r/EDH • • 3h ago

Discussion Need Advice for Dealing with Pod Bullying

0 Upvotes

Hi All,

I am looking for some advice in dealing with a dynamic in my pod I'm currently playing weekly in. I believe I'm being unfairly targeted and I could use some input from other EDH players. Using my throwaway to post.

Some context:

I've been playing mtg since 2015 and EDH since C17 came out. I'm not a great player by any means, but I've been playing long enough to understand dynamics and threats and assessment and all that.

I started playing this year with 2 new friends after moving city. They've only been playing about a year and are good guys. I've taken to playing more low bracket and janky decks with them. Games are longer, but it's a good time.

Recently, a friend of theirs has joined us as a 4th, let's call him Kevin. He has been playing edh for a while. I'm guessing almost as long as me. Anyway, it feels like he keeps targeting me, and the result is always me not getting close to winning. Don't get me wrong, I understand I should only be winning up to a quarter of my games, but this seems to be with him in the group, I can only ever lose.

For example,

#1

I've played a durdly trostani life gain deck one game. It plays 1 or 2 creatures a turn, and passes. No GC, no aetherflux, it just, gains life. My ramp pieces are 3 CMC, there are 5 board wipes in the deck, etc. He played landfall that game. He managed to get over 80 power on board, and with the rest of our life totals at 20 or less, with the exception of mine at 60, and just full swing at me. And I get it, I had the highest life total, but one of the other players had lethal commander damage on him on their turn.

#2

Another game, we had player hit about 100+ power on board and pass the turn, letting us very clearly know next combat he would win. So I attempted to win with life drain on my turn, only for him to remove a piece of that engine. Obviously he proceeds to pass and then we all lose to other guy.

Like i get it, both these examples, it seems kinda understandable to come after me, but also it's not the best play. The hard part here is the other guys are newer and don't really see it and there is enough plausible deniability of specific targeting that how do I bring it up at the time? He also tends to politics against me. Like: "take him out or he'll do something" type of thing. And yes I will proceed to play a strong card or something, but it's EDH, we are all going to do something (?). But you see what I'm saying, after I do play the card, he gets very "I told you so". But then he proceeds to win on his turn or something like that.

Either way, game results are him winning half the time, or the others winning the other half.

So I'm asking what should I do? Like do I just dial up the power and fight fire with fire and go at him and leave the others alone and play the same game he is? Or do I go the other way and bust out bracket 1 pauper decks and just make it very apparent I'm being bullied?

Let me know.

EDIT:

I'll add some additional context as my game examples were recent and, as mentioned, there is plausible deniability.

I met Kevin first at a board game night with the 2 others and their greater group of friends. We played a bluffing game, similar to werewolves or Amongus. He specifically came after me. Like in a way that is "I don't care what else is going on, I am getting you voted out." The strangest thing about this was I literally just met him 30 minutes prior.

Spoiler: I wasn't a "werewolf".

We have now played about 16 or so games all together. I have not won a single one. He's won about half, and the others have gone to either of the other guys. He specifically ether wins, or burns resources to prevent me from winning. Prior to him joining us 3. I would win about a quarter of the games.

EDIT2:

Example #3, as there was too much nuance in the previous 2 about me being a threat (it's EDH, we're all trying to win)

I played an artifact deck (fallout energy -mostly- precon), he played an grixis spell slinger deck with recursion as a theme. One of the others is playing dragons, he had the opportunity, for 3 turns in a row, to either remove a key dragon, or board wipe. He vandalblasts every single time. Which, after the first one, was entirely just a one sided wipe on me as tried to rebuild. Dragon player won.


r/EDH • • 22h ago

Deck Help New player, Stumbled onto Kaalia as my first Commander

2 Upvotes

Im having a bit of a problem. When going to make my first custome deck I wanted to run an angels and demons tribal, it sounded like a fun flavor to try. A friend of mine suggested using Kaalia as a commander, knowing nothing, I saw her ability and her art and was 100% in on that idea (lmao).

I have rebuilt the deck many times and have experienced the, what i now know, are common kaalia things. Being targeted by everyone, not enough mana, needing protection, etc.

