r/HonestHotTakes • • 6h ago • Bravo 3

đŸ”„ Hot Take Slavery is taught in an extremely biased way to demonize only Europeans. Most people have no idea about the real history of global slavery.

I am a Nigerian American who studied about slavery in school as a kid. It has since become obvious to me that the education I and most American kids have received about slavery is extremely biased. It barely mentions the slavery that was happening worldwide, and it paints white or europeans as the only people who ever did large scale slavery. Which is just objectively untrue.

White colonialism didn’t start till around the 1500s. First with Portugal and Spain, then later other European powers followed suite. Previously enslaved Africans and their generations became part of those countries populations. And eventually Europeans ended slavery around the 1900s. The European legacy of slavery was approximately 400 years.

Meanwhile, and this is the part that almost no one seems to know, Arabs were enslaving millions of subsaharan africans since the 600’s. Yes, all the way since the year 600. They also took african women as sex slaves. Part of why this is so unknown and was easy to hide, is because they actually routinely castrated the African male slaves, preventing them from ever mating with Arab women and effecting “pure Arab” demographics.

The Arab slave trade (also known on as the Arab-Muslim slave trade since it was in large part a religiously led conquest, not unlike “manifest destiny” and other Christian justifications for conquering lands) continued all the way until the 1900s. Seriously, look it up. It was literally three times longer than european slavery.

There is also the idea that Africa’s resources were all plunderered by white people and now that’s why they’re poor. But in reality, africans still have SO many rich resources, that now CHINA is even capitalizing on and essentially enslaving subsaharan black people to mine said resources for them, in their own countries. I read a Nigerian news article online speaking about the harsh conditions and extremely low pay, if any, that may Africans working for Chinese mining companies (again, in their own countries, so pretty much modern colonialism) have been enduring for years since the Chinese began entering Nigeria.

So it’s not apparently not the case either that “white people took everything and now africans can’t get rich”. that’s not how it happened at all. It’s a vast oversimplification and miseducation. Perhaps even intentionally obfuscation done en-masse.

The truth is that foreign entities keep coming to Africa for its rich resources and human labor, african “leaders” don’t really give a shit about their people so they accept the enslavement of their people and extraction of their resources for their own selfish financial gain, keeping whatever the outsiders given them in exchange, for themselves. Millions and billions of dollars the african leaders use to enrich their families and inner circles while their citizens starve or continue to be trafficked by foreign entities (like china, libya and saudi arabia today, and arabs, then europeans, in the past).

Africans who actually live in africa are well aware that their leaders aren’t sh*t. The ones who aren’t are busy giving the little then have to Nigerian pastors who claim to be prophets (so, another layer of exploitation by their own people). and the irony in all of this is that Europeans/white people are the only ones in the present day sending humanitarian aid and money to africa.

The kind of money their own leaders won’t even share with them.

2.6k Upvotes

1.6k comments sorted by

61

u/xdsm8 6h ago • Regret Bravo

Where is the bias? No one is erasing history.

American slavery is focused on in American schools because it is American history. I don't know what your argument really even is. This is like claiming that there is an anti-Zhou dynasty bias because you didn't hear about it in an American public school.

22

u/free-real-sensei 6h ago • Bravo

world history was a subject and it still left out almost all of what i talked about.

8

u/JustOneVote 5h ago

World history is incredibly broad, we can't teach every student every aspect.

On the topic of slavery specifically, it makes sense that American students focus on slavery as it was practiced by Americans in America.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ShanghaiBebop 3h ago

Not sure what your schools curriculum was. We definitely learned about the Arab Slave trade, and the prevalence of institutional slavery in west Africa, and the uniqueness of race based chattel slavery in the new world. 

→ More replies (4)

15

u/Electrical-Web-4475 6h ago • Bravo

Finnish history education has arguably given more attention to American slavery and overseas colonialism than to some atrocities committed against Finns themselves.

During the Russian occupation of Finland known as the Great Wrath (Isoviha, 1713–1721), Russian forces committed widespread killings, torture, rape and forced displacement.

An estimated 20,000–30,000 Finns, predominantly children and adolescents, were abducted and transported to Russia into slavery. Many were forced into domestic servitude, military labour and construction work.

It could be because of the left leaning education system and teachers. This framing of colonialism is a product of anti capitalist anti western Soviet propaganda.

→ More replies (23)

3

u/anathema__device 5h ago

So outside of the US, no schools mention slavery in the American South? They only cover slavery in their own countries?

9

u/Proiegomena 6h ago

American students: “but what about pre-medieval thralldom in European scandinavia or slavery on the arabian pensinsula in the 11th century????!” 

→ More replies (17)

2

u/TheSpacePopinjay 6h ago

There's a lot of line blurring, synonymising slavery with parochial American slavery.

That goes beyond mere focus.

3

u/starrywisd0m 5h ago

So disingenuous. It's blatantly clear that slavery as a concept is being associated with white Europeans, and this is a global phenomenon, not strictly western

3

u/bloopblorpblep 3h ago

Chattel slavery was, and I agree that the education system doesn’t do enough to explain or contextualize any of it.

Slavery existed for a long time, but the colonial plantation model introduced the new concepts of racial hierarchy and slaves as an industrial input. The profit motive led to extreme conditions that hadn’t been a normal part of slavery, and the racial dehumanization of Africans allowed society to go along with those extremes. People blame Europeans because that model of slavery was a product of European colonialism.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Repulsive_Range_6627 6h ago

The bias is most people don’t know the facts OP is presenting and will go nuts when told them.

Native Americans also had slave and we’re a lot more cruel but we don’t learn that either.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (6)

29

u/SavingsComplete7901 6h ago • This Bravo

It’s not a hot take, it’s a self-hate take.

  1. We talk about European slavery in the USA because it’s engrained in the history of the nation. Arab slavery is irrelevant to the foundation of the USA hence why it is not mentioned. You are using White Supremacist deflection tactics to minimize the atrocities inflicted on Black people in the USA. The Rape, Torture, Murder, Beating, Forced Labor for hundreds of years
according to you doesn’t matter because Arabs did it too. 
  2. Economic exploitation on the continent. Research the AES as they are a modern examples of nationalization of resources and reinvestment into the people. Now look at how many attempts France has made to assassinate the ASS’ leaders to return to the status quo where France backs a dictator that allows France to plunder the resources. Look at how Niger kicked out Chinese companies that underpaid and abused Black workers. A lot of the system you see is forced on the continent and we need strong Men and Women to fight against it. 
  3. You highlight the backstabbing culture that cripples many nations in Africa. You or your family left Nigeria, moved to a country with a Black population that is / has been subjugated by Whites, and you identify and take sides with the Whites. This is how Europeans have been able to destabilize the continent for hundreds of years because there are people like you who venerate them and are willing to step on your own to be in their good graces.

2

u/free-real-sensei 5h ago

“holding african leaders accountable for profiting off the exploitation of africans while hoarding millions for themselves is self-hate” oh. wait what?

