r/HonestHotTakes • • 6h ago Bravo

đŸ”„ Hot Take Slavery is taught in an extremely biased way to demonize only Europeans. Most people have no idea about the real history of global slavery.

2.6k Upvotes

I am a Nigerian American who studied about slavery in school as a kid. It has since become obvious to me that the education I and most American kids have received about slavery is extremely biased. It barely mentions the slavery that was happening worldwide, and it paints white or europeans as the only people who ever did large scale slavery. Which is just objectively untrue.

White colonialism didn’t start till around the 1500s. First with Portugal and Spain, then later other European powers followed suite. Previously enslaved Africans and their generations became part of those countries populations. And eventually Europeans ended slavery around the 1900s. The European legacy of slavery was approximately 400 years.

Meanwhile, and this is the part that almost no one seems to know, Arabs were enslaving millions of subsaharan africans since the 600’s. Yes, all the way since the year 600. They also took african women as sex slaves. Part of why this is so unknown and was easy to hide, is because they actually routinely castrated the African male slaves, preventing them from ever mating with Arab women and effecting “pure Arab” demographics.

The Arab slave trade (also known on as the Arab-Muslim slave trade since it was in large part a religiously led conquest, not unlike “manifest destiny” and other Christian justifications for conquering lands) continued all the way until the 1900s. Seriously, look it up. It was literally three times longer than european slavery.

There is also the idea that Africa’s resources were all plunderered by white people and now that’s why they’re poor. But in reality, africans still have SO many rich resources, that now CHINA is even capitalizing on and essentially enslaving subsaharan black people to mine said resources for them, in their own countries. I read a Nigerian news article online speaking about the harsh conditions and extremely low pay, if any, that may Africans working for Chinese mining companies (again, in their own countries, so pretty much modern colonialism) have been enduring for years since the Chinese began entering Nigeria.

So it’s not apparently not the case either that “white people took everything and now africans can’t get rich”. that’s not how it happened at all. It’s a vast oversimplification and miseducation. Perhaps even intentionally obfuscation done en-masse.

The truth is that foreign entities keep coming to Africa for its rich resources and human labor, african “leaders” don’t really give a shit about their people so they accept the enslavement of their people and extraction of their resources for their own selfish financial gain, keeping whatever the outsiders given them in exchange, for themselves. Millions and billions of dollars the african leaders use to enrich their families and inner circles while their citizens starve or continue to be trafficked by foreign entities (like china, libya and saudi arabia today, and arabs, then europeans, in the past).

Africans who actually live in africa are well aware that their leaders aren’t sh*t. The ones who aren’t are busy giving the little then have to Nigerian pastors who claim to be prophets (so, another layer of exploitation by their own people). and the irony in all of this is that Europeans/white people are the only ones in the present day sending humanitarian aid and money to africa.

The kind of money their own leaders won’t even share with them.

r/HonestHotTakes • • 4h ago

đŸ”„ Hot Take If women can prefer tall men, then likewise men can prefer young women in dating

0 Upvotes

What's up with double standard? As long as they are two consenting adults, there is nothing wrong/creepy about it. Either both of them are wrong, or neither of them are wrong. Height and age are both immutable traits, so i think the comparison is right. Also both preferences are somewhat patriarchal as they infantilize women.

Edit: Y'all saying that this is a cold take is funny lmao. Look at the upvote and comment ratio. It's a literal warzone in the comments. This might be a cold take irl, but def a hot take here on reddit

r/HonestHotTakes • • 22h ago This Bravo Heartwarming

đŸ”„ Hot Take Society has no solution for incels.

1.3k Upvotes

I'm not an incel, and I detest the average incel community's set of ideas. However, I think the underlying concept of an incel is very real.

Take the entire male population and rank them by conventional attractiveness, social ability, intelligence, and other natural talents that might make someone desirable to potential partners. Now select the bottom 10%.

Those men are going to have a much harder time finding women who are romantically interested in them.

If you have a problem with my choice of attributes, we can make it even simpler. Imagine having all women rate all men on overall romantic attractiveness, and then selecting the bottom 10% based on their average ratings.

The exact percentage doesn't matter. Neither does the precise definition of attractiveness. Obviously, attraction is subjective, and being near the bottom of some hypothetical ranking doesn't guarantee that you'll never find a partner. My point is simply that, whatever criteria you use, there will always be people who end up near the bottom, and their romantic prospects will generally be worse.

