r/Gnostic • • 17h ago

Thoughts Gnosticism Beats Christianity on Answering Problem of Evil

Thumbnail
19 Upvotes

r/Gnostic • • 6h ago

Information An open academic space for studying early Christian diversity

3 Upvotes

Hi all. I study early Christian texts historically, and I think the Nag Hammadi library, the Gospel of Thomas, and related texts deserve to be studied as historical sources in their own right, especially for what they tell us about the New Testament and its world.

The main scholarship Bible subreddit, r/AcademicBiblical, is quite restrictive about sources and posts. I go to subreddits like r/CredibleDefense a lot, and I noticed they have a space called r/LessCredibleDefence for posts that don’t meet the rigorous qualifications of r/CredibleDefense. I always thought that r/AcademicBiblical should have a similar alternative. If you can’t post something on r/AcademicBiblical, but it’s a serious academically grounded contribution, then I believe there should be a space for that. So, I’ve created r/OpenAcademicBiblical as an alternative.

It’s a new subreddit. I am the only mod there at this time. I welcome new submissions and mod candidates too. Here’s a summary of the basic rules:

  • Be respectful and no ad hominem attacks. Intense debate is okay, but don’t ever make it personal.
  • All perspectives are welcome: Gnostic, Christian, Jewish, skeptic, or otherwise. Just make a historical case and cite your sources. Scholars like Elaine Pagels, Karen King, Michael Williams, David Brakke, April DeConick, and Marvin Meyer are all fair game, and so is anyone who disagrees with them.
  • Patristic sources are usable as evidence, but not all patristic sources are equal. When it comes to the Gnostics, Irenaeus and Epiphanius are hostile witnesses, and posts that weigh their reliability critically are welcome.
  • Non-canonical texts are welcome, but posts should connect them to the biblical texts or their historical context (parallels, dependence, dating, reception). For example, a post comparing the Gospel of Thomas with Matthew and Luke fits; a post solely on Pistis Sophia’s cosmology doesn’t.
  • Use proper sources and do not misrepresent your sources. Keep it historical, critical, and not devotional.
  • AI use is permitted to research, brainstorm, organize, edit, etc., but not to generate the post itself. If a post is considered majority AI-generated, it will be removed.
  • Feel free to ask questions via post as long as they are decently structured questions.

Fair warning: some of my own posts argue against early dates for texts like Thomas. If you disagree, I’d genuinely like to hear it. Bring sources, and let’s discuss.

If you’re interested in Gnostic texts, early Christian diversity, or the history behind the Nag Hammadi library, I hope to see you at r/OpenAcademicBiblical!


r/Gnostic • • 8h ago

On the Absolute—Book Recomendation

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

The “Pythagorean doctrine of the first Principle as an ultimate unity (the One) and the Peripatetic doctrine (…) that the first Principle is the divine Intellect thinking itself, these two perspectives are in fact easily reconcilable (…) the realization that Intellect cannot be regarded as the ultimate Principle may be the outcome of exegesis (…) or stem from a rigorous analysis of transcendent unity as the basic reality.

The One is boiling with activity, though it is viewed as simple and non-composite, i.e, without parts and internal or external relations. The term ‘One’ does not really describe the Principle, which is beyond form; it is therefore false even to say of it that it is one. Being formless (amorphon) and infinite (apeiron), the One, as a perfect actuality (energeia), contains everything and lacks nothing, thus having the supreme power (dunamis) to generate the noetic world. This does not mean that the One is compelled to generate being, life, and intelligence: it simply causes the existence of all manifested reality by the principle that its contains everything and lacks nothing, thus having the supreme power (dunamis) to generate the noetic world.

This does not mean that the One is compelled to generate being, life, and intelligence: it simply causes the existence of all manifested reality by the principle that its inexhaustible perfection and freedom (itself beyond necessity) produces by sheer undiminished giving, like water flowing from a source or light radiating from the sun.

Since the One is the universal cause of all things, it is not only transcendent but also immanent: its omnipresence fills all things. The final causality of the One is related to the actualization of Intellect and the mystical return of the soul to its source.”

— The Heart of Plotinus