“holding chinese, arabs, AND europeans accountable for enslaving africans is self-hate” yeahhh naw.

i think your brain just might struggle with processing “multiple things can be bad at once”.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/Plastic_Persimmon_91 1h ago

Istg (wealthy) Africans in the US say shit like OP all the time dehumanising black Americans and then they wonder why Black Americans aren’t inclusive of them

4

u/Wise-Blueberry-3901 4h ago

Placing something in its proper historical context doesn't result in minimisation, it results in accurate understanding. Intentionally teaching something without proper context will always lead to misrepresentation. 

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (45)

281

u/Sure_Scar4297 6h ago • Bravo

I think Americans are taught about how slavery came to and persisted in America. The end goal is American history

98

u/LurkerBurkeria 5h ago

I also think Non-Americans seem to gloss over the whole "the bloodiest moment in US history was over our version of chattel slavery so it kind of looms large" thing

27

u/jjcrayfish 2h ago

Even today some Americans refuse to acknowledge what the Civil War was really about, and no it's not about "state's rights" only.

17

u/Ok_Profile175 2h ago

Yeah, it was also about State's rights to enforce chattel slavery.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/nagrom7 1h ago • Mindblown

It wasn't even about states rights full stop. The Confederate constitution specifically took away the right of their states to ban slavery, mandating it to be legal across the whole country. Also even before the civil war they trampled over the rights of free states by the enforcement of various fugitive slave acts/laws.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/Serious_Swan_2371 5h ago

But we do have world history classes

My school spent a while on medieval Europe as well as antiquity

Seems weird to not talk about how slavery changed from antiquity into the Islamic slave trade and eventually the trans Atlantic slave trade

82

u/Windowdressings 5h ago edited 1h ago

Yeah, in American schools you're probably not also taught about Pol Pot, but it's not to hide his crimes or diminish the human rights abuses. There's atrocoties throughout human history and the transatlantic slave trade is not only particularly abhorrent, it's fundamental to the founding and funding of USA and still affects millions of people to this day.

48

u/Sure_Scar4297 5h ago

In all fairness, I was taught about pol pot in the US

12

u/Dmienduerst 3h ago

I was also but it was brief. What we didn't learn was basically any of the India empires. We learned about some of the Chinese ones in relation to the Silk road but the Persians went from Xerxes and Darius to the Iranian revolution under President Carter with nothing in between. We didn't even learn about Pahlavi and how he came to power.

→ More replies (3)

21

u/OskaMeijer 5h ago

Nah, any chance to vilify communism is absolutely taught in American education.

17

u/MerelyMortalModeling 5h ago

Most states publish their education standards and Pol Pot rarely is featured

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (26)
→ More replies (46)

5

u/ShawtySayWhaaat 2h ago

Yeah I think it's more of a case that most euro countries don't really talk about it nearly as much as we do about ours. For us, it's a huge part of how we got to where we are today, over there it's just kind of a sore that they wish didn't happen so it gets swept under the rug

50

u/Aniki_Simpson 5h ago

There are TONS of Americans who still believe that white Europeans were going into Africa and catching Africans with nets. The simple fact is that they were sold by other African nations. But, that is not what people think still today.

7

u/LucianPitons 2h ago

As a West Indian I was taught that Africans captured slaves and brought them to the coast in exchange for goods.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/I_Went_Full_WSB 3h ago

That doesn't mean they were taught that in school.

5

u/cownan 3h ago

I just watched a movie (Descendants) about the descendants of the last slave ship to come to America, the Clotilde. There’s one scene where they show the ship’s route to Benin and they say “the slavers captured our ancestors.” The king of Benin has apologized for his nation’s role in selling Africans to slavers and for running one of the biggest slave markets in the world. It was a little surprising that the movie didn’t mention that.

16

u/Jareddiesattheend19 4h ago

Than they didnt pay attention during class because it was covered pretty thoroughly

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (47)

3

u/ExtremeNebula729 4h ago

Context is important. You can’t learn about American history in total isolation of the rest of the world. At least not well.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/ryverrat1971 2h ago

Only if it involved European colonists. Some native tribes did slavery too but it's not covered. Most US history starts around 1600 with Jamestown. It neglects the Native Americans that were already here. So yes the slavery issue is skewed toward whites being enslavers.

It seems even when we do teach world history in US schools, it only involves world history where the US had a part. You don't learn about the Mongols invading China. Or the Golden Horde. Or even the city states of Italy. US history also will mention things if it involved England before the Revolution or if it causes a mass immigration to US (30 Years War or Great Irish Potato Famine).

9

u/Sure_Scar4297 2h ago

We learned about literally all of the things you mentioned in the second paragraph in my school and I’ve taught literally all of those things as well. Where did you go to school? This may be a discrepancy in state standards

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Ok_Profile175 2h ago

Slavery amongst Native Americans was covered in my high school, so I know that their form of slavery was nothing like the chattel slavery of European colonists in the Americas. Which is why they aren't taught in the same way, because they weren't the same things.

Edit for spelling.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)

4

u/Wooden-Protection211 6h ago

I mean OP you are also falling for this yourself with your focus on Africa. Slavery has been part of almost every single culture for the entirety of human history. Yes the modern hyper focus on the Africa -> US slave trade and the blame being placed squarely on "white" people for this (when most enslavements were by locals, of locals/neighboring polities), is very narrow-minded, I agree, particularly when it comes to "slavery = white people enslaving black people". That is a very dumb take. Particularly if we want to remain reductive, we can simply throw back "Barbary slave trade was African people enslaving European people and went on far longer and enslaved far more".

But that type up reductivism is still a problem and doesn't actually encompass the fact that slavery is like cancer - it has always existed, and it has always existed everywhere.

Reparations? We ALL deserve them at some point.

1

u/free-real-sensei 6h ago

was the barbary slave trade sub-saharan africans enslaving white people? or north africans/arabs enslaving white people?

3

u/Wooden-Protection211 6h ago

Fuck me does it matter?

It's a world of all against all.

Slavery was a world of everyone enslaving everyone. "Sub Saharan Africans" enslaved other people too. Africa isn't and never was a monolith - it's a HUGE continent full of different cultures, tribes and polities, and they warred and enslaved like everyone else.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/FLSteve11 4h ago

Meanwhile, the UN only has come out against the Atlantic slave trade. The rest of it 


→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (17)

8

u/been_blissed 5h ago

Thank you for sharing this perspective. Education about world history is not so good in the US.

92

u/RageFucker_ 4h ago • Bravo

The ignorance being displayed in this sub is incredible, even by Reddit standards. There are a lot of fucking idiots who apparently think slavery started in the 1500s by Europeans or that it was happening before then but the slaves had it pretty good and then it only got bad in the 1500s.

Slavery has been going on all over the world since ancient times. For example, the Code of Hammurabi explicitly mentions it.

Some slaves faced conditions worse than others, but they all had it bad in some way or another (forced castration, rape, beatings, forced labor, etc). Thinking that slaves had it pretty good in the ancient world is peak stupidity.

Some of you should be embarrassed by your ignorance and you really need to read some history and get offline before you infect others with your stupidity.

