r/DungeonMasters • • Feb 22 '25

New Space for DMs & GMs to Connect – Discussion, Resources, & More!

26 Upvotes

Hello, fellow Dungeon Masters and Game Masters!

This subreddit is under new management, and we’re excited to create a fresh space for all of us who run games in Pathfinder, Dungeons & Dragons and other systems to connect, share ideas, ask questions, and support one another. Whether you’re running a campaign, preparing an adventure, or simply looking for advice, this is the place for you.

Here’s what you can expect from the subreddit moving forward:

  • Discussion & Questions: Got a tricky encounter you need help with? Or just want to bounce around ideas for your next session? Ask away!
  • Resources: Share homebrew content, encounter ideas, adventure hooks, or other helpful resources for fellow DMs and GMs.
  • Friday Promotional Posts: Want to share your campaign material, online game services, or other relevant promotional content? Feel free to post it on Fridays only, and please use the "Promotional" flair when posting.

We’ve also updated the community rules and flairs to better organize content and improve our discussions. Please be sure to check out the rules and use the new flairs as needed to help keep the space running smoothly.

This is a space for everyone—whether you’re a veteran DM, new to the GM role, or anywhere in between. Let’s build a supportive community for those who craft the worlds we play in!


r/DungeonMasters • • 2h ago

Discussion Accidental TPK. Never again.

24 Upvotes

Hi !

I've been DMing for a few years now. But I have always used my own homebrew systems. Now that I have more time, I tried to learn DND's.

However, this has lead to a little issue...

I accidentally misunderstood the CR system.

My level one party of six players just tried killing a Cyclops (CR 6).

My understanding was that the combined level of the party members must roughly be equal to the monster's CR.

I must have been tired, because I was very surprised when I rolled for damage and one-shotted the paladin first turn.

Welp. I'm an idiot. Hopefully my players know I'm knew and they forgave me... But never again ;-;

(My English is probably bad, sorry)

Edit: I think I missunderstood the acronym TPK. I just realised it meant total PARTY kill and not total PLAYER kill. I thought it was for when you one shot a player. So that's a woopsie on my part here. Sorry


r/DungeonMasters • • 1h ago

Resource Hand-drawn, paper & ink clifftop battlemaps

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 10h ago

DM's you do not need to ask your players for a backstory before you start rolling dice.

27 Upvotes

So some backstory about me first.

  • Over 25 years playing Forever DM (hate being a player
  • Run multiple systems, DnD is my least favorite mechanically but my fav for storytelling in a world with dragons and elves
  • I generally run homebrew campaigns set in my own worlds (unless it's a system like Cthulu or WOD, or Cyberpunk in which case its on earth with my own flavor to the history and situation)
  • 3 bullet points, tells you all you need to know about me that is pertinent to this post.

Over the years I have seen a raft of posts on Reddit from DM's lamenting the lack of detail in characters back stories, or having to prompt, or wait. I am going to be a bit harsh here, but, as a DM/GM the story creation is on you. Especially the opening 5-10 sessions, if you are reliant on your players giving you hooks and story threads then stop and think.

3 -5 Bullet points is the only thing I need from my players before session 1. I don't need a raft of backstory or history, I don't need to know parents names, or if they are living or dead, I don't need to know there characters deep dark secrets in order to make session 1 happen.

All I need are.

  • Why is your character in the place we are starting (one sentence)
  • What about your characters personality will make them stop what they are doing and follow the thread of whatever story I put in front of them (inquisitive mind, need to prove themselves etc)
  • What is one fear your character has (emotional fear not physical)
  • If your character saw someone in danger, and saving them would put themselves in danger and risk of death, what would they do.
  • If a fight was brewing but not yet started would your character be the first to swing a punch, try and talk out of it, or do something else.

This is to allow the player to understand the very basics of what there character is in the kind of situations they will be put in in sessions 1-3

Yes it can be rewarding and fun to weave a characters story into your own campaign in time, but it is also really fun to create a campaign that has nothing to do with your players characters back stories,

In the past I have found (and the few times I have been a player this is my prefered approach), that getting into the skin of my character is the most important thing before I even think about backstories. I will come to session 1 knowing nothing of my characters history, and just a vague sense of the kind of person they are. Then as time progresses I will figure out what and who they are.

