r/EU5 • • 8h ago

Discussion As an EU5 fan, I finally tried EU4.

187 Upvotes

Eu jogo CK3 há um bom tempo e, depois de experimentar o Vic3 (que eu gostei bastante), fiquei interessado em conferir o EU5. Atualmente, tenho apenas 180 horas de jogo (o que é bastante para mim), embora tenha atingido essa marca bem rápido em comparação com os outros.

O que posso dizer é que ele se tornou meu jogo de estratégia favorito. Acho certas mecânicas focadas em simulação fascinantes. Eu realmente sinto que estou desenvolvendo e moldando meu país. Gosto de ter que planejar minha expansão e adoro ainda mais as possibilidades de jogar com foco em desenvolvimento interno.

No entanto, depois que comecei a acompanhar este sub também, fiquei surpreso com a quantidade de negatividade. Também fiquei surpreso com o número de posts afirmando que o EU4 é um jogo superior. Um dos argumentos mais comuns é que o EU4 ainda tem um número maior de jogadores ativos.

Então, decidi experimentar (eu nunca tinha jogado porque já achava que o jogo era muito antigo). E depois de umas 30 horas, ficou um gosto amargo na boca. Quer dizer, é só isso?

Simplesmente não há nada para fazer no jogo quando você não está conquistando o mapa. Você ganha mais dinheiro conquistando mais províncias, simples assim. O comércio é estático, as árvores de missões — que são muito solicitadas para o EU5 — dão uma sensação de linearidade, etc., etc.

Acho que a Paradox vai ter dificuldade em trazer o público do EU4 para o EU5. É um jogo genuinamente diferente. Mais simples, mais arcade. Simplesmente focado em conquistar o mapa e obter uma dose rápida de dopamina. Pessoas que gostam disso dificilmente vão gostar do EU5, não importa o quanto ele evolua e se expanda no futuro.

Enfim, só queria compartilhar meus pensamentos rápidos. Espero que a Paradox mantenha sua visão original para o EU5. Tudo isso me lembrou um pouco do lançamento do CK3. Naquela época, lembro-me de como muitos fãs do CK2 reclamavam dos novos modelos 3D e de como isso era um "desperdício de recursos".

Edit:

Look, I didn't expect this post to blow up like this. I even saw comments saying I must be one of the game's devs.

Well, just so I don't give off that impression, here are a few criticisms I have for EU5:

1 - Devs, stop adding new mechanics and focus on balancing, bug fixes, and quality of life (QoL). This should be the main direction for at least the first year post-launch.

2 - Stop adding magic "here's your dopamine" buttons that grant instant bonuses. The game was built around sliders, where changes happen gradually over time—like a ship changing course. Stop trying to cater to players that EU5 wasn't designed for.

3 - For the love of God, look at the maps in CK3 and Victoria 3. What happened here? The map in EU5 is massive and I love that, but why is it so ugly?!


r/EU5 • • 2h ago

Image Why is Genoa selling me Corsica without me having a say ?

Post image
159 Upvotes

Genoa selled me Corsica for like 1m200k ducats without any proposition. They just served themselves in my treasury. What's the cause of this ??


r/EU5 • • 4h ago

Question How playable/fun is the Yuan Dynasty in the current 1.4 patch?

Post image
138 Upvotes

Never did a run this far east and I was curious to see how it'd go? Can you save it from collapse? Is there enough content? Is it extremely bugged and unplayable? Let me know!


r/EU5 • • 4h ago

Dev Diary (mod) Project Warcraft - Magic system

Thumbnail
gallery
94 Upvotes

Hey, hey, it's been a while since the last update. For the past month I've been working almost entirely on one thing: badum tss magic system. It's nearly finished. What's still missing is part of the technologies and the events. Still, there's finally something to show, so I'll walk you through how it works.

Cosmology

Magic is built around the six cosmic forces of Warcraft: Light, Void, Life, Death, Order and Disorder. Every country picks a primary and a secondary force. The secondary can't be the opposite of the primary, and you can't swap them on a whim, as changing them has a long cooldown. Your forces decide which talent trees and spells you have access to. At the bottom you can see your spell bar with 6 slots and your mana.