14

u/Miserable_Ear9879 2h ago

Slavery is a problem even today

→ More replies (1)

23

u/JoblessNeckbeardUwU 4h ago edited 3h ago • Bravo

Be Chinese, everyone enslaved/tried to genocide everyone at some point in history so it’s actually pretty chill

My mom’s ethnic and political groups oppressed the fuck out of my dad’s, took a fat L in a war and millions were displaced/massacred/enslaved including herself and her parents, while my dad’s dad was orphaned because my mom’s side were greedy ass evil bourgeoisieđŸ€

The leaders tell you (x) group is evil, we are owed (x) and it’ll be all better once we’re in power, but then the same cycle of evil and violence is inflicted on others and it’s justified because we’re just getting even, right?

but so much fucked up shit by every group happened that keeping score would be pointless, and it unironically encouraged a lot of Chinese people to stop playing ethnic/political suffering olympics and actually work together under a united Chinese identity so that no one suffers what they did.

At some point someone has to suck it up all the shit with a straw and take the poop to their coffin so that the next generation lives in a feces-free environment. No group is perfect, and it’s totally fine to admit that your group has a massive poop pile instead of saying “but that guy’s backyard has even more shit than mine”

11

u/MelissaMiranti 3h ago

The problem is that China does that whole "unity" thing to cover up the ongoing genocides it's conducting.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

4

u/Grumpy_Troll 4h ago

Bobby Lee pretty much proved OPs point in the most hilarious way possible.

https://youtu.be/p_Hzn-r2YJ8?si=hF1N5gUCZSyPiac4

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Effective-Composer94 1h ago

This is just whataboutism lol what are we doing here

Lemme call Lincoln real quick bro u might have something here

→ More replies (23)

28

u/BananaTeleoperator 4h ago • Bravo

There are a few things being conflated here.

  1. American schools teach American history. The reason American education focuses so heavily on the transatlantic slave trade, European colonialism, and American chattel slavery isn't necessarily because educators believe Europeans were the only people who ever practiced slavery. It's because those systems are directly relevant to the formation of the United States, its economy, its institutions, its racial hierarchy, and the social inequalities that continued long after emancipation. American chattel slavery has a particular historical legacy in America that other systems of slavery, however significant, simply don't have. It's not about demonizing white people. It's just teaching the history of the country. Nobody is suggesting slavery was uniquely European or American.
  2. The frequent emphasis on Arab muslim in the African slave trade is often used as a form of white nationalist whataboutism. The underlying history isn't fabricated, but it is often used to suggest that the history of racial inequality in America is being unfairly attributed to white people. That you seem to be doing this in your post is suspect.
  3. I actually think there's a legitimate points made about contemporary foreign exploitation of African countries, including by Chinese companies and other foreign actors.

4

u/November19 1h ago

And especially regarding the white supremacist whataboutism: What's the attitude toward American chattel slavery supposed to be? It's not worth talking about because slavery has always been a global thing?

That's like saying because rape is a longstanding global crime, it doesn't really matter that you raped someone.

Or if your country had institutionalized rape for hundreds of years, we don't need to feel bad about that. Because, you know... everybody does it.

I honestly don't understand how the whataboutism is supposed to make anything less bad. It's not only unethical, it's downright illogical.

→ More replies (2)

60

u/SnooMarzipans1149 6h ago edited 5h ago • Bravo

The Arab slave trade and the Barbary slave trade never get even 1% of the attention that the transatlantic slave trade gets.

In fact, many Americans today think that only Europeans engaged in slavery. They seem to think it was something unique to white people, when in reality, slavery existed all around the world.

26

u/OHotDawnThisIsMyJawn 5h ago

  In fact, many Americans today think that only white people engaged in slavery.

Many Americans think a lot of stupid shit.  Sadly we’re not going to be able to teach everyone everything. 

→ More replies (3)

13

u/Anaevya 5h ago

People do know that certain Arab states still have a slavery problem. 

→ More replies (4)

18

u/Illustrious_Pay685 4h ago

most americans when referring to slavery just tend to focus american slavery because it shapped the racial dynamics we have today in america.

I'm not sure why people interpret americans talking about american history as "they think it only happened here" with zero evidence of that

10

u/Soggy-Bedroom-3673 3h ago

Yeah, OP is making some questionable claims on that front. Like, who was taught in America that white people took everything from Africa and that's why Africa is poor today? Honestly we never even got into African history enough for that to even come up. 

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (13)

9

u/EI_TokyoTeddyBear 4h ago

Reminds me of this video of this Korean American guy who thought Koreans didnt do slavery lol

https://m.youtube.com/shorts/p_Hzn-r2YJ8

3

u/mbnmac 1h ago

i love how he breaks down reading that line

→ More replies (13)

30

u/coconubs94 6h ago

I think it's because you never actually learn about slavery in school. Like there's not a slavery class or a slavery section. You do learn American history though, and you can't learn that without learning about the slavery. But learning about slavery isn't the point, it's the social dynamics in the American South that the lesson is actually about.

So everytime you learn about slavery is in the context of American or European history

7

u/Reppin420 5h ago edited 5h ago

I think OPs point was exactly what you just said though. It's only taught from American and European context. American education doesn't tell the whole story. I don't know about your curriculum in school, but many schools I attended taught World History, and barely (if at all) mentioned slavery.

Edit: what asshat would downvote this, and why? People are fucking stupid. Which is basically what this post is about, ignorance.

7

u/GIFWarrior 5h ago

Because in reality, slavery was so normalised in our history that essentially every country was dealing with it in certain forms at one point or the other in their history. Did you know the famous Saint Patrick of Ireland probably had slaves and traded them for favours from Irish Kings for example?

Countries teach their own history to children. So slavery in an American context is taught.

If you wanted to talk about 'all' slavery the curriculum for American Kids would be 99% slavery and 1% everything else.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Appropriate_M 5h ago

You mean world history didn't cover "let my people go" etc. laborers for pyramids, great wall, persians vs greeks, or mention spartacus, russian revolution?

Also, theoretically, you can be taught "world history" at most three times: elementary school (build pyramid fun!), junior-high(maybe) (great wall! ) , and high-school (ancient persian expansion into greece, russian revolution etc) once generally and maybe once for AP.

I feel like slavery's been part of my awareness since first grade. But I'm old. I actually went to see Prince of Egypt in theaters.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

39

u/LadyIsabelle_ 6h ago

Idk if your schools education is lacking but in Sweden we know this.

23

u/gaybisexualvampire 3h ago

Sweden as well and no this is not taught commonly lol

→ More replies (2)

19

u/Sea_Engineering_5773 6h ago

We also learnt about this here in Eastern Europe. An ordinary and standard part of history curriculum.

8

u/Supersperg92 5h ago

Beaded based eastern Europe. Canadian teacher here. My province doesn't even have history as a topic of study.

