r/Edgic • • 11h ago

Survey Survivor 51 Episode 9 Edgic Survey

Thumbnail
forms.gle
1 Upvotes

r/Edgic • • 28d ago

There are no spoilers this season

95 Upvotes

there's a couple people running around in this sub claiming to have spoilers and then spoiling them. just putting this post up to confirm that there are actually no spoilers this season (one person confirmed pre-merge from social media activity, that's it.) so do not fret if you see a "spoiler" in the comments! it's not real.


r/Edgic • • 9h ago

Ready to lock my picks in Spoiler

27 Upvotes

I will probably be completely wrong, and I definitely have been before. But here it goes:

F5 dragon: Sharonda. I understand that most people have her at #1, but her content has been so…clinical. She explains her strategy, but gives us very little personality or character to hook onto. And I’m willing to bet it’s not because she’s boring in confessionals. We’ve seen her be very expressive around camp. Rather, I’m guessing they’re trying to focus on her strategic side so she’s someone the winner can slay at the end without most fans feeling too torn up.

F4 firemaking loser: Devin. He has the Rizo edit all the way. Electric, fan favorite, probably a lock in a returnee season, but doesn’t have to face the bitterness of FTC. He also has the Kamila edit. Partner to the eventual winner, loyal #1 until the end. There’s no way he’s not the firemaking loser.

F3: Jelly, Maggie, Eric. Eric is the zero vote finalist; we’ve seen enough about how people don’t like him. Maggie is the contender they build up in the last minute to make you think FTC is competitive. She reminds me a lot of Sam from 47: gets a decent amount of content, is shown to be likable, but is ultimately not a real winner contender, even though she needs to be propped up that way.

Winner: Jelly. Everything some of y’all seem to see in Sharonda, I see in Jelly, plus some. She gets tons of strategic content, and her relationships are quite fleshed out. She also gets a ton of character building, is often shown as in danger/a threat, and is starting to build a clear narrative for FTC. Like I said, I’m willing to be wrong. But I feel very confident that Jelly is our winner.


r/Edgic • • 5h ago

im having a very hard time determining who the contenders are... Spoiler

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/Edgic • • 7h ago

Every season doesn’t need a dragon

17 Upvotes

We really haven’t gotten many edits like Shan, Omar and Jesse - three main character, confessional dominant, strategic (but flawed) people who were a significant turning point in a winner’s story - since Erika, Maryanne and Gabler.

Yam Yam didn’t have a dragon.

Emily was a journey edit, not a dragon for Dee (and it’s worth pointing out, it’s part of why some people thought all season Dee was the dragon).

Kenzie didn’t have a dragon.

Genevieve and Shauhin were in the ballpark for Rachel and Kyle. But unlike the winners in 41-43, it wasn’t a turning point/major emergence in ther stories, they were already clear frontrunners.

Savannah didn’t have one.

Bottom line: Not every winner is going to have some final boss to slay that catapults them to relevance and victory.


r/Edgic • • 1h ago

Sharonda, Jelly and Maggie - post episode 9 Spoiler

• Upvotes

I'm very much convinced it's Sharonda but I also think there is plausibility for a Jelly/Maggie win. Let me go in depth LMAO.

Sharonda

If you are looking through edgic traditionally (no BS, no tricks, no unconventional edit) it's her. Sharonda is winning DOWN. We got the personal content in episode 8, we got the insight on Kristin leaving being bad for her game. We got the post tribal explanation at the start of the episode. During Linnea's vote out she got protected by the edit, despite her tribe being focused on the most that episode. Her edit is so pristine it's hard not to think she's taking it. Logically, as of this episode, she's not in anyone's radar so she is in for a deep run.

My only gripe with her edit is and this is because survivor has been taking liberties with editing lately (especially in the new era) is because Sharonda is not on the complex tribe. Yes. Savu is not the complex tribe. You can bend over backwards trying to convince me and I will insist Toka is the complex tribe. Complex tribe theory exists for a reason but it can easily just be a theory. Another gripe about Sharonda is that she has very little NTOS visibility. Almost always absent. That's why I'm hesitant. She's being edited within the episode as the winner but the POS and NTOS features her very little. Her individual content is great but her relationships with Kristin and Christian being not as fleshed out with the fact Savu is not the complex tribe coupled with her little NTOS visibility makes me hesitant that we're being set up for a rug pull with Sharonda.

Jelly

I honestly don't see it for Jelly but I have to consider what others see with her edit and maybe I might not be picking up what they are clearly picking up.

Jelly has been protected during the Aaliyah and Patt vote outs to an extent. She has a lot of personal and strategic content and we hear her thoughts even if they aren't necessary. The edit wants us to invest in Jelly and for good reason. I see the relevance in her as a player this season.

My gripes with Jelly is that gamewise, not edit, her threat level has exploded and unless she wins out, I don't see her making finale without a fight. However, this I can overlook if the helicopter alliance gets the upper hand on the salt alliance. BUT, edgic is still half logic at the end of the day, and logically, she is on a timer. Another gripe is that Devin is clearly an ominous presence in her game. I don't know if I'm reading it wrong but the way I am reading the edit, Devin is Jelly's downfall. That one confessional from Devin during the Ori episode. I think it was about playing his game for his own self and taking the game into his hands, I believe he was saying he'd do anything to get to the end or something and at the time I thought it was dangerous thing for Jelly's game because at that point Jelly was talking about keeping Devin and playing with him loyally. Unless Devin is taken out, there is a cloud hanging over Jelly's head.

Maggie

Her edit intrigues me so much because it's not everyone's go to.