Do they have parents? Session 1 have no idea, Session 15 another character asks me about my parents, by that moment, maybe I have figured that out, or maybe I come up with the answer in the moment.

DM's stop putting pressure on your players to create a back story, especially when you hav a home brew world the player doesn't know. The number of times I have seen a DM complain that a player came along with a character concept that was out of place for the homebrew world the DM had in there own head. It doesn't matter how well you describe it, a one page outline will not get across to players what your world feels like, being in it, smelling it, walking in it in real sessions will.

So please, stop fixating on this idea that every character needs a backstory for your game to be fun, it really doesn't.


r/DungeonMasters • • 1h ago

Discussion Sanity check: 1 Wil-o-Wisp appropriate against 4 level 3 PCs?

2 Upvotes

Hey all,

My party is about to traverse a swamp and I need a sanity check on one of my encounters. They were warned not to leave the path, but will pass by a ruined wooden house where a light seems to be glowing on the 1st floor. Actually, it's a Wil-o-Wisp trying to lure prey.

The (single) CR2 Wil-O-Wisp would face a party of a level 3 paladin, cleric, fighter and warlock. I'll use the MM25 version, although the difference with the MM14 one is minor.

My worries are that the resistances, high AC, and versatile movement (both speed and passing through objects with Incorporeal Movement), and the fact the Warlock tends to use Fire Bolt rather than Eldritch Blast (for flavor) which makes those attacks resisted too.

The terrain provides ways for the wisp to break line of sight and use its movement to its advantage. I think the movement mitigates its action economy disadvantage.

Anyone ran this monster, and what were your experiences?

The monster fits well thematically but I don't want to risk a TPK here. 1 death is acceptable (and on the table with Consume Life).


r/DungeonMasters • • 7h ago

Resource Every Great Story Needs a Memorable Villain. | Extended Preview of Tome of Villains v2.0!

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

Behind a kingdom’s unrest, a spreading cult, or an army gathering at the border, someone is pursuing an ambition that could change the world. Who will your adventurers discover behind it all, and how far will they go to stop them?

The Tome of Villains is an illustrated compendium for 5E and 5.5E, spanning well over 100 pages of dangerous antagonists, sinister schemes, and resources for building memorable adventures. At its heart are 10 unique villains ranging from CR 3 to CR 30, from criminal masterminds and relentless assassins to ancient undead rulers and otherworldly conquerors.

Inside this compendium, you’ll find:

  • 10 fully developed villains, each with a complete statblock and dedicated sections exploring their background, ambitions, personality traits, flaws, methods, and more.
  • Plots, schemes, and adventure hooks to introduce the villains, reveal their influence, and draw the characters into their plans.
  • Minions, allies, and organizations, including additional creature statblocks and details on the forces supporting each antagonist.
  • Tactics, lairs, and strongholds, with selected villains featuring lair actions, regional effects, and distinctive mechanics that shape their encounters.
  • Guidance on defeating villains and exploring the aftermath, including opportunities to exploit weaknesses, undermine alliances, and deal with the consequences of their downfall.
  • Custom magic items, monster statblocks, and additional resources tied to the villains, their histories, and their powers.
  • 10 character backgrounds connecting adventurers to these antagonists as former followers, survivors, rivals, or enemies with unfinished business.
  • The Art of Villainy, an appendix exploring how to develop original antagonists, turn ambitions into schemes, establish their influence, and build memorable confrontations.
  • Five d20 villain creation tables, providing 100 entries covering ambitions, methods, personality traits, flaws, and weaknesses, accompanied by guidance on how to create memorable antagonists.

The manual just received a v2.0 update, introducing new artwork, revised mechanics, improved layouts, and additional content!

Black Friday Sale!

To celebrate Black Friday, Tome of Villains is currently 40% off, alongside all my other titles! The sale runs until the end of November, so it's a great opportunity to pick up any manuals you may be interested in at a discounted price.