In response to all of that I have dug around the internet and have upgraded the deck considerably in order to shore up those defenses, only to realize the deck may be a little strong for my pod potentially.

So the issue im having is can I even play Kaalia in a B2/B3 environment? What i mean is either im too weak and dont get to really play, or feel so strong that im enemy number one and no one is having fun lol.

I will post my decklist if that helps:

https://moxfield.com/decks/c5LpXpfpBkym1HZ5itO5dA

I really like this commander, but im starting to feel myself min/max and im not trying to stomp my friends every game (not that this actually happens). Im sure most people will suggest removing MOC, and this is something I have debated heavily. I almost never use it, so its wasted space, but the idea of using it to win feels like a fun concept.


r/EDH • • 19h ago

Discussion EDH players seemingly want the game to be midrange soup

197 Upvotes

I was having a conversation after last night’s weekly commander night with friends, and someone brought up how the average LGS random seems to complain about most archetypes that aren’t some form of slow, generic midrange “Simic value engine” style of deck. Aggro and control are deemed to be too mean despite being perfectly valid archetypes.

Then if someone brings a generic value engine deck to the table, whiny players still complain because it’s “boring and unoriginal”. You’re damned if you do and damned if you don’t with this game. I seriously think a good portion of the player base hates Magic but feels too invested to find another hobby.


r/EDH • • 20h ago

Discussion How to Build a Perfectly Balanced Commander Deck With Only 120 Cards

0 Upvotes

Every responsible Commander deck runs at least 20 pieces of interaction. It also needs to win through fair combat damage, which takes roughly 40 cards that make creatures, pump creatures, or politely explain to creatures how to get past a 1/1.

Then add 38 lands, 12 ramp spells, and 10 draw spells. You now have a perfectly responsible 120-card deck.

If you cut interaction, you're the reason games get out of hand. If you cut creatures, you're the reason games take three hours. If you cut lands, you're the reason we have a sign.

Some people tell me there isn't room for all of this. I explain that they can't cut lands, because then they won't hit their drops. They can't cut ramp, because then they're too slow. They can't cut draw, because then they run out of gas. They can't cut creatures, because then they can't win, and they can't cut interaction, because then nobody else can. So they'll just have to figure it out.

I keep up removal when I'm ahead, when I'm behind, and when I'd really like to cast a creature. Sometimes I draw creature removal against a spellslinger deck. That's fine. I can look across the table at the exact permanent I could have killed and know that, under slightly different circumstances, I would have been an asset to the pod.

Some players run less interaction and try to win before the scary permanent matters. I once watched a man respond to a scary permanent by untapping and winning. We asked him to leave. There's a time and place to end a game of Commander, and it's after we've all agreed the scary permanent has been dealt with.

Tymna/Kraum gets to run a pile of interaction because its win condition fits in a coat pocket. Two cards win the game, and nearly everything else gets to be an answer. That's why our pod banned compact win conditions. Now everyone has to win like a green deck and interact like a blue one, regardless of color identity.

One guy tried cutting lands to make room for his attackers and his removal. We tapped the sign: 38 LANDS MINIMUM. He asked how he was supposed to win like a stompy deck while holding up answers like a control deck.

We asked him to leave. Last I heard, he's on Tymna/Kraum now, running 25 lands and winning on turn four. Some people just don't want to play balanced games of Commander.


r/EDH • • 2h ago

Question Why isn't sol ring banned/ a gamechanger?

0 Upvotes

Yes, there's the whole "invalidate all precons" argument, but swapping out 1 card for like a talisman or another mana rock isn't the end of the world. Wotc can just start by leaving out sol rings from precons for like around 10-ish years, then implement restrictions on the card, which should soften the impact on the market.