Maggie has been consistently been getting personal, strategic and constant check in confessionals every episode. Her thoughts this season how little they may be, have always been included in the edit. Game-wise she is in a good position. Jelly even calls her a threat to win. Which I'll get into again in my gripes with Maggie's edit. Maggie to me has been getting the fair balance of strategic, personal and premerge negativity that is a formula in modern survivor edits. One thing about the Maggie-Brady relationship was also Maggie always got the upper hand. One thing Maggie said stuck out with me, she said something along the lines of that she waited years to be on survivor and she's not gonna let some twenty something get in the way of her. Maggie was also instrumental in the Linnea vote, not Kilby or Lewis. It's Maggie. I cannot credit Kilby and Lewis anymore. It's Maggie. Maggie's weird relationship with Kristin could go good or bad. Good because she got Kristin, who wanted for a while to go out, out. Bad because it was indirect. Maggie also was featured in that slomo victory shot in episode 2 when they won Toka won immunity. That was something to note.

Now my gripes, introduced late in the premiere. Rachel and Kyle were introduced late too but Maggie was awfully quiet with her premiere while Rachel and Kyle had substantial visibility in their premieres. Her relationships, her relationship with Thien An is less fleshed out but this could be because the Thien An relationship might not be relevant. Thien An said Maggie was her number one but she also says Kilby is her number one. She might not be a reliable narrator so I have to reconsider what Thien An says. Maggie's main featured relationships are with Mike and Brady who she has mixed relationships with. A lot of y'all think the negativities in these relationships are disqualifiers but Brady (gone) and Mike are not a reliable narrators. Jelly calls Maggie a threat so her name is now floating out there. This could spell doom for her if the season is rewarding the Jelly story but Jelly just last week says she doesn't wanna target Maggie because of her connections. The 180 on Maggie is ... something. Idk what to make of it yet. Jelly did back out on the Maggie plan because the rest wanted Lewis who I'll get into a bit. But as far as disqualifiers go, Maggie to me doesn't have anything that makes me wanna count her out yet unless I've been reading the edit wrong.

I firmly believe it's one of these three. Sharonda>Jelly=>Maggie>>>the rest

Other player edgic reads:

Everyone else is drawing dead if not dead already.

The Lewis edgic read was also bad. I'm genuinely shocked but maybe I missed some signs that he wasn't the winner. The premier was so good but I should've known Lewis was not winning when he got zilch at the merge. I couldn't defend it as protection when a lot of y'all did. No follow up on the bad merge episode too. Still I thought he could bounce back only for him to be eliminated in the latest episode. I need to get better at reading the edit.

The zero confessional episode getters are still in the game by the way. That's something...

The season's edgic could end in a super easy to read win (sharonda) or more competitive medium fairing reads (jelly, maggie)


r/Edgic • • 9h ago

Heaven, Hell, Limbo - Survivor 51 Episode 9 Edgic Spoiler

15 Upvotes

Hello, and welcome back to Heaven, Hell and Limbo, where I am God and the Survivor contestants are my souls to judge.

Tonight we lost Lewis, who ranked **4th* in Limbo. *Contenders are dropping like flies. I was so sure that with the edit Lewis was given, he was our firemaking loser. I was wrong, he was the failed coin flipper.

So now we have a coin failure edit. What I noticed here is how often Lewis was shown embracing chaos and loving mischief. "Play dangerously," he was shown saying during the Linnea vote. A choatic player. This to me, all but puts to rest the assertion that the winner must be the contetant that's shown embracing the chaos of the season. "Permanent uncertainty" has been a plague that's haunted edgicing this season and it's claimed another victim. If we follow suit, Devin should be seen as the next "Lewis and Kilby".

I don't believe we will though. I think the lesson has been officially learned: best embodying the theme =/= the winner.

Category Explaination Time!

The Holy Trinity Theory: Narrative, complexity, visibility; the contestant that best embodies these 3 aspects in their edit has the highest likelihood of winning.

Narrative - Is the edit connecting throughlines episode-to-episode and creating a story for this contestant, or are they given only single-episode importance? Do we know their background? Their motivations? Their values? Are they given a protagonistic or a villainous edit?

Complexity - Is the edit only positive, only negative, or a well-rounded mix of both? How many different aspects of personality are we given from this contestant? How many established relationships do they have? Are they one-dimensional or multifaceted? Do other contestants speak on their game or personality?

Visibility - Is this contestant shown too much, too little, or just enough? Is it circumstantial, or unnecessary? Were they shown at fault for voting incorrectly, or were they shielded? Were they shown as a/the driver of a vote when they voted correctly, or did the edit not give them enough credit? Do their confessionals mainly consist of self-narration, or simply SPV's (Second-Person Viewpoint) for others.

Arch Angel: My selected winner. They embody the aspects of the Holy Trinity better than all other contestants.

Heaven: If a contestant falls into this category, they either embody all three or at least two aspects of the Holy Trinity very well. High, noncircumstantial visibility. Having any form of a narrative. Personal or endearing content. Is shown either mostly positively, or is shown to be multifaceted in their portrayl.

Limbo: If a contestant falls into this category, while not a death sentence, their edit is inconsistent. One episode they're shown prominently, the next they're hardly shown. One episode they're shown positively, the next they're shown not-so-favorably. Either severely lacking in one aspect of the Holy Trinity, or slightly lacking in two aspects.

Hell: If a contestant falls into this category, they are almost certainly not winning the game. Severely lacking in two or all three aspects of the Holy Trinity lands you here. Consistent negativity, not enough or any personal or endearing content. Nonexistent narrative, and/or zero complexity.

With that out of the way, let's get started with our rankings this episode!

Hellish Contestants:

9.) Eric: Eric received rare positive SPV tonight, with Cristian and Carter saying how smart and good of a move it was to keep the extra vote as a fake. This could be seen as only good for Cristian and Carter however, as "look at how this could benefit us" was my main takeaway for that scene, and less about how good of a player Eric is.

Then we have his conversation with Jelly. Which again, showcases more how he is a player to be used rather than a player that has good connections. He does display self-awarness to an extent in saying how he's sitting pretty because no one is looking at him. But that's the thing, no one is looking at him. He doesn't have a resumè. He's not a threat. He's Eric.