28

u/starrywisd0m 5h ago

That's a false generalisation. The only slavery I was taught about in school was the Transatlantic slave trade, with maybe the exception of a short segment on ancient Egypt

→ More replies (20)

4

u/sticksandstones420 4h ago

As far as I recall slavery wasn't studied indepth. But I for one didn't learn anything about arab slaves, nor about african slaves in africa. I'm not even sure they said anything about swedens slave colony.  I did learn about trÀlar and that there were slaves in Sweden. If I recall the focus on slaves were the atlantic slave trade.  You learnt about arab slaves? Somehow I doubt it.

7

u/greenhampster 5h ago

American here and this was taught to us. Not sure about anymore, there’s a lot of liberal influences anymore unfortunately, but it was taught 30 years ago at least.

6

u/HH_Creations 5h ago

Never heard of any of this

But im also Texan

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (27)

5

u/Reppin420 5h ago

It's American education. So yes, it's lacking.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/The_loony_lout 5h ago

Yeah, American education only can talk about America or we get sued for some ism.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (14)

28

u/SinfullySinless 6h ago • Bravo

I’m an American history teacher. The first lesson of the slavery unit I go over POW slavery vs chattel slavery and how all people have been enslaved or enslavers.

The heavy focus on American slavery is: (1) it’s American (2) it was extremely dehumanizing and brutal to the point Hitler in part would be inspired by the whole thing (3) show how Black slave labor quite literally built the backbone of America (southern wealthy antebellum society with the most millionaires per capita in the world, the first and largest northern factories were textile or clothing related from southern cotton, the suffragette movement literally comes from young women being hired at said factories and being able to talk with other women and read books, etc).

13

u/frink99887 5h ago

Yeah. Chattel slavery was a particularly brutal form of slavery that was extreme compared to more ancient forms of slavery. For instance, Roman slaves did not pass along the servitude from parent to child. Also Barbary-type slavery (not an official term) was different since Islam forbids enslaving other Muslims. You could convert to Islam and no longer be held in slavery.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (11)

88

u/Diligent-Chance-7161 6h ago • Bravo

I am zimbabwean and its hilarious watching films Kunta Kinte or BLM blaming white peope for slavery. Slavery in North Africa was started primarly by Muslims ( Islam has two ethical codes one for muslims and one for non muslims, you can do whatever you want to infidels and non muslims) Africans then took part in it as well. All slaves were captured by africans who in turn taught white people how to dehumanize africans and crush there spirits. So when they demand compensation from white people but stay quite on Muslims and Africans ( who for the record NEVER showed any remorse for slavery and slavery is still alive and well in north africa) Its so funny and sad to me. Also most africans look down on african americans they view them as lacking in heritage and culture, they are literaly more racist than white people LOL. Meanwhile white people realsied how shitty slavery was and stopped it and constantly apologize for it.

33

u/bigdickbigdrip 5h ago • Bravo

So you expect a movie (Roots) that occurs in America about a slave brought from Africa to be about slavery that occurred in north Africa?

This country actually had laws legalizing and endorsing slavery so yes people are demanding compensation. 

People aren't demanding white people pay reparations but the country btw.

Saying white people realized how shitty slavery was and stopped is very silly. An entire war was fought to keep that system in place.

You should learn American history and do some self reflecting.

19

u/mwobey 5h ago

People aren't demanding white people pay reparations but the country btw. 

Where do you think money from "the country" comes from? If a large-scale reparations program were enacted, that money would need to come from the tax base, and obviously not from the people the benefit is being disbursed to. That means asking for reparations is asking white people to pay black people by increasing their taxes to cover the bill. 

→ More replies (37)
→ More replies (28)

6

u/Prior-Bag3841 4h ago

The western world abandoned slavery more out of practicality than anything else. Wage labor was more compatible with an industrialized economy than chattel labor. Emancipation was just a happy offshoot of the changing times.

6

u/I_Went_Full_WSB 3h ago

The Europeans buying the slaves caused it to become huge. Yes, that fire existed before gasoline was thrown on it by slave trading.

→ More replies (21)

3

u/391976 3h ago

Except Roots showed Kunta captured by Africans.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/SunsetGrind 5h ago edited 4h ago • Bravo

Are you suggesting white ppl are blameless? Like what is the point of this comment?

Slavery ABSOLUTELY existed in North Africa LONG before Islam. Muslim societies absolutely participated in and perpetuated horrific systems of slavery, and that history deserves scrutiny. But claiming Islam introduced slavery to North Africa is historically false. And while Islamic law certainly discriminated between Muslims and non-Muslims, claiming muslims could simply do whatever they wanted to non-muslims is a gross misrepresentation.

Second, nobody is denying african participation in the slave trade. African rulers and merchants who profited from it deserve condemnation. But suggesting Africans somehow taught Europeans to dehumanize Africans is absurd. Europeans weren't passive students. They HAVE enslaved people thousands of years before. They established, financed, expanded and legally institutionalized a system of racialized, hereditary chattel slavery in the Americas. They are responsible for their own actions, regardless of who supplied the captives.

Third, your claim that Africans and Muslims have NEVER shown remorse is an extraordinary generalization about billions of people across centuries. And yes, modern slavery persists in parts of Africa. That's reprehensible and deserves condemnation too.

But perhaps the most revealing part is your conclusion that white people realized slavery was wrong and stopped it. You're conveniently leaving out centuries of resistance by enslaved Africans, Black abolitionists and the Haitian Revolution. European abolitionists def deserve recognition, but abolition wasn't some exclusively white moral awakening graciously bestowed upon everyone else. Get real. The Civil War in America was also due to white ppl fighting to KEEP slavery. Did you consider that?

What I find particularly ironic is that you're criticizing the collective blame of white people while simultaneously assigning collective guilt to Africans and Muslims, and collective moral credit to white people.

You can't condemn entire populations for their ancestors' participation in slavery while celebrating another entire population for their ancestors' role in abolishing it. That's being selective in accountability.

We can acknowledge african complicity, the brutality of slavery in muslim societies, and european responsibility for Atlantic chattel slavery simultaneously. None of these historical realities cancels out the others.

→ More replies (36)
→ More replies (24)

31

u/Certain_Bit3809 4h ago

So your question is “why do American history courses focus in American history instead of Arab conquests of Africa a millennium prior”?

If you are arguing with people online who say simplistic things like “white people took everything” then you can just ignore them. They dont matter.

→ More replies (18)

2

u/DikDangerous 5h ago

Oh noes learning history can bring up uncomfortable topics that white people might not like

Fuck off with this shitty opinion

0

u/free-real-sensei 5h ago

you sound like facts hurt your feelings and you’re projecting.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/FLSteve11 4h ago • Bravo

Doesn’t seem the UN cares either. They only came out against the Atlantic Slave trade, calling it the gravest crime against humanity. While basically ignoring the rest of it.

4

u/Desperate_Object_677 2h ago

something being “the worst” doesn’t mean that other bad things don’t exist, or were not in the running. the well of human evil is very deep indeed.

but the fact that other peoples have done truly horrific things does not diminish the horror of the atlantic slave trade.

