r/IndiansRead • • 15h ago

General My October Reads (better late than never XD )

Thumbnail
gallery
43 Upvotes

I was going through my November reads and thought that my October was very happening too. Thus sharing:)

Note: I note down by monthly wraps based on the books I finish in the given month, not necessarily started in the same month. For example, in October I finished Cuckold and The Greatest Hindi Stories Ever Told which I had picked up a month before and then paused. The rest were read in October itself.


r/IndiansRead • • 3h ago

Review Four S. L. Bhyrappa books in a month, and I think I’m a little obsessed!

Post image
4 Upvotes

A month ago, when Smitha ji started the Samvacana initiative, I thought, why not join? It would give me an opportunity to interact with her, talk to her and, more importantly, listen to her. She is one of those people you just want to keep listening to. Somehow, everything she says feels like a light bulb going off in your head.
I had heard about Avarana from a friend who had recommended it back in May. I finally picked it up, thinking that before Samvacana began, I should at least know who S. L. Bhyrappa was. I didn’t want to be the person sitting in meetings while everyone discussed his books, without even knowing who the author was!
I finished Avarana in two days. I simply could not put it down.
I had always thought fiction wasn’t my thing. J. K. Rowling had managed to change that to some extent, but Bhyrappa did something entirely different.
With Rowling, it was entertainment. With Bhyrappa, it was self-exploration.
Through stories of human relationships and emotions, he makes you peel away layers of biases and assumptions you didn’t even realise you carried. He unpacks the nuances of Dharma through the eyes of people caught in their own Dharma Sankatas.
Today, most of us cannot imagine ourselves in Arjuna’s place. We know what the Bhagavad Gita teaches us, but when those dilemmas are brought alive through human characters and their circumstances, something shifts. You don’t just understand an idea intellectually; you begin to experience it.
Next, I picked up Vamsha Vriksha, this time in Marathi.
That was when I realised the difference between reading a translated book and reading it in an Indian language. It simply isn’t the same.
I literally wept while reading this book. Proper, full-on tears.
The book explores some deeply uncomfortable questions. Somewhere in the middle, you stop being a reader and become a participant. You start judging the characters. You take sides. You arrive at conclusions. You convince yourself that you have understood a complicated aspect of Dharma and that perhaps you now know better than you did before.
And then the book ends.
And even those conclusions collapse.
You realise that the very certainty with which you judged the characters was perhaps the problem. You thought you had become wiser, but the ending makes you question how cruel and judgmental your earlier conclusions were.
By the end, you feel a little freer from your own biases, a little less burdened by your ego. And, above all, humbled.
Then came Uttara Kaanda, about which I have already written separately.
This book made me extremely uncomfortable. It is so far removed from the Valmiki Ramayana that, at times, I found myself wondering what distinguished this retelling from the liberties taken in a film adaptation of the Ramayana.
The more you explore it, the more uncomfortable it gets. And yet, the characters speak to you. Your insecurities get exposed. Certain situations and emotions feel uncomfortably relatable. You find yourself wanting to explore them further, even when you don’t particularly enjoy what you are discovering about yourself.
I think the biggest difference lies in the intention behind the book and that behind a film adaptation. One leaves you with questions that you cannot easily walk away from.
The latest book I completed was Nirakarana.
WHAT. A. BOOK.
I am someone who, at times, wants to run away to my Guru, to the Ashram, convinced that what I am doing in my everyday life is somehow pointless. That perhaps I am meant to be doing something else.
This book was a RUDE MIRROR.
It also made me understand, at a much deeper level, the genius of Sadhguru’s teaching when he says, “See Me in everyone and everything around you.”
Somehow, He has made Samsara itself a spiritual Sadhana.
Nirakarana is about a man who, at different points in his life, rejects both Samsara and spirituality, only to find himself rejected by both. You know the expression — na ghar ka, na ghat ka.
I think this is particularly relevant to those of us who are exploring a spiritual path while continuing to live in Samsara.
When faced with everyday situations and responsibilities, how often do we wonder:
What am I doing all this for?
What is the point of this?
What am I contributing to in the larger scheme of things?
Is this really worthwhile?
And then we find ways to justify our desire to escape.
Someone else can do this better.
I am not made for this.
I am meant for something else.
Perhaps I should just go and do that instead.
Some people even muster the courage to make that move. I know people who have gone to the Ashram and returned, realising that life there comes with its own challenges.
But the way Nirakarana portrays the consequences of our choices is chilling.
I genuinely feel that anyone who feels drawn towards the spiritual path but is living within Samsara must read this book. And then listen carefully to what Sadhguru says.
When Sadhguru speaks about finding the spiritual dimension in everything you do and everyone around you, it can sound like common sense. It made sense when I heard it. But Bhyrappa, through this emotionally exhausting, almost chilling roller coaster of a story, made me internalise what that teaching actually means.
I understood a little more of the genius behind the idea of seeing the Divine in the very life we are living, rather than imagining that spirituality exists somewhere away from it.
And that, for me, was the most powerful takeaway from Nirakarana.
Next on my list is Dharmashree. Hopefully, I get my hands on it by next month!
I think I am officially obsessed with S. L. Bhyrappa. Four books in one month probably say enough.
Until then, I have started Ami Ganatra’s book on the Arthashastra. She is another person I could listen to endlessly. Every other sentence is another light bulb moment!