8.) Thien An: Thien An has for several episodes now been reduced to narrator. She's less of a player and more of a story-teller at this point. She does have a couple of interesting SPV's I want to dive into, but it really has nothing to do with her, so that's saved for actual relevant players.

7.) Cristian: Look at how he's grown. So much content recently, but it still very much feels as though he's a player to be used for a greater game being played. He's playing the middle, working with both Sharonda and Carter. And both believe to have him in their pocket. A good spot to be in gameplay wise. Editorially though, he's just a pawn.

6.) Carter: Carter was shown strangely indecisive this episode, which is a complete 180 from his confidence last episode. His Salt Alliance has completely fallen apart as we knew it would. And now, his closest ally is schemeing behind him. Carter had great potential during premerge, but since has completely fallen off.

5.) Mike: An extremely quiet episode for Mike. We had him celebrating the reward challenge and.. that's about it. I really believed him to be an up-and-coming contender only for this episode to slap me silly for even entertaining the thought.

4.) Maggie: To be clear, Maggie still isn't winning. There's little about her edit that suggests she wins in my eyes. However.. I can't ignore Jelly calling her out as a jury threat, and how well integrated she is within the camp. This is the first time someone has identified Maggie as a threat, and to me, that really just spells death. Unlike Jelly and Devin, the edit has done nothing to show how obviously threatening Maggie is as a player. The edit has shown exactly why Jelly and Devin are a threat however. But it's the fact that the edit hasn't shown why Maggie is so threatening, that makes Jelly suddenly calling her out as a threat now so damning against her. But, on the flip side she's shown eager to utilize the knowledge of Devin's "idol" against him, so that's a plus.

3.) Devin: Devin reenters Hell for a singular reason, "weaponized honesty" has reared its ugly head back out again. After having confessionals of saying "we're going to see a new Devin" only for Devin to then revert back to his destructive way of playing is his edit death. And we immediately see how this comes to bite him in the ass when his fake idol plan backfires on him. It's curtains.

Limbo; Death or Resurrection:

No contenders for Limbo this week. As we approach the latter half of the season, edits become more clear. "Potential" at this point should either be crystalizing into a winner's edit, or falling flat. This isn't to say someone being in Limbo in the future is now impossible, just highly improbable.

Heavenly Contestants:

2.) Sharonda: Alright lets dig into the real meat and potatoes of the season. At this point, it should be clear to anyone, even to those who don't edgic, that either Sharonda or Jelly is going to win this season.

First, the acknowledgment.

- I acknowledge Sharonda outright saying she gets all the credit for the immunity idol play.

- I acknowledge how many different contestants want to work with Sharonda.

- I acknowledge Sharonda being the first one to say she wants Lewis out of the game, and Lewis goes home that very episode.

- I acknowledge Sharonda saying how covert she is and no one sees her for the threat that she is.

- I acknowledge how Sharonda hasn't received a single negative thing about her edit. Neither from the edit, or contestants' SPV's about her.

- I acknowledge Sharonda as always, without fail, shown to be in the right.

So now I present my case: does no one else find it odd how there's no complexity to her edit? And I don't mean the personal content she received last episode. In my edgic, how I describe complexity is a mixture of positive and negative aspects. How many different sides of a contestant are we seeing? Are they one-note or multi-dimensional?

Sharonda is very one-note. She's always shown positively. She's always correct. She always gets her way. Where is the adversity? Where are her low moments? Where is the struggle? And I don't mean just gameplay, I mean the actual survival aspect of it all. The mental wear. The physical.

For example, this episode, we saw multiple sides of Jelly. But one thing we also saw? Hunger. We saw her angry. We saw her bitter that others got to enjoy a reward while she starved and had to listen to Lewis brag about cookies. This is complexity. This is low moments being shown. This is the struggle. This is multiple sides of a contestant being explored.

Again I ask, where is this in Sharonda's edit? Where is the multi-dimentality of it all (not a word but who cares you get it).

And lastly, the biggest blow to Sharonda right now and something I've been screaming about forever: what is her narrative? I have yet to find anything resembling an episode-by-episode story arc for Sharonda. And what's more I have yet to see other edgicers present a compelling case for what her narrative could even be. Because there truly isn't one. At least, not for a winner's narrative.

No, I believe the reason for this is because Sharonda was never our winner, she was always our dragon to be slayed by the winner.

That's why she's always shown as right. That's why she's never wrong. That's why the edit always takes care to show Sharonda as being a covert operator and why no one sees her as a threat. It's because when she is finally revealed as the threat she is, that's when...

Arch Angel:

1.) Jelly: ...will be the one to take her out. Jelly's edit, her narrative, has always been one of weighing what's best for her game since the premiere.

Before that though, acknowledgements.

- I acknowledge Jelly at the start of the episode celebrating her triple win: building her résumé, taking out what she saw as two of the biggest targets, and saved her #1 ally in Devin.

- I acknowledge the edit showing Lewis as saying Jelly is the biggest threat in the game, and then promptly losing in the same episode.

- I acknowledge Thien An restating how much of a threat Jelly is, but then saying she doesn't see a path forward with Jelly.

- I acknowledge Jelly having awareness about the fact that she has a huge target on her back.

- I acknowledge Jelly setting up Maggie as a jury threat to be taken out eventually.

- I acknowledge that even though Sharonda was the first to mention Lewis being taken out, it was Jelly shown as the one making sure all the pieces were in place and her alliance was still on go.

Now my case for why she beats Sharonda:

"Permanent uncertainty.. it sounds scary but also exhilarating. I just think.. there's so many people and so many bonds to be made." - Jelly in the premiere.

Bonds. The central theme of Jelly's story. We saw her make a bond with Jenna, and didn't want to see her leave the game. She weighed what was best for her game and her bond with Devin won out.

