Apparently I’m collecting shady game industry horror stories now. Last week I wrote about a publisher who contacted us, wanting 55% of our revenue in exchange for essentially nothing (post linked here). This time I have the pleasure of telling you about a vibe-coded marketing scam that tried to sell us stuff using a portfolio full of games as proof of their previous successes. Our game was one of them, despite us never having worked with them.
So what exactly happened…
A couple of days ago, someone joined our public Discord and said they do game marketing. I told them we're good. We've already got someone helping us with marketing, things have been going great, and we don't need any additional services.
They sent me their website anyway, which they said also included their portfolio. Even though I did not care in the slightest, out of boredom I went and checked it out anyway.
And right there under "Portfolio & Campaign Proof" was our game, PINBOMB.
They had taken information from a Reddit post I made about our Steam numbers and were using the image and information from that post as an example of their marketing work. If it wasn’t apparent by now, I had never worked with this person. Ever.
I told them to remove PINBOMB from their website, and what followed was them blocking me on Discord.
At this point I got a little angry. Our game was being used as a tool to scam people. So I decided to start a war.
Our game was not the only one on their website. There were quite a few others under the same "Portfolio & Campaign Proof" section, and I had a hunch this marketing agency had never worked with any of them either. This agency apparently crawls Reddit, looks for posts where developers have had some sort of marketing success, reskins them a little, and uses them on their own website as proof of results they supposedly helped achieve. I contacted most of the developers, and my suspicion turned out to be correct, none of them had worked with the agency.
I got to work. I contacted the scam agency’s hosting provider’s fraud team. I found that the agency had another website, so I contacted that provider’s fraud team too. I also found that they provide services on Fiverr, so I reported them there. Then I told all of the developers on their portfolio page what I had found and suggested they do the same.
Since I was blocked on Discord, I contacted them through Fiverr. This time I told them I would take the matter further if they did not comply with my request to delete not only my infringing content, but everyone else’s false portfolio pieces as well.
Then I started getting a boatload of excuses. “I’m sorry, it was not intentional” and the likes.
A few excuses later they removed my section of the portfolio entirely, but I again told them that this wasn’t only about me. Every false testimonial and portfolio piece had to go.
Finally, after a few days of this, I got a message saying they had deleted the website entirely.
War… won?
Well... Eh... The sad fact is that we're a tiny indie game and I already get multiple people trying to sell us questionable marketing stuff every day. These last two stories I've posted here are just the ones that were outrageous enough to almost be funny. I genuinely can't imagine what the inbox of a game with 50k or 100k wishlists looks like.
And while I’m happy about this small win, I’m quite sure the same guy can just sprout another vibe-coded webpage doing the exact same thing tomorrow.
The page was hilariously bad, by the way. It still had these huge yellow warning boxes from whatever AI tool they used telling them that they should NOT claim to deliver results they couldn't actually prove they could deliver. You can see one on the right side of the image above.
I'm curious how common this is for everyone else. How many marketing / publishing / "promotion" / straight-up scam messages do you get? And has anyone actually found a good way to manage it or get less of this stuff?
Especially when your studio's / game's community Discord is public and anyone can just find the dev team’s usernames and start DMing them.
TL;DR: A marketing agency tried to sell us marketing services, then sent me their vibe-coded website as proof that they knew what they were doing. On that website, our game, PINBOMB, was listed as one of their previous marketing successes, complete with Steam numbers and an image taken from one of my Reddit posts. We had never worked with them. Ever. I contacted the other developers they were using as portfolio pieces, and everyone who replied said they had never worked with them either. We reported the websites and their Fiverr account, and after a few days the entire website was deleted.
Here’s our Steam page for convenience:
https://store.steampowered.com/app/4869310/PINBOMB/
If anyone wants to follow PINBOMB development, we also post stuff on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/pinbomb_official/