r/Intactivists • • 16h ago

All the Medical Reasons for Circumcision Are Reverse Engineered

43 Upvotes

What frustrates me about the American circumcision debate is how rarely people question why the practice became widespread in the first place.

Outside Jewish communities, circumcision wasn’t historically widespread in America. It was popularized through a deeply paternalistic medical establishment, the same medical culture that gave us twilight sleep during childbirth, routine separation of newborns from their mothers, and eventually the husband stitch. This was also an era when respected physicians promoted racist theories linking race and intelligence.

We’ve spent generations rejecting the assumptions and practices of that era, yet circumcision somehow gets a pass.

The studies people cite today to justify circumcision didn’t even exist when the practice became widespread.

The procedure was already entrenched in American medicine long before the modern evidence used to defend it.

Instead of questioning why we began routinely removing healthy genital tissue from newborns, we’ve spent decades finding new reasons to continue doing it.

The practice came first. The modern justifications came later.

And somehow, the burden of proof has been reversed. People are expected to defend leaving their children intact, while those advocating an irreversible procedure on someone who cannot consent point to potential medical benefits as though that establishes their authority to perform it.


r/Intactivists • • 13h ago

Has circumcision fallen below 50% in the US? Georganne Chapin's and Martin Novoa's thoughts

16 Upvotes

Bit of a downer topic and I'm sure it's discussed to death but let's talk rates. A 2025 paper claimed the rate of infant circumcision has now fallen under 50% in the USA. A 4.8% decrease over ten years, from 54.1% to 49.3%. Is that promising? Some people say we should actually be sceptical.

Two talks I'm summarising:
Georganne Chapin (Intact America, ARC) at 17:20
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=exH4VRky0sU&t=1040s

Martin Novoa, JD, MBA at 21:10
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q85XbzvaTYo&t=1270s

MGC: male genital cutting

Alright. So why should we question this?

1. Chapin and Novoa remind us to be sceptical of the source. Johns Hopkins and the CDC promote MGC both in the USA and in Africa, and have a history of misrepresenting MGC rates. In 2010 the CDC once proclaimed rates had hit an unbelievable 34%. Intactivists contacted the CDC and they admitted it was false and they retracted the number. This current figure is from Johns Hopkins, and Aaron Tobian, who is a prolific promoter of MGC.

(See further below on why they would lie.)

2. Chapin and Novoa criticise the methodology.
• The paper's circumcision figures are based on voluntary survey data of inpatient infant circumcision. This means during birth period, surveyed at time of hospital discharge. i.e. usually around three days.
• Voluntary=people can refuse.
• Ignores circumcisions that take place when you leave the hospital.
• Anecdotally, many more parents now cut their sons outside the hospital in pediatrician offices, community clinics, or as hospital outpatients at later dates (after discharge). Originally it was always done in the hospital directly at birth.
• So the drop in inpatient hospital circumcision rate might actually be reflecting the shift in location of circumcisions and of policies, and not the rate.
• 50% is likely understating the true rate of infant MGC. The paper itself recognises this.

==//==

Intactivist opinions: Novoa reports that an activist bought the HHS data of all hospital circumcisons (in and outpatient) in the US. He claims the infant circumcision rate is around 72%. I'm not sure of the specifics though. And also this wouldn't account for non-hospital circumcision like in clinics? The data aren't public, but safe to say, people who know more than me think it's substantially higher than reported.

So is the rate decreasing?

States re-funding MGC on medicaid:
Since around the 2012 AAP statement, states have been re-funding MGC. Colorado. North Carolina, with their HIV-exemption loophole. South Carolina and Florida apparently by privatized medicaid partners. Since more states are funding MGC, I wonder if this is a leading indicator of increasing rates.

Why aren't they lower where we expect?
Novoa says states that defund medicaid MGC are still funding and cutting anyway by coding it differently. Think California, Washington, Oregon, Nevada, etc. Novoa mentions that some hospitals may even put up signs that call for mis-coding, an intentional act of fraud.

Why would researchers lie about rates being lower than they are? Chapin says one reason is to create public health panic that causes more interest and funding in infant MGC. Ex. 2012 paper by Senator-Elect Dr Annie L. Andrews: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1155/2012/540295
The fact that South Carolina previously defunded MGC is presented as a public health crisis. They're worried about rising healthcare costs if more boys are left intact, the rising HIV, HPV, cervical cancer, vaginosis, etc.

Does it matter for us? I think we should be cautious. If Chapin and Novoa are right then we could lose urgency and mistakenly believe we're doing more than we are. I've also seen people use this decreasing figure to dismiss us: "Hey, circumcision's dying out on its own so no need to give it focus!" It probably isn't going away without attention.

To conclude, Chapin and Novoa strongly believe we shouldn't trust the published numbers. Both them and the authors of the paper say the sub 50% rate doesn't capture all the circumcisions in the USA. Novoa says they could be as high as 70%. We have no reliable way to count all circumcions and we probably don't know if rates are decreasing, unchanged, or increasing.

My extra thought: Doctors don't stop preying on boys after early infancy, so infancy rates prob won't always match adult rates.

Anyway, hope I've accurately summarised the talks by Chapin and Novoa. I'm not an expert but I hope it's useful and adds some discussion.

...

The paper:

>Trends in Circumcision Among Newborn Males in the US; published 2025. Authored by: Ping Yang; Xianming Zhu; Eshan U. Patel; Thomas C. Quinn; Mary K. Grabowski; Aaron A. R. Tobian https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapediatrics/fullarticle/2838312


r/Intactivists • • 3h ago

How the midterm elections affect the circumcision issue

9 Upvotes

We should expect frequent government shutdowns this directly means that circumcision will be defunded in the upcoming months because Medicaid will be affected by government shutdowns

Why a government shutdown is likely going to happen

Opposition to the Iran War opposition to funding the Israeli government opposition to funding ice

Opposition to government subsidies for AI companies

This means that the upcoming political conflict between Trump and the Democratic Party is ultimately going to save baby boys from genital mutilation

Democrats winning the house and the senate is a net gain for baby boys who would have otherwise faced the knife but didn’t precisely because of the upcoming government shutdown that is going to happen