You can also find Tome of Villains at an exclusive price on my Patreon! If you'd like to follow my work, you can also join my Patreon for free to get access to plenty of free previews, announcements, and regular updates on my current and upcoming projects!


r/DungeonMasters • • 3h ago

DREAMS OF A BETTER DAWN — EPISODE 4

Post image
0 Upvotes

The village grows quieter. Then sickness comes.

Soon, five twelve-year-olds may have no choice but to spread their wings.

“Spreading our Wings” — Rolemaster Actual Play.

https://youtu.be/sKdHe1LywAg


r/DungeonMasters • • 3h ago

DMs, how would you recommend me running this one-shot?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 3h ago

Help me tie a few plot elements together.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 4h ago

DMing for local drop-in groups: How do you have the energy?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 5h ago

Hiding information behind rolls

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 6h ago

Discussion Need ideas for 'second phase' Boss

0 Upvotes

Completely home-brew campaign, and I'm just getting to my first boss.

He's more or less just a noble who has a militia that will be the 'main threat' for the first phase.

Second phase, however, sees him transformed into a monster.

These monsters are a mixture of undead and Shadows (both thematically and in their stat blocks).

In the briefest way possible, the world is being infected by a mysterious black shadowy-sludge. Normal people can get turned into these angry, hollow monsters by exposure to the sludge or things connected to it. This boss (who doesn't like the PCs) has done secret research into the sludge, and so has had a sort of 'mega exposure' to it, so I want to make him, well, into a boss version of these monsters.

My three players are only level 3. They've only really come across the weakest versions of these monsters so far, but this fight is the herald for what is to come. The main threat will then shift from the militia to the big ol' shadowy, angry monster.

The ones they've fought so far are AC 8, <20 HP, basic simple weapon attacks, like zombies. The only features they do have are Undead Fortitude and Life Drain.

Not sure what I want the vibe of the boss monster to be yet, which is why I'm hoping to get some inspiration from you guys - does anyone know of any pre-existing monsters that would fit the bill of a shadowy, undead, were-animal type beastie? Or any ideas for what features could be good for it?

Thanks in advance!


r/DungeonMasters • • 1d ago

Resource Lynoir - City of Pearl by Rustymaps

Post image
48 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 4h ago

Starting my journey as a ''pro'' gm.

0 Upvotes

Hello there ladies and gentlemen , im Chris and after 10 years of gming experience in ttrpg's i took the decision to shift it and start making a living out of it starting slowly of course.Any tips you can give me?Thing is i am overpreparing myself i believe with maps , music(thanks god pocket bard exists) , wether to launch my own custom world , start with a module or maybe some oneshots first to get some positive reviews.Got around 7 five star reviews from my old players , will be posting on startplaying.games.


r/DungeonMasters • • 8h ago

Version 1.1.0 Released! - Character Printing Options for Offline Play

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 9h ago

Need some advice

1 Upvotes

So i have a player that finally reached level 9 in his inventor level (a new class i had from 3rd party). He wanted to take an upgrade that gives his golem he made sentient (between his abilities and his cleric deity). I wanted to add a twist. Currently the golem is holding an anchor (flavored flail) he got when they took down a warlock pirate. I was thinking that when he gives the golem sentience the pirates soul takes over from the cursed anchor and they have to figure out how to remove it. Im just figuring out how I can set that up and how would they remove him. Any fun ideas?


r/DungeonMasters • • 20h ago

New DM Looking for Advice

7 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I am new to DMing and honestly still pretty new to D&D. Regardless, I find myself running a Discord server for games that appears to be gaining steam. I got quite lucky in that a almost immediately found about 10-15 players that I enjoyed playing with and that seem to be invested. So far I have been running oneshots that have been in a shared world. Plan to put together a few short campaigns that keep the same group through a bigger arc, but still exists in the shared world. Also plan on opening up the server for others to DM some games.

I imagine this is a fairly common setup, but would love some direction if someone has run something similar. Would also be curious what pitfalls I should be looking out for, as I have already grown pretty fond of my setup and group. Being so inexperienced, I am sure there are some things I should be doing different / better that I am simply unaware of yet.