We see her bond with womanhood, and struggle with intersectionality in not wanting to vote out either Alexis or Devin, another woman or a POC, both being tied and bounded to her identity. We see her bond with Ori, before ultimately still going through with her bond with Devin

And now we see her bond with Sharonda. This has been a season long setup showing Jelly struggling between making decisions for what's best for her game, womanhood, black identity, and the bonds she's made within the game.

For the longest time, I believed Jelly's narrative and edit to indicate her taking out Devin as her win condition. But what if I was wrong? What if it was because I didn't have all the pieces to the puzzle yet?

What if Jelly's win condition the entire time wasn't taking out Devin, but taking out Sharonda?

Their souls have been judged, until next week.


r/Edgic • • 10h ago

Survivor 51: Episode 9 Contenders Spoiler

15 Upvotes

Oh New Era my least favorite friend. Yeah, didn't enjoy this episode that much either.

Chart is above for quick reference.

Eliminated:

  1. Lewis: Didn't expect him to leave so soon, but the edit post immunity made it clear. Him going to the coin however completely changes my way of reading the edit going forward. The entire sub thought the coin flip victim would get a quiet edit to not upset the audience, but we got the opposite.

No Shot:

  1. Cristian: Barely anything meaningful this late. He does have some scenes with Sharonda and Carter, but it was just for portraying him as a swing.

  2. Thien An: Almost dropped her below Cristian this week. Another terrible episode when she needed a breakout back in episode 2 to be viable.

  3. Carter: "Oh, I'm 100% trusting Cristian" *Cut to Cristian backstabbing him* Also, double 0 confessional episodes.

  4. Eric: I liked his strategic scenes better and he actually got little to no negative SPV for once.

Probably Not (35% Collectively):

  1. Mike: After the merge episode, he's fallen to the waste side in 2 episodes. His relationships with the helicopter alliance is also not a focus anymore.

  2. Devin: Saying and explaining you want the coin all episode and then backing out doesn't look that great. Also, neither does failing to give away your own fake idol.

  3. Maggie: A bit of NTOS bias but with how bad Devin's edit was this episode, she would be here anyway. I think if anyone with an "Aubry" edit is winning, it's clearly her. A confessional every episode checking in on their strategy, an alliance constantly restated, and now thanks to Jelly this episode being portrayed as an actual threat to win.

  4. Jelly: I get the hype, but unlike other potential targets she is getting constantly brought up and getting votes. I'm still worried about all the Devin foreshadowing her downfall stuff from before and logically I don't see a path where the likes of Eric/Mike don't turn on her, even if it's not this week.

Clear Contender (65%):

  1. Sharonda: Given credit both in the recap and after about saving Jelly/Devin but also explains how she's not taking credit at the moment to avoid being a threat. She becomes the loudest voice to take out Lewis, Her relationship with Cristian is reestablished, she's in the helicopter alliance. I think the one downside is her tone was very neutral at first, but I think that is turning around.

r/Edgic • • 13h ago

Live Discussion Survivor 51 Episode 9 Live Discussion

21 Upvotes

I think Drew is finally going to flip the coin tonight


r/Edgic • • 10h ago

Episode 9 Contenders Spoiler

13 Upvotes

9) Cristian (+1): Cristian’s content has picked up to the point where I am seriously questioning why he was completely irrelevant for the first 4 episodes, but he is clearly not the winner.

8) Eric (-1): I am still confident in Eric being a losing finalist, as he’s not necessarily on anyone’s radar but doesn’t have the strategic prowess to win the game. He is oddly present, but not in the way a winner would be.

7) Thien An (+1): Thien An is clearly very solid at the strategic part of the game the 2 times an episode we hear her speak. She has a relationship with Carter that we have since heard nothing about and her number 1, Lewis, went home this week.

6) Carter (+3): Carter is this high because he is the main voice of the salt alliance. I am also fairly certain that the salt alliance does not win this season. Still he has been shown in the edit, wildly inconsistently, but shown.

5) Maggie (-): Maggie is getting a very odd edit. She is consistently present, we get a solid amount of strategic content from her, but the strategic content is often incoherent and wrong. I’m fairly certain she’s not winning, though Jelly randomly called her a threat tonight, so maybe she’s taken out right before FTC?

4) Mike (+2): Mike is in the same boat as Maggie in the sense that I’m fairly certain neither wins, but there edits are so weird. Especially Mike, who is one of the least entertaining narrators I’ve ever witnessed! Still, I think Mike has longevity, as he has randomly vanished from everyone’s mind as a target all of a sudden.

3) Devin (+1): This episode was sort of all over the place for Devin, but there is a very clear divide in my mind between these top 3 and the rest of the pack, as well as Devin and the top 2. Devin has been OTT from the very beginning, and I can’t tell where it’s going. His side now has the power, but they have to work around Carters idol. Still, I don’t think Devin would be the target.

2) Jelly (-): Jelly has been a consistently present force on this season. She is in a power position, has a great edit, but is also a clear and obvious threat. Edit wise, she has no issues, but it’s tough to see a realistic path to the end for her in the game.

1) Sharonda (-): Sharonda’s edit has been damn near perfect all season, but is it too perfect? She gets just enough content every episode, and the content is always pristine. We get all the strategic insight from her, and nobody has even thought about uttering her name for a vote. My only worry is she is being built up as the ultimate final boss.


r/Edgic • • 10h ago

Survivor 51 EP9 Edgic + Contenders Spoiler

Thumbnail gallery
14 Upvotes

Well! That was honestly quite a boring episode. They really didn't try and hide that Lewis would be the one to flip it at all. Solid end to his story though, makes a lot of sense for him to go here. By this point in the season I don't have too much to say anymore. I simply just don't think anyone has a chance outside of Sharonda and Jelly, and they've been my top two ALL SEASON. Can't lose my third contender (again) if I drop down to two!