Talent trees

Each force has its own talent tree with 200 nodes, which some of you have probably noticed inspired by Path of Exile 2. As your Magic Department works, your forces gain experience and level up, and every level gives you a talent point. Force levels also slowly decay, so keeping them high takes constant investment. The Order tree has three paths, Ice, Arcane and Fire, which start apart and later weave into each other. Along the way you'll find small stat nodes, build defining passives, big power spikes and, of course, new spells. Some of the strongest nodes require an Epic or even a Legendary mage in your department, more on that in a moment.
Feel free to ask questions below! :)

Spells

Spells you unlock in the trees go onto your spell bar: right click an empty slot and pick from everything you've learned. Every spell costs mana and has its own cooldown, often measured in years, so each cast is a real decision rather than something you spam every week. Right now only Order has real spells, such as Frostbolt, Blizzard, Polymorph, Fireball or Meteor. The other five forces are still placeholders (at launch, the mod will likely feature shortened trees capped at 50 nodes which will be expanded later on).

Magic Department

This is where your mana and force experience come from. The department has four seats: Head of Department, Spellcaster, Channeler and Scholar, each focused on something different: force XP, mana or the mage's own growth. Every character in the game has a magic tier from Common to Legendary, and better mages produce a lot more. Department members also give power to their estate, just like cabinet members. Not every country can use magic, though. Otherwise small countries would simply bury the big ones in spells. To unlock the department you need:

• a magic government reform: Court Sorcery which isavailable to everyone, with heavy drawbacks on game start or Arcane Magisterium that can be unlocked by technology (other governments will be added in the future, such as those for Dalaran or Karazhan)

• a high enough country rank: the Spellcaster needs a Duchy, the Channeler a Kingdom and the Scholar an Empire

• a mage tower which is expensive building in your capital, because without one the department works at -75% Without a Head of Department you can't fill the other seats or cast any spells.

By default only characters of the Crown estate can serve. If you want nobles, clergy, burghers or peasants as your mages, you need to grant that estate its magic privilege, which comes at its own price in estate power. Appointing someone costs political influence and locks the seat for 6 months, and the tooltip shows exactly what the new mage will add before you commit.

Casting

Targeted spells are cast straight on the map. Every cast is marked with a ping showing the caster's flag, the spell icon and an arrow, and everyone can see it: green for you and your allies, red for your enemies. The Logs tab keeps track of the latest spells cast by you, your allies, your subjects and your enemies, along with how many soldiers they killed, and a small floating window shows the most recent ones.

Thanks for ur time reading this all :)

Also, if you found this post interesting and would like to help out, everyone is welcome regardless of skill level. You can join the development server here: https://discord.gg/7sDmnRH6rU.

For general mod news, hop into our public server: https://discord.gg/pwCac4sUVR.


r/EU5 • • 15h ago

Discussion Why don't defensive structures give a bonus to defense?

80 Upvotes

So if I place my archers at the top of a hill, I get a +1 to defend that position.

But if my archers are behind a city wall they get no bonus to defense?

It feels weird that defensive structures are only able to slow down invading armies instead of, you know, helping you defend the positions


r/EU5 • • 9h ago

Suggestion There is no way to get Columbus and Magellan as Spain if you annex Portugal too early. And that is an incredibly stupid mechanic.

71 Upvotes

The events required to obtain them only trigger in Portugal. Portugal must decline them, at which point they will move on to Spain. So, don’t make the mistake of annexing Portugal before the 1550s. I hope the developers fix this.


r/EU5 • • 9h ago

Image I feel the need to tag switch to France and win the HYW with her as Queen

62 Upvotes

One eye genius daughter? That's crazy lol


r/EU5 • • 4h ago

Image 1837 Prussia RP

Thumbnail
gallery
50 Upvotes

1837 Prussia post Treaty of Vienna (1815)

Brought the Hohenzollern Dynasty to power in 1378 (37 Years early) through some events from a Bohemian Emperor. I took this expansion slowly very similar to how it really went for the Prussian's. I only connected Ducal and Royal Prussia in 1624, after holding Konigsberg for near 70 years prior.

I am almost positive these locations are as accurate as you can get. There is another post that is very close to accurately describing them, but after consulting this map below from 1819, I found some discrepancies that I altered.

Here is the map if anyone is curious:
https://www.davidrumsey.com/luna/servlet/detail/RUMSEY~8~1~335861~90103656:Germany-?sort=Pub_List_No_InitialSort%2CPub_Date%2CPub_List_No%2CSeries_No&mi=199&trs=204&qvq=w4s:/when%2F1819;q:congress%20of%20vienna;sort:Pub_List_No_InitialSort%2CPub_Date%2CPub_List_No%2CSeries_No;lc:RUMSEY~8~1


r/EU5 • • 18h ago

Advice Wanted I have 5k hours in EU4. I played EU5 on release, but it never really gripped me in the same way. What are the things EU5 does better than EU4 that might make me switch?

