I have done some very rough testing on different shelling scaling with specifically the wsfb loop, thatâs my preferred way of playing the gunlance but couldnât find anything on how they were just how wide and normal shelling were different in a few ways. So I took it into my own hands
Im normally a Lance player so switching to gunlance has been a good fun and nice change of pace a little but I always love playing as tanky as possible too
But anyway I made 2 gogma GLs and one with normal one with wide shells and put them head to head
I did this on the training dummy set to 7 star and no wounds inflicted and soft hide if that matters
At base they felt with the full combo including wyverns fire and a double wsfb combo, these come with small variance depending on crits and what not so not perfect but close
Normal 1630~
Wide 1550~
So at base with 0 skills on that help with anything normal is flat better, but there are a few things such as wide charged shellings firing so much faster that they absolutely have higher dps and charge the wyverns fire faster, speaking of which
Normal wyverns fire only 530~
Wide wyverns fire only 830~
This was expected it has been known that wide helped the wyverns fire a lot a lot
But something kinda crazy happened here, I wanted to see how they scaled up with attack boost and stuff of that sort, so I put on my personally build which honestly, isnât done yet, but still gives a good base level of understanding in how they scale. I will leave a picture of my build if anyone wants to give recommendations tho Iâm definitely taking some
The full combos with the build on went like this
Full load out wide 2300~
Full load out normal 2300~
They equaled out
These numbers do go up and down a little especially since itâs based on when certain perks proc
Which was really really crazy to me at least personally, so Iâm definitely going with wide for the faster charge speeds if there isnât any sort of meaningful difference in damage especially since it seems that wide ends up scaling a bit faster due to higher wyverns fire damage.
Sorry if this is all known already I just couldnât personally find anything on which would be best for my play style. I tried to but all I heard was that wide was good for it and then normal was good for it. So I wanted to look and see for sure for myself. So again sorry if this isnât needed or known I just thought it was interesting I hope this helps someone with something at some point tho