EDIT: Thank you for all your feedback! I feel better knowing there are others and that you guys are playing just fine. It’s really motivating to hear!😊
TL;DR: I’m a beginner guitarist with a short, bent pinky, which makes it difficult to play without muting the string below it. I’ve tried changing my hand and thumb position, but either my pinky still mutes the strings or the rest of my hand gets cramped. Most advice I’ve found is about having short fingers in general, so I’m wondering if anyone has dealt with a similar problem. Should I keep practicing exercises like the spider walk even if I’m muting strings, just to build strength and coordination? I’d love to hear from anyone who has found a workaround. I need some hope that I can actually get better.😭
Hi!
So I bought an electric guitar 2 weeks ago. I started on an acoustic a while back before I kinda gave up when I was trying to learn barre chords.😭 It’s been a bit easier on the electric.
So I was doing some exercises and then I noticed that my fretting hand looked really different compared to the videos. My fingers are quite bent, especially my pinky finger. As you can see on the 2nd pic. I can’t press down the string with just the fingertip, which causes the string to mute sometimes and the string bellow it to mute almost every time.
I tried adjusting my hand position but I just end up with a cramped hand and still muted strings! I noticed this when I was doing the spider walk exercise, the string pressed down with my pinky was playing okay but when I moved my other fingers to the string bellow (keeping the rest of the fingers on a string always, just clarifying cause I saw some people doing the spider walk with lifting their fingers), they end up being muted by the pinky.
I’ve also tried shifting the whole hand and moving my thumb lower to make more room for the fingers to stretch. That helps the pinky finger a little but then I struggle with the rest of the fingers. The finger is just so freaking bent that I’m literally pressing with the tip and the side of the finger too. And the further the stretch, the more that tip of the pinky finger is going toward the other fingers and laying on its side.
The issue is not only that the finger is bent but also the fact that it’s much shorter than the rest of the fingers which is also making it harder to adjust and finding a comfortable position.
All the videos I’ve seen are about having short fingers in general, so not that helpful.
I was thinking if I should just do the spider walk exercise anyways, even if the strings are muted to get my fingers get used to switching strings etc. MAYBE it would get better if my pinky finger got stronger. What do you think, would this be a bad approach?
And before anyone says it - I know there are many people who can play well despire having any kind of disadvantages!
I’m still very much a beginner. Been pretty demotivated to continue and just stick to what I already know. But I want to get better! I’d really appreciate any advice and if you struggle with the same thing and managed to play around it, let me know! I would love to hear that there’s hope for me.🤣
Oh and I keep my nails as short as possible. This was just a quick photo.