r/EngineBuilding • u/190e30 • 7h ago
Chrysler/Mopar Another "What's that noise" post - need someone smarter than me
Hey all,
The video above is my 2002 Dodge Neon I'm supposed to go to the track with in two days. The car has 32k miles, but it's also a former SCCA car. It's spry, but it's also lived hard on occasion.
Bought it knowing it had a "tick" and an original belt when I bought it, did a bunch of work (including new rockers) right after I got it (literally within 5 miles). On startup again, I noticed the tick sounded more like a bottom end noise in my uneducated opinion and seemed to become fully audible around 5 min of idling, but neons are notoriously rattly.
Drove the car 300 miles and drained oil/cut filter last week to find a good amount of non-ferrous. After removing the valve cover, it became apparent multiple new rockers were defective. Roller bearings were dumping aluminum into the motor.
Swapped back in the old ones (which looked totally fine) and the motor got noticeably quieter...but once the oil gets some heat in it, that bottom end noise returned.
Dropped the pan and pulled the rod caps. Nothing visibly concerning and no play. Reassembled with original bearings, lube and everything as it came out (in theory - a perpetual self-doubter, kept waking up last night thinking I had to have done something wrong).
Start the car up, whisper quiet. Nice.
5 min into idling, I have the video you see above. Same noise, same rhythm - makes sense, I literally took it apart and put it back together with everything the same minus the rod bolts.
I have to go out and drive it today and see if it gets worse (indicating I screwed something up during reinstall) but it seems to be same volume/location. Plan was to change the oil one more time and go for it, assuming the next change isn't complete glitter from me damaging the bearings on install.
What the fuck is this? Logic says it wouldn't be piston slap, because it starts when warm. Even if it's rod bearings now courtesy of yours truly, it wasn't when I opened the motor up. Maybe something in the head?