Contenders

  1. Sharonda (=) - I've been hyping up that someone from the Helicopter alliance would win since the start. Between her and Jelly, Sharonda simply had a much better episode here imo. They seemingly gave her more of the credit in the edit. She also got the elusive CP2 ❤️ Aubry got that last season and I think I gave Gabler one too LOL

  2. Jelly (=) - She does still have a chance, though it's lowkey like 70/25/5 for me at this point. The five is everyone outside of these top two. Anyway, Jelly and Devin are clearly the biggest players of this season, I just find Sharonda's edit to be much stronger. Even if it's "too perfect". Sometimes perfection wins bud.

Not Happening

  1. Devin (+1) - Mostly defaults to this spot due to Lewis going and Devin being the other remaining member of the Helicopter alliance. It's so obvious someone from this alliance is winning, Devin is just the one with little to no chance imo. I just don't think we'd have gotten all this negativity on him early on if he went to win. He literally named a chicken Jenna and cut it's head off. That's a bit much. This episode really tried to make him the mouthpiece for how production wants you to play Survivor, which is a good sign.

FTC Upside

  1. Mike (+2) - Had the quietest episode of everyone tonight, but at least it wasn't negative! Everyone in this tier is lowkey such a textbook losing finalist edit, so we'll see how wrong I am. It'll be really funny when the edit tries to hype him up in episode 12.

  2. Maggie (=) - The fake idol finding scene was not a great look, and she has looked pretty bad in practically every other recent episode too.

  3. Eric (+2) - He has got to let the vampire thing go man.

Too Quiet

  1. Carter (=) - Lowkey barely even got a MOR here. It's kind of crazy how quiet his edit has been for most of this season.

  2. Thien An (+1) - Got her most visible episode ever ❤️ good for her.

  3. Cristian (+1) - This episode was not flattering at all for him, though it wasn't as bad once tribal hit. Still, not a great look for him and he was already too quiet.

Eliminated

  1. Lewis (-7) - I called him boring and the whole server proceeded to threaten to murder me.

Genuinely I just do not have much to say about this episode LOL. The twist isn't good, it was worse TV than last season honestly. Hopefully next episode is back in the right direction. See you tomorrow for the end of New Blood! Surely I won't have an abysmal Edgic failure... (lowkey it'll be one regardless of who wins)


r/Edgic • • 7h ago

Survivor 51, Episode 9 - em-gic rankings chart... :3

8 Upvotes

i don't got much 2 say tbh :3 !!!! i feel very confident jelly is the winner after the last few episodes. big threats have been voted out and she's very far ahead on the numbers and i don't see anyone else catching up!!! this season has been really good though and i've thoroughly enjoyed every episode

coin flip should be voluntary not mandatory ggez lewis pwnd by mr beast


r/Edgic • • 11h ago

Episode 9 contenders Spoiler

10 Upvotes

Let’s make it fast

Contenders:

  1. Sharonda: all of her content is just positive and shows her being right

Alive:

  1. Devin: I think his edit is definitely leading to Kelly going home, but also it is very positive considering how he’s played

Pretty close to dead:

  1. Jelly: I’m 99% confident she’s like the final boss end gamer, and Devin is the reason she goes home.

  2. Mike: His edit is consistent. But it just doesn’t have the extra sauce it needs.

  3. Maggie: I feel like this is a good runner-up edit lol.

  4. Carter: A lot of solid content but feels like that’s because he’s pretty important to the tribals at the moment.

  5. Eric: I think he might make some big moves but I don’t think he’ll win.

Dead:

  1. Thien An: so little content

  2. Christian: yeah


r/Edgic • • 11h ago

One and Only Edgic Post @ Survivor 51 Ep 9

9 Upvotes

Hi y'all! I have not watched the current season due to life, but I binge watched S51 in one week of dinners, and watched Ep 9 live. I have not read any other edgic posts to avoid knowing the results. I want to go into it blind this time and see how it turns out based on quick feelings...

GIRL BYE

  1. Carter. ☠️ Purpled to death... If he was not hot, he would have 0 content. Kyle 2.0

  2. Cristian. ☠️ Who? Flop edit until Ep 8 when he went on that journey but at least he's giving a bit more but he will be locked in the dungeons. He might rise up as a Dragon, his edit is giving Genevieve lite

  3. Thien An. ☠️ She had a shot but having no content at merge... cooked. Her connections are so fraught and unexplained in the edit. She's done

  4. Eric. ☠️ Yeah, they are not editing their winner like that after the momental season 50. I know people are saying omg but 41 happened after 40 WaW but let's be serious. Erica was not portrayed as a clown unlike.

  5. Mike. ☠️ Yeah, don't even try me. His edit has poor social game written all over it, he talks like a corporate AI bot like wtf? The production team is not going to constantly dunk on a winner like that, might be a FTC loser

  6. Sharonda. ☠️ Hot take, but her edit is not giving enough for me. It is the fact that they are focusing on the Eric vs Sharonda rivalry thing in the first 6 episodes. Her edit has no complexity for me, it is too one tone. Like I see the vision but my gut says she is not our winner

4. Lewis. ☠️ There is something there, he does have a consistent edit but the story is very vague. He feels like a supporting character, a side kick, and even a joke character...

CONTENDERS

  1. Maggie 🤔 - I can definitely see her fusing out like Chaos Kass but I can see the vision of her taking the whole thing. She's making end game in my opinion, and maybe F3

  2. Devin 🤔 - I love him and he's a clear main character. He seems like a big threat though so making it to the end seems like a tall order.. but not impossible in the "open era".

🎉🍾TRUE SURVIVOR 🎉🍾

  1. Jelly 👑 - She is only a bit ahead of Devin. I have more faith in Jelly due to her more personal content in the edit and more UTR gameplay. It's very Kenzie-like, I think she can slide and make it all the way to the end. Jelly + Devin are the strongest relationship within the edit, one of them is making it to final 5 at least, and if one of them leaves before that, the target is more likely to be on Devin.

