Title: Former small business owner correcting W-2 filing errors from almost 3.5 years ago. Looking for advice.
Almost 3.5 years ago, I operated a small LLC that eventually closed due to financial difficulties. I had an employee working remotely in another state, and I've been trying to resolve some old payroll and W-2 reporting issues.
I recently reviewed my electronic filing history with the Social Security Administration and discovered that three W-2s had been submitted for the same employee and tax year.
Here's the filing timeline:
First W-2 — Incorrect filing
The original W-2 was electronically submitted with an incorrect, overstated wage amount. It also contained an incorrect or incomplete Social Security number, resulting in an informational error in the SSA system.
This W-2 was never furnished to the employee.
Second W-2 — Correct filing
A second W-2 was submitted with what I understood to be the correct wages and withholding.
This was the W-2 actually furnished to the employee and the one intended to represent his earnings for that tax year.
Third W-2 — Duplicate filing
A third W-2 was subsequently submitted containing the same wage and withholding figures as the second W-2.
This was an unintended duplicate of the correct filing, rather than additional wages paid to the employee.
The electronic filing history showed informational errors associated with the first and third submissions, but both were marked completed.
W-2C corrections
After identifying the errors, I obtained the employee's correct Social Security number and electronically submitted W-2C corrections through the SSA.
I corrected the first W-2 to zero out the incorrectly reported wages and withholding and corrected the third W-2 to eliminate the duplicate reporting.
The second W-2 was intended to remain as the valid wage statement.
The SSA now shows the W-2C submissions as completed, and I have confirmation emails documenting the corrections.
My current concerns
The employment period was almost 3.5 years ago, and I have never personally received any notices or inquiries from the IRS or SSA specifically concerning these W-2 filing discrepancies.
I'm currently paying down outstanding payroll tax liabilities from the former business.
I'm also reviewing bank statements, payroll records, and electronic transfers to independently verify the actual wages paid and withholding amounts. Although I believed the second W-2 was correct when I issued it, I'm now checking everything carefully because some payments were made outside the payroll software.
Recently, the former employee contacted me with questions about his W-2 and tax reporting.
I want to make sure the records are accurate and that any remaining errors are properly corrected.
My questions:
If two incorrect W-2 submissions were corrected using W-2Cs and the SSA shows the corrections as completed, does that generally resolve the duplicate wage reporting?
Is there a way to confirm that only the second, intended W-2 remains reflected in the employee's earnings record?
Does the fact that almost 3.5 years have passed without any agency notices concerning these errors have any significance?
If I discover a discrepancy in the wages or withholding reported on the second W-2, can that still be corrected?
Could these types of administrative filing errors lead to criminal allegations, or are they generally handled through corrections and civil penalties absent intentional misconduct?
Should I have a tax attorney and CPA review the W-2C submissions, payroll records, and Form 941 filings together?
Since closing the business, I've found stable employment in healthcare, returned to school, and have been working to address my outstanding financial obligations.
I'm not trying to avoid responsibility. I just want to make sure everything is accurate, correct any remaining mistakes, and finally move forward.
Any advice from tax professionals or others who have experienced something similar would be appreciated.