r/DraculasCastle • u/Oh-no-and-knuckles • 6h ago
Discussion Discussing the "gaiden" status of Konami Kobe's games
I don't know why certain fans are so upset about the "gaiden" status of Konami Kobe's games.
Their games were not trying to establish continuity with previous titles, CotM doesn't even share the same timeline as 64.
The main timeline connects titles that share continuity with each other, what's so controversial about excluding titles that were conceived as standalone stories?
When asked about it multiples times, IGA always stated that he did that following the intentions of their directors.
Interviewer: I realize this might be a difficult question to answer, but is it accurate to interpret the third Gameboy game "Castlevania: Legends" as a parallel world created by the staff at KCE Nagoya at the time?
IGA: While works such Castlevania 64 and Circle of the Moon are treated as "gaiden", according to their creators' intentions, this particular work does not fit that category no matter how you look at it. So I think that interpretation is correct.
-GAME SIDE Vol.16
With the label "gaiden" IGA means an alternate timeline with the same worldview logic as the main timeline.
There's an interview which shows that the director of 64 (Yuji Shibata) was well aware about Richter's story taking place in 1792, and yet, in the final game you have Dracula resurrecting after 100 years, in 1852.
I'm quoting a very early interview here. The initial plans were to have the plot take place around the same timeframe as Richter or Alucard's stories (around 1792, these are the director's words), and even then, he mentioned the detail about 64 Dracula awakening after 100 years.
First of all, having two inheritors of the Belmont destiny and the Holy Whip at the same time doesn't make much sense. Second, even if it took place after SotN, and you were supposedly following that game's story, you have to keep in mind that Richter passing the whip to the Morris family after the events of the game was already a plot point.
Reinhardt went by the name of "Schneider Belmont" back then, it wasn't changed to "Reinhardt Schneider" due to timeline consistency or anything; it was done because some fans sent letters to the developers telling them that "Schneider" is actually a surname, so they did a little naming contest.
A kid literally proposed "Bruce Belmont", but at the end "Reinhardt Schneider" won the contest.
Even without resorting to official statements or anything, you can still see that the game's story is standalone simply by playing the game (and paying attention to the story).
Not following RoB and SotN timeline-wise is the clearest example, and the director being well aware about the date in which Richter's story took place is pretty much the nail in the coffin.
These games' consistency is found in terms of atmosphere (while featuring an unique flavor), tropes, gameplay flow, and music, since, of course, it's still a Castlevania game.
I really don't get why categorizing a title that don't attempt to establish continuity with previous entries as "gaiden" or "non-canon" is seen this negatively, as if it was something done out of spite to "demote" them. Being "canon" is not a badge of superiority, nor is being the opposite one of inferiority.
Is this information still obscure? People don't pay attention to the dialogues? Are fandom myths yet to die?
"IGA decanonized Konami Kobe's games" is one of the most common statements you can see in this community, despite being one of the series' biggest misconceptions, so much that it recently bled into official materials with Belmont's Curse writer Matthew Willis stating in one of his Reddit comments that many titles in the series were "retconned".
I'd like to hear your opinions on the matter, in general, I really don't get why some people tend to get so salty about this.
P.S. The second image is from the vol. 20 of the official Konami Magazine.
The article is annoucing Circle of the Moon, the text states that the games' story takes place in a timeline different from that of the Belmont and Morris families, but despite that, its core conflict still remains the battle between mankind and Dracula (perfectly fitting IGA's definition of "gaiden").