I mean, we have to start somewhere for a card as busted AND as common as sol ring.


r/EDH • • 16h ago

Question Half of my pod says my Teshar is Bracket 5 the other half say 4 I need the councils opinion

0 Upvotes

https://moxfield.com/decks/ftmfAaQ9eHm-k4t9wjTnow

I am one year into Magic yay. So i made this Teshar deck fully intending it to be bracket 4 however half of my pod says its a 5 due to being able to turn 4 win. Now to be fair this bracket system wile seemingly simple on the surface acually for me is a bit allover the place and I dont understand it well I though Cedh was like turn 2 wins and such im just looking for calcification.


r/EDH • • 11h ago

Discussion X-Spells as Win Conditions

4 Upvotes

Hi folks! You're probably tired of 'what bracket is my deck?' conversations, but I was curious to hear what the general consensus is on where to draw the line between bracket 2 and 3 with regards to how telegraphed win conditions are.

One of the commonly shared graphics for brackets says that bracket 2 win conditions should be incremental, telegraphed on board and easily disruptable, whereas bracket 3 should have win conditions that can be played from hand in one turn, usually because of steadily accrued resources. I've heard people say that big x-spells are a good way to end the game for bracket 2, but is there a case that a large X spell that finishes the game is played from the hand in one turn and therefore bracket 3? Would the answer to this change if the spell was played at instant speed with [[Quicken]]? Or if a large [[Entreat the Angels]] was cast at instant speed in the previous players end step?

I'm not arguing that planning to win with [[Exsanguinate]] should make your deck bracket 3, and I know that the brackets are just a conversation starter for your pod, but I can't explain very well why a game-winning [[Debt to the Deathless]] is within the spirit of bracket 2. Is the idea that if you can't do it before turn 8, it's fair game?

Any thoughts?


r/EDH • • 20h ago

Discussion In which bracket would you put this deck ?

0 Upvotes

decklist

https://archidekt.com/decks/28410969/jace_multiverse_storm_architect

---
basically this deck is a prismari the inspiration deck wrapper but using [Jace, Multiverse Architect] as commander


r/EDH • • 9h ago

Deck Showcase Ms. Rumbleflower

0 Upvotes

Hey :)

Please rate/rank my Br4 Ms. Bumbleflower (Pet-Deck): https://archidekt.com/decks/9205654 i tried to give it a comprehensive primer…

I bought the precon on the „Commandfest“ in Frankfurt in 2024 and upgraded, foiled and also got some signatures till then. I own those exakt artworks.

Greetings
Ben


r/EDH • • 9h ago

Discussion Looking for a specific combo in Temur

0 Upvotes

TLDR: Looking to be able to tutor for Omniscence, Plat Angel, Darksteel Forge, K'Vort-Class Raider (Or Lightning Greaves, tbh), an extra-turn card, Walls of Ba Sing Se, Veil of Summer, and Worldslayer.

It occurs to me that it would just be easier to tutor for Omniscence and Enter the Infinite, but I'm willing to entertain other sequences that let me use Omniscence to let me dump an indestructible, hexproof board, untap, and swing to destroy everyone else's everything while everything of mine remains intact, all while my stuff can't be countered.


r/EDH • • 4h ago

Question Hearthstone player here, which deck should i play?

3 Upvotes

I'm an hearthstone player and sometimes I play yugi too, i'm approaching the magic world right now with commander because I have some friends that play it and seems so fun. What deck should I start with? I like control decks in almost every card game I've played and I want a deck that is strong, not meme. What's you suggestions?

Thank you anyways


r/EDH • • 18h ago

Discussion The strongest deck in our LGS is 60 dollars.

437 Upvotes

We play with proxies, so cost isn’t an object. People bring duals, game changers, all of that stuff. Most decks are some high bracket 3 nonsense. And yet… the best deck is my sister’s [[Naru Meha]], which has a net value of 60 dollars. It’s an extremely simple deck. It accrues small draws here or there, counters every thing under the sun that’s a threat, and then by the time she’s counted to 7 mana, the almost always one of the A + B combos that Naru Meha has to win. She basically guarantees I always have to mulligan for a counter spell or two. And I found it funny how a ton of people in our LGS don’t see her board as anything scary so they don’t target her and if they do then they can’t whittle her down fast enough. The deck on paper should be at a massive disadvantage, it doesn’t even have any game changers, but I’ve seen it win again and again. Have any of you guys seen such a phenomenon? A budget deck that punches far far beyond its weight class?


r/EDH • • 2h ago

Social Interaction A stinky experience…

32 Upvotes

OMG - went to a newly opened LGS that I really enjoy (2nd time here and will be back next month), but holy crap!

