I recently hired a contractor to install a wooden exterior stair railing with aluminum spindles on my newly poured concrete steps.
The railing looks nice overall, but I’ve noticed that it has quite a bit of side-to-side movement when pressure is applied to the top rail. The movement is especially noticeable near the bottom where the 4×4 posts connect to the concrete steps.
The brackets currently installed are marked MiTek D44-TZ. They appear to be surface-mounted to the concrete with several fasteners, with the 4×4 posts secured inside the brackets.
I brought the movement to the contractor’s attention. Initially, he told me that the brackets were bending more than they should and that he had selected the less expensive brackets to save me money. He has since suggested replacing them with different brackets, but is now saying the original brackets were designed for railing posts and installed correctly, and that the issue may be a manufacturer problem.
He is asking me to pay an additional $60 for replacement brackets and $75 in labor to swap them out.
I’m trying to get some independent opinions before moving forward.
My questions are:
- Is the MiTek D44-TZ an appropriate bracket for securing a 4×4 post supporting an exterior stair railing?
- Is this type of bracket appropriate for mounting directly to concrete, rather than a wood deck?
- Should there be this much side-to-side movement when pressure is applied to the top rail?
- What type of mounting hardware would you recommend for this application?
- Would you consider replacing these brackets a correction of the original installation or an upgrade that the homeowner should pay extra for?
I’m not a contractor, so I’m relying on professional judgment when hiring someone for this type of work. I chose the wood railing option because it was more affordable than aluminum, but I still expected a sturdy and safe installation.
I’d appreciate opinions from anyone familiar with exterior stair railings, post anchors, and concrete mounting. As well below is a link to the railing bracket attached to the concrete and a video of the railing.
https://imgur.com/a/qtSIirv