Hey! So recently I bought my first water kefir grains, in dehydrated form. Said and done I rehydrated them by adding all of the grains to approx. 800 ml water and adding 35 grams sugar, and after a couple batches they were nice and hydrated again.
However, I've been having lots of issues with getting any carbonation at all.
Initially I used all of the grains (and unfortunately did not weigh them), washed with tap water, together with 35 grams of organic cane sugar and approx. 800 ml of water. I cover it and let it ferment for 48 hours, at which point it does look active, i.e if I lift the jar bubbles get released from the grains.
I then filled two 500 ml bottles, and add 100 ml of juice containing 8.8 grams sugar per 100 ml to each bottle. I then let this ferment for 48 hours.
However to my disappointment, there is no carbonation. I mean there is some but it's super super slight, not really worth mentioning.
I then moved on to the next ratios. This time I used 30 grams organic cane sugar together with 5 grams of blackstrap molasses, and again approx. 800 ml tap water. Same 1F and 2F time of 48 hour each, with the same disappointing lack of carbonation.
Now to the ratio I'm currently using, between two jars as the grains had grown enough to weigh >100 grams:
For jar 1:
30 grams organic cane sugar
5 grams blackstrap molasses
50 grams grains
Approx. 800 ml water
One lemon slice (new addition, did not add lemon slices to the previous attempts)
For jar 2:
35 grams of muscovado sugar
50 grams grains
Approx. 800 ml water
One lemon slice
Same disappointing result, 0 carbonation. I've tried both using 100 ml juice, as well as carbonation drops meant for beer, wine etc. I used 2 drops per bottle (each drop containing 2g sugar, the instructions mention using two drops per bottle but I might increase it to 4 just to see if it helps, and then to 6 if that doesn't help but at that point it'd be wasteful to use carbonation drops).
What's confusing is the fact it looks super active during 1F, i.e if I look at the jar currently it has tons of small foam on top from bubbles, with bubbles being formed by the water kefir.
Additionally I've been starting to measure the pH as well, and it's struggling to get acidic, at least during 1F. The latest batch had a pH of approx. 5, which is unusually high when I compare to kombucha brews which usually land around 4. The pH does drop to around 4 or so after 2F, so there's definitely activity going on but not much carbonation.
The flavor of the resulting water kefir is disappointing too, there's too much sweetness left, and there's not really any noteworthy nice flavors, at least not enough that I can remember them off the top of my head currently.
Any ideas what's wrong? I don't think the issue is the fact I'm using tap water, I use the same water for brewing kombucha which works perfect, nice delicious sour kombucha with perfect carbonation. So it's just the water kefir that's having carbonation issues.
I'll admit this has been somewhat disappointing as I've been super curious about water kefir for years, and so far I've been having much more success with kombucha, which I've been brewing on and off since around 2020. In fact, the kombucha has turned out so good I've scaled up the latest batch to a gallon jar, so I really badly want to get the water kefir tasting equally good.
Any help is greatly appreciated, I'm sure there's something obvious I'm missing. Currently I'm thinking maybe either the issue is 48 hours 1F being too long, or I'm using too little grains (which confuses me as people online seem to be using 50 grams grains too), but not sure.
Edit: Thank you all for the replies :)
The issue was indeed the amount of sugar, after I increased it to 50 grams sugar, it gave better carbonation now and the flavor is great, I tried using carbonation drops to make a neutral flavored soda and it's really unique and different compared to the kombucha!