r/IndiansRead • • 2h ago

Suggest Me About Kathasaritsagara

1 Upvotes

So I am writing a story and I want to take ideas from Indian Fantasy. Which edition of Kathasaritsagara should I get so that I can get most of the ideas down and also enjoy the stories.


r/IndiansRead • • 17h ago

Discussion Is it original or counterfeit.

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

So I purchased this along with volume 1 & 2 all three from the same seller [Trans Infopreneur (Kantoor)] from Amazon, the other two volumes shipped from Karnataka and this one shipped from haryana this one reached me and the other two are still in transit, the book seems fine but the packaging was bad and the original sealed plastic already torn open (3rd pic) the package have delhivery tape on it the product seemed returned or replaced product and the most important thing check the last pic guys the cover didn't have that arabic sign stuff that present in the book from the website.


r/IndiansRead • • 5h ago

Suggest Me Suggestions needed

1 Upvotes

Guys suggest a fiction book from any of the 2 genres.

  1. A comforting, happy go lucky and not so heavy theme.
  2. A suspense thriller.

r/IndiansRead • • 1d ago

Fiction Children of Time : A novel that does Existential Dread really well

Post image
58 Upvotes

I read Children of Time recently, and it is an amazing piece of hard science fiction. Albeit not presenting itself as sci fi horror, it has, in my opinion, deeply disquieting and unsettling undertones of horror.

One of its primary elements is the accelerated evolution of a species of spiders. It explores the thin line of difference between natural evolution and intentional reprogramming, referred to as 'understandings' in the novel. In a way, evolution is treated as the iterations of a negative feedback loop.

Another particulalry disquieting theme that it explores is the loss of linear time. With human beings sleeping for centuries in suspension chambers as their ark ship explores the vastness of the cosmos, waking up in disjointed bursts where entire eras pass while they remain frozen.

And finally, another deeply disturbing element it explores is human-AI hybridization. One of the characters merges her decaying biological consciousness with a machine intelligence, creating a fractured entity where human ego collides with cold algorithmic logic.

I would recommend reading this, and Tchaikovsky in general, if you love hard science fiction.


r/IndiansRead • • 3h ago

Review 👩‍❤️‍👨🇮🇳 BELONGING - Sonia Gandhi {Power of Love, Love of Power, Cost of Both} Review

Post image
0 Upvotes

Premise:

A memoir by Mrs. Sonia Gandhi. Not much introduction required…
37 chapters structured into 7 parts: Love & Courtship; Finding my Way; Triumphs & Defeats; Rajiv as PM; Denouement & Aftermath; Leading Congress; 20 years on.

Here’s what I liked, disliked and learnt from the book. Slightly long review – sorry! But it might save your time, money and effort.

Important Caveat: 

I've treated this memoir as an autobiography. I looked up the difference just prior to posting this review, and realised I had over-analysed and fact-checked a subjective narrative to death...but then again, we don't know if we'll get a more objective, factual book from Mrs. Gandhi anytime soon. 

Apologies in advance. 🙏

Why did I read this?

- I listened to the audiobook available on Storytel. That’s really the main motivation. I don’t read much about politics, and read memoirs even less. The narrator Sneha Mathan has a beautiful voice – so once I’d started listening to it, I had to finish the book. 

What I liked/ Enjoyable Trivia for me:

- Memoir indeed begins and ends with the theme of Love. How it grew – from meeting Rajiv Gandhi at Cambridge to her love for India to a renewed hope for a functioning democracy.

- Sonia’s early life + her Italian family – some really colorful characters (Sonia’s dad, Nonno Marco, Nonno Beppi, Nonna Ige). For me the most engaging parts of the book were this (till chapter 8) and the 1990s period…rest is just… well you’ll read the next section hopefully.

