TL;DR: I got 615 on my first official attempt, then 675 (Q85 V83 DI82), the 94th percentile, on my second. My prep was course-based, with a mentor reading my data, so it wasn't self-study. Three things mattered:
- An error log that showed which block was leaking points
- Writing constraints down before solving
- Skipping a Quant question after about 2.5 minutes
Where I started
My first official attempt was a 615. Before I got proper guidance my prep was haphazard. I was hitting every topic at once instead of working block by block.
What I was getting wrong
In Quant I saw a question and just started solving, and I missed a lot of constraints. In CR, for the first three or four months, I only studied why the correct answer was correct. In table analysis I read fast and clicked.
Three things that helped
Error log. Every week or two I sent my mentor my error log and what I'd achieved, and they sent back insights from it and my data. After 8 to 10 Quant quizzes, the practice platform's block-by-block view showed algebra was fine except absolute values, or except inequalities. Before solving, I read the question for 30 seconds and wrote down every constraint. Once they were written, I often had the answer in about a minute.
CR. I stopped looking only at the options and started thinking before reading them. I also began working out why each wrong option is wrong, until I could state the reason.
Table analysis. I wrote out every statement and started with the easiest, to build confidence. Within two to three weeks it became one of my strongest areas, with hard accuracy at 80 to 90%. My mentor noticed I sometimes had the right answer but switched the columns, so I started writing what option one and option two were each asking.
Mocks and test day
Sectionals felt easy next to a full-length, where you sit for two and a half hours. In my last two weeks I did two sectionals back to back, even if the first went badly, because one bad section can't be allowed to wreck the next two.
On my second official attempt the first Quant question was calculation-heavy. I gave it 2.5 minutes, skipped it and moved on. It was still wrong after review, but the rest of the section held up. In DI I finished in about 43 minutes with one question left. I skipped it, got the next one right and then went back.
What I'd do differently
When I returned to a flagged question I started again from zero and wasted about a minute. Keep your partial work on paper and continue from it.
I also did MSR first. It cost me in both attempts, and I got all three wrong on the second. Data sufficiency was harder than MSR in both exams, so doing MSR first didn't pay off for me.
Final thoughts
This is one person's experience, not a promise. It may help if your section scores look fine but one block keeps leaking points. Ask me anything.