This post is partly venting because I would be too embarrassed to say some of this stuff to people I know in real life. And partly looking to see if there is advice on how to maximize my success and if my ideas sound like good ideas or not. Sorry for the long post.
I'm in my mid 20s, straight male, couple years out of college and still haven't had sex yet. I feel like part of the reason why is some of the excuses I made for myself, but those excuses have been resolved now, so I have no more excuses and I feel like it's now or never for me. Because I am starting to get to the age where if I do get in a serious relationship, my fear is a women is going to be weirded out by my lack of experience, and her initial reaction could be "is there something wrong with him I haven't noticed".
So anyways, I'll give a quick overview of my history to give context. Growing up, everything was mostly fine, I was kind of the awkward nerd kid in high school. Had some friends, but not many female friends looking back. Went to college, that was good for me to be outgoing, but I was so busy during college with classes, working part time, extracurriculars. Also, didn't help I was an engineering major so my classes were majority guys. Part of it was I would be too nervous to ask out women in real life, part of it was I was busy and stressed out about my future career so honestly I might not have been the best boyfriend at that time anyways. Excuse number 1.
Graduated college, got a decent job where the work was cool, the problem was the location was rough for dating. Think almost as bad as going to work on the oil fields in West Texas (not quite as bad but you get the idea). Talking to my friends in college, they would think I was joking when I said I legitimately have trouble finding women in their 20s where I lived, but I was serious. Excuse number 2.
There was one woman about my age that I worked closely with, but the personality was just not compatible with me. After I knew her for several months, I forgot how she got on the topic, but she straight up unironically said "all men are evil" (I knew her well enough at the point to tell she wasn't saying that as a joke), probably got it from TikTok or somewhere and was just repeating, but I said well I disagree, and she argued with me for a minute, and then the conversation died out. I think after that she thought I was gay or something and maybe told a couple people at work this rumor, because I also have a bit of a nasaly voice for a guy which doesn't bother me, but maybe some people might mistake that for a sign of being gay. And maybe her logic was no girlfriend and defending guys? Does he like guys or something? Because soon after this I went to a bar with another guy coworker and at one point he said "I think a guy over there is checking you out" and my reaction was just "the hell? even if that's true, why are you even telling me that?" Then later on, I was thinking ohhhh, did that one woman suggest something about me to him? So yeah, anyways, the woman I would encounter the most during this time wasn't exactly a good woman influence on me. But stating the obvious, not all women are like that. And the fact she was single, couldn't find a boyfriend when there were tons of guys around, might suggest maybe her personality wasn't the best.
I did have a dating experience in this location. It might be questionable to count it because we never had sex or were exclusive, but I will count it. I was on the subreddit for the area, and some woman posted along the lines of "can't meet any decent guys, need dating advice" and I responded "hey you're my age, I got nothing to lose, I'm willing to meet in a public place". If she turned out to be a guy or just weird, I would leave. And she was sweet and fun to be around. Went on 6 dates I think. The dates itself went well, she had a good time, but the weird thing was she would always be so busy (or claim to be busy), and only hang out for like 1-2 hours so it was difficult for me to progress romantically during the date because she would always be like oh I got this thing in a few hours I need to be at (she would say this at the start of the dates, so not like I did something weird on the date, and she was making an excuse to leave). I was willing to give her the benefit of the doubt, because she was in college still (she was 22, I was 23) and also lived with her parents and said her parents always wanted to do stuff. The last date we went on, was Friday or Saturday night, can't remember. And she starts the date with "oh I got to leave early, I have a homework assignment due midnight", I just shrugged it off, but internally in my head I was like "what the actual hell?!?! Why didn't you just finish your homework, I would have been willing to meet up later in the night." And then she broke up with me over text a few days later, along the lines of "you're a great guy, but I met someone else". I am glad for some experience, but I wish I would have been more assertive and asked her to be open with why she is so busy, because after she sent that text, then I realized maybe she was talking to multiple guys at once.
There was another woman I went on a date with. A different coworker set me up. Date was fine, but honestly she was just not my type at all. Facial piercings, and main interest was gaming. And I am not a gamer at all, my main interest is outdoors stuff.
Anyways, I lived in that area about 2 years, before I said I need to make a change and moved.
I found a job in my field near a major city (city large enough that they have a NBA, NFL team, etc.). Been living in the area about 9 ish months. I can already tell it's going to be way better. In a perfect world, I would live downtown. I am out in the far suburbs because otherwise my job would be a crazy commute. But I do know some guys who still decided to live downtown to be around the bars, young people and stuff and put up with the slightly over an hour one-way commute. Yes, this makes it more difficult to go to bars, but I just have no more excuses, living far from downtown is not an excuse, and I need to not make a new one.
Should also mention, I've tried dating apps in the past, but the only rare likes I would get are women I am not attracted to, may get some negative reaction to what I said, but I find the majority of women my age I see walking around attractive, it's not I was being too picky. You'll have to take my word for it, but it would be women significantly overweight, which is not a bad thing, I've heard some guys may even be into it. But I am really into sports, hiking, active stuff, and just couldn't see myself dating someone I am not physically attracted to.
Anyways, I moved to the area not knowing a single person, so it's taking me a while to build up my friend group. I go to a run club, met some I'll say friend-ish people there, by that I mean we are regulars at run club all the time, but I haven't hung out with most of them at run club yet.
I have asked out 2 women so far at the run club. Both responses were I'm busy. Which I assumed as an indirect no since there was no other follow up on their end. The trouble is there are a lot of people who are very irregular (might show up once a month) and only a fraction of the group is regulars. The regulars are mostly guys. So it is kind of hard to build a connection with women this way before asking if they want to do something outside the club. Another problem is, I am just a very average dude, honestly there isn't anything that stands out about me, and my personality is just ok, kind of introverted, slightly awkward at times talking to complete strangers, but not wow this person is weird awkward. Basically, I'm saying I am no pickup artist, and I don't blow people away with a charming personality.
Ok long vent over. If you have questions, I'll reply to comments. What am I doing? This needs to be a focus of mine in the next year. Like I said, I have no excuses, and this is the only part of my life where I really need to get it together. I need to be more comfortable with rejection. I am not talking to and then asking out nearly enough women it seems. Would cold approaches actually help? What are some good places for that? Of course I will be respectful. And no worries if the answer is no.
I just a couple weeks ago started going to this dance lesson thing that is free and meets once a week (although it seems like it will be winding down because of the winter and it's outdoors). I haven't figured out if there is a regular group that shows up to that yet. I honestly don't like dancing maybe because I suck at it, which maybe the lessons will solve that issue lol. But this seems like it will be huge, because it is partner dancing, so it is in a good way forcing me to interact with women. Also, thinking of signing up for co-ed volleyball after the holidays.
Besides that, I recently joined a gym, I don't intend to go out of my way to meet women here, might be tough anyways since 90% of people have headphones in, I am just doing it as another thing to do. And while I said I am in good physical shape, I am definitely lean, so maybe putting on slightly more muscle might not be the worst thing.
Any other ideas to help me? Or general advice for asking women out? The asking women out seems to be my biggest issue. Thanks if you read the whole thing.