- Some flex moments: Sonia’s school was visited by Sophia Loren! She’d come to visit Italian pioneer cinematographer Giuseppe Fillipe, in Sonia’s village. Later, when Sonia arrived in India 1st time, she stayed with the Bachchans, since Amit(abh) was close friend of Sanjay then.

- Some incidents were funny - Rajiv’s 1st meeting with Sonia’s father; Ball room invitation card torn by Rajiv as he’s angry at Sonia for her unpunctuality! (For some reason I’d have thought her strict father would have made her punctual too?!) Another was when she and her friend Preeti removed a panel/board above the Bhutani Majesty’s room, thinking it was a rumored trapdoor  – Sasu Maa Indira scolded, then laughed with them; and the Sheep eyes of Uzbekistan 👀

-  I do share many interests with Sonia ji I guess – history, museums, art history, reading, movies – I got a small TBR and TBW list from this book 😊 Her fav childhood book is - Cuore(the heart) by Edmondo De Amicis – I’ll try if it’s short read.

- High praise for the people around her – that’s a quality I admire. This memoir is almost a biography too, of other people who made/helped her in her journey. Gotta read Sharada Prasad's book now – he’s highly praised here.

- 2010: Breast cancer diagnosed. Removed in Italy. Then 2011: pancreatic cancer/tumor treated. Twice cancer survivor 💪  

- 2022: Sonia's mother painful death, aged 97. “As she was laid to rest in the family crypt, Anoushka’s daughter Aruna spontaneously began to sing in her lovely voice her Nonna’s favourite song, “Scrivimi” (“Write to Me”), a melancholy love song of the 1930s”. I heard the song, it’s beautiful. Here are the lyrics. :’)

- Chapters 27-30: Her inner turmoil is reflected when her sister Nadia questions her stay in India after 2 tragic deaths - that Sonia should come back to her home in Italy; her decision to enter politics, seeking Gita's guidance; when she gives up the PM position in favor of MMS, to avoid "foreign origin" attacks by the opposition.

- When Sonia's father dies by heart attack, she regrets not meeting her sooner. Similarly when Rajiv had asked her to accompany him to Sriperumbudur, she regrets not going – these are where the memoir truly reflects her pain.   

 

What I didn't like/Stuff that’s somewhat sad, disturbing:

- 1975 The Raj Narain case: Didn't know about the 2 trivial counts on which Indira's 1971 win was invalidated.  

- Chapter 16:- Operation Blue Star is discussed not in detail. Never mentions the causes nor discusses what led to that situation in the 1st place. I would have liked more information about how much Indira Gandhi was involved in Bhindranwale's rise - it's almost absent here. Just the aftermath.

- The ugly rumours about her – yes it’s part of public life, but it’s sad – I feel the vitriol against her is extremely misogynist. One example is  - Jan 18,1969: her 1st born child dies.🪦 Right wingers even then displayed utter inhumane commentary ("Indira Gandhi failed in her attempt to become a grandmother of a bastard child" – ran an article, newspaper unnamed though)

- Sonia admits Sanjay Gandhi's rash and unconstitutional role in govt policies. Maneka + Sanjay vs Indira Gandhi...and yeah, she doesn't like Maneka Gandhi at all.

- 31/10/1984: Indira Gandhi dies. Sonia’s emotional reaction is truly sad to read, and then the gut punch : when she hears the news that ‘they’ want Rajiv to be next PM, she pleads against it, but Rajiv says “They’ll kill me anyway.”

- 1985: Shah Bano case. In 2001: SC upheld the 1986 law. Sonia here defends Rajiv’s actions using SC's decision, but it’s not convincing: Govt. had 1st welcomed the court order, THEN seeing the Muslim clergy backlash, drafted the 1986 law.

- "Rahul as general secretary in charge of the Youth Congress signed a party-to-party Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with his Chinese counterpart. However, nothing substantial came of that formal exercise." In 2008. I had to check, if this is legally possible! It is, since it's not legally enforceable, and as long as it's of non-financial nature. But the MoU hadn't been made public yet...

- Some facts are wrongly stated – e.g., RSS founded in 1921. (Fact - 1925). I saw this reel while reading it. Trivial for me, there were bigger gripes I had…

- Sonia mentions “I would reiterate here that this is a memoir, wherein politics serves to frame the main narrative, which is a personal account of my thoughts, feelings, and decisions."-  problem for me is – there’s a lot of crucial decision-making missing in such landmark events! There are virtually no thoughts/feelings about Sonia’s own political ideology here – no insights into the diverse States, the people, the culture, the history of India. No mention of dynastic politics. No information regarding the blunders of her govt., nor of Indira/Rajiv’s govts.

