This actually happened a month ago but Iāve been finding that lately it keeps coming to mind and I canāt stop thinking about itā¦
I recently learned that someone I would consider a close friend has been viciously posting about the I/P conflict since Oct 7. I am not the type to check friends posts a lot and if I go on a social media page I am not on my newsfeed muchā¦so somehow I missed this over the years. I saw a comment of theirs about āoccupied Palestineā on a Jewish page while I was doomscrolling, which led me down the rabbit hole to going to their page and discovering over 80 posts starting on Oct 8 saying that āthey deserved itā all the way to celebrating and justifying the shooting in DC or saying he wants to see more of this about how Israelis are being chased on vacation for being zionists. Theyāve been fully trolling Jewish pages and commenting. Someone tried to tell me theyāre just passionate and sees what their algorithm shows them and reacts, which I believed, until I saw a comment on a page that had fine print saying that you cannot leave a comment unless youāve been following the page for over 24 hoursā¦so that shattered my delusion of it being less deliberate.
Unfortunately when I asked around to others who know them, I got a lot of āoh, we thought you knewā. This person apparently also thought I knew, because a mutual told me they were shocked and confused that I was upset by what they had been posting. Apparently this has also been an obsession of theirs since high school, and I am genuinely shook by how I never knew. We never talked about it, but apparently they were under the impression that we had an understanding, which feels antisemitic because having never talked about it, they only knew Iām Jewish, and probably assumed based off of that.
But thatās not the issueā¦that happened earlier in the year, and since then I stopped talking to them cold turkey. I havenāt spoken to them, invited them to anything, or addressed this directly. Based on what I read, theyāre beyond reasonable discussion and it felt safer to just step away.
The conflict Iām having has to do with a mutual of ours who said they would help try to communicate with the person about their behavior. Weāve all known each other since high school, well over a decade, and I wanted to get perspective from someone also close to them.
We met after I first saw the posts and our mutual told me that this person was ānot antisemitic, theyāre just antizionistā, and mention how they have Jewish friends, which cause my brain to short-circuit because I know I was one but the logic just shocked me. Apparently our mutual has other Jewish friends that theyāve gone to Free Palestine rallies with, so they appeared to think I was confused in the discussion. Specifically called me indoctrinated at one point and implied that Iām brainwashed to like Israelā¦which made my brain short-circuit even more. They took a class in college and let me know this conflict has been going on for a long time, but then when I brought significant historical references, they hadnāt heard of any of themā¦they like to travel but have never been to Israel, which felt so odd hearing someone tell me Iām brainwashed when I describe a place Iāve seen with my own eyes and my experience there, knowing theyāve never been.
The main thing that I canāt stop thinking about is the fact that this mutual recognized that the former friend had gone too far, and told me itās not on me and they would take it upon themself to hold the person accountable. But a month ago around midnight they forwarded me a Instagram post saying they were āgentlyā sharing it with me. I donāt use Instagram so they had to send me a screenshot because I couldnāt see it. It was a post about āstruggling with your Zionism?ā and a list of anti-Zionist book recommendations for Jews that are āconfusedā. They said theyāre excited to read themā¦I noticed Molly Crabappleās book listed, for example.
I waited to talk about it with them and made it clear that I did not appreciate that. I recommended Dara Horn if theyāre looking for books because it would be good to get multiple perspectives.
Since then we havenāt talked as muchā¦and I canāt stop thinking about it. Iām so unsettled and this experience between them and our former mutual has had me really questioning most of my friend circle. That being said, Iāve had a lot of support and many are more confused about how the mutual defended the person and simplified it down to them just being politically motivated. Iāve also had friends cut the person off after I shared the posts with them.
Honestly just wanted some other opinions from my people about itā¦itās been a rough year and I canāt decide if I think this is worth addressing more or just bury it down and try to stay off the topic with them so I donāt lose another friend.