r/EdwardII • • 8h ago

Tiresome myths The Middle Ages according to historians VS the middle ages according to "Hollywood"

Thumbnail
youtube.com
6 Upvotes

This is a good, simple non-AI video lasting only 1:33 mins. which nicely points out what's wrong with the way Hollywood insists on portraying medieval towns. Make it make sense. It's so dumb.


r/EdwardII • • 6h ago

People The Women Who Mothered Edward II

Thumbnail
themedievalbeekeeper.com
5 Upvotes

Oh Edward, you really did like to be mothered!


r/EdwardII • • 4h ago

Discussion The "Sea-Monster"— Hugh Despenser the Younger, Terror of the English Channel

Post image
5 Upvotes

In August 1321, armed barons surrounded London in matching green-and-yellow liveries and forced King Edward II to banish his favorite, Hugh Despenser the Younger, from England forever. Hugh's aging father boarded a ship and retired quietly to Bordeaux to wait out the political storm. Hugh the Younger had other ideas. Instead of slinking off into French exile, he stepped onto the deck of an armed warship in the Strait of Dover, teamed up with the toughest privateers on the English coast, and spent the autumn of 1321 terrorizing the English Channel; earning himself an unforgettable nickname from a contemporary chronicler who called him a "sea-monster."

Hugh was an inland Welsh Marcher lord who didn't know a bowline from a rudder, so he partnered with a man who did: Robert Batail of Winchelsea, a seasoned Baron of the Cinque Ports and one of the sharpest naval commanders in England. Together with a pack of veteran Kent and Sussex shipmasters, Hugh and Batail turned the Narrow Seas between Dover and Calais into a private hunting ground.

Their biggest prize came off the sands of Sandwich. Out of the Channel mist loomed two massive Genoese merchant carracks, towering Mediterranean "dromonds" built like floating castles and packed to the gunwales with luxury Italian cloth, rare Eastern spices, and chests of silver bullion. Hugh's low-slung cogs swarmed the heavy merchantmen, grappled their hulls, and swarmed over the rails with swords and crossbows. After a brutal deck fight that left Genoese sailors dead in the scuppers, Hugh's men stripped the holds clean and hauled a king's ransom in contraband back toward their coastal anchorages.

Emboldened by the Sandwich haul, Hugh and Batail grew even bolder. At the end of September 1321, while technically an outlaw under sentence of death if he set foot on English soil, Hugh sailed his flotilla straight into Southampton Water. Over September 30 and October 1, his crews raided the port of Southampton itself, seizing cargo and shaking down coastal shipping right under the noses of local authorities who had no fleet strong enough to stop him.

Even wilder was what happened after dark. Hugh wasn't just raiding ships; he was running a shadow war room from the sea. While royal heralds officially proclaimed him banished, King Edward II repeatedly rode down to the Kentish coast at Queenborough and the Isle of Thanet, and later near Portchester. Under cover of night, small boats slipped out of the surf onto the shingle beaches, bringing Hugh ashore to meet the King in person, plan the winter military campaign against the barons, and row back out to his fleet before dawn.

When Edward II's army finally crushed the Marcher rebellion in early 1322 and cancelled Hugh's exile, Hugh stepped off his flagship and marched straight back into Westminster as the most powerful man in England. With a few strokes of the royal pen, he handed out blanket pardons to Robert Batail and his Cinque Ports captains, turning a gang of Channel pirates into honored naval officers overnight.

The only people who never forgot the autumn of 1321 were the merchants of Genoa. Furious over the butchered crews and stolen carracks off Sandwich, Genoa slapped trade embargoes on English wool and hounded the English Crown for compensation for fifteen years; creating the exact diplomatic pipeline that later brought papal notary Manuele Fieschi (author of the famous letter claiming Edward II survived Berkeley Castle) directly into the English royal court.

Primary Sources: Vita Edwardi Secundi; Calendar of Patent Rolls (1321–1324); Calendar of Close Rolls (1321–1322); The National Archives SC 8/17/833 (Southampton Raid Petition); Rotuli Parliamentorum (1321 & 1326); Anglo-Genoese Diplomatic & Compensation Rolls (Edward II–Edward III).