I said it in the live thread, but Sharonda, Devin and Jelly feels like the Tika 3 on Season 44, like I think all 3 make it to Final 6 at least. Sharonda is giving Carson for me with this comparison.

Anyway, I don't feel confident at all but I'm here to stand on business and pick one person instead of waffling between a few, and that person is Jelly!

-------------------------
Previous edgic guesses: Ozzy (50), Kamilia/Shahuin tied (48), Sue (47), Tiffany (46), Cassidy (43), Shan (41), Kim (40)


r/Edgic • • 10h ago

Survivor 51 Episode 9 Player Ranking Spoiler

8 Upvotes

This is gonna be short asf cause GTA 6 is in a couple of hours and I ain’t got time for this. The twist is so dramatic that I’ll always be on the edge of my seat, but damn, this was a shitty outcome. :(
I was a huge Lewis truther until last episode and with him gone, I think the season is all but solved.

🐋Absolute Top Contender Tier🐋

  1. Sharonda.

Perfect post-tribal content. Takes all the credit for the idol play, speaks how it was a great move for her, randomly got to mention how Kristin was her ally for the first time in 6 episodes, and even has some FTC foreshadowing.
Sharonda clearly wants Lewis out, and he goes.
With the main season theme being permanent uncertainty, the winner staying calm and level headed through it all is a great storyline. Even connects to what Ori said during the opening when asked about what the winner of this season has to exemplify.

Sharonda’s edit is bullet proof, I think she might have a shakey episode soon; but that would only make her edit better in my eyes. Some dragon downside but I think it would make the season too unsatisfying if she were to lose .

🐋Contender**** Tier🐋

  1. Devin.

Great showcase for his radical honesty play style, which worked with wanting to play against people who are also playing. His strong playstyle is a good storyline and he’s been shown more dynamically than at the beginning of the season.

  1. Mike.

Kinda a nothing episode but he didn’t have much to do. Mike probably would have ended up siding with Lewis this episode, so just some basic narration is good enough.
Storyline is the main thing on Mike’s side, his Aurby-like rising from the bottom content could really start to kick into high gear next week, and Sharonda would be a perfect dragon to slay.

🐋You’re In Danger Tier🐋

  1. Jelly.

Really Genevieve coded. She’s such a big threat that I couldn’t imagine her surviving until the end, especially with all the Devin being her downfall set up.
Her edit is huge, but I think that’s due to her game-importance and just being a phenomenal narrator. Good post-tribal content for sure! This is definitely the ranking I’m most unsure about; I just wish she had a stronger narrative.

  1. Maggie.

Still getting just enough to not drop her.

🐋Yeah, Its Not Happening Tier🐋

  1. Carter.

Same as before. Not a good look having him ready to bat for Lewis, but at-least it’s something. Very circumstantial edit, only really shown when very important

  1. Thein An.

She got a confessional about losing Kilby, which is something.

  1. Eric.

Least negative episode in awhile, but very obviously 0 vote finalist. Weirdly very present in the edit, which is weird.

  1. Cristian.

Current pick for 5th placer, very inline with those quieter edits.


r/Edgic • • 5h ago

Survivor 51: Episode 9 Winner Rankings & Commentary Spoiler

Post image
4 Upvotes

TOP CONTENDERS

1 - Sharonda (45%): This was a fine episode for her? a bit almost too quiet for my liking.. I know this episode didn’t lead to a vote so there wasn’t really much to show in terms of straetegy, however we do see Sharonda get her way here in wanting Lewis out so I think that’s ultimately a great look and what’s keeping her above everyone else. She once again gets way and she explicitly tells us at the beginning of the episode that she is “quietly” taking credit for the Kristin/Kilby move. I do think her lack of character moments is a detriment.. this will be one of the most boring winner edits in a while if it is Sharonda who ends up winning. 

2 - Jelly (40%): She got a HUGE episode here, and she is clearly the opposite of Sharonda, regarding that she is getting the character moments that I would expect in a winner, and she is getting a lot of content.. (maybe almost too much?) but I think after Aubry’s edit last season they probably go with a BIGGER edit for this season? The negatives for me is that she is not getting the same strategic credit that Sharonda is getting and in this episode in particular we saw her wanting to get rid of Maggie out over Lewis. Having said that I think with the coin flip it doesn’t really matter much and I still think her edit is very complex.

UNLIKELY, BUT POSSIBLE: 

3 - Maggie (8%): A fine episode for Maggie? I think she was on the quieter side, but she did look good against Devin and she also got called a BIG threat by Jelly, which is always good for your chances to be called a big threat. I just don’t think there is much storyline here to warrant a win yet, but if her content picks up next week then I could maybe see it. 

4 - Devin (6%): Her weaponized honesty coming back here after he told us he would play a more strategic game just feels like it goes against the storyline that he was building of changing his game up from the premerge.

OUT OF CONTENTION (NO CHANCE TO WIN) (1%):

5 - Eric

6 - Mike

7 - Carter

8 - Thien An

9 - Cristian


r/Edgic • • 11h ago

Survivor 51: Episode 9 Edgic + Contenders Spoiler

Post image
8 Upvotes

Contenders:

  1. Sharonda: She got credit for Jelly's big move, which is a massive plus. One thing I am concerned about is that her and Cristian really only had their relationship established this episode when they've been on a tribe the entire time, which ties into my bigger concern about CTT, but I'm willing to push it aside because her helicopter relationships were established well. Plus, she got to talk about Kristin going out, which is also a plus.

  2. Jelly: If it wasn't for Sharonda getting credit for her big move, I would have kept Jelly at #1. However, because she did, I have her down here, but it's as a close second.

Non-contenders:

  1. Devin: He went against the Devin 2.0 storyline by reverting back to the old Devin. Still, that could have been content that they couldn't avoid due to Lewis flipping the coin, so I think there's a chance Devin could come back into contention if his Devin 2.0 storyline picks up again next episode.

