r/GrahamHancock • • 21h ago

Cave west of Hail, Saudi Arabia, with paintings Dr. Eid Al-Yahya identifies as lions, zebra and kudu, next to Thamudic inscriptions.

28 Upvotes

Dr. Eid Al-Yahya inside a cave west of Hail, Saudi Arabia. The original video is in Arabic with no English subtitles: https://youtu.be/W5vmnHgyZIk. An unofficial English translation of his words is in the first comment. I'm sharing it because the cave combines painted animals he identifies as a lion, zebra and kudu with Thamudic inscriptions, which, if his reading holds, bears on how we understand Arabia's green savanna phase. The identifications and dating are his own interpretations, not established findings, and I'd welcome input from specialists.


r/GrahamHancock • • 22h ago

Ancient Civ Where did Noah's Ark actually land? Comparing the Quran, Genesis, and Gilgamesh with real geography in Turkey

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I've been researching the flood narrative lately and looking into where the ark might have actually ended up. If we put aside the extreme theories for a second and just look at the three oldest written accounts alongside the actual geography of eastern Turkey and northern Iraq, some really interesting patterns show up.

Starting with the texts themselves, they each give us very different clues:

* The Quran: It doesn't actually give any dimensions for the boat, just that it was made of planks and nails (Surah Al-Qamar 54:13), Noah preached for 950 years (29:14), and one of his sons refused to get on board. What it does give is a specific mountain name in Surah Hud (11:44): "And it was said, 'O earth, swallow your water, and O sky, withhold [your rain].' And the water subsided, and the matter was accomplished, and the ship came to rest on Mount Judi...".

* Genesis: The biblical account gets way more specific about the build—gopher wood, pitch, three decks, and exact measurements of 300 by 50 by 30 cubits, which puts it around 135 to 157 meters long (Genesis 6:14–16). As for the landing spot, Genesis 8:4 simply says it came to rest on the "mountains of Ararat" (notice it's plural).

* The Epic of Gilgamesh: Tablet XI is older than both of these. Here, Utnapishtim builds a massive, pitch-coated cube, and after the storm, the text says: "On Mount Nisir the ship came to a halt; Mount Nisir held the ship fast, allowing no motion." Most historians link Mount Nisir to the Zagros range near the Iraq-Iran border, which puts it in the same broader southern region as Mount Judi.

Now, if you look at the actual terrain in eastern Turkey today, the debate usually comes down to three spots:

  1. The Durupinar site (Pic 1): This is that famous boat-shaped geological formation about 29 km south of Mount Ararat that a Turkish pilot spotted back in 1959. The most surprising thing about it is its length—right around 157 meters, which lines up almost perfectly with the 300 cubits from Genesis. That said, almost every geologist who's looked at it says it's just a natural mudflow and rock formation, and there's zero archaeological proof of any wood structure there.

  2. Mount Ararat (Pic 2): It's over 5,100 meters high and covered in glaciers. Honestly, trying to land a massive wooden ship on a freezing, jagged volcanic peak and expecting animals to walk down from there doesn't make a whole lot of sense practically. Most historians point out that the biblical "mountains of Ararat" was really just referring to the ancient Kingdom of Urartu as a whole region, not this specific peak.

  3. Mount Judi / Cudi Dağı (Pic 3): Located much further south near the Tigris River and the Iraqi border. It's at a way lower elevation and sits right above ancient Mesopotamia. Both early Middle Eastern traditions (Judi) and the oldest Mesopotamian story (Nisir) put the landing right in this southern area, centuries before Mount Ararat became the standard tradition in the West.

To me, Durupinar has that interesting coincidence with the Genesis measurements, which is hard to ignore, but the southern mountains (Judi/Nisir) make way more sense geographically and actually line up with both the Quran and Gilgamesh.

What is your opinion? Do you think the northern Ararat/Durupinar sites are more likely, or does the southern mountain range make more sense to you?