I’m a mens foil fencer, so im only talking about MF in this post. You look at a recent World Cup, so many off the line actions that both fencers genuinely think is their point. Sure, sometimes it is genuinely one fencer initiating and the other reacting, but most times you have both fencers initiating attacks and one gets the point because he sold it better. The other fencer is not really counterattacking, he’s attacking 50 milliseconds after.
At what point are we deciding touches based on factors not relevant to who’s performing the best actions? I’m not saying it’s necessarily wrong; I accept it as part of the game that I’m in (especially in my NCAA bouts where that shit is 4/9 possible touches in every bout). But can we ask, does this really make fencing a better sport that more fairly rewards the better athlete? Or does it add an element of randomness and human error that causes referee controversies and upsets fencers unnecessarily? Simultaneous is an available call, why not use it? Because technically one fencer was 1.5 inches ahead on his extension when you look at slow motion video replay?
There’s a reason why, for example, Olympic swimming doesn’t count down to the millisecond on the timer. It’s because doing so reduces otherwise-equal competitive results down to randomness, like sensor sensitivity or circuit speed. At that point, you are increasing precision to lower accuracy. You are no longer tracking who the best performer is and rather tracking which one got luckier. Now, of course the off the line game is not by any means entirely random. But it is still holds that the less inclined you are to call simultaneous, the more randomness you introduce.
I actually really like the world fencing league system. If both fencers make a solid effort to attack immediately off the line, it’s always simultaneous. After that, a random fencer is given the advantage to score the next off the line touch, should there be one. Then if there is, the advantage switches over.
I think a goal of the ruleset should be to minimize the burden on the referee and maximize the ability of the fencer to secure points with his own abilities. This makes EVERYONE happier