I am looking at Oscar Health who is new for 2027 to the South Carolina market, but has sold ACA plans into North Carolina since 2025. I live in South Carolina next to the Charlotte, NC area where there are 4 health systems within 50 miles, 3 in North Carolina and 1 in South Carolina. The 1 in South Carolina has a small, limited hospital with few doctors and is not suitable for a major health problem (trauma, heart, cancer, stroke, orthopedics, etc.). The vast majority of doctors and care options are affiliated with the 3 health systems in North Carolina (Atrium, Novant, Caromont).
Healthcare.gov says that Oscar has Atrium and Caromont in network, but Novant is not in network. Oscar’s network search and provider directory for the South Carolina plan shows all 3 North Carolina health systems (Atrium, Novant and Caromont) in network. Atrium Health has promoted a partnership with Oscar Health in North Carolina. However, Atrium’s website says that Oscar Health in South Carolina is not in network for 2027. I verified this by calling Atrium’s billing department. Novant’s website says that Oscar South Carolina plans are in network for 2027, even though healthcare.gov says they are not. Caromont’s website says Oscar is in network for North Carolina but doesn’t say anything about South Carolina plans. I tried contacting Oscar, but the website and phone calls are geared toward transferring me to a third party to enroll in the plan. There are disclaimers that their network is still under development, subject to change, and that they do not take responsibility for content provided by third parties.
A health plan that only has providers and one hospital in South Carolina has almost no value compared to a plan that has access to Charlotte specialists and hospitals. Since nothing aligns between healthcare.gov, Oscar and the health systems, I have no idea if this is a useful plan and may have to rule out Oscar. Oscar did not reply to an email requesting provider network verification.
Are ACA plans allowed to publish whatever aspirational provider network they wish? I know that provider networks can change whenever disputes or pricing disagreements arise, but I need some sense of value before committing to an ACA plan for the next year. Unfortunately, other companies are not looking good either. Thanks in advance for any suggestions.