r/JapanTravelTips • u/Himekat • 13h ago
META: Some clarifications on our AI-generated content rules and self-promotion rules
Lately, you may have noticed an uptick in a specific type of post in this subreddit: Japanese locals (or users purporting to be Japanese locals) who make a guide-like post that is clearly crafted by AI and often includes some sort of promotion at the end (like "Full disclosure: I made a PDF guide and it's available in my Reddit profile" or similar). They often also have names that point toward a business venture such as "KaoriGuidesYouThroughJapan" or "TohokuUnlocked" or similar.
While our moderation filters catch a lot of these posts, they don't catch all of them, so please continue to report anything that looks rule-breaking to you. I promise that we read all the reports and review all reported posts.
I also want to be clear on what's allowed vs. not allowed regarding AI-generated content:
- We welcome questions/advice/guides/trip reports/etc. from people people who write posts in English in their own words. We do not allow obvious AI-output posts, even if they are accurate/helpful.
- We welcome questions or advice from people who have used AI or other translation tools to translate their own words into English. We do not allow AI output that looks like you simply prompted AI to write you a post/question/guide and asked AI to put it in English for you.
- We welcome Japanese-speaking locals to post guides and advice in English as long as this content has been first written in their own words and then translated. We do not allow obvious AI output.
For our self-promotion rules:
- We do not allow self-promotion of any kind in posts or comments. It doesn't matter if you don't include a link, or you don't say the company/service name, or that the content is otherwise helpful. If the intent of a post is clearly to direct people to your profile/business/service/app/blog/etc., it's not allowed and you risk getting banned. This is very clearly stated in the rules and has been the subreddit's policy since the beginning, so "sorry, I didn't understand the rule properly" or "my post falls into a gray area" is not an excuse (I see these responses a lot in modmail when I remove a post).
- We also do not allow obvious "market research" from users asking vague questions in order to figure out some sort of product/service/guide they can provide to tourists. These posts are typically a little harder to spot, but they tend to sound very AI-like, start with some sort of obviously made-up story ("On my first trip to Japan, I got lost in Shinjuku Station for two hours while trying to find this cute dessert shop I read about! It was so confusing!"), and then end with some sort of call to action ("What has your experience been? What would make it easier for you to navigate big subway stations in Japan?").
We are a subreddit designed for tourists to help other tourists, and for residents/locals to help tourists if they so choose. We are not a subreddit for abusing the goodwill of our helpful contributors, for taking advantage of tourists trying to plan their trips, or for farming ideas/answers/information for businesses. Ultimately, we want posts here to be genuine, human, and free of ulterior motives.
It continues to be harder and harder to catch AI posts/comments and malicious content, but we are trying. Other travel subreddits are having similar issues with spammers, bots, and AI content—for instance, you can see /r/travel and other travel-related subreddit have been dealing with bot farms (and see here for the update) recently, which for a while were also affecting our subreddit.
Please report anything suspicious, and if you ever have further concerns that go beyond a report, feel free to send a message to /r/JapanTravelTips so that we see it in modmail. Thank you all for continuing to help each other and contribute to our community!