Conclusion:

Mrs. Sonia’s journey is remarkable, no doubt – and deserves to be told. How a shy Italian village girl fell in love, got swept up in the messy democracy of 1.4bn people, gained/lost everything due to her love – these parts of her life are Interesting. Until 1990s, the memoir is basically like a report, mostly of Sonia’s POV on others.
She talks about Indira, then Rajiv’s govt decisions, but only at a distance – there’s little criticism, little illumination or BTS – I can accept that, since she was uninterested by the politics by then, just wanted a family life. It’s only when she begins her reluctant political journey in 1990s - we begin to see some political views here and there, her defence of govt.’s actions, immense praise of her kids, her aversion to BJP/RSS ideology.

For someone who was never meant to be in politics, she has endured more than enough, and is an inspiration in that respect (she also admits this quality of growth and resilience in Modi’s rise within RSS, there’s a line somewhere…) however...

Mrs. Sonia's subjective views contrast too much with her factual descriptions of the landmark events for me - here I praise her emotional commitments; there I wonder about crucial factual omissions! 🤦

Rating: 6.5/10 [As a memoir strictly, I'd rate it probably 7.5/10.]

I'm now eager to read Modi's memoir - it'll be quite a contrast...


r/IndiansRead • • 19h ago

Suggest Me Need you recommendations! what are some well written romance books with real, not overly polished, characters and an authentic potrayal of love, angst and relationship (Note: loved pride and prejudice and now have my standards high above in the sky) ?

3 Upvotes

HI, I am a part time student and a full time reader from jaipur. I usually read literary fiction but I've been getting more into classic recently. I read pride and prejudice a few months ago and now I fall short of actually good books (romance) on my tbr. all jane austen and brontes are obv the next read but I'm wondering if any modern romances have met the standards, the love, the yearning, the angst.. I've tried reading a few but they never quite did it for me.


r/IndiansRead • • 1d ago

Now Reading Picked another one for November

Post image
7 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I am picking this another book this November. The last book I read (mentioned in my last post) was an interesting one which took just a couple of sittings (at the airport ) to complete. So I will start reading another one this November.

Why this?

A known bangalore based tech startup founder recommended this along with a couple of others (the other two are software books btw).

What am I expecting?

He mentioned this will genuinely boost your confidence in owning engineering leadership roles as well. Let's see how it does.

Where do I stand now?

I mostly read software books. But recently started picking non technical books mostly when recommended by someone I look up to. I have a list of To-read and already-read. Ping me personally if you want to share ur reading list or know mine.

Review?

Status is still - 'Reading'


r/IndiansRead • • 20h ago

Now Reading Revision before the exams. Rereading the trilogy for the third time. The background is made by AI for fun, the book is mine.

Post image
2 Upvotes

Revision before the exams. Rereading the trilogy for the third time. The background is made by AI for fun, the book is mine.


r/IndiansRead • • 20h ago

Now Reading It's me.... I am the Alan

Post image
2 Upvotes

🥲


r/IndiansRead • • 1d ago

General Isn't it an investment?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/IndiansRead • • 1d ago

Review Finished Look Closer by David Ellis

Post image
1 Upvotes

A good quick crime thriller if you’re looking for something to get you back into reading. Good twists here, and there! The plot was brilliantly woven though! It was a lovely cat and mouse game between the perpetrator and the detective.
4/5


r/IndiansRead • • 1d ago

Suggest Me Im going to start reading it's the first non academic book that I'm buying what's the difference between these two

Post image
31 Upvotes

.


r/IndiansRead • • 1d ago

Suggest Me To all the hindi book lovers, Looking for a good hindi book community ?

7 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I am a hindi book reader from jaipur. I was looking for a hindi book community but couldn't find any active ones here. I would love to find new peoples to talk to about Hindi books and share my thoughts and opinion.

Lemme know if anyone has any such community in mind or feel free to DM to form a small community ourselves...


r/IndiansRead • • 1d ago

Discussion Need Sahitya varshiki pdf

3 Upvotes

Hi guys
I am looking for India today’s Sahitya varshiki magazine
If someone has the pdf please share with me.
Thank you


r/IndiansRead • • 2d ago

My collection How's it

Post image
66 Upvotes

Suggest more


r/IndiansRead • • 2d ago Heartwarming Bravo

Discussion Let People Read. It's Really Not That Deep

90 Upvotes

First of all, READING IS READING. It doesn't matter what someone chooses to read. Whether it's Fifty Shades of Grey, War and Peace, a fantasy novel, a romance book, or some Wattpad smut, you don't get to look down on people for their reading choices. Judging someone's intelligence, taste, or worth based on the books they read is nothing but having a superiority complex

I own The Count of Monte Cristo, books by Dostoyevsky, and Dan Brown because my sisters read them back in the early 2010s. So are you telling me that, back then, when social media wasn't as popular, her reading these famous authors wasn't performative, but someone reading them today automatically is? How does that even make sense?

