Nobody walks into a pub and asks which beer is the best. You look at the taps and ask yourself what you feel like tonight. Earbuds deserve the same question, and almost never get it.
Signatures are styles. Warm and neutral are styles of sound, the way stout and pilsner are styles of beer. The word tells you what a pair leans towards, not how good it is.
Taste is trained. The beer you hated at twenty can be your favourite at thirty. Ears work the same way.
EQ is the pretzel. It can change half the evening. It cannot put a different beer on tap.
The lesson. There is no best pair. There is your glass, and it may be a different one tomorrow.
The first sip
My first beer made me wonder why people ever drink such stuff. Then, slowly, a taste developed. Today I enjoy beers I once pushed away, and I can see the point of the ones I still don't order.
Sound goes the same way. Big bass is the sweet drink of audio: easy to like on day one. A clean, neutral pair can seem thin at first, the way a dry beer seems to be missing something. Give it a few weeks and the details you now hear are hard to give up.
From research: Harman's listening tests found that younger, less experienced listeners chose more bass and treble than older, more experienced ones. Taste moves.
One confession before we order. I know beer far better than wine. With wine I ask for a Cabernet Sauvignon and stop thinking. So this is a beer post.
The tap list
Five beers I like, and the sound each one reminds me of.
| Beer |
In the glass |
In the ears |
| Guinness |
Dark, creamy, roasted |
Warm: full bass, smooth top, nothing sharp |
| Franziskaner or Paulaner Hefeweizen |
Soft, cloudy, banana and clove |
Smooth and voice-first: easy for hours |
| Stella Artois |
Crisp, clean, dry finish |
Neutral: nothing added, nothing hidden |
| Kronenbourg 1664 |
Citrus and a bit of bite |
Bright: detail and air up top |
| Fuller's London Pride |
Malt and bitterness in balance |
The all-rounder that offends nobody |
On my shelf, the Melomania A100 pours like the Guinness. The EarFun Air Pro 4+ is the wheat beer. The Nothing Ear (2024) is my Kronenbourg. The Moondrop Golden Ages 2 is a Stella with some of that Kronenbourg bite.
Two pairs more of you will know. The Sony WF-1000XM5 is another stout, my Murphy's, and a fantastic one: play electronic music with reverb in it and it does something I cannot even explain. The Technics EAH-AZ100 is my London Pride, balanced with a malty lean, and its bass is 3D, almost holographic.
Three things beer teaches better than any graph:
- Dark does not mean heavy. From research: Guinness Draught is only about 4.2% ABV, and nitrogen makes it creamy rather than thick. A warm signature is not a muddy one either.
- Same style, different beer. Franziskaner and Paulaner are both textbook Hefeweizen, and I like both. Telling them apart is its own small hobby. Two "neutral" pairs differ in the same quiet way.
- The serve changes the drink. From research: London Pride is 4.1% on cask and 4.7% in the bottle. The same earbuds also change with other tips, another codec, or ANC switched on.
Two glasses I love equally
I enjoy the Golden Ages 2 and the A100 for opposite reasons, and cymbals show it best.
The Golden Ages 2 reveals every detail. Nothing in a recording hides from it. The price is natural decay: a cymbal hit is there, the long ring after it is not.
On the A100 the cymbals are majestic. You literally feel their weight. The price is that last layer of detail: it is lovely rather than analytical, and the top is a touch relaxed.
Each one pays for its strength with something the other has. This does not make either of them better or worse. They are different. One is my pilsner and one is my stout, and I am not giving up either glass.
Not my glass of beer
There is a pub in London, the Jerusalem Tavern, where the ales came to me at what felt like room temperature. I tried. It was not for me.
From research: it was not a mistake by the barman. Cask ale is meant to be served at cellar temperature, 11 to 13°C, so the flavour comes forward. The style has devoted fans. The pub reopened in 2022, now as the Holy Tavern.
Some earbuds are my cask ale. The Soundcore Liberty 5, the OnePlus buds and most Nothing models, the Ear (2024) aside, are not my cup of tea. Or glass of beer. The OnePlus are bassy, with the bass leaking into the midrange.
From research: reviewers hear much the same and often like it. One long-term review describes the Liberty 5 as heavy bass with bright treble, the classic V shape. Stuff calls the OnePlus Buds 4 sound energetic and made to please a crowd.
And that is the point. I easily see the audience. Plenty of people want that big, exciting low end, and they are not wrong. They just ordered a different beer.
Pretzels and blackcurrant
EQ is the pretzel in a good German pub. A big, good pretzel can change half the evening. What it cannot do is replace a beer that is missing from the taps.
So I am fully for EQ. It is a perfect tool, and I wish every maker shipped the best and most complete EQ they can build. A pub with bad pretzels is a worse pub.
But I also know the limit. I cannot make a Nothing Ear (3) out of a Moondrop Golden Ages 2. Blackcurrant syrup in a Guinness does not make it taste like Stella Artois.
I know, because I have ordered it. In a London pub you can simply ask the barman to add blackcurrant to your Guinness, and I did that many times on my visits. It comes out sweeter and fruitier, and it is still Guinness.
From research: the order has its critics. Guinness lists stout with blackcurrant cordial among its own cocktails, yet an MP told the House of Commons that asking for one nearly got them thrown out of an Irish pub. EQ purists and tinkerers have the same argument every week on Reddit.
When the label and the tongue disagree
Kronenbourg 1664 tastes sharp and a bit bitter to me. From research: the brand says its Alsace hop gives full taste with low bitterness. Nobody is lying. The label describes the recipe, and my tongue describes my evening.
Audio has the same gap, and it has been measured. From research: in Harman's tests, 64% of listeners preferred the Harman target, 21% wanted less bass and 15% wanted more.
That target is the best-researched house pour in headphones, and it still misses one drinker in three. So when a reviewer's 10 is your 6, neither of you is broken. A signature describes a balance, not a quality.
How to find your glass
- Start with what you already like. If one pair or one car stereo has always sounded right to you, work out whether it is warm, bright or bassy. That is your first style.
- Pick the style before the brand. "Which earbuds are best?" has no answer. "Which warm pair under $100?" has several.
- Give it more than one sip. First impressions favour the loud and the sweet. Live with a pair for a couple of weeks before you judge it.
- Order the pretzel. Use EQ to move a pair closer to you. If you are fighting it every day, you bought the wrong beer.
- Allow yourself a second glass. I keep a stout and a pilsner on the shelf, and I reach for each on different days.
No ranking and no winner this time. Tell me what is in your glass.
Take care, everyone.
Disclosure: every pair I own was bought at retail. There are no affiliate links. I build Arclet, an app that replaces the manufacturer's app for the earbuds it supports and goes beyond it, starting with a full parametric EQ. So yes, I have an interest in the pretzel business.