Now take that group and select the men who aren't doing anything obviously wrong. They're not assholes, they don't feel entitled to women's attention, they're trying their best to get their lives together, and they're genuinely making an effort.

You're left with a group of men who have an extremely difficult time finding romantic relationships, through no obvious fault of their own.

Even if this group makes up only a small minority of the population, we're still talking about an enormous number of people. Potentially more than the number of transgender people, for instance.

And before anyone misunderstands that comparison: I'm not claiming these groups face the same problems, or that transgender people receive too much attention. I'm pointing out that being a small minority clearly doesn't prevent a group's struggles from becoming a recognized social issue. So why is there so little acknowledgement of this one?

I think part of the reason is that these men are inherently difficult for society to sympathize with.

It's relatively easy for society to rally around groups that fit our familiar understanding of disadvantage and oppression. But there is a deafening silence about the privilege associated with intelligence, natural beauty, charisma, and social ability.

You can't just decide to become an extrovert, exceptionally funny, highly intelligent, or beautiful. Sure, you can improve yourself, but there are limits, and people start from very different positions.

And people who lack these advantages have a drastically harder time succeeding in life. Not just in dating, but in many other areas as well.

Yet there's no movement of "ugly people" demonstrating to raise awareness of their disadvantages. Nobody wants to publicly identify as ugly, unintelligent, or socially undesirable.

Well, except for incels online.

They actually do identify themselves through a collection of traits that society considers undesirable. And of course, society doesn't particularly like them.

And of course, the most vocal incels tend to be the ones with the most extreme and misogynistic ideas. I'm not defending any of that. But I suspect many of the men who find themselves in this situation are simply sad, frustrated, lonely young men who have been dealt a shittier hand than most people.

And because the loudest people associated with their predicament are so unpleasant, the entire issue becomes something we don't want to talk about.

To be clear, nobody is entitled to love, sex, or a relationship. Women don't owe these men anything, and I'm certainly not suggesting otherwise.

But acknowledging that nobody is entitled to love doesn't mean we should pretend everyone has an equal chance of finding it. As soon as you accept that some people (through nothing they could voluntarily control) have an easier time finding love l, you immediately have to acknowledge the other end of this spectrum.

We readily acknowledge that people are born with unequal opportunities in many areas of life. Yet when it comes to romantic relationships, there seems to be an expectation that everyone can succeed if they just work on themselves, improve their attitude, and put in enough effort.

For some people, that simply isn't going to be enough.

And the worst part is that I don't have a solution. I genuinely wouldn't know what to tell these men. You can't force attraction, and you can't redistribute romantic opportunities the way you might redistribute economic resources.

But the fact that there is no obvious solution doesn't make their suffering any less real.

And I think we should at least be able to acknowledge that without being accused of defending incel ideology.

r/HonestHotTakes • • 21h ago Bravo

đŸ”„ Hot Take For unattractive men, "real life" isn't any better than dating apps

417 Upvotes

I either don't get any matches, or it just ends in ghosting and rejection. So the magical solution is... try real life? It's no different at all.

Go to a college campus, who are the girls hanging out with? Hot guys, or the rich ones with luxury cars. Or guys who possess an extraordinary ability, like being a top athlete, who are also- surprise!- hot and rich. No regular guy gets a girl just because "he is a good person" or whatever.

A common piece of advice is to attend clubs and social events, but that doesn't help either. Say you go to a Japanese history meetup and meet a girl to talk about, well, Japanese history. Perhaps you become close friends who chat and text a lot, which is good if you're looking for a friend. But our problem is getting a girlfriend, and when you eventually ask her out on a one-on-one date outside of college, if you're not attractive, you still hit the brick wall of "I'm busy" or whatever.

If you're not physically attractive, the only solution is to become attractive, or to possess extreme wealth or other rare qualities. There is no shortcut like "touching grass" or "becoming a better person."

r/HonestHotTakes • • 1h ago Bravo

đŸ”„ Hot Take Hamas literally live-streamed their rapes and dismemberments, and still ended up with large parts of the world defending them, including a large contingent of Redditors

626 Upvotes

Most redditors have no moral compass. They have no critical thinking skills. And they are DESPERATE for a sense of higher purpose.

So they latch on to whatever cause is trending. Right now, that means they wear keffiyehs and defend "From the river to the sea" as a call to liberation.

Keep that in mind when they call anyone who disagrees with them a bigot or a nazi or whatever other insult they've collectively decided to go with this week.

