r/ECEProfessionals • u/teleskopez • 6m ago
Professional Development The Head of my social constructivist program called me a 'natural'
[A little context: I was hired late in the cycle for a part-time position, offered and took a full-time resource position when it opened up a month later, and have been working at this program for about three months total.]
Am I crazy for being genuinely kind of unsettled about this? I feel like this is the kind of conversation many would want from their Head of School: external validation, a tacit near-job offer ("what are you thinking of for the next few years? what grades?"), an offer to fund my further education, and a genuine request for feedback ("nothing leaves this room," "tell me some things I might not know about the program").
Maybe I'm being too dichotomous so I want to run this by others to check myself. I see two basic ways to read this:
1.) My Head thinks I'm pretty good at this but is trying to subtly nod toward my comparative lack of experience and education, while offering financial help to complete my degree as the 'path forward.' I'm not gonna look a gift horse in the mouth or anything and I'm grateful for this opportunity after a violent crime and Covid derailed my last year at university, but still. This reading would mean the Head is effectively saying "yeah, you've got decent instincts, but stop acting like you know a lot."
Bluntly put, when I join an esteemed program and see the teachers being generally uninterested in or unable to ask open-ended questions, maintain their composure, read behavior as communication instead of sabotage (!!!!), kindly hold boundaries, name/guess emotions in children, operate on the children's level for more than two minutes at a time, etc., I start to feel like I do know at least a thing or two. So yeah if this was meant as functionally a put-down I'd be a bit frustrated, but sincerely it's the alternative I'm worried about, which is that...
2.) My Head genuinely believes that things as complex as pedagogy, social-emotional learning, or child development broadly have 'naturals' and not...learned people. I'm not trying to be full of myself, but seriously, professional growth will always happen over the course of years, so aptitude quickly becomes about what you can do with a year before consideration of how many years you've been doing it. I was frank and said, to the best of my recollection: "well, I'm not a natural. My practice was sculpted by my instructors and mentors, then more and more over time, by me, every single day, when I write, reflect, and read." It's easy to understand this through the lens of my own ego, but my ultimate concern is how the institution thinks of professional learning in general. I'm not mad or judgmental toward my colleagues for lacking certain skills I take for granted due to the unique circumstances of my entry to the field, but I could grow to be frustrated with my administration for failing to train them in skills that really aren't that hard to grow once pointed out (I feel most I mentioned above are a first six months in the field sort of fare).
The most senior people in the preschool program have taught here for about five years, the program director has been here fewer than two, and that's about the time the Head of School has been around, too. It's been a tumultuous go since Covid, it would seem, though of course I don't know the half of it. How much should I read into this? I know it seems pedantic, but I've worked places where we consciously trained ourselves not to conceive of 'naturals' at anything because there's nothing to gain and some to lose in doing so. This comes in light of the Head of School giving a brief presentation on classroom composure in orientation, during which she said, "but at the end of the day, you just need to remember that you're in control of the classroom." I've worked with a fair amount of teachers and children at this point; never met one who's gotten anything but more stress, rupture, personal and classroom dysregulation from the idea that they have 'control' over others. Influence, but not control. Again, it's just words...but is it?
If it needs saying I have a different sort of tone when I'm actually speaking to administrators at my school, but I want to ask lastly: how can I continue to point out challenges and problems in the program, which I feel can be found totally non-judgmentally, that are in fact part and parcel of there being a program at all without coming off as a pain in the ass or a nag or pedant or know-it-all? My interests don't lie in litigating the particulars of my Head's speech, but seeing as I have limited exposure to my Head's thought, I'm going to take her words seriously. I imagine someone in such a position would have to understand this is the nature of this sort of leadership role.
I admittedly live in fear because I wore out my welcome quickly at another program years ago overestimating how aligned my values and the directors' were + how much they valued my opinion. They took on a really defensive stance, sort of pointing to (absolutely rigged) votes about how it's the best local program, and just kind of simplifying everything to "the program is Good, so the things that happen here are Good." So when I pointed out, totally innocently, and only in hopes of serving the children a developmentally appropriate curriculum, that a classroom of young three year olds was being made to sit in front of a whiteboard and go through every letter in the alphabet for twenty minutes, without prior scaffolding, it was taken as a grave offense, not probably because the director thought that was actually appropriate, but because it was precocious old me who /dared/ to say so. Thanks for any input or advice, I know this post is not exactly well-focused.