Premise:
A memoir by Mrs. Sonia Gandhi. Not much introduction required…
37 chapters structured into 7 parts: Love & Courtship; Finding my Way; Triumphs & Defeats; Rajiv as PM; Denouement & Aftermath; Leading Congress; 20 years on.
Here’s what I liked, disliked and learnt from the book. Slightly long review – sorry! But it might save your time, money and effort.
Important Caveat:
I've treated this memoir as an autobiography. I looked up the difference just prior to posting this review, and realised I had over-analysed and fact-checked a subjective narrative to death...but then again, we don't know if we'll get a more objective, factual book from Mrs. Gandhi anytime soon.
Apologies in advance. 🙏
Why did I read this?
- I listened to the audiobook available on Storytel. That’s really the main motivation. I don’t read much about politics, and read memoirs even less. The narrator Sneha Mathan has a beautiful voice – so once I’d started listening to it, I had to finish the book.
What I liked/ Enjoyable Trivia for me:
- Memoir indeed begins and ends with the theme of Love. How it grew – from meeting Rajiv Gandhi at Cambridge to her love for India to a renewed hope for a functioning democracy.
- Sonia’s early life + her Italian family – some really colorful characters (Sonia’s dad, Nonno Marco, Nonno Beppi, Nonna Ige). For me the most engaging parts of the book were this (till chapter 8) and the 1990s period…rest is just… well you’ll read the next section hopefully.
- Some flex moments: Sonia’s school was visited by Sophia Loren! She’d come to visit Italian pioneer cinematographer Giuseppe Fillipe, in Sonia’s village. Later, when Sonia arrived in India 1st time, she stayed with the Bachchans, since Amit(abh) was close friend of Sanjay then.
- Some incidents were funny - Rajiv’s 1st meeting with Sonia’s father; Ball room invitation card torn by Rajiv as he’s angry at Sonia for her unpunctuality! (For some reason I’d have thought her strict father would have made her punctual too?!) Another was when she and her friend Preeti removed a panel/board above the Bhutani Majesty’s room, thinking it was a rumored trapdoor – Sasu Maa Indira scolded, then laughed with them; and the Sheep eyes of Uzbekistan 👀
- I do share many interests with Sonia ji I guess – history, museums, art history, reading, movies – I got a small TBR and TBW list from this book 😊 Her fav childhood book is - Cuore(the heart) by Edmondo De Amicis – I’ll try if it’s short read.
- High praise for the people around her – that’s a quality I admire. This memoir is almost a biography too, of other people who made/helped her in her journey. Gotta read Sharada Prasad's book now – he’s highly praised here.
- 2010: Breast cancer diagnosed. Removed in Italy. Then 2011: pancreatic cancer/tumor treated. Twice cancer survivor 💪
- 2022: Sonia's mother painful death, aged 97. “As she was laid to rest in the family crypt, Anoushka’s daughter Aruna spontaneously began to sing in her lovely voice her Nonna’s favourite song, “Scrivimi” (“Write to Me”), a melancholy love song of the 1930s”. I heard the song, it’s beautiful. Here are the lyrics. :’)
- Chapters 27-30: Her inner turmoil is reflected when her sister Nadia questions her stay in India after 2 tragic deaths - that Sonia should come back to her home in Italy; her decision to enter politics, seeking Gita's guidance; when she gives up the PM position in favor of MMS, to avoid "foreign origin" attacks by the opposition.
- When Sonia's father dies by heart attack, she regrets not meeting her sooner. Similarly when Rajiv had asked her to accompany him to Sriperumbudur, she regrets not going – these are where the memoir truly reflects her pain.
What I didn't like/Stuff that’s somewhat sad, disturbing:
- 1975 The Raj Narain case: Didn't know about the 2 trivial counts on which Indira's 1971 win was invalidated.
- Chapter 16:- Operation Blue Star is discussed not in detail. Never mentions the causes nor discusses what led to that situation in the 1st place. I would have liked more information about how much Indira Gandhi was involved in Bhindranwale's rise - it's almost absent here. Just the aftermath.
- The ugly rumours about her – yes it’s part of public life, but it’s sad – I feel the vitriol against her is extremely misogynist. One example is - Jan 18,1969: her 1st born child dies.🪦 Right wingers even then displayed utter inhumane commentary ("Indira Gandhi failed in her attempt to become a grandmother of a bastard child" – ran an article, newspaper unnamed though)
- Sonia admits Sanjay Gandhi's rash and unconstitutional role in govt policies. Maneka + Sanjay vs Indira Gandhi...and yeah, she doesn't like Maneka Gandhi at all.
- 31/10/1984: Indira Gandhi dies. Sonia’s emotional reaction is truly sad to read, and then the gut punch : when she hears the news that ‘they’ want Rajiv to be next PM, she pleads against it, but Rajiv says “They’ll kill me anyway.”
- 1985: Shah Bano case. In 2001: SC upheld the 1986 law. Sonia here defends Rajiv’s actions using SC's decision, but it’s not convincing: Govt. had 1st welcomed the court order, THEN seeing the Muslim clergy backlash, drafted the 1986 law.
- "Rahul as general secretary in charge of the Youth Congress signed a party-to-party Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with his Chinese counterpart. However, nothing substantial came of that formal exercise." In 2008. I had to check, if this is legally possible! It is, since it's not legally enforceable, and as long as it's of non-financial nature. But the MoU hadn't been made public yet...
- Some facts are wrongly stated – e.g., RSS founded in 1921. (Fact - 1925). I saw this reel while reading it. Trivial for me, there were bigger gripes I had…
- Sonia mentions “I would reiterate here that this is a memoir, wherein politics serves to frame the main narrative, which is a personal account of my thoughts, feelings, and decisions."- problem for me is – there’s a lot of crucial decision-making missing in such landmark events! There are virtually no thoughts/feelings about Sonia’s own political ideology here – no insights into the diverse States, the people, the culture, the history of India. No mention of dynastic politics. No information regarding the blunders of her govt., nor of Indira/Rajiv’s govts.
Conclusion:
Mrs. Sonia’s journey is remarkable, no doubt – and deserves to be told. How a shy Italian village girl fell in love, got swept up in the messy democracy of 1.4bn people, gained/lost everything due to her love – these parts of her life are Interesting. Until 1990s, the memoir is basically like a report, mostly of Sonia’s POV on others.
She talks about Indira, then Rajiv’s govt decisions, but only at a distance – there’s little criticism, little illumination or BTS – I can accept that, since she was uninterested by the politics by then, just wanted a family life. It’s only when she begins her reluctant political journey in 1990s - we begin to see some political views here and there, her defence of govt.’s actions, immense praise of her kids, her aversion to BJP/RSS ideology.
For someone who was never meant to be in politics, she has endured more than enough, and is an inspiration in that respect (she also admits this quality of growth and resilience in Modi’s rise within RSS, there’s a line somewhere…) however...
Mrs. Sonia's subjective views contrast too much with her factual descriptions of the landmark events for me - here I praise her emotional commitments; there I wonder about crucial factual omissions! 🤦
Rating: 6.5/10 [As a memoir strictly, I'd rate it probably 7.5/10.]
I'm now eager to read Modi's memoir - it'll be quite a contrast...