Ignore them. Pity them for the fools they are.

r/HonestHotTakes • • 1d ago Bravo

đŸ”„ Hot Take Men do not “always” benefit more from marriage

34 Upvotes

I’ve seen an influx of comments online hating on marriage and saying that marriage “always” benefits the man more and women shouldn’t get married cause they will get the short end of the stick. It’s such a ridiculous and close minded thing to claim.

r/HonestHotTakes • • 3h ago

đŸ”„ Hot Take Abrahamic religions never have and never will be good for women

64 Upvotes

This means Christianity, Judaism, and Islam. They will never treat women right, there is no amount of "it's out of context" that will be convincing because these religions have only been used to harm women and other minorities. Abrahamic religions were used to colonise majority of the world and as a result destroy existing cultural practices that gave women equitable rights and abilities. This post does not discuss other religions by the way. Dharmic religions and other faiths also have their problems.

Here are some reasons specific to each individual religion:

Christianity -

  • Deuteronomy 22:28–29; God’s punishment for the raping of a virgin is to pay her father 50 shekels of silver and marry her for life. The rapist was seen as ruining someone else’s property, not ruining a young girl’s life. 
  • 2 Samuel 7:11; God, through Nathan, says he is going to punish David’s affair with Bathsheba by making all of David’s wives prostitutes. 
  • 1 Numbers 31:7–18; God decides to not kill everyone this time. This time, He commands the Israelites to kill all the Midianites except the virgins, whom they will take as spoils of war. 
  • Timothy 2:12 instruct women not to teach or have authority over men
  • Ephesians 5:22–25 and 1 Peter 3:1–7 call for wives to submit to their husbands
  • Purity customs (applicable to all 3) that basically banish female pleasure
  • 1 Corinthians 14:34–35 instructs women to remain silent in churches, stating they are not permitted to speak, must be in submission, and should ask their husbands at home if they want to learn something.
  • 1 Timothy 2:13–15 argues that women should not hold authority because Adam was formed first and Eve was the one deceived into sin, adding that women will be saved through childbearing.
  • Exodus 21:7–11 permits a father to sell his daughter as a female servant, outlining rules for when she does not please her master, unlike male servants who are automatically freed after six years.

Islam -

  • The hijab. It is not a choice because the alternative is to burn in hell. The argument that men also have to adhere to some modesty is inadequate as it is very clear that women have to submit to higher degree of modesty. Navel to the knee is not the same as covering whole body and hair. Other than limiting women's autonomy, it also makes women responsible for male desire because the whole reason that women have to cover up is to not tempt.
  • Surah An-Nisa basically outlines how husbands should beat their wives. It describes men as qawwamun (often translated as protectors or maintainers) over women and outlines steps for marital conflict (nushuz), including admonition, separation in bed, and physical action (variously translated as striking, hitting, or separating/leaving).
  • Quran 4:11 and 4:176 often allocates a male heir twice the share of a female heir in certain family relationships.
  • Men can take 4 wives but the same is not allowed for women. I agree that this does come with financial obligations but it still means that men have more control over the family structure than women.
  • Quran 2:223: women are the "field" for their husbands sexually. no context is this okay.
  • Being on your period means you are unpure and cannot pray.
  • Quran 2:282 says that in financial contracts the testimony of two women is equal to that of one man, stating that if one of the two women errs, the other can remind her.
  • Sahih al-Bukhari 3237 says that if a husband calls his wife to bed and she refuses, causing him to go to sleep angry, the angels curse her until morning.
  • an adult woman cannot contract her own marriage without the approval of a male guardian.

Judaism -

  • Only a husband can grant a religious divorce. If he refuses, the woman cannot remarry within traditional Judaism, creating a major legal power imbalance.
  • Women cannot be religious leaders (applicable for all 3)
  • Synagogues seperate men and women and women's sections are smaller and further awayf rom Torah readings.
  • While a man’s vow is automatically binding, a father has the legal right to annul his unmarried daughter’s vows, and a husband has the right to annul his wife’s vows on the day he hears them.
  • Women are impure while menstruating and 7 days after
  • Women can only inherit from their fathers when there are no sons
  • In the traditional daily prayer book, men recite a blessing thanking God "who has not made me a woman" while women recite "who has made me according to His will."
  • women are generally disqualified from serving as formal witnesses in religious courts
  • a woman's singing voice is considered sexually distracting.

Just to add, to me all of these religions are the same sexist doctrine. I see little difference between them.

I just don't understand how women can follow these religions especially when they know how it's not made for them and that their god does not have their best interests in mind.