Hello, and welcome back to Heaven, Hell and Limbo, where I am God and the Survivor contestants are my souls to judge.
Tonight we lost Lewis, who ranked **4th* in Limbo. *Contenders are dropping like flies. I was so sure that with the edit Lewis was given, he was our firemaking loser. I was wrong, he was the failed coin flipper.
So now we have a coin failure edit. What I noticed here is how often Lewis was shown embracing chaos and loving mischief. "Play dangerously," he was shown saying during the Linnea vote. A choatic player. This to me, all but puts to rest the assertion that the winner must be the contetant that's shown embracing the chaos of the season. "Permanent uncertainty" has been a plague that's haunted edgicing this season and it's claimed another victim. If we follow suit, Devin should be seen as the next "Lewis and Kilby".
I don't believe we will though. I think the lesson has been officially learned: best embodying the theme =/= the winner.
Category Explaination Time!
The Holy Trinity Theory: Narrative, complexity, visibility; the contestant that best embodies these 3 aspects in their edit has the highest likelihood of winning.
Narrative - Is the edit connecting throughlines episode-to-episode and creating a story for this contestant, or are they given only single-episode importance? Do we know their background? Their motivations? Their values? Are they given a protagonistic or a villainous edit?
Complexity - Is the edit only positive, only negative, or a well-rounded mix of both? How many different aspects of personality are we given from this contestant? How many established relationships do they have? Are they one-dimensional or multifaceted? Do other contestants speak on their game or personality?
Visibility - Is this contestant shown too much, too little, or just enough? Is it circumstantial, or unnecessary? Were they shown at fault for voting incorrectly, or were they shielded? Were they shown as a/the driver of a vote when they voted correctly, or did the edit not give them enough credit? Do their confessionals mainly consist of self-narration, or simply SPV's (Second-Person Viewpoint) for others.
Arch Angel: My selected winner. They embody the aspects of the Holy Trinity better than all other contestants.
Heaven: If a contestant falls into this category, they either embody all three or at least two aspects of the Holy Trinity very well. High, noncircumstantial visibility. Having any form of a narrative. Personal or endearing content. Is shown either mostly positively, or is shown to be multifaceted in their portrayl.
Limbo: If a contestant falls into this category, while not a death sentence, their edit is inconsistent. One episode they're shown prominently, the next they're hardly shown. One episode they're shown positively, the next they're shown not-so-favorably. Either severely lacking in one aspect of the Holy Trinity, or slightly lacking in two aspects.
Hell: If a contestant falls into this category, they are almost certainly not winning the game. Severely lacking in two or all three aspects of the Holy Trinity lands you here. Consistent negativity, not enough or any personal or endearing content. Nonexistent narrative, and/or zero complexity.
With that out of the way, let's get started with our rankings this episode!
Hellish Contestants:
9.) Eric: Eric received rare positive SPV tonight, with Cristian and Carter saying how smart and good of a move it was to keep the extra vote as a fake. This could be seen as only good for Cristian and Carter however, as "look at how this could benefit us" was my main takeaway for that scene, and less about how good of a player Eric is.
Then we have his conversation with Jelly. Which again, showcases more how he is a player to be used rather than a player that has good connections. He does display self-awarness to an extent in saying how he's sitting pretty because no one is looking at him. But that's the thing, no one is looking at him. He doesn't have a resumè. He's not a threat. He's Eric.
8.) Thien An: Thien An has for several episodes now been reduced to narrator. She's less of a player and more of a story-teller at this point. She does have a couple of interesting SPV's I want to dive into, but it really has nothing to do with her, so that's saved for actual relevant players.
7.) Cristian: Look at how he's grown. So much content recently, but it still very much feels as though he's a player to be used for a greater game being played. He's playing the middle, working with both Sharonda and Carter. And both believe to have him in their pocket. A good spot to be in gameplay wise. Editorially though, he's just a pawn.
6.) Carter: Carter was shown strangely indecisive this episode, which is a complete 180 from his confidence last episode. His Salt Alliance has completely fallen apart as we knew it would. And now, his closest ally is schemeing behind him. Carter had great potential during premerge, but since has completely fallen off.
5.) Mike: An extremely quiet episode for Mike. We had him celebrating the reward challenge and.. that's about it. I really believed him to be an up-and-coming contender only for this episode to slap me silly for even entertaining the thought.
4.) Maggie: To be clear, Maggie still isn't winning. There's little about her edit that suggests she wins in my eyes. However.. I can't ignore Jelly calling her out as a jury threat, and how well integrated she is within the camp. This is the first time someone has identified Maggie as a threat, and to me, that really just spells death. Unlike Jelly and Devin, the edit has done nothing to show how obviously threatening Maggie is as a player. The edit has shown exactly why Jelly and Devin are a threat however. But it's the fact that the edit hasn't shown why Maggie is so threatening, that makes Jelly suddenly calling her out as a threat now so damning against her. But, on the flip side she's shown eager to utilize the knowledge of Devin's "idol" against him, so that's a plus.