I was playing with, what I thought was a family - husband/wife, their kid and a friend. All adult age.

Their kid, who seemed early 20’s had something wrong with his ass - homie was letting out a series of silent farts the entire two hours we were there.

It was the most foul thing I ever smelled.

Being a new LGS, it isn’t well known yet, and it was the only pod there so I couldn’t get up to change tables.

It was like sitting next to a human [[Bojuka Bog]] - his tightie whities probably had a whole 8-lane highway instead of just skid marks…

I’ll probably be back at this place again next month when I go out to game again 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Anyone else ever sit next to a gaping asshole? And yes - his “family” was saying shit to him about his stank ass


r/EDH • • 18h ago

Deck Help Isshin Bracket 3 Discussion

0 Upvotes

https://archidekt.com/decks/27923061/isshi_issho

Hello,

I wanna build my "first" deck I´ll actually use and found Isshin to sound like a lot of fun

Ive watched multiple videos, post, decks etc. and learned you have to play him more as an aggro / go wide commander.

I tried to include some burn and token creation/interaction.

Would highly appreciate any type of help / improvements for this deck. It is a bit overwhelming finding the best cards for each categories but we´ll see.

I do not really wanna to above that 330$ mark

Thank you!


r/EDH • • 10h ago

Question I call upon the part of the magic community that knows the Anime/Manga Gachiakuta, for a deck idea.

4 Upvotes

So I am a commander player and Artist and currently am building a commander deck for which I want to make costume artworks, but of course we aren't gonna just make random cards into random artworks.

This time I am going with {Mishra, tamer of Mak Fawa} as Rudo, keeper of the forgotten Things.

So the plan is gonna be like most Mishra decks Mill and Discard, as a reference to the Sphere throwing their trash down, and then we dig through that dirt and to find those artifacts/equipments to turn them into Jinki.

Here I am going to make the first alt artworks, so I am wondering if you guys have ideas for what Artifacts could fit for the Jinki Rudo has created/used in the anime and manga.

Secondly I also want to work in, some of Rudos friends, but I am having a lot of problems finding Cards that fit for them, so here I also wanna ask you, any suggestions to which cards could be them.

Right now the plan is to call the deck "Echoes of the Discarded" and I want to make it a mostly thematic deck, but it should also be playable in a chill pod with friends.


r/EDH • • 6h ago

Discussion Which Nauctis precons will you be buying, if any?

46 Upvotes

My favourite family of animals is sharks, so I will almost certainly be buying the Blood in the Water precon. Though I will hold out to see if there's a more interesting shark commander in the main set and possibly build around that instead.

I'm also very interested in Terrors of the Abyss and Seal the Deal, but I'm trying to build no more than one deck per set. So will have to see.

But I also understand not wanting to buy the precons, given that they've removed the borderless commanders and are selling it back to us as a premium product. If this were any other set, I would have been turned off by that, but this is literally my most anticipated in years.

But what about you all? Planning on buying one or more precons? Going to build something from the main set? Boycotting it entirely? Curious to hear!


r/EDH • • 17h ago

Deck Help Trying to build Picard into a B3 Spacewhip (typo but I'm keepin it) Swinger

0 Upvotes

Current build of the deck

I initially wanted to build a spaceship-focused deck with [[Dawnsire, Sunstar Dreadnought]] as a secret commander, triggering the +10 ability for stupid things like lifelinking 100 health or changing the target to players to nuke one/all with freakin lazer beamz. However, I want to run multiple spaceships in the deck and want to keep it available as as a finishing option. I started with Jimmy Wong's Picard and took my favorites from the Picard and Kilo precons, but I want to bump it a bracket to play more consistently and deflect the removal I know is coming.

Goals are:

- Hit people with spaceships, not creatures

- Have a lot of space/EOE/TRK theming

- Dawnsire does something stupid and fun because 100 damage goes brrrr

If you have any suggestions, let me know! Thanks!


r/EDH • • 31m ago

Discussion What's a card that is really good in one of your decks but your to lazy to go through all the effects?