If someone reads Colleen Hoover, let them. If someone reads Dostoyevsky, let them. If someone reads nothing but romance novels, LET THEM. People read for different reasons. Some read to escape reality, some for entertainment, some to learn, some to challenge themselves, and some simply because they enjoy a good story. None of these reasons is more legitimate than the other.

Also, are we seriously going to pretend that reading a popular or classic book automatically makes someone performative? THESE BOOKS ARE FAMOUS FOR A REASON. THE COUNT OF MONTE CRISTO, DOSTOEVSKY'S WORKS, AND COUNTLESS OTHER CLASSICS HAVE SURVIVED GENERATIONS.

And even if someone DOES pick up a book because it's trending, so what? Maybe they saw it on BookTok. Maybe their friends recommended it. Maybe they liked the cover. Maybe they wanted to be part of a conversation. That's how people discover books EVEN IN THE OLDER TIMES.

WE SHOULD BE ENCOURAGING PEOPLE TO READ MORE, NOT MAKING THEM FEEL EMBARRASSED ABOUT WHAT THEY READ


r/IndiansRead • • 3d ago Bravo

Discussion Am I a slow reader?

Post image
104 Upvotes

I've devoured books. Dostoevsky. I love his way of writing and the complexity of characters, their internal turmoil. It's too relatable and makes me feel less lonely. However, I can't read more than 10 pages in a day. Sometimes I get tired at just 5. My reading progress feels too slow when I read dostoevsky. Every page contains at least 5-6 words that I don't know and trust me I've learned vocabulary for competitive exams and I've read so many books and watched so many films n shows. But, dostoevsky you make me feel a little dumb n slow.


r/IndiansRead • • 3d ago

Review ⏮️🕉️ITIHASA - History of Hindu Mythology: Devdutt Pattanaik {Evolution of Hinduism} Review

Thumbnail
gallery
179 Upvotes

Phew! What an exhilarating journey this was!! Tired me out this one, in a good way though :) 

Long review incoming...

Premise:

What is Hinduism? Which ideas have contributed to it ? And do we know all of them? Which do we prioritize more? Which ones do we ignore? What can we learn from each one?

This is Devdutt's most comprehensive book so far - as he attempts to tell the story of Hinduism by integrating history, geography, archaeology, DNA Studies, literary analysis, temple art, pilgrim routes, trade routes, and of course - MYTHS (stories, symbols and rituals of a culture).  

Book is full of Devdutt's illustrations, timelines, maps etc. Some I've shared above 👆

Important Caveats:

  • Itihasa here should be read as "evolution of deep, spiritual concepts throughout history, aided by current knowledge, subject to change". So when author presents "Itihasa of Indra/Prajapati/Mangala-Mari" - I read it as a historical/psychological/anthropological evolution of the idea. Not seeing it as strictly spiritual or religious is crucial, for that's a matter of faith - immeasurable for outsiders or skeptics like me. 
  • DNA studies, biogeography, history, linguistics, archaeology, textual interpretations etc - given what we have now, what is the most coherent picture possible to explain the beliefs core to Hinduism? Their origins and their evolution? That's what this speculative book tries to present. 
  • Not prescriptive, only descriptive and speculative. That's the Disclaimer this book begins with.
  • It may difficult to read for those who believe in the eternal timeless static nature of the Hindu Gods (Brahma, Vishnu, Shiva for example), or those who prefer OoI to AMT, or the Vedas to be Apaurusheya. If however, you're interested in the evolution of such concepts along with historical changes in Indian society (shaped by migrations, geography, trade, invasions etc) - it's really fascinating. 

Themes of the Book: 

Devdutt mentions 6 landmarks in Hinduism's evolution: 

1️⃣Bangles: Since IVC, bangles are a continuous tradition denoting Mangala/Shubh/Labh/auspiciousness in Hindu household, also celebrating female agency, fertility, beauty etc ; How it clashed with Patriarchal attitudes of Monastic/Vedic myths is discussed, as another Axis of Purity slowly overshadowed Axis of Auspiciousness; Mangai and Poth-raja, both come from Dravidian root words, both signify the primal myths (now subaltern) of the auspicious female and buffalo sacrifice. 