4

u/FLSteve11 2h ago

Was it the worst? There can be a lot of ways you could look at the Arab or Asian slave trade as being worse. The issue isn’t that they considered the Atlantic trade bad, it’s that they ONLY considered that one bad. What was worse, Stalin or Hitler or Pol Pots killings, which could easily be considered worse then the slave trades. Would you condemn one of thise but ignore the others?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

14

u/jmanhawk_ 4h ago

it's just another step in the manufactured division pretty much

7

u/LilKingMusic 38m ago

The majority of people that you see talking about slavery on Reddit are Americans, and Europeans are the ones who started and continued slavery in America, which is probably the reason for this skewed view. Most of us know that Africans enslaved each other and so on, but we aren't really taught much about African history other than Europe's colonization of it.

2

u/Long_Ad_2764 14m ago

The natives were enslaving each other long before the white man came along

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/Tiny_Spread5712 5h ago

There is a lot of nuance to this question but maybe tough for a Nigerian without context but a) American slavery reflects a stain on the moral fabric of American, b) European interests have split up Africa in such a way that it is very difficult to be a leader without having the support of European countries and corporations.

For a) We know that tragically there are pedophiles out there, but people are going to focus on Bill Clinton and Donald Trump going to Epstein island because of the moral stain on them in particular.

For b) you can't blame Europe for everything but it created a uniquely shitty situation where countries/ companies were only investing in countries where they could keep the supply of human capital cheap. So to get a school you'd have to send a village to the mines. 

This is why China has been very successful is they basically are training people up to reap the benefit of the labor without most of the value going to another country.  Its also starting to show that there was an artificial pressure from Europe because as Europe has less influence Africa is finding more success.

Its not all Europe, but as Europe's time wants, everyone else seems to be doing better.  Not perfect, but better.

3

u/Kopalniok 6h ago

My history courses focused on serfdom over transatlantic slave trade because it's the locally relevant part of history, it's only fitting that US history courses focus on American slavery over global slavery

12

u/starrywisd0m 4h ago • Bravo

And it's completely ludicrous how 'western slavery' remains at the forefront of global discourse, all the while there are more slaves living TODAY in Africa, Asia and the middle east than during the entire Transatlantic slave trade.

→ More replies (8)

10

u/airwavesinmeinjeans 6h ago edited 5h ago

The whole idea of demonizing Europeans is stupid anyways. It's a continent with many countries, e.g., Switzerland, Poland & Ireland, as well as many Balkan and Eastern European countries. They never colonized anything.

And yeah, neocolonialism is a thing. Redditors are still going to be pissed reading this.

6

u/pissedRAIL 5h ago

Redditors are some of the most uneducated, high & mighty tools I have ever experienced.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/340magnums 6h ago

Thanks for the education my European friends think slavery was only an American racist issue.

5

u/ManyLength545 4h ago

Today on things that never happend.

1

u/Southern_Conflict_11 5h ago

Your rant is that you're mad that separate subjects aren't taught as if they are one subject 

2

u/free-real-sensei 5h ago

WORLD history did not cover the subject of non-european enslavement of africans at all.

4

u/Southern_Conflict_11 5h ago

So you are attacking the wrong subject. I learned about chattel slavery in American History. 

9

u/Latter-Entrance288 5h ago

Interesting post and I'm sure there will be some angry replies from people who feel they have the moral high ground on what constitutes the "bad" people from the "good" people, ie. Caucasion Europeans and the west in general and everyone else. In the end, it boils down to who we can "guilt" to get money. I mean, what is the endpoint of the incessant push for "reparations". Spanish treatment of native S. Americans, Italians killed 40,000 Hebrews building the colosseum. England and the slave trade (especially Liverpool as a major port for slaves). These countries don't have the money, so no one talks about it. But who has the money? Non-African citizens of the US. And of course, it's only going to be a one time payment, ha!

6

u/ditobandit0 6h ago

I say this all the time. Its so tiring battling uneducated dumbasses.

Im especially furious when arabs run their mouth about these topics.

And also i feel sad that to this day africa cant catch a break... but yeah, part of it has to be to stop being the victim, acknowledge the problem and take action.

Leaders like ibrahim traore really give hope for a better africa.

6

u/TinyInformation3564 6h ago

Every country focus on certain aspects of history, South Africa will largely focus on Apartheid, Boer war, Zulu British war. Why would American, or European countries focus on Arabian history. 

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Sufferer-Of-Cheese 5h ago

I believe because it's recent in that proportion it makes sense but at the same time history has proof that there was monsters and slavers before the dreaded mayo menace.

And when you point out those facts, you are quickly met with insults, deflections and the most important remark the legendary "No U"

→ More replies (8)

4

u/AnonSwan 6h ago

Im not in school anymore but in high-school I had a world history class that covered slavery around the world and its history and then I had another class that just focused on US history which covered Atlantic slave trade and slavery in US. Are these not taught anymore?

5

u/Many-Cartographer278 5h ago • Bravo

Thise post is just weird nazi shit trying to pretend like slavery isnt so bad because everybody did it

→ More replies (9)

4

u/Multicultural_Potato 4h ago

Guys are yall are missing the point on purpose?

When you are in the United States what makes more sense for the curriculum for a history class? The Arab slave trade in the 600s or European colonization of the Americas which brought slaves and the subsequent American slavery that helped develop the country. It’s not rocket science that you learn history that’s more relevant to your country. For world history the classes are there for a fixed amount of time. Learning about the renaissance, Black Death, the World Wars, and etc. are more important and relevant than slave trading back when everyone was doing it.

As for modern day slavery I don’t think many high schools have a class on modern day events. My high school was lucky enough to and we did touch on it, but like history classes there’s a lot of curriculum to cover.

Literally if you guys think about it for more than 2 seconds it makes sense.

5

u/bluecheese2040 4h ago

Its cause no one really cares about the slaves or their descendents....slavery is specifically taught this way to make a specific political point.

Malcom x was right on this

3

u/blaze92x45 3h ago

What political point?

→ More replies (20)

5

u/Roam1985 3h ago

Fun examples of this:

The Bobby Lee podcast where he claimed Korea never sold slaves to find out that Korea had the longest unbroken slave trade in human history.

The complete desire to not claim the Ottoman empire was an empire or had a slave trade, or had a slave trade that didn't stop even after it was outlawed.

2

u/Hour-Ad78 6h ago edited 5h ago

I went to a school that took us to a weird slavery reenactment camp, looking back it’s crazy it was allowed but that was over 20 years ago.
Everyone was deeply uncomfortable with that place.
Never really heard Africans talk about slavery as opposed to black Americans.
Didn’t realize until this post, but it’s probably because black Americans were affected more by slavery than Africans.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/anathema__device 6h ago

It’s also a matter of geography. Obviously, Arabs could easily replace their old African slaves with new African slaves, so did not want or need a self-sustaining population. A permanently disoriented, alienated slave can’t establish relationships or connections or learn his or her environs, and will not rebel. He or she will not reproduce and create families because the men were castrated, and will live until they can’t perform their duties and will then be killed and replaced by a newly purchased slave. The ”new world” was way too far away for the traditional strategy, but that convenience also meant relationships and connections across multiple generations could be established, and that laid the groundwork for their eventual rebellions, connections with sympathetic abolitionists in the US and abroad, the families thet nurtured and grew and children whose violent removal from their homes provided fuel for that rebellion, and ultimate liberation. Without that geographical distance no reason to believe new world slavery would’ve looked any different from old world slavery.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/InfamousGod1999 5h ago

Slavery is everywhere

2

u/Popular-Pin-4659 4h ago

This isn't even hot take if you are from anywhere not third world country like us

2

u/ChartPuzzleheaded747 4h ago

This is true 

2

u/Critical_Raisin_2504 4h ago

Humans aren’t very nice to each other

Most peoples in history practiced slavery, the Vikings, the Anglo-Saxons, the British Empire, the Egyptians, the Romans, the Ottomans etc

In fact the Ottomans were doing it up until relatively recently. 