Much appreciated!

EDIT: I am running a community of 10-15 people. Any given game seats 4-6.


r/DungeonMasters • • 1d ago

Is this a hot take? I think maybe I prefer new players to experienced ones.

45 Upvotes

I’m going to preface this by saying I’m basing this on my experience with only one group so obviously it’s not a valid sample size and I’m returning to roleplaying after a long hiatus so I have changed. “Changed” may be code for “gotten old and grumpy.”

Also a better way to express what the impression I’ve came to is “It’s easier to gather a group of people that are fun to be around and teach them to play an RPG than it is to find a group of gamers that are fun to be around.” Part of this may be that I live in a smallish town and a lot of people in the RPG community have let’s say … big personalities.

I guess I would rather be reminding someone for the third time to add his strength bonus than reminding them not to talk over people. Or telling a grown man that he should not show up smelling like a homeless person. Or telling a rules lawyer that I’ll gladly discuss it between sessions, but we aren’t putting things on hold because he wants to argue.

Not really trying to convince you of this is you have had different experiences, but I am curious if anyone else has come to this same conclusion.


r/DungeonMasters • • 1d ago

Ravenloft Village

Post image
25 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 16h ago

What would you add or change about these city factions in a Celtic-Italian City-Island-State? Round Two - Subfactions, Important Members, and Unofficial Factions

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 20h ago

Resource The (Barovian) Laughing Salesman - Art by Morrigains [OC] [Art]

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 1d ago

Resource [OC] [Art] Something fell from the sky, you decide what it is.

Post image
10 Upvotes

Near the banks of a river, you find a crater that still looked fresh. In my first version of this map, I put a wounded dragon at the bottom. Anyway, let your imaginations run and have fun. Perhaps, whatever fell had already ran away and those little yellow wisps are sprites that saw the whole thing!


r/DungeonMasters • • 1d ago

Help finding maps

2 Upvotes

Hello fellow dms, I am running a siege of a city as a big part of the finale of the first arc of a campaign, and I had imagined running like a dungeon, where each "room" is a section of the city "the outer farmland and town, the southern gate, the market, etc." Any ideas where to find battle maps for all this? It's a medieval fantasy Europe analog.


r/DungeonMasters • • 1d ago

Resource We Just Released 300+ Mythological Magic Items for D&D 5E & 5.5E! Here's a Huge Preview of Our New Book!

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

After months of work and a successful Kickstarter campaign, we're really excited to share that Mythological Items is finally available on DriveThruRPG!

For this project, we wanted to bring some of the most fascinating weapons, artifacts, and magical objects from real-world mythology into D&D, giving them their own mechanics while staying faithful to the legends that inspired them.

The result is a collection of 300+ mythological magic items for both D&D 5E and 5.5E, drawing inspiration from Greek, Norse, Egyptian, Asian, American, and many other mythological traditions.

You'll find everything from lesser-known magical curiosities to legendary artifacts wielded by gods and heroes, including items such as Mjolnir, Atena's Aegis, Hermes' Winged Sandals, Draupnir, the Book of Thoth, and many more!

The book also includes scaling magic items that grow alongside your characters, sets of interconnected artifacts with additional powers, and items of every rarity, from uncommon to artifact. We wanted to make sure there was something for every stage of a campaign, rather than focusing exclusively on extremely powerful legendary equipment.

We've included a bunch of preview pages in this post, so you can take a look at the artwork, layout, and mechanics of some of the items before deciding whether the book is for you!

And since Black Friday is here, all our other titles are currently discounted on DriveThruRPG! This includes our collections of magic items, monsters, subclasses, spells, companions, and more. Our complete bundle of creations is also available at 55% off, if you're interested in exploring the rest of our work!

We're incredibly grateful to everyone who supported the Kickstarter and helped us bring this project to life. We hope you'll enjoy looking through the previews, and we'd love to hear which mythological artifacts you'd be most excited to introduce into your campaigns!

Thanks for checking it out, and happy adventuring!