2️⃣Horses: All about The Vedas, The Aryan Migration routes; How Indra's character changed from Vedic Poetry to Prose to Philosophy to Puranas (and the pastoral nomadic Aryans to settled agri-communities) ; Story of Indra vs Virochana; How RV Prajapati evolved into Puranic Brahma, and many stories of Prajapati got later attributed to Vishnu (seems like Brahma+Vishnu=Prajapati in RV) ; Gayatri; 3 Realms of Vedas v/s Puranas; Pravargya Ritual, Maha-Vrata ritual

3️⃣Money: Lakshmi and Vishnu: 500BC mercantile class arose on backs of elephants, monastic orders and trade routes {2nd Urbanisation of India} ; How Wealth evolved (Go-lakshmi (cows) to Bhu-Lakshmi(land) to Coins (Shri-Lakshmi)); With urbanism comes pleasure, its troubles and solutions - hence rise of monasticsim (Buddhism, Jainism) - It's countered by the Hinduism's Fifth Veda, like Shiva-Parvati stories, and the Dharma-Shastras. Householders are prioritized over hermits. 

4️⃣Temples: Shiva-Uma: How Hinduism (thru stories) traveled South, mapping to 5 Tinais; Lakulesh; Skanda/Kartikeya/Murugan; Temple building spreads to SE Asia; Importance of Tantra; Uma:Nature/ Female agency; The 5th Veda goes viral!

5️⃣Mosques: 1000yo as Arab invasions occurred in India, Chola invade Buddhist Sinhala; How Ramayana evolved North-South as anti-monastic response, Ideal kingship model sees Ram as ideal king, dharma-upholder and against the Huns/Buddhists/Turks; regional retellings of Ramayana infused with Bhakti/Rasa of Tamil poetry (local, emotional rather than cosmic, intellectual); Rise of Hanuman + monastic orders like Nath-yogis ; Sharada: Goddess of Script-->Sword; Shift of God-Goddess Love to Deity-Devotee, from Tantra to Monastic Bhakti; Folk Ballads (Alha-Udal). 

6️⃣Passports: Krishna worship across Indian geography and classes; Effect of British definitions, Sufi influence (~monotheism); Bhakti+Patriotism; From Arya-vrata to Bharat-Mata: invention of a nation-state-Goddess; Hemadri's Standardization; Bali's PHD is a case of study of Hinduism-->monotheism; Modern Marble temples.

7️⃣ Conclusion: Devdutt reaches a truly beautiful conclusion: Only in India, do we see the idea of Rebirth applied so diversely - to accommodate multiple conflicting ideas and peoples - that's what makes Hinduism a 5000yo continuous culture. The West eradicates the Old, the East controls centrally.

These 6 challenges shaped Hinduism, its tensions and solutions : Native Mangla-Mari Wild/Mild Goddess + Asura-Deva Aryan conflict + Monastic Hermit vs Householder conflict + Conjugal-Pair Temple + Tantric Worship + Formless vs Form (Mosque) + Bharat-Mata (colonial). 

What I didn't like: 

Mostly these gripes are really minor - some I need to fact-check later, some ideas just seem far-fetched to me.

  • Baghor Stone --> Yantra/sacred geometry today...Idk. Some basic shapes are so universal, it seems like an overstretch to say they hold the same meaning across 5000+ years. Same with the seals of a person holding/separating 2 animals - is it depicting peacemaking or hunting? 
  • The sheer number of rituals, stories, symbols, God/goddesses etc can be used to verify/reject any idea it feels like... Example - practice of drawing Kollams, or bangle wearing - how old is it? Is it continuous since IVC? With same intended meaning?
  • Some critics point out the creative but etymologically wrong interpretations of certain basic Sanskrit terms (Brahman /= expanding manas; para-atma /= other etc).  Brahman = expanding mind and "the Other" instead of Subject-Object Duality are his most used interpretations generally. This book doesn't have much of them, but it's important to point out - it's a creative exercise.
  • I truly appreciate the myriad diagrams as an artist myself, but most are really too small for the details to notice. I guess eBook would be better medium for this one...
  • Devdutt may not have updated his own beliefs it seems sometimes (is Ephedra the Soma plant? Is it established for sure? Or his claim about lions being introduced to India 3kya only? It was an unproven theory till 2014-20, but now DNA evidence settles that Asiatic lions came to India much before (~10kya))
  • Pg 405 is Devdutt's fear and insecurity I guess - to say that "modern citizen is entrapped by their national identity." - Except pilgrimages, weren't people also bound to their lands earlier, sea-faring a caste taboo? "Things seem worse now", "old myths being erased in the name of equality,unity and justice" - isn't this also part of Itihasa? These are the rare instances where I feel Devdutt inserts his own judgements. Sometimes it feels as if Devdutt is simply bothered by erasure of certain rituals/myths (like Conjugal-Paired Gods worship, Vegetarianism being considered "purer" than non-veg;). Or maybe he's just pointing out the replacement/imposition/erasure of one myth by another, stemming from newer insecurities of the mind. Including his own! 
  • The book ends with Devdutt's recurrent message, that unlike Western myths, Hindu myth is about rebirths, eternal cycles of hierarchies with the implicit message about contentment. Hindu myths are descriptive, not prescriptive. But then the comment about 21st Left-Right divide being irrational and purely Western myth based - seems far-fetched to me (rationally pointing out unfairness/corruption/reform for better society can't be simply seen as Utopian Abrahimic Myth!)

