r/HIMYM • • Jul 07 '22

Hi, I'm Carter Bays, co-creator of HIMYM. I’m also the author of a new novel called THE MUTUAL FRIEND. AMA!

3.7k Upvotes

Hello Reddit, it's been a while! I'm here ask-me-anything-ing because I’ve written a new novel called THE MUTUAL FRIEND, which I think you'll love. I’m happy to talk about that, or How I Met Your Mother, or anything else. Maybe the Loch Ness Monster? I was just in Scotland with my son and we have opinions. Have at it!

UPDATE: Wow, its been much fun talking to you all, and I see that I've only scratched the surface here and there's many more questions to get to, but if I don't get my son some dinner soon he might tie me up with a phone charger. I will try to come back to this over the next few days in order to get to as many of these as I can, but in the meantime, thank you all so much for being here. Your love for HIMYM is really touching and I'm so grateful for all of it.

And please if you get the chance check out my novel THE MUTUAL FRIEND -- I'm dreadfully proud of it. (Can you tell I've been in the UK for a week? I'm like Lily before the intervention at this point.) Anyway, cheerio!


r/HIMYM • • 9h ago

🤵🏼‍♂️Stinson. Barney.. Stinson.

Post image
565 Upvotes

r/HIMYM • • 5h ago

This guy is the only reason to rewatch the 9th season

Post image
87 Upvotes

r/HIMYM • • 3h ago

Hammond Druthers is probably freaking out right now

Post image
34 Upvotes

r/HIMYM • • 22h ago

Marshall Eriksen set the standard so high that nobody else in sitcom history even comes close.

Post image
831 Upvotes

r/HIMYM • • 2h ago

Musical theater time! I haven't seen anyone post this here yet. Josh is playing Josh!

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/HIMYM • • 3h ago

Robin is an amazing character

Post image
18 Upvotes

One of the things that gets me so involved with the series is how they unfold the female counterpart of the male main character so well. I feel like in most of the sitcoms she would be releged to a modern damsel in distress archetype and her journey would be all about her realizing Ted is a good guy and she should settle down and meanwhile those are still dilemmas in her arch she's stuffed with so much more. Her relationship with her father, her career goals, her loneliness, her insecurities and not in a shallow way, but in a deeper somehow even tragic way, she got her happy ending and she makes us learn our happy ending might look like the thinga we want the most but nothing like the path we thought we'd choosen to walk


r/HIMYM • • 28m ago

After completed the HIMYM i am started watching NEW GIRL

Post image
• Upvotes

Is it good decision.i watch 3 ep and love all the ep
and i dont hate summer that much now hahaahahahahah


r/HIMYM • • 8h ago

Still can't imagine how they found a perfect cast for Tracy

34 Upvotes

I mean, Cristin Milioti is perfect for Tracy. Considering how many details we have already known about her, the producers really found a perfect cast for Tracy.

It's not like the original five, we knew little about the character at the beginning. The actors/actresses themselves help shape the character through their acting. For example, Ted, who the thing we only knew at pilot is he fell in love with Robin at first sight and is the narrator. Later we knew that he had a lot of quirky interests, he intended to romanticize everything, he is a people pleaser, he cared about everyone he loves. But how did we believe that? By Josh's acting.

But casting Tracy is like casting for HP or LOTR, tens of millions of people already had imaginations and expectations of how she should look, how she should interact with others, even how she walks, how she talks.

And Cristin Milioti met every aspect of the expectations and imaginations in just an hour of screen time, while having incredible chemistry with Ted, sometimes even better than Robin. It's just "wow'. If the producers made a different decision, probably people wouldn't argue about the ending for a decade because no one would care if she died or not.

It's exactly because Cristin Milioti did such a great job that it's heart-wrenching that she died in the finale. Anyway, words failed me, I couldn't think of any other character with so many expectations and imaginations is so perfectly cast in the TV history.


r/HIMYM • • 3h ago

Accidental Foreshadowing in The Platinum Rule?

11 Upvotes

I just re-watched S3E11, the platinum rule, and notice an interesting piece of dialogue. At the end of the episode, Ted explains that he does not care that the odds are stacked against him and Stella working out, it’s not enough to stop him from trying. Then he says something along the lines of “and when it doesn’t work out, it could be for one of 1 million reasons won’t be for some stupid rule.”

For re-watchers, of course, we know that Stella ends up leaving Ted because Tony is at the wedding, which is why Ted adamantly repeats the rule “don’t invite an ex to a wedding.” It seems like a rule is the reason they broke up after all.


r/HIMYM • • 5h ago

Fine.

12 Upvotes

You want it to be a chain of screaming? Its a chain of screaming. I came up with the circle idea halfway through because I thought it was a more elegant metaphor, but fine, RUIN IT. You guys always undermine me when I'm trying to make a point and I'm sick of it! God! I'm surrounded by idiots! IDIOTS!


r/HIMYM • • 11h ago

Lily and Marshall

Post image
33 Upvotes

Lily and Marshall are like the father and mother of the gang the glue that holds them together


r/HIMYM • • 13h ago

"Reporter attacked by owl"

Post image
37 Upvotes

r/HIMYM • • 14h ago

🕊️ RIP Larry Poindexter: Veteran Actor who appeared in scores of different shows as well as HIMYM

Thumbnail gallery
21 Upvotes

RIP! If you look at this guy young and old, you will see that you have been watching him for decades. And what a tragic way to die! FFS!


r/HIMYM • • 4h ago

Zitch dog

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/HIMYM • • 2h ago

you cant just tack on a new ending because you are not satisfied with how a story wraps up

0 Upvotes

in S5 E19 Zoo or false; ted said this when barney was trying to give a new false ending to his story... and well was he preparing us for the bigger heartbreak as if the show was supposed to not end with an ending that would have felt "satisfactory"


r/HIMYM • • 4h ago

HIMYM Survivor! (Season 5 Edition) Round 20

Post image
0 Upvotes

Jenkins is eliminated! Only the top 5 remain now.