0 Upvotes

For me it's Cathar Crusade in my Samwise Gamgee deck. It generates a whole lot off value. Especially with all the token creature generators but I just don't feel like keeping track off all the triggers and counters that I need to put on my creatures. So I'm curious. Does anyone else have a card like this?


r/EDH • • 3h ago

Question Deck Brewing

7 Upvotes

I’ve heard of top down: starting with the commander and building the deck around it.

I’ve heard of bottom up: starting with a mechanic and then finding a commander that fits.

But what about starting with a win con and trying to build the deck around that?

Any advice for how to get [[The Millennium Calendar]] to work as a viable win con in a casual commander deck is welcome.

I’ve got some proliferate and some extra beginning steps. I’m guessing a counter doubler maybe if it works for stuff other than +1/+1s.

Love to hear your ideas. Thanks!!!


r/EDH • • 23h ago

Question Ref themed deck

5 Upvotes

Hi good morning i hope this finds you all well.

I just got into magic a little bit ago. My friends and I all got precons on a whim and took over a local brewery and that was fun. I played some elemental guy. Like four colors.

Anyway. We're thinking about trying to do this again soon and one of us suggested making iur own decks and i immediately thought abiut my one true passion, hockey. And naturally there isnt a hockey themed commander deck and and i cant exactly use hockey cards instead. So as cool as it would be to rock up with a sid crosby commander deck i think that's going to have to wait.

What i was more intrested in was this blue/white/black or white/black decks where you kind of control how everyone plays and like make people pay more to do things and stuff and it felt very referee.

So long story short

Any suggestions for blue/white/black or white/black decks that could work as a ref themed deck? Money isnt really a concern im probably going to take all of the card text and badly photoshop hockey things in their place like my own personal secret lair.

Thank you for sitting with me for my very specific hyper fixation.


r/EDH • • 3h ago

Question Which merfolk cards should I grab before Nauctis drops in February?

0 Upvotes

I already preordered the merfolk precon and want to grab some extra merfolk singles before prices jump when Nauctis comes out in February. Which cards would you pick up now? Mainly looking for staples or anything you think is likely to spike once the set is out.

Any suggestions are appreciated!


r/EDH • • 11h ago

Deck Help Is this B4?? Muad’dib

0 Upvotes

https://moxfield.com/decks/LfGhAd_fF3SEnz0b4SGTfQ

just played a game with this. and it just seems really fast. i think i can consistently win on turn 6 and maybe get a win sooner, im not an underworld breach player and just won with a brain freeze and a lotus petal on my turn 6. this was the second game i played with it and the first i won with senseis top and just drawing my deck to then brain freeze everyone. so i have a feeling it is B4 just based on how fast its moving. i want to shift this to a more Lantern Control list. any suggestions on what i can do to accomplish that??


r/EDH • • 4h ago

Deck Help Hello i would like opinions on what braket this deck is and what kind of changes i should make

0 Upvotes

Being relatively new to the format, I'm not yet fully proficient in evaluating bracke power, So I would like more informed opinions. Thanks to everybudy in advanced

