r/IntensiveCare • u/tzxx33 • 20h ago
Black Americans and “futile care”
DISCLAIMER: This is NOT a post to promote hatred, racism, bias, or any other form of ill will towards fellow humans. If that is what you are seeking, please get out of medicine and go elsewhere.
I come humbly and seeking to lessen my ignorance in the matter. I realize that this can be a very delicate subject matter and I really hope people do not take this the wrong way, I truly am only looking to learn and improve my understanding. And hopefully promote a insightful discussion.
For context; I am a white individual and have worked as a nurse in the ICU for several years and have generally been in an area with a fair amount of Hispanic and Black Americans, but otherwise largely white populations.
Over the years I have had a number of patients with quadriplegia, Trached/Pegged, and with extremely poor neurologic function. A disproportionate amount of these patients have been Black. Now this higher frequency may be from poorer health care in the Black community, but that is another conversation entirely.
What I have noticed as well is that these patients are almost always full codes and family is very disinterested in any kind of palliative care/hospice. Often they end up sent back to their SNF once the acute problem has been fixed or LTACH to continue their “lives”.
I am fully aware of my bias having worked in the ICU of seeking quality of life over quantity. Yet, that seems to rarely be the view in these instances and often we are so far apart that a fruitful conversation seems unattainable.
Has anyone else experienced this? And if so, where do you think this viewpoint comes from? And why does it seem more prominent in the Black community?
I have theorized that some of it comes from an understandable level of distrust in the medical system, based on America’s tarnished history. And a coworker felt it was more of a religious component and the beliefs often held by Black Christians.
Would love some insight, thanks!