I've recently enrolled a jazz course. I already knew what modes are, but not much about why and how they're used. Now the teachers are beginning to mention modes, so I've asked them the question I've had in some corner of my mind for a long time:
"What is better about thinking in terms of modes, compared to thinking in terms of keys and chords?"
In other words, how is "this piece is in C, now I'm on F lydian and the next bar is G mixolydian" more useful for you than "this piece is in C, using the major scale, now I'm on the IV chord and the next bar is the V7 chord".
For now I've asked two different teachers -both of them accomplished jazz players- and they've both treated the question as a profound one and given me a long-winded, philosophical-sounding answer from which I did not get to understand anything specific (that could be on me, who knows, but I assure you I'm generally not someone who doesn't understand a well-made explanation). Also, they both seemed to use a bit of a straw man, like "if you're only playing on a scale you miss what's happening in the music".
What's your take on this? What do you find better about thinking of the changes in a piece in terms of modes, rather than keys and chords?