Some recurrent themes/stuff I loved: 

  • Matter and Spirit, Nature and Moksha. Cost of Consumption being contemplated through various subaltern and Vedic ways. Modern secular rational people often ignore these ideas - I'd have to agree. 
  • I really liked the "Itihasa of" timelines.
  • Possible Origins of the Caste system
  • Further Reading lists are ... very informative. I recognize some names, but am eager to read more of them. I've shared some of them above 👆
  • Had no idea ammonite fossils are considered Vishnu's manifestations! Or the Banalingas of Narmada as Shiva's manifestations. I did read about dinosaur eggs being worshipped in MP,  in Pranay Lal's Indica. India truly is, spiritually turbocharged. 
  • 2000yo Tamil Gods v.different from Vedic Gods - Ceyon, Mayon, Vendon, Kadalon, Kotravai. (I'd only heard of the last). Each mapped to the KMMNP landscape of Sangam poetry! Really fascinating. 
  • Predator-Prey, Householder-Hermit, Merging/Splitting of Gods, Axis of Purity > Axis of Auspiciousness; Wild/Mild Nature of Goddess - these are really fascinating ideas to think about.
  • Smarta school motto - "Shakta on inside, Shaiva outside, Vaishnav publicly" - very Smart indeed
  • Broadly speaking, how Hinduism was informed by Subaltern Mother Goddess+Nature worshippers, Vedic Mantras, Monastic ideas, Tantric Temples + Puranas, Bhakti and Monotheism. 
  • Hemadri's Dharmashastra Standardization I wish to study ... How much did it influence Hinduism?! 
  • Bar-headed goose might be the original hamsa, which travelled long distances from Central Asia. 19th.c. art used instead the European white swan as hamsa. 
  • Gayatri's Itihasa was amazing. Did you know about Gayatri Ramayana? Each syllable of this Gayatri Mantra stands for the 24000 shlokas of Valmiki Ramayana! An amazing mnemonic?! (I don't actually believe Gayatri Mantra in RV presupposed VR, but whoever came up with this mnemonic, was indeed a genius.)

Conclusion:

Without a doubt - my favorite book from Devdutt. It condenses so much knowledge in simple terms... It's hard to describe. Individual strands which I'd read, disorganized, come together in this one book (Peggy Mohan, Tony Joseph, David Reich, GN Devy, Karen Armstrong, Rianne Eisler etc). His recent books have been more history than religions/myths - which are really fun - Ahimsa (about IVC), Bahubali (Jainism).

For a mythology/Philosophy/history/psychology/anthropology novice like me, this was just awesome - a treasure-trove of ideas. And hopefully for anyone who's curious enough! Highly recommended. Even if one doesn't wish to rationalize matters of faith, one can read this work as speculative historical/mytho-fiction. It's speculative, but I think it's a good framework atleast to understand the various tributaries. Many wisdoms we choose to ignore. 

I read a comment somewhere, regarding this problem of interpretation of texts - "If it's proven right, it was always true - if not, it's a metaphor!" There's some truth to it. There's a lot of creative liberty taken here - imposing later ideas onto earlier ones - to present a coherent universal mythological/psychological landscape.

I'd highly recommend this book for its illustrations and diagrams. Very informative. Will help in conceptual clarity regarding Indian thought, geography, evolution, timelines etc. You can fact check them later. I for one, truly enjoy Devdutt's visual simplifications. If you like world mythology, are curious and open to some reasonable speculations, I would recommend to give this a try.

Read it as mytho-fiction if need be, but it's damn enjoyable. 

Rating: 12/12 (For all 2x6 Chapters)

I learnt a lot. Taking everything still with a grain of salt.

