i've played both FFX and FFVII pretty recently, and i went into VII already knowing how it goes (yeah yeah, the whole internet made sure of that years ago). X i went in totally blind. so basically i got this weird little experiment where one gut punch was announced like 40 hours ahead of time and the other one came out of nowhere.
and the strange part? the one that ambushed me hurt LESS. its sad, obviously, im not made of stone, i teared up, but it didnt follow me around afterwards. the other one did. im still kinda annoyed about it tbh.
everyone keeps saying X has the saddest ending in the series and i just cant agree, and i think i know why, but explaining it means spoiling both games so everything below is tagged. if you havent finished them stop here, seriously.
X lets you say goodbye. thats the whole thing. Tidus and Yuna get their moment, he gets to say what he needs to say, his entire party sends him off, and the ending even leaves you a little crumb of hope that hes still out there somewhere. its devastating but its clean. its a tragedy that holds your hand the whole way through.
VII doesnt hold your hand, it doesnt even look at you. Aerith spends the first third of the game being the warmest thing in it, the flowers, the church, the way she teases Cloud, the only person who treats him like a human being instead of a weapon, and the game spends all that time making sure you love her. and then she goes off alone to do the one thing nobody else can do, kneels down to pray, and theres nobody with her. she dies alone. thats what i cant get over. not that she died, but that she was by herself, and her last act was faith in a world that didnt even give her a witness.
and then Cloud. his own sword raised over her. his hands. sure its Sephiroth puppeteering him, but the game still makes you sit there with that image. no last words, no "it wasnt your fault", nothing. she never even gets to tell him anything. then the lake, he lays her in the water and lets it take her, and about a minute later the game goes ok back to the quest. no funeral, no time. you dont get to grieve, you get a missing party slot. all the hours you spent levelling her up, just gone. the game doesnt just kill her, it deletes her from your menu. thats mean. thats genuinely mean and i think its exactly why it works.
and the relationship itself never got to be anything. thats the part that eats at me. its all almost-moments, the gold saucer, the things nobody says out loud. X lets Tidus and Yuna actually be a couple before it takes them apart. VII takes the possibility away before it ever became a fact. you grieve a person AND a future that never even got to be a maybe.
so honestly? i think VII is the crueler one, by a mile. X is a heartbreak with a goodbye and an epilogue. VII is a heartbreak with a hole in it, and holes dont close. it isnt about the surprise, i knew it was coming and it still destroyed me, its about the no closure, the no dignity in how it