People just like the moral high ground.

2

u/LoudMusic 4h ago

Romans were enslaving people back into BC time. And Egyptians were even before that.

Effectively any population that has surpassed its neighbors has stolen from and enslaved their populations.

2

u/Fancy_Chips 3h ago

Absolutely. Im finishing up my Pan-Africana degree and I feel like I know less about the subject than I did before. Its just such a vast topic you could dedicate your life to studying it and never make a dent. Even just the Tran-Atlantic slave trade had multiple actors, legal codes, conflicts, trade networks, over centuries.

It also doesn't help that White Supremacists and Pan-Africanists don't seem to care about the real history as much as they care about one upping each other.

2

u/Candid-libertarian 3h ago

Because we are not interested in truth. We are interested in agenda. Agenda cherry picks facts and thrives on half truths. There is a racial economic agenda in the US called reparations. Using race as a weapon to transfer wealth. Plain and simple.

2

u/WegGOAT 3h ago • Bravo

Lot of Americans are obsessed with forcing constant black vs white race wars while ignoring reality.

2

u/shesunseen 1h ago

Wait until you hear about wage slavery. 

2

u/Future-Bunch3478 31m ago

Brutal honesty is the way forward. 

2

u/Particular-Bat-5904 26m ago

All the ancient democratic kultures where based on slavery, the volks did need time for politics.

5

u/Strong-Addition5296 1h ago

Thank you for helping to enlighten people and thank you for pointing out this issue. It is a very unfair bias in our societies that we blame only certain groups for slavery

→ More replies (1)

4

u/nfjsjfjwjdjjsj4 6h ago

Only americans believe slavery was only a colonial thing

5

u/ADirtFarmer 2h ago

I've heard that claim a lot, but I've never met an American who actually believed that.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/mommiesgoodboy67 6h ago

People who live in europe and america learn mostly about european and american historyđŸ˜±

3

u/CookinTendies5864 6h ago

I am Nigerian/Hispanic American been in the US all my life I can tell you what we were taught in school was vanilla comparatively to the reality of chattel slavery.

3

u/jings8 5h ago

In Europe you learn slavery from a European perspective, just like you learn about all of history. The purpose is not to make europe look bad, you cannot make slavery look good tf 

8

u/Strict_Extension331 6h ago

I'm sick of this talking point. If you want to make the argument that American education is too focused only on American history that's one thing, but recognize that it is teaching you about AMERICAN history. This means that we learn about slavery primarily fron the American context, which was the importation of slaves to serve as labor in the 13 Colonies. It is not the job of your standard American history class to also teach you about the history of slavery across the world. The resources are there if people would like to learn about this, nobody is stopping you. Most people don't though because the average person doesn't actually care about history at the best of times.

7

u/The_loony_lout 5h ago

OP is making the argument that we miss world history and focus on the grievances. Even other commenters from non-American countries say that there is a weird focus on American slavery in their country too.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/becEverythingB 4h ago

Why does everyone think you are only taught American history in American schools? You all presumably went to school, so do you just not remember? I graduated in 2006 and the curriculum had 2 years of world history, 1 year of American history, and one year of US government. So 1/4 of our time was focused on US history and half was focused on world history.

3

u/Big_Arrival_626 1h ago

In my school world history was optional.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/0rangelantern 6h ago

We have World History classes, too. We are supposed to learn about more than just America.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Main_Cauliflower5479 6h ago

Romans and Persian and Greeks have thousands of years of history of slave owning, as a result of their warring. They are all fairly well considered to be "White."

→ More replies (13)

0

u/I_Went_Full_WSB 4h ago

Europeans are almost not talked about in regards to slavery in the United States. Your entire post is fantasy.

1

u/free-real-sensei 4h ago

???

nice gaslighting.

1

u/I_Went_Full_WSB 4h ago

Calling out your lie isn't gaslighting.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Goalie32NJ 6h ago

Don’t tell liberals this. It totally defeats their narrative

6

u/Angel061803 5h ago

Liberal narratives have nothing to do with historical slavery in other countries. So you’re making things up.

3

u/imaginary-dirt2000 5h ago

You work for turning point USA? Ha

But here’s the perspective of a professor that teaches about racial discrimination among other things :

yes, we can acknowledge that numerous societies around the world have kept and own slaves.

But we can also acknowledge that the triangle trade of Europeans was the only form of slavery used to enhance the colonization of a continent and install a new World system of capitalist production.

Slave owners throughout history have been cruel. But few if any have created races in the same way as Europeans did in order to justify and perpetuate economic inequality.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Think_Bluebird_4804 3h ago

Us chatel slavery was particularly cruel. The world banned the atlantic slave trade so the us started slave breeding plantations rather than stopping slavery.

→ More replies (10)

3

u/Shadowchaos1010 3h ago

Where do you live?

What system did you learn in?

Did you stop and think for half a second that maybe you learned the history of slavery relevant to the society you're from?

Of course people who live in a society defined so much by European slavery is going to focus on European slavery when you only have so many hours and so much to cover during compulsory education.

7

u/webfar34 3h ago • Bravo

Yeah, but the problem OP is pointing out is mainly that people actually believe that the only type of slavery that exist is that of white Americans against black Africans, which is objectively untrue. 

It's not a problem to learn mostly about what affected your country and culture, but it is also very important to at least mention that slavery is not something new. 

→ More replies (8)

2

u/taco_jones 6h ago

We learn American history so it's focused on America. Slavery in Arab countries is irrelevant when talking about the American colonies.

16

u/HawkBoth8539 5h ago

I don't know what state you're in, but i was required to take American history specifically, and World history another year. I don't know why i keep seeing comments acting like we didn't literally also get taught world history.

4

u/LiveShowOneNightOnly 4h ago

Great. Now I am having flashbacks to 3 months of learning about ancient Sumerians.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

9

u/Jumperontheline 6h ago

Did you not also take World History several times like every other kid in the country

5

u/The_loony_lout 6h ago

Funny thing is, the majority of slaves weren't sent to the US. They were sent to South America.

→ More replies (5)

19

u/Chustle207 6h ago

Wrong our first foreign war was fought against the Barbary pirates enslaving US sailors

→ More replies (6)

11

u/teremaster 6h ago

Literally the first foreign war ever fought by the US was because of slavery in Arab nations. Dafuq you mean it's irrelevant?