3.) Devin: Devin reenters Hell for a singular reason, "weaponized honesty" has reared its ugly head back out again. After having confessionals of saying "we're going to see a new Devin" only for Devin to then revert back to his destructive way of playing is his edit death. And we immediately see how this comes to bite him in the ass when his fake idol plan backfires on him. It's curtains.
Limbo; Death or Resurrection:
No contenders for Limbo this week. As we approach the latter half of the season, edits become more clear. "Potential" at this point should either be crystalizing into a winner's edit, or falling flat. This isn't to say someone being in Limbo in the future is now impossible, just highly improbable.
Heavenly Contestants:
2.) Sharonda: Alright lets dig into the real meat and potatoes of the season. At this point, it should be clear to anyone, even to those who don't edgic, that either Sharonda or Jelly is going to win this season.
First, the acknowledgment.
- I acknowledge Sharonda outright saying she gets all the credit for the immunity idol play.
- I acknowledge how many different contestants want to work with Sharonda.
- I acknowledge Sharonda being the first one to say she wants Lewis out of the game, and Lewis goes home that very episode.
- I acknowledge Sharonda saying how covert she is and no one sees her for the threat that she is.
- I acknowledge how Sharonda hasn't received a single negative thing about her edit. Neither from the edit, or contestants' SPV's about her.
- I acknowledge Sharonda as always, without fail, shown to be in the right.
So now I present my case: does no one else find it odd how there's no complexity to her edit? And I don't mean the personal content she received last episode. In my edgic, how I describe complexity is a mixture of positive and negative aspects. How many different sides of a contestant are we seeing? Are they one-note or multi-dimensional?
Sharonda is very one-note. She's always shown positively. She's always correct. She always gets her way. Where is the adversity? Where are her low moments? Where is the struggle? And I don't mean just gameplay, I mean the actual survival aspect of it all. The mental wear. The physical.
For example, this episode, we saw multiple sides of Jelly. But one thing we also saw? Hunger. We saw her angry. We saw her bitter that others got to enjoy a reward while she starved and had to listen to Lewis brag about cookies. This is complexity. This is low moments being shown. This is the struggle. This is multiple sides of a contestant being explored.
Again I ask, where is this in Sharonda's edit? Where is the multi-dimentality of it all (not a word but who cares you get it).
And lastly, the biggest blow to Sharonda right now and something I've been screaming about forever: what is her narrative? I have yet to find anything resembling an episode-by-episode story arc for Sharonda. And what's more I have yet to see other edgicers present a compelling case for what her narrative could even be. Because there truly isn't one. At least, not for a winner's narrative.
No, I believe the reason for this is because Sharonda was never our winner, she was always our dragon to be slayed by the winner.
That's why she's always shown as right. That's why she's never wrong. That's why the edit always takes care to show Sharonda as being a covert operator and why no one sees her as a threat. It's because when she is finally revealed as the threat she is, that's when...
Arch Angel:
1.) Jelly: ...will be the one to take her out. Jelly's edit, her narrative, has always been one of weighing what's best for her game since the premiere.
Before that though, acknowledgements.
- I acknowledge Jelly at the start of the episode celebrating her triple win: building her résumé, taking out what she saw as two of the biggest targets, and saved her #1 ally in Devin.
- I acknowledge the edit showing Lewis as saying Jelly is the biggest threat in the game, and then promptly losing in the same episode.
- I acknowledge Thien An restating how much of a threat Jelly is, but then saying she doesn't see a path forward with Jelly.
- I acknowledge Jelly having awareness about the fact that she has a huge target on her back.
- I acknowledge Jelly setting up Maggie as a jury threat to be taken out eventually.
- I acknowledge that even though Sharonda was the first to mention Lewis being taken out, it was Jelly shown as the one making sure all the pieces were in place and her alliance was still on go.
Now my case for why she beats Sharonda:
"Permanent uncertainty.. it sounds scary but also exhilarating. I just think.. there's so many people and so many bonds to be made." - Jelly in the premiere.
Bonds. The central theme of Jelly's story. We saw her make a bond with Jenna, and didn't want to see her leave the game. She weighed what was best for her game and her bond with Devin won out.
We see her bond with womanhood, and struggle with intersectionality in not wanting to vote out either Alexis or Devin, another woman or a POC, both being tied and bounded to her identity. We see her bond with Ori, before ultimately still going through with her bond with Devin
And now we see her bond with Sharonda. This has been a season long setup showing Jelly struggling between making decisions for what's best for her game, womanhood, black identity, and the bonds she's made within the game.
For the longest time, I believed Jelly's narrative and edit to indicate her taking out Devin as her win condition. But what if I was wrong? What if it was because I didn't have all the pieces to the puzzle yet?
What if Jelly's win condition the entire time wasn't taking out Devin, but taking out Sharonda?
Their souls have been judged, until next week.