How this works:

You select the episode you like the least

The episode with the most upvoted comment is eliminated from the list

Please either refrain from downvoting or upvote more episodes than you downvote

If there’s a tie, both episodes are eliminated

Only the best episode will win!

Episodes Eliminated:

Zoo or False (76%)
Hooked (28%)
Duel Citizenship (45%)
Slapsgiving 2: Revenge of the Slap (36%)
The Rough Patch (56%)
Last Cigarette Ever (44%)
Bagpipes (61%)
Twin Beds (29%)
The Wedding Bride (35%)
Home Wreckers (40%)
Girls vs Suits (34%)
Double Date (30%)
Say Cheese (23%)
The Perfect Week (38%)
Robin 101 (43%)
The Window (30%)
Doppelgangers (38%)
Definitions (47%)
Jenkins (39%)


r/HIMYM • • 2d ago

🏆 Barney for the Win

Post image
8.1k Upvotes

r/HIMYM • • 2d ago

Marshall’s journey in Season 9 is the most boring storyline in the entire show....!!!

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

Watching the show for the first time


r/HIMYM • • 23h ago

I think HIMYM is the only show that feels authentic to the experience of life

3 Upvotes

While it's not my number ONE favorite sitcom, it's absolutely up there. And as the title says, I think it feels the most like real life. I'm not saying it's realistic at all really, but the characters feel a lot more willing to be unlikeable sometimes than most other shows. And I do mean everyone. There are plenty of moments where every character (except marshall) says or does something so annoying or outright selfish that you feel like you just hate that character now. Then eventually they do something super wholesome and selfless and now you've forgiven them. That feels real. Sometimes, on occasion, the people you love thoroughly piss you off. And you feel like you hate them. But that doesn't last. Eventually you remember why you love them and all but forget what they did to make you mad at them. Lily, for example, makes me hate her because of her self-righteousness and her meddling and then resorting to "Oh I'm just lil ol Lily, how could I have known" whenever her meddling temporarily ruins someone's life. But she's also a very good and very loyal friend to everyone in the group and is there for them when any of them need her. Like the conversation between her and Ted when he tells her he's selling the house in season 9. Or Ted, who can come off as absolutely insufferable, or pretentious, or hypocritical. But he is also so generous and cares more about others than he does himself. Like his speech about (I just rewatched the whole show so S9 examples are all that's coming to mind rn but I stand by this applying to the whole show) how he knows Barney makes Robin happy and he would never be a part of ruining that, even though it meant he had to TURN DOWN the girl he'd repeatedly admitted to still being in love with. And even when people act out of character, they act out of character in character if that makes sense. Like sometimes irl people act in ways you'd never expect from them. But they're still the same person. Same goes for HIMYM. And I love the way you can interpret the scenes in different ways sometimes. For example, the scene where Ted is trying to tell Barney Robin isn't as cool as he thinks and he should stop being so playboyish. Barney sort of snaps at Ted and says "Oh right, cause you know my fiance better than me." And Ted says "I'm just saying, if I were marrying her-" and Barney cuts in "but you aren't, Ted. Robin's marrying me, not you." That could be read as Barney is being unnecessarily rude and insistent that he knows his woman best. Prideful and mean to his best friend. But on the other hand you could read it as Ted being way too familiar and presuming that he WOULD know Robin better than Barney, maybe on some subconscious level because he still loves her and thinks he loves her ergo knows her more than Barney does. Anyway just wanted to rant about my love for this show, self-five 🙏


r/HIMYM • • 1d ago

The show is on sale!

Post image
49 Upvotes

I’ve been waiting for the show to go on sale for the past few months. I missed it a few times but it just went down to $29.99 on Apple TV


r/HIMYM • • 3h ago

SLAP BET

0 Upvotes

I just hate the slap bet bit so much. it makes me so upset how Marshal dangles it in front of Barney seeming so happy to be able to hit him. I’m not soft I swear i just hate it lmao. It also just seems so out of character for Marshall.


r/HIMYM • • 1d ago

HIMYM Survivor! (Season 5 Edition) Round 19

Post image
5 Upvotes

Definitions is eliminated!

How this works:

You select the episode you like the least

The episode with the most upvoted comment is eliminated from the list

Please either refrain from downvoting or upvote more episodes than you downvote

If there’s a tie, both episodes are eliminated

Only the best episode will win!

Episodes Eliminated:

Zoo or False (76%)
Hooked (28%)
Duel Citizenship (45%)
Slapsgiving 2: Revenge of the Slap (36%)
The Rough Patch (56%)
Last Cigarette Ever (44%)
Bagpipes (61%)
Twin Beds (29%)
The Wedding Bride (35%)
Home Wreckers (40%)
Girls vs Suits (34%)
Double Date (30%)
Say Cheese (23%)
The Perfect Week (38%)
Robin 101 (43%)
The Window (30%)
Doppelgangers (38%)
Definitions (47%)


r/HIMYM • • 2d ago

Hate her

Post image
2.7k Upvotes

She is such a bitch. She wants both ted and barney.

When ted shower her with love she want barney. And as soon as barney loves her she want ted.

When ted and barney love some other person then bang she wants them. Why do they have to write such a character.

Can anybody be like her irl? Hate her so much.


r/HIMYM • • 20h ago

I never understood why marshall did this

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Why did marshall put the soup and jalapeno poppers in his suit case 🫪