r/Indigenous • u/celestialsexgoddess • 7h ago
Turtle Islanders: thoughts on American Thanksgiving?
First things first: I recognise that what is "Thanksgiving" to US settlers is a National Day of Mourning for the First Nations of Turtle Island. I send my love and solidarity to all Turtle Islanders here, and honour your fallen ancestors who have defended your land, lives and sovereignty. I support Land Back and stand with you in your ongoing fight for Indigenous liberation.
I'm Indigenous but not from Turtle Island, but I've spent some of my early childhood there and my younger brother is a US citizen by birth. We're from Southeast Asia, and through the international church my parents worship at, they have close American friends who celebrate Thanksgiving.
So I'm familiar with American Thanksgiving, but it's also always been a foreign holiday that's otherwise out of sight, out of mind. The only times you'd see me at a Thanksgiving party is if I happen to be home when my parents are hosting one for church, and this one white American friend of theirs would teach our international fellow churchgoers his colonial propaganda about "how Squanto the translator helped the pilgrims."
Since I haven't been to Turtle Island in decades, it's maybe only been five-ish years since I've been making more effort to learn the First Nations' perspective on what really happened around the First Thanksgiving. Last time my parents hosted Thanksgiving was 2 years ago. I remember feeling utterly disgusted by the propaganda, and regretted not saying anything to challenge it. I have no defence for that other than simply I wasn't ready.
Tonight I told my mother that I have other plans on the day she's hosting Thanksgiving. She looked hurt but wasn't going to stand in my way. I happened to come across a video about "What Really Happened" on that First Thanksgiving, so I put that on speaker and we talked about it. Unfortunately, what my mother got from all that was, "Those Puritan Pilgrims sure were evil," but ultimately gave me the "Not all Christians" talk.
I don't identify my Indigenous affiliation on Reddit, but through my mother, I am from a small Eastern Indonesian tribe that's not very well known even in Indonesia.
My historical knowledge is patchy, but I know that our island was an important Dutch trading post in the Spice Trade era. To neutralise the threats of land seizure and slavery, my ancestors converted to Christianity in the 18th or 19th century. On the one hand we became known as one of the most "educated" tribes in the region, including in writing our language dictionaries, translating the Bible, and producing a lot of teachers and government officials. On the other hand, we also became known as the coloniser's lapdog, so neighbouring tribes despised us and some of those historical tensions remain today.
My mum doesn't quite live up to my ideals of the attuned Indigenous matriarch. Rather, she's a fragile product of centuries of erasure and selling out as a survival strategy. Although Indonesia eventually dismantled Dutch colonialism and sent them back to where they came from, Indonesia also reinvented the empire on steroids and made sure to keep our people small and invisible.
So Mum turned to Christianity and capitalism to compensate for all the things she's lost Indigenous-wise, and learned to align herself with empire. Where empire comes in layers of hierarchy, America is the most superior among them all. Why Mum loves Thanksgiving is a manifestation of that programming. Which is why despite her own Indigineity, she can't seem to relate to the Wampanoag's perspective of the story, and can't see past the coloniser's lens. I'm the generation under her that's striving to undo the colonial damage and reclaim what colonialism tried to take away from us.
And then there's the psychology of how it's human nature to care more about belonging to a group they align with than about coming to terms with factual truths that rock the boat and risk no longer being welcome in that group. Which is why Mum gets defensive about Thanksgiving and tries to gaslight me about "building your own empire."
As I mentioned, I likely won't join the Thanksgiving party my parents are hosting, and have better things to do than challenging an old white man jerking off to his colonial wet dreams. But if my life were a TV show, American Thanksgiving will likely be this recurring extra for many seasons to come due to the showrunner's creative decisions that I don't really have control over. And when this recurring extra just happens to make an appearance on my turn to direct a proverbial episode, I'll want to be able to put on my director's pants, teach this wayward character a lesson, and let the truth take centre stage.
With that, I have some open ended questions for Turtle Islanders: What Indigenous perspectives do non-Turtle Islanders need to know about American Thanksgiving? What are some good Indigenous sources to learn about these perspectives? And what are some questions I should be asking to challenge settler colonial narratives of American Thanksgiving?
While I'm someone who doesn't hesitate to burn bridges as a last resort, I might also appreciate some tips on how to school white folks about their colonial delulu without causing more drama or fracture than necessary.
Thank you for staying with my post, and sharing your perspectives with an Indigenous woman from another corner of the world. May your ancestors rest in peace and power, and our collective remembrance empower new energy to dismantle colonialism and uphold our peoples' sovereignty.