{Some things are bound to be proven wrong with future research, DNA findings etc. But like I said, for a broad framework of Hindu beliefs, this is really good}  

{Going forward, I really wish Devdutt writes about other mythologies too - Chinese, Japanese, Egyptian, African, American etc} 


r/IndiansRead • • 3d ago

Review 20 Years over a Thousand Miles: A Review of Helene Hanff's 84, Charing Cross Road (5/5 ⭐)

Post image
14 Upvotes

If you happen to pass by 84 Charing Cross Road, kiss it for me?

Read this short book over the weekend and would recommend everyone to pick it up if they want a warm, cozy time spent with books.

It is a collection of letters sent over twenty years establishing a correspondence between a New York writer, Helene Hanff and a bookstore in London at 84, Charing Cross Road. The writer is a woman in her old age where she sends letters to this “antiquarian" bookshop in London in order to get some books for her shelf. She is a hardcore re-reader of books and thus is very particular about the copies that she wishes to have. The bookstore from London is also very particular about sending her first copies of famous books including all the classic writers beginning from Chaucer till the mid 20th century.

The letters are sent in the mid 20th century, thus establishing the air of the USA and England as just coming out of the Second World War. This presents a significant cultural setting of correspondence. We see the cultural differences of both the countries where one was ruled in one sense by the other and the other one is suffering the loss of finances because of the war. The correspondence starts with a professional tone where the old woman who is a writer and has a knack for reading, asks for particular copies to keep in her shelf. But eventually both the parties establish a close personal contact. What's interesting to note is that on one hand the woman is a single person sending the letters. However, on the other side of this correspondence is a group of people working in the bookstore.

The letter is almost always referred to a single man at the bookstore (until it isn't). However, since everyone is reading it, a connection is established between both the parties. The people at the bookstore develop companionship with the woman on the other side of this letter exchanging feats. Eventually, we see them exchanging gifts with one another, wishing each other on Christmas, sharing about their personal lives while discussing books in almost every single letter. The woman shares her professional life, the projects that she has been getting, the stories that she has been planning to write, and the large money that is being offered to her as a writer of shows and television commercials and other things. The bookstore people share about their daily life, about each other, their personal life, family, children going to school, growing up, becoming teenagers and eventually getting married.

By the time we reach the end of this book, the last letter is a beautiful hit on the idea that companionship transcends age, factors of age, distance, region, culture. And sometimes shared interests are what brings people close. However, as time progresses, this shared interest might also whiff off. But the very idea of having a correspondence and companionship holds together two people sharing about each other's life.

There are so many things that left me with a warm smile while reading this one book. Unfortunately, if I jot it all down here it might just become a spoiler. But since it is a review, I will choose to speak at least about one of those, which is the beauty with which time passes. The people working in the bookstore get married, have children, see their children getting married and have grandchildren. All this is saved in the letters that they are sharing once in a while with the person sitting thousands of miles away from them. All this while the connection that they feel with the books, second-hand copies, first prints of famous titles never leaves the site and the priority of discussion.

What's amazing is that it's a real story!! And the letters were actually exchanged between the two parties, which leaves you not just with a warm feeling but a feeling of hope that writing letters might actually create something much better than what we have been creating over instant messaging services.

(5/5 ⭐)


r/IndiansRead • • 3d ago

Suggest Me I want to explore more gerne

6 Upvotes

Till now I have read

Adventures of Sherlock holmes

The hound of baskervilles

And then there were none

Animal farm

1984

Treasure island

The call of the wild

the art of war (don't suggest anything like this)

Astrophysics for people in hurry

Crime and punishement

Meditations

The gay science

I wanted to explore more gerne all through i like mystry and philosophy

I need something fresh

+ I am not into romance

I can go with any gerne if it's a good book but if u ask me I would like to read fantacy book next


r/IndiansRead • • 3d ago

Discussion Why is that everyone is reading Dostoevsky, McFadden, Dan Brown etc. or titles like Silent Patient, Metamorphosis and so much hype over The Count of Monte Cristo?

Post image
63 Upvotes

Same as the heading.

Is it because of the creators/influencers on social media? It is definitely not because all of them are good for example silent patient, all the reviews that I read about it was that it was bad and misogynistic. I enjoyed it though. But seeings mixed reviews, there shouldn't be this much craze over these books, so what is the exact reason this is happening? I am a beginner reader so I fell into the trap too and bought C&P but the english was really hard for me in it. Read around 100 pages and now am building my reading skills so that I could enjoy while reading and not keep looking in the dictionary after every 10 words.

Edit: got my answer thank you. Now I'll be reading The Count of Monte Cristo.


r/IndiansRead • • 2d ago

Suggest Me hey suggest me life lesson books?

0 Upvotes