  2. Carter: He has the salt alliance, but that alliance is quickly falling apart. Plus, his edit's been pretty quiet outside of episodes where he needs to be shown.

  3. Eric: He has losing finalist upside, but he has more relationships that have been introduced so he's above Mike.

  4. Mike: He has losing finalist upside. Other than that, I don't have much to say.

  5. Maggie: She's someone I've been low on for a while due to all of the holes in her edit, and this episode has done her no favors.

  6. Cristian: He got more good content, and this time it wasn't circumstantial. Still, it's too little and way too late.

  7. Thien An: Her main content this episode was about Lewis being her #1, so... Yeah, girl really needs a storyline.


r/Edgic • • 4h ago

Survivor 51, Episode 9 - Helicopter rides, fried chicken and a coin flip Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Hello, everyone! I've decided to truly put my Edgic thoughts into words for the first time this season. I've heard about Edgic for the first time during 41, really took an interest to it during 43 and have been really looking at the show through that lens since 44, but I have been watching the show since Samoa and knew that the edit plays a part in determining the winner. Just never knew there's a whole science behind it. I have very reactionary takes, I'm biased towards the players I like which sometimes clouds my judgement and the thing I let guide me the most is vibes. I was adamantly anti Aubry last season, but my claim to fame is clocking Dee as the winner after the premiere of 45 and riding that train the whole season.

I have never been a part of Edgic during a two tribe season which I believe will make it a bit difficult for me since there are so many more potential relationships to explore. Different from the New Era where there were 3 duos in every tribe with 2 duos in each tribe forming a core 4.

Anyways, I'll try to make a post every week, briefly assessing the boot and ranking the remaining players based on what I think their odds at the win are. I'll try to stay away from other people's Edgics so as to not get influenced or worse, so keep in mind that that'll result in plenty of mistakes and horrible takes.

Lewis going is a bit of a shock, ngl. Another one of my top contenders gone, although I wouldn't have really kept him in contention after this episode as I'm pretty all in on my top two. Puts his edit in a bit of a perspective and I honestly don't think this gave us much info on the coin flip edit. Glad he got a strong edit even if he did miss it, but I don't think it would've been as strong or as positive if he didn't volunteer for it.

TOP CONTENDERS:

1. Sharonda (-) - I mean, what more could you want? Mentioned how losing Kristin was bad for her, found the silver lining and got all of the credit for Jelly's idol play and then just slid into the background. Also is the only person to know about Carter's idol. Sharonda is playing a Kim Spradlin, Tommy Sheehan game out there and it's boring as hell, but it's sure damn effective. Here is where a bit of my bias comes into play because it's clear to me that she's the best player this season and it'd be a damn shame if she doesn't win.

2. Jelly (-) - If it's not Sharonda, it's her. I actually thought this episode was pretty good for you. I feel like the hater montage was a nice touch, she got a lot of threat talk and although she probably would've went if Lewis' coin hit, it never really felt like she would leave. I still don't like the fact that she's tied to the hip with Devin and I feel like the edit blueballing us with her cutting him is eerily similar to Sophi Balerdi dangling the prospect of stealing Rizo's idol the entire back half of 49 and not doing it. I wouldn't be surprised if she won at all, but my gut tells me it isn't happening.

KEEPING AN EYE ON:

3. Maggie (-) - Got a lot of threat talk, we were hit over the head with the fact that she has good relationships with everyone. Didn't turn out to be a fool by Devin's ploy and seems to have sniffed him out in the NTOS. She's playing a great game and while I would be surprised if she or anyone else won over my top two, if she did, I wouldn't be able to say I didn't see it coming.

4. Carter (+2) - I've come to the point where I don't really give a fuck anymore and I'll put whoever I want wherever I want. I just get good vibes about Carter. Sharonda knowing about his idol isn't ideal, but he's shown to be a capable player, strategically sound, strong in challenges and just great socially. Has two strong supposed allies in Cristian and Thien An. Not sure what to think of his self deprecation storyline. He's been saying he's not very smart a bunch and said in this episode that he has no luck. I'd like for him to turn around and go "Wait. I'm actually pretty great."

I DON'T KNOW WHAT TO THINK:

5. Mike (-1) - I don't think him or anyone below him is winning. I'm of the opinion that if he wants to win, his edit should've been crazy amazing for the postmerge. I was ready to look past his merge disaster, but I wanted basically a CP5 from him the whole way through. He understandably wasn't here because of the coin flip. The entire episode was Jelly and Lewis. But still, I wouldn't call myself a truther anymore.

6. Devin (-1) - Yikes, what bad gameplay lmfao. The idol sequence was an absolute disaster. Don't force it dude, if she isn't biting, count your losses and head home. Except there wouldn't have been any losses. Weaponized honesty proves we haven't moved away from the old Devin. He's a big character, a camera hog, but I'd have a really hard time seeing him as our winner.

THERE'S NO WAY:

7. Cristian (+2) - I actually thought of keeping him at last because despite his edit picking up, him winning with that start would be unprecedented while the two people below him have edits that have arguably won before (maybe not Eric). However, it'd be easier to stomach him winning than the other two. They're really starting to make us care for him and I'm starting to think that he doesn't get screwed over or quits. The whole energy thing and him and Devin hearing voices was a major eye roll for me, but the show spun it positively. Fucked up by telling Sharonda about the idol.

8. Thien An (-1) - Was a bit more present today, talked about losing Kilby, about fluffing up her resume, but I don't think there's a point anymore.

