r/EDH • u/underscore_436 • 3h ago
Discussion Need Advice for Dealing with Pod Bullying
Hi All,
I am looking for some advice in dealing with a dynamic in my pod I'm currently playing weekly in. I believe I'm being unfairly targeted and I could use some input from other EDH players. Using my throwaway to post.
Some context:
I've been playing mtg since 2015 and EDH since C17 came out. I'm not a great player by any means, but I've been playing long enough to understand dynamics and threats and assessment and all that.
I started playing this year with 2 new friends after moving city. They've only been playing about a year and are good guys. I've taken to playing more low bracket and janky decks with them. Games are longer, but it's a good time.
Recently, a friend of theirs has joined us as a 4th, let's call him Kevin. He has been playing edh for a while. I'm guessing almost as long as me. Anyway, it feels like he keeps targeting me, and the result is always me not getting close to winning. Don't get me wrong, I understand I should only be winning up to a quarter of my games, but this seems to be with him in the group, I can only ever lose.
For example,
#1
I've played a durdly trostani life gain deck one game. It plays 1 or 2 creatures a turn, and passes. No GC, no aetherflux, it just, gains life. My ramp pieces are 3 CMC, there are 5 board wipes in the deck, etc. He played landfall that game. He managed to get over 80 power on board, and with the rest of our life totals at 20 or less, with the exception of mine at 60, and just full swing at me. And I get it, I had the highest life total, but one of the other players had lethal commander damage on him on their turn.
#2
Another game, we had player hit about 100+ power on board and pass the turn, letting us very clearly know next combat he would win. So I attempted to win with life drain on my turn, only for him to remove a piece of that engine. Obviously he proceeds to pass and then we all lose to other guy.
Like i get it, both these examples, it seems kinda understandable to come after me, but also it's not the best play. The hard part here is the other guys are newer and don't really see it and there is enough plausible deniability of specific targeting that how do I bring it up at the time? He also tends to politics against me. Like: "take him out or he'll do something" type of thing. And yes I will proceed to play a strong card or something, but it's EDH, we are all going to do something (?). But you see what I'm saying, after I do play the card, he gets very "I told you so". But then he proceeds to win on his turn or something like that.
Either way, game results are him winning half the time, or the others winning the other half.
So I'm asking what should I do? Like do I just dial up the power and fight fire with fire and go at him and leave the others alone and play the same game he is? Or do I go the other way and bust out bracket 1 pauper decks and just make it very apparent I'm being bullied?
Let me know.
EDIT:
I'll add some additional context as my game examples were recent and, as mentioned, there is plausible deniability.
I met Kevin first at a board game night with the 2 others and their greater group of friends. We played a bluffing game, similar to werewolves or Amongus. He specifically came after me. Like in a way that is "I don't care what else is going on, I am getting you voted out." The strangest thing about this was I literally just met him 30 minutes prior.
Spoiler: I wasn't a "werewolf".
We have now played about 16 or so games all together. I have not won a single one. He's won about half, and the others have gone to either of the other guys. He specifically ether wins, or burns resources to prevent me from winning. Prior to him joining us 3. I would win about a quarter of the games.
EDIT2:
Example #3, as there was too much nuance in the previous 2 about me being a threat (it's EDH, we're all trying to win)
I played an artifact deck (fallout energy -mostly- precon), he played an grixis spell slinger deck with recursion as a theme. One of the others is playing dragons, he had the opportunity, for 3 turns in a row, to either remove a key dragon, or board wipe. He vandalblasts every single time. Which, after the first one, was entirely just a one sided wipe on me as tried to rebuild. Dragon player won.