→ More replies (8)

2

u/Scary_Spinach4924 5h ago

You might not realize this, but America is part of the world, therefore world history has an impact on America

→ More replies (31)

2

u/Agitated-Duty-4721 5h ago

I remember learning from a podcast that Korea had the longest unbroken chain of slavery of any society in history.

And it was funny because the topic was brought up by one of the Asian hosts, who asserted that Asians didn't really do slavery.

We really are equal. We're all pieces of shits.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/jeffismybaby 5h ago edited 5h ago

WasR/asablackman

" White colonialism didn’t start till around the 1500s. First with Portugal and Spain, then later other European"

Lmao they were enslaving "Indios" and people all the way as far as Southeast Asia in the 1400s. Even 30-40% of Europeans were enslaved to other Europeans for almost all of history.

Your bit on China is also Western propaganda.

2

u/Intelligent-Pop-2032 6h ago

My ancestors were slaves to a farm. Property of the farm owner. I am white, they were white. This was less than 100 years ago.

2

u/IndianBurn42069 6h ago

The irony is it was white people that abolished slavery and yet here we are with a bunch of idiots blaming whites for it.

At this point, the abolitionists screwed up because they're being called slave traders for nothing

7

u/bigdickbigdrip 5h ago

SOME white ppl fought to abolish slavery. The other half went to war to keep it. It's almost like white people aren't a monolith.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (6)

2

u/RxDirkMcGherkin 5h ago

Left leaning Reddit won't like your narrative above even if it's true and comprehensive. Be prepared to be called a white supremacist facist (even if you are African American)!

6

u/Khalid232310 4h ago

Americans tend to focus on the slavery that is most tied to the history of their particular nation. I don’t think thats a hard concept to grasp.

6

u/TenderDurden 4h ago

Especially in high school. The class is American history. It's not like you can't take more advanced courses in high school, college, or university. I think you expect too much of the good ol' USA given their average citizen's reading level.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/rescue_inhaler_4life 6h ago

I mean, yeah, it’s all just identity, society and politics.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Rebelology 5h ago

But that would contradict the "white man bad" rhetoric.... In terms of slavery white man actually not too bad

→ More replies (6)

-4

u/Agitated_Sugar4174 6h ago

What the fuck are you talking about? We weren’t taught Europeans were the only ones doing slavery. This shit reeks of weird desperation. lol are you trying to be a pick-me for dead slave traders?

19

u/Snickerdoodledoo55 6h ago

Too be fair never knew the arab slave trade was that extreme

12

u/free-real-sensei 6h ago

most people did not. he is gaslighting me because he knows it’s not common knowledge.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/free-real-sensei 6h ago

nice gaslighting.

15

u/HotPotatoes9973 6h ago

Ottoman slavery was never taught at my school. Additionally it was never taught that there are more slaves today than there were during civil war era slavery

7

u/bussybody_69 6h ago

That's definitely the focus of the Maxwell approved textbooks. No one likes to follow where this thread goes tho.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/ThatFatGuyMJL 5h ago

Mate. The internet shows most people literally only know about the trans atlantic slave trade.

And they think the british went over there with nets to steal black people.

22

u/OofIamTired 6h ago

Well, you definitely do see an overwhelming belief that all that's evil in the world is because "muhmuh white european racist evil colonizer".

After all, it removes the responsibility of admitting that even countries that were colonized were not perfect and provides a scapegoat

→ More replies (17)

17

u/LeighAlexander 6h ago

Please present evidence against OP's case, which ideally should include early education Social Studies or History books devoting as much time to the Arab slave trade as the European one.

→ More replies (43)

4

u/Jumperontheline 6h ago

What a gross thing to say. You almost sound like youre about to crack a whip on her for thinking her own way. Are you?

2

u/ThatsCommissarHolt 6h ago

Yeah? We kinda are?  The Muslim-Arab slave trade was never once brought up in high school. 

The Atlantic slave trade though?  Boy was it taught. 

2

u/TheSpacePopinjay 5h ago

Op seems mad that history is too soft on Arab enslavers, not too hard on European ones, except in the sense of anomolising them in such a way that gives a pass to everyone else.

→ More replies (15)

1

u/AutoModerator 6h ago

Hello! I'm AutoMod, and I'll be hanging out in the comments on every post! Be sure to give our rules a quick read, and most importantly, have fun!

Think this is a hot take? Cast your vote in the comments using Not a Hot Take, Cold Take, Warm Take, Hot Take, or Nuclear Take! Our voting bot will tally the votes and automatically assign the winning flair when voting closes.

Feel free to join our Discord! https://discord.gg/ev2g72FNJ2

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/sl33pytesla 6h ago

A lot of the slave trade we were taught were from corporations such as the west and east India trading company and insurance companies that ensured these missions payed out. Capitalist society is awesome.

It got bad when these corporations were in debt and had to do what they had to do by selling opium grown by slaves.

1

u/_redmist 5h ago

europe has had slavery looong before the 1500's lol not so much africans perhaps. 

1

u/therob91 5h ago

Most of them also dont know about the peaks of other civilizations. We just study our own history more so we know more about it. Few of these people talking about "hey talk about the slavery of the rest of the world" want us to acknowledge good things that people did in China or Middle east in the past. Its just people with an agenda.

1

u/blueViolet26 5h ago

Is there an unbiased way to teach about colonization? Come on. 😂

1

u/ronshasta 5h ago

The world continuously demonizes America for slavery and it’s wild because the amount of elves vs the time there was slavery here is nothing compared to literally every other country in the world that had slaves

1

u/Sea-Original-5824 4h ago

We're taught about slavery within the context of American history. You can take more advanced or specialized classes in college to learn about slavery in other contexts. The point of how it's taught in the US is so that every American citizen has a complete understanding of the how and why of their nation and the people that inhabit it.

1

u/Haunting_Baseball_92 4h ago

Yeah, this is a uniquely US problem.

In the rest of the world we know that slavery was a free for all and had nothing to do with race and everything to do with opportunity.

Sadly, with the explosive growth of social media this US problem has started to spread a bit among the younger generation elsewhere as well.

1

u/KiwasiGames 4h ago

It’s not that we don’t think non Europeans didnt do slaves. It’s that we don’t think about non Europeans at all.

Western history lessons go Egypt, Greece, Rome, medieval Europe, Industrial Revolution, colonisation, world wars, today.

We spend no time at all on cultures and civilisations outside of our own cultural ancestors.

1

u/LFAdvice0909 4h ago

Context is important. You're an American, and getting an American education. Of course it's going to focus on the group of oppressors that caused not only American slavery but talk about their impacts globally.

If you were getting educated in Nigeria, you would learn about the things you posted here.

High-school curriculums are designed to go broadly, not deeply into topics. You're supposed to go to college to specialize and get deeper knowledge in the fields that interest you.

This is just a post where you share things you've learned about your culture which is great for you. American curriculums don't care about Nigeria and will not dive into it.