44 Upvotes

EU4 is certainly my favorite game of all time, but I understand its never getting another update. Its "complete" for all intents and purposes. The logical follow up is to play EU5, assuming an evolution of mechanics and similar gameplay. I played it on release, and unfortunately found it pretty empty. I know that's pretty common for paradox titles, but its been a while at this point. Why should I give EU5 another try at this point in its lifecycle?


r/EU5 • • 5h ago

Video [45:35] Why I Can't Talk About EU5

Thumbnail
youtu.be
40 Upvotes

Hi, I have some thoughts about EU5 after a year of its public existence, and its trajectory, and what that means for me, personally, as Paradox's resident historography pedant and anti-gamer


r/EU5 • • 18h ago

Question How does coinage law work?

29 Upvotes

If you swap your coinage law from gold and silver coinage to bullion coinage, how much silver and copper does your mint actually use? Is there a way to view it? I’m playing Isle of Mann and my one tile RGO is a copper mine, so I am wondering if it is actually worth swapping to bullion coins. Any help would be appreciated.


r/EU5 • • 3h ago

Discussion Italian Wars - The worst situation in the game?

Post image
23 Upvotes

R5: Iberian League in the Italian Wars

(The flair is Discussion because Rant doesn't exist)

Hi there! Did you ever felt like having a accurate depiction of historically Italian leadership behaviour? Fear not, you will if you have ever played Italian Wars Situation with your own League.

Backstabbing is the word, and you'd think I've learned something with WW1 and WW2. Fortunately Paradox Tinto wanted to create a historical depiction of the Age and in their oh so delightfull spirit they did.

If you try to play with your own League your members will say fuck y0u and at the first opportunity they will either leave for another League or just leave your League, because why not am I right? Let's say you have a country that really likes you, well in my game it was Naples, my Junior Partner. And I in my so foolish display of naiveness tried, for the first time, to play with the League members territory counting to win the situation instead of getting myself the whole 200 locations.

So counting Naples locations with mine we got 204 locations together, well that's more then enough, or was it? Nope, because Naples my Junior Partner decided to leave my League a month before the Situation ended, and surprise you not it left me to go to a league commanded by a nation he was a month ago fighting against. I also like that there's a cooldown for inviting someone for a League, like there's not a big button called "bribe". You know a true leader if he stays in the league for a minimum of 5 years before getting bribed or invited away.

Could I have done something different? YES! I could ignore the really fun League mechanic and play it by myself and get 800 antagonism with the whole HRE which they will never forget me EVER for. Could I win against the whole HRE? Of course, I could. Is it fun when they declare the 9th Coalition War against me with France and get beaten to a pulp? No!

Side note: Who the f@ck thought of the "Reined in Junior Diplomacy" action, because I guess they didn't give it much thought. The only thing that it does is removing your Junior Partner the ability to declare war. What about joining IO, or in this case other Leagues? Nah, that he can do at will, you know you are just using 4.17 Diplomatic Capacity just to prevent your Junior Partner from expanding.

I feel like it could be a good idea to have:

  • to know the reasons why would they leave for another League;
  • give some concession to the League members like locations, or promises of land, to keep them in the League;
  • royal marriages with the league;

What are your thoughts on this situation? (Not my Skill Issue, the Italian Wars)


r/EU5 • • 9h ago

Question HRE Question [1.3.11]

Thumbnail
gallery
19 Upvotes

So, I was finishing my campaign as Brandenburg in an older version of the game.

This might sound a bit silly, but I didn't know how to disband the HRE. So, after becoming Protestant, I decided to annex every country in the HRE. The only ones left were the building countries.

But one strange thing happened. During the Reformation, the Protestant League lost, so all the countries converted back to Catholicism. I was the only Protestant country left, with Bohemia being the only Hussite country.

Anyway, to get to the point, I thought that after the Protestant League lost and I annexed all the countries in the HRE, I would either become the Emperor or the HRE would be disbanded.

But it seems the game just gave the Emperor title to Spain instead.