https://moxfield.com/decks/OCjM1bocTEeGT6Ma2Imrcg

1 Arachnogenesis (FDC) 187

1 Arcane Signet (C20) 237

1 Archdruid's Charm (MKM) 151

1 Balefang the Unslayable (MBC) 20

1 Blackcleave Cliffs (OTC) 272

1 Bloodthirsty Blade (C21) 235

1 Blooming Marsh (OTJ) 266

1 Boltwave (FDN) 79

1 Bramble Familiar / Fetch Quest (WOE) 164

1 Calculating Lich (CLB) 742

1 Call Damage Control (MSH) 162

1 Chandra's Ignition (FDC) 145

1 Command Tower (ELD) 333

1 Copperhorn Scout (SOM) 116

1 Copperline Gorge (ONE) 249

1 Crown of Doom (C14) 55

1 Cultivate (PLST) C18-138

1 Curse of Bounty (SCD) 178

1 Curse of Clinging Webs (MIC) 25

1 Curse of Disturbance (C21) 138

1 Curse of Hospitality (VOW) 152

1 Curse of Opulence (PLST) C17-24

1 Curse of Predation (C13) 140

1 Curse of Shallow Graves (PLST) C13-71

1 Curse of the Restless Dead (MIC) 18

1 Death Kiss (CLB) 675

1 Deathcap Cultivator (SOI) 202

1 Deathcap Glade (VOW) 261

1 Diamond Pick-Axe (LCI) 143

1 Dolmen Gate (SPG) 145

1 Evolution Charm (C20) 171

1 Evolving Wilds (PLST) C18-245

1 Exotic Orchard (C19) 242

1 Eye of Nidhogg (FIC) 44

1 Farseek (NCC) 290

1 Fog (30A) 189

10 Forest (J25) 95

1 Frontier Warmonger (CMM) 224

1 Garruk, Curse Breaker (FRA) 314

1 Ghoulish Impetus (SOC) 214

1 Harrow (PLST) C18-150

1 Havoc Eater (MKC) 31

1 Heroic Intervention (TRC) 465

1 Ignoble Hierarch (PLST) MH2-166

1 Incriminating Impetus (CLU) 35

1 Jund Panorama (ALA) 225

1 Kaima, the Fractured Calm (NEC) 3

1 Kang, Suspicious Captain (TRC) 71

1 Karplusan Forest (DMU) 250

1 Kodama's Reach (MMA) 151

1 Koloth, Tribble Hunter (TRC) 72

1 Life of the Party (NCC) 48

1 Llanowar Wastes (TDC) 376

1 M'Baku, Jabari Chieftain (MSC) 67

1 Marchesa's Decree (FDC) 113

1 Mirkwood Spider (LTR) 178

6 Mountain (J25) 90

1 Nature's Lore (CLB) 244

1 Obelisk of Jund (C13) 252

1 Parasitic Impetus (SOC) 222

1 Puppet Master, String Puller (MSC) 59

1 Rampant Growth (PLST) DDS-48

1 Return to Nature (ELD) 173

1 Revenge of Ravens (PLST) ELD-104

1 Roiling Regrowth (ZNR) 201

1 Savage Lands (MM3) 243

1 Shadowblood Ridge (NCC) 426

1 Shared Roots (SOA) 58

1 Shiny Impetus (C20) 55

1 Slumbering Dragon (M13) 148

1 Sol Ring (PLST) C18-222

4 Swamp (J25) 89

1 Swarmyard (BLC) 133

1 Tainted Peak (VOC) 184

1 Tenured Tethermage (FRA) 154

1 Terramorphic Expanse (CM2) 273

1 The Sound of Drums (WHO) 97

1 Twisted Landscape (MH3) 232

1 Twitching Doll (DSK) 201

1 Vengeful Ancestor (MKC) 163

1 Vernal Fen (EOC) 24

1 Warped Landscape (SOI) 280


r/EDH • • 10h ago

Discussion Ideas for an Elden Ring deck: G/W Arwen for Marika or Atraxa for Malenia?

0 Upvotes

So I really love building themed decks, especially ones based off videogames I enjoy (my flair is my attempt at replicating one of Shin Megami Tensei 3’s ending) and I’ve been wanting to do an Elden Ring deck for a while now.

Right now I’m considering two options, either [[Arwen, Mortal Queen]] as a stand-in for Queen Marika where I proliferate and distribute her indestructible counters to mimic Marika removing Destined Death from the land. The deck would probably be about creating an indestructible army with lots of different kinds of counters.

I’ve also considered [[Atraxa, Praetor’s Voice]] whose combination of abilities always seemed perfect for Malenia to me. This one will probably go the opposite of the Arwen deck where I instead distribute -1/-1 counts and possibly play around with Toxic & Infect.

I’ve also considered [[Inalla, Archmage Ritualist]] for Renalla but it’s kinda hard to turn that into an Elden Ring themed deck.

I’m open to any ideas or discussion! I really like Miquella and St.Trina too but I’m not sure who to play to serve as them. Miquella I can see with [[Eriette, the Beguiler]] or [[Yasiva Dragonclaw]] maybe…

Thank you for any help!