1

u/Majestic-Plate-8222 4h ago

Europeans had europeans slaves for most of their history. The russian empired abolished servdoom in 1860, before that labourers were disposed of by the owners more or less as cattle. Vikings ruotinely took slaves from the countries they raided. I think if you were to study Asia's history you will also find many instances of slavery. India still has a cast system for gods sake. 

1

u/Superb-General7007 4h ago

Slavery still exists in the 21st century but people do not want to recognize it or the subset that still practice’s it.

There has always been a form of it, every conquering army throughout history enslaved those they conquered even in the 20th century including Imperial Japan and Nazi Germany. To blame slavery on one exclusive group is a failure to be honest. Understandably it doesn’t fit a particular narrative most want it to fit in, but to fail to recognize that just about every society, racial background, and every economic group has practiced it in one form or another is a failure of historical education.

To not recognize that it was fellow African tribes and Muslim slave traders that fueled the slave trade on the African continent during that time period that supplied the captured slaves is a blight of truth as well.

To not Recognize that the mass migration issues facing the world today doesn’t encourage and facilitate it today is a reflection of just how undereducated we as a society truly are.

1

u/rewanpaj 4h ago

since your american they’re teaching you what’s relevant to you

1

u/Oldnbold22 4h ago

In Myanmar they teach about American slavery as sort of cautionary tale that the slaves or descendants are really net negative for the economy. 

1

u/Jaded-Flight-8554 4h ago

Fellow Naija American here who went to school (K-12 and college) in the D[M]V!

tldr; this is cold take because we already know that what we are taught is focused (not necessarily biased) to America. It’s not demonizing them to focus on what European descendants did to shape the country we live in. For reference to what we are taught, google the AP World history and AP US history curriculums. They are available online and just ctrl-f “slave” to see what we are taught.

Not sure where you went to school but maybe you have a school system that had a poor world history and American history curriculum, but this post mashed things together and neglects how we are structurally taught over the years. Even though you’re right that we don’t get a comprehensive history on Arab colonialism and enslavement (or any other historic slavery) in American schools, we are taught that slavery as a concept is old.

  1. You’re talking about global slavery which is lightly covered in high school world history class, but in American history classes, we specifically learn about black chattel slavery, and how it shaped the economic and social threads of America. You may learn in passing about other civilizations and how they generally engaged in slavery (e.g., how the Mongols captured dissenters, how the Brit’s captured engaged on indentured servitude, how the Egyptians enslaved people, etc. t), but American history is about America.
  2. I realize most people simply have forgotten what they learned in their history classes in High School. We may not learn everything or even close to everything, but by high school, you’ll get at least a 1 liner about the basics. Most people don’t even remember more than 1 trigger for any of the wars fought on American soil, let alone that George Washington didn’t have wooden teeth or that abolition is as old as America (shoutout the Quakers and people in Philly back in those days!).
  3. Lastly, we in America and in much of the world live, and have lived, in a world that is the brain child of European colonialists since they began their shenanigans 500+ years ago - except for the Middle East. That’s why much of the modern conflict involving “Western” powers is in the Middle East today - the West did not try and imperially dominate there until the mid-1900s. Most of their attempts at domination have lead to bloody wars and terrible conflict. So for us, Euro imperialism and the white are the biggest Ops. And in other places, the Arabs were.
  4. Western aid is soft power and a direct result of how the Euro’s destabilized Africa via slavery, colonization (think Southern Africa), and economic bullying post colonization even after they “left” the places they occupied. China and Russia are doing the same thing (giving aid and seemingly more sustainable investment) today for the same reasons and resources - people, oil and minerals - and they are the current people being demonized for destabilizing African countries. It takes a long time to completely deplete a land mass as big as Africa, and we now have new foreign pillagers.

Framing is important because it lays the field of vision. For example, the Brits didn’t take slaves from our country because it didn’t exist until Unilever was done babysitting the land they bought and fought for from African rulers and communities. But just because they didn’t go around with nets doesn’t mean that they weren’t conspiring with the worst of our ancestors for profit, manning the ports and ships trading people, and eventually pillaging from our communities by proxy. There’s enough blame to go around, and imo the Europeans take more blame than those that were happy to give up or people or were eventually threatened to.

Recommendation: I encourage you to read the words of the countries that sent conquistadors and explorers tonAfrica and the America’s and how they talked about manipulating black people with made up inferiority. I also encourage you to learn about black chattel slavery in America and how unique (not singularly but still unique) it is. Lastly, it’ll be a looong journey, but African history is written by sooooo many people - both local to the land and from foreign entities. To learn about the history of Africa is to put together a puzzle with almostt infinite pieces. Much more to digest over a way longer period of time. But it’s worth it.

1

u/havenofeardaveishere 4h ago

It's verboten to speak about Arab slave trade! They don't even teach in schools about it lol

1

u/Huffers1010 4h ago

At this point, this barely qualifies as a "hot take."

Nobody's making excuses for the sins of the past, but after the release of the film The Woman King, in which the Kingdom of Dahomey is (absurdly, if I need to say it) depicted as taking an anti-slavery stance, I think the debate has centralised a bit.

It remains miserably true that slavery has been fairly normal throughout history, and that the British Empire was one of very few jurisdictions to actually stop it.

1

u/Thick_Couple7055 4h ago

Americans need to focus on American slavery deeply because there's no way to understand American history or culture without exploring the tension between three facts. 

  1. That our country was founded over the following precept: " We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created  equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness".
  2. Those people held black men as slaves.
  3. Those men were highly educated elites who were certainly aware of both the abolitionist movement and the fact that black people are, in fact, people.

The story of America is one of setting impossibly high ideals, failing to meet all of them and then getting upset when the next generation tries to finish the mission 

1

u/ScatterTheReeds 4h ago

You’re correct. Native Americans owned Black slaves. People in Africa (and the rest of the world) enslaved each other. 

1

u/CatCowFluffySupreme 4h ago

These comments won't be a catastrophe or anything.

1

u/READ88088 4h ago

we live in the modern world

1

u/Danielovando 4h ago

agreed,

at least in South America(Bolivia) they do tell you that slavery was not subject to religious or race.

1

u/ATXoxoxo 4h ago

Intelligence agencies destabilize African countries so they can be robbed by our corporations. Russians, Americans, Chinese European. All imperialist assholes with no regard for the value of labor or the working class of the world. 

1

u/At0ms2019 4h ago

So most history is told from a specific lens. If you are American and are taking an American or European history course, they will focus on that slave trade and not go deeper into all slavery. That doesn’t mean it didn’t exist, it is just outside the scope of the course materials. Glad to see you have done further research, but that is usually what college is for and not the general education of high school.

1

u/Superb-General7007 4h ago

Communism is a form of slavery as well , Communist countries such as China, North Korea, and the former Union of Soviet Socialist Republics enslaved their population while the leaders lived and live entirely different.

The Quran embellishes and promotes slavery calling to enslaved all those who do not adhere or convert. Sure you can coexist as long as you pay a tax but you are still a second class citizen