Is that normal, or does the game just assign the title to the closest Catholic nation with a positive opinion?


r/EU5 • • 5h ago

Video I was Wrong! Serfdom is EU5's Early-Game Economic Meta. But when to go Free Subjects?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
18 Upvotes

A critique on my previous video, and i'm happy to admit where i'm wrong - as long as we get the right answer eventually :)


r/EU5 • • 18h ago

Image Casual 1364 France

Post image
18 Upvotes

The key is annexing the subjects along the road to Bordeaux, which is taken along with most of Aquitaine, to have a local governor. Keep the big subjects happy, like Brittany, Burgundy, Flanders, and Normandy. Go bankrupt while the peace is still going to reset the loans (hence the 50 ducats a month balance). Take land from Aragon to release Catalonia and Valencia to later return cores. Not shown: I also have one location Scotland and Northumberland for future reconquest. Put the other local governor in Montpellier after taking from Aragon. Next steps: take big chunks of Iberia, Italy, and Britain while integrating France.


r/EU5 • • 3h ago

Image Dear lord

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/EU5 • • 7h ago

Image Cool thanks dude

Post image
13 Upvotes

R5: The new world is apparently broke.


r/EU5 • • 2h ago

Question Is the nobility tax meta historically accurate?

13 Upvotes

Currently taxing my nobles for a 1000 ducats of income a month in 1520 which is nearly 50% of my income. Does anyone know if that's historically accurate? I'm assuming yes since nobles technically owned everything the agrarian based economies at the time functioned off of. With the middle class just buying goods from them to refine or resell them (220 ducats a month by comparison).


r/EU5 • • 11h ago

The AI did something Poor Mayapahit

Post image
12 Upvotes

I just thought is share what happens in my campaign with mayapahit because i literally NEVER seen them get eaten ever.


r/EU5 • • 6h ago

Image Cursed Iberian Wedding

Post image
6 Upvotes

Did i mess up all chances of a personal union with Aragon?

R5: I was blessed with an female heir as Castile. Aragon was as well, so my queen would have been infertile by the time the first male in the aragonian line of succession would have been an adult. So i had her marry in hopes of better luck in the next generation. Then this happend, the Iberian Wedding with Bretagne.


r/EU5 • • 2h ago

Image Can you explain naval range?

Post image
6 Upvotes

Why is the closest port a French one in the Great lakes (I'm not even allied to them), when I have subjects in west Africa and Haiti?


r/EU5 • • 15h ago

Discussion Is intervening in wars useless?

7 Upvotes

I am playing as Scotland. England dows Holland and enters a war against them, Sweden and Norway.

I get the notification: you can intervene in a war. Probably because England is my rival, I dont know.

I check the war. I am pretty sure I can win England in a 1:1 war, but with this alliance is too good to pass. I intervene.

I have more regulars, more leavies and si start marching south triumphally winning battle after battle and slowly occupying their forts.

But holland and Norway arent doing so well. They are unable to deal with 5-6k troops which is kinda sad.

Then all of a sudden, after destroying some of their vassals armies and one of England’s main ones, the pop up appears. PEACE!

The deal? Holland loses nothing. Norway loses nothing. They just pay some ducats. But England takes my land. What? They grab around 2-5 areas that were not even occupied.

I rage quitted. I get it, I am not the war leader, but I dont understand how any of this makes any sense. I would have understood a white peace or them losing terrain and me not being able to grab any land. But how does this make sense at all?

So what’s the point of intervening then? If I intervene, I wont be the war leader (yes I know that you can spend favors, but you can’t have those with every random country that your rival wants to chew). And most probably I will intervene when my rival is trying to eat a smaller country. So with these rules, intervening is basically an invitation to the minor party to chicken out from the war and sell your provinces as payment?

I dont understand it, honestly.


r/EU5 • • 22h ago

Question Where to see the reason why I have 0 levies? I have a stable country this time with happy estates

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/EU5 • • 2h ago

Image Golden Century Flashpoint event means I'll be facing noble uprisings every couple of years for the next 50 years or so.

Post image
6 Upvotes

Got a flashpoint event as Andalusia during the Golden Century that gives all my pops +100% reason to rebel, declining by 1% yearly. Despite the fact that I have really high pop satisfaction everywhere, and all of my estates are 50% satisfaction or better, I'm doomed to suffer noble rebellions every few years for the next, probably, 50 years or so.

The worst part is when the event happens, there's literally nothing you can do about it. It's completely RNG. Never mind that all my pops are happy, I have 100 Dominance in both aspects of the Golden Century, and I'm the #1 Great Power, RNG says everyone is mad now, deal with it.

(Seriously, Paradox, I don't mind negative events. I think it's good that there's some challenges involved. But make them make sense. This was just RNG fucking me over for no reason.


r/EU5 • • 14h ago

Question Do I destroy Nobles buildings during Court and Country?

5 Upvotes

My nobles are going to rebel anyway. I can handle that. So do I take the chance to just destroy as many of their buildings as possible? It will instantly force the civil war but that was coming anyway. And they'll have lost a lot of power. Almost all of their buildings list only malices so what is the point in having them if I can destroy them?