broken). Mina was 1.5 at this time.
So I know they can all get along, but I am worried that now that Mina is past 2 her personality is more settled, I know that dogs can become less friendly with other dogs at this age. So she is a bit of a wildcard. But I don’t want to stay in my brothers house because he will have a newborn.
So that leaves my parents…I have begged them to get dog training before and they refuse. But the dogs kind of rule the house over there. My mom has become agoraphobic because Rudy is so neurotic and they all freak out when left alone. Rain also broke her shoulder recently from playing too hard with the bigger dogs and will have just finished the 8 weeks of recovery so there is some concern with Mina and Rain since Mina is the largest of all the dogs. When people come to the house the dogs bum rush the door and jump all over people entering. My mom stopped going grocery shopping and switched to delivery because it became too difficult for her to carry groceries inside while the dogs were freaking out jumping all over her. My parents have a yard and a pool but they don’t walk their dogs, ever. So the dogs have a lot of energy. They do run around the yard and jump in the pool and swim around on their own but that is it. So they are not really leash trained.
When we reintroduced Lacey to Mina and Merle we had happened to have a dog trainer appt (we were working on Mina’s recall, which she does beautifully now 90% of the time) and the dog trainer really helped them be cool with each other, and pointed out some things to me about Merle’s body language which was much more defensive and stressed than I had realized.
So…my plan was to call some trainers in the area and see if someone would be willing to help us introduce our 2 dogs to their 4 dogs. And also dose everyone with gabapentin to ease tension. Is that something a trainer could help us with or based on this situation does it just sound like a nightmare waiting to happen and we should find somewhere else to stay? My dad’s BFF has two dogs that he has brought over no problem (whippets) and all 6 ran around just fine. But I have a pit and Rottweiler, so if there’s a scrap it would be much more damaging than the whippets. I don’t want to see anyone hurt. But at the same time, 4 weeks is a long time and I feel like with a little effort everyone could get along.
Extra info: my dogs are trained with an e collar. Merle especially fears the collar as he has noise phobia. So if I make it make a beeping sound it would stop all aggression in its tracks.
TLDR: my parents have 4 dogs that are mostly neurotic poodle mixes and uncontrolled but okay with other dogs. I have a rott mix and pit mix that are semi-trained, not the best with other dogs but respond well to e collar. Would a trainer be helpful to introduce all the dogs or is trying to create a temporary 6 pack a bad idea?