9. Eric (-1) - Got scraps today with the extra vote thing. Can't believe that didn't backfire. And got scraps with the Jelly talk. I think he fully believes he's one of the people in charge. His edit went from annoying to irrelevant in a week's time.


r/Edgic • • 9h ago

Endgame prediction

4 Upvotes

Just wanna get my idea out there in case I end up being right. The power has shifted to the Helicopter Alliance and the next 3 boots are Carter, Christian and Thien An. Eric gets too close to Sharonda and goes out at F6. Sharonda follows him out at F5. Devin wins F4 immunity and takes Mike, sending Maggie and Jelly to fire where Maggie wins.

Then Maggie either wins in a F3 OR they take it to a F2 where Mike beats Devin with a bitter Jelly and Sharonda.


r/Edgic • • 1d ago

Traitors Canada S4 EP9 Edgic + Contenders Spoiler

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

Boring episode to a really boring season. I was higher on this season earlier on than most people were, but by this point I'm just so ready for it to be over. At least it's better than New Blood! I've been kind of washed up with contenders recently in other shows, so it'd be nice to see a Sherod win LOL

Top Contenders

  1. Sherod (=) - It is so clear that at minimum, Sherod is winning. It's just a matter of whether Spicy will also win along with him. Honestly, it's kind of a coin flip. Sherod has had a very strong edit and it's crazy how literally everyone trusts him so much. Dare I say one of the best Traitors players ever. At least top 1 for Canada.

Coin Flip

  1. Spicy Vee (=) - One of the biggest plot lines of this season has been the will they won't they of them turning on each other. Honestly, it feels similar to parts of UK4 with Stephen and Rachel. That honestly makes me feel better about this being another joint win. Either way, it's just a matter of whether Sherod solo wins or Spicy joins him.

Runner-Up Contenders

  1. Cassandra (+2) - Has had some positivity but also been shown being constantly wrong. One of two textbook archetypes for faithful runner-up edits.

  2. Aisha (-1) - Has been SUPER visible and a lot of care went into edit early on. Now it's just clear that was because she is going far. Probably gonna be the most visible player in the finale episode, as long as she isn't the first or second to go (which I doubt happens). MAYBE she gets banished after Ronnie is murdered. Still, Aisha really does fit a lock of the boxes of someone like Lisette from last season.

Not Happening

  1. Icesis (-1) - I swapped her and Aisha a few times while making this ranking. I did decide on having Aisha higher as I just really struggle to see any world where Icesis isn't banished at 5 or 4. While with Aisha, the odds of being banished earlier are slightly higher, but she at least has a way to make it further.

Murder Prediction

  1. Ronnie (+1) - While I grow less confident of this being the case the more I think about it, I'm still going to bet on her being the murder. Usually when one of these traitors pushes that a faithful is throwing the other traitors name out, that faithful gets murdered. Either way, Ronnie has a very bad edit.

Eliminated

  1. Kyle (-1) - Honestly had more of a flattering exit than I expected from his edit. Not saying it was super positive or anything, far from it, but I felt like they made him more complex than I expected.

  2. Keturah (=) - Was obviously being murdered here, no surprises there.


r/Edgic • • 1d ago

TWE S51 - E8

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
14 Upvotes

This week Spencer from Sequester Season 4 joined as we mourned the loss of Kilby, landed on a strong coin flipper prediction, and zeroes in on a small handful of contenders.


r/Edgic • • 1d ago

Results Survivor 51 Episode 8 Edgic Results

Post image
9 Upvotes

Contender ratings

  1. Sharonda 4.31
  2. Jelly 4.00
  3. Lewis 3.56
  4. Devin 2.76
  5. Maggie 2.41
  6. Mike 2.25
  7. Carter 2.24
  8. Thien An 1.76
  9. Cristian 1.47
  10. Eric 1.41

Character ratings

  1. Kilby 3.71 (five 5s, six 4s)
  2. Lewis 3.71 (five 5s, five 4s)
  3. Kristin 3.69
  4. Carter 3.65
  5. Maggie 3.44
  6. Mike 3.35
  7. Eric 3.29
  8. Jelly 3.24
  9. Devin 3.18
  10. Sharonda 3.06
  11. Thien An 2.71
  12. Cristian 2.47

Raw results

Spreadsheet


r/Edgic • • 1d ago

Koh-Lanta (French Survivor) All-Stars (s34) Final edgic Spoiler

Thumbnail gallery
4 Upvotes

r/Edgic • • 2d ago

Opening Credits Easter Eggs

Thumbnail
gallery
30 Upvotes

I remember during 45 Jeff in a short video stated that there will be Easter Eggs in the opening credits for the season and since then each season hints the winners.

45 showed Dee and Austin jumping into ocean before the credits with the name cards and then her name card was higher than others

46 showed Kenzie in the background with Tiff inside the Ocean and then the 46 logo was golden immediately after her name card.

47 hinted a silhouette of a woman holding a torch just before the Gata name cards

48 was a tricky one and couldn't deduced the Easter Eggs.

49 showed Savannah shocked after a cannon ball fired and then after her name card it showed another fired cannon ball.

50 showed Aubrey hitting a ball before the name cards started and that's the only thing I had.

For this season three people who are possible contenders have the 51 logo showed before their name cards

The first image is before Jelly's name card

The second image is before Lewis's name card

And the third image is after Devin's name card.

I don't know if these are the Easter eggs or something else. What do y'all think?


r/Edgic • • 1d ago

PREDICT NOTHING

4 Upvotes

I was trolling YouTube, hoping they dropped another one of them Sneak Peeks for episode 9, and came across this 60 second spot from a couple months back. As a Mike Truther, there were two things I found pretty compelling:

  1. Gangster’s Paradise

There is only one person who has directly been compared to a gangster so far this season - Magic Mike. Both Eric and Kristin compared Mike to a Mafia Don in the merge episode.

  1. EXPECT EVERYTHING/PREDICT NOTHING

….flashes on the screen, cut to Brady groaning pushing the box, cut to Mike’s “who me?” face, cut to Jeff “does it get much better?”, cut to Eric surprised happy screaming

🎤💁‍♂️🏆