i’m a 20yo cradle catholic born into a polish family who is potentially looking into converting to the lcms, but it is so hard to leave and decide what is the “right” faith. growing up, my faith has been rocky. throughout highschool, i turned away from christ into self destructive and selfish habits, and even turned to new age spirituality/pantheism for some time, you could almost say i was agnostic. i was still attending mass and i still got confirmed and i honestly did feel the presence of Jesus at that time, i just had the wrong idea for some time.
growing up, i went to public school and i have never really been involved in the faith. i feel our family was jsut a “go to church every sunday” family because that’s the way they were raised. i feel like i was also raised up to be scared of God and was told he would punish me, and that the devil was inside of me when i didn’t want to go to church. hearing these things as a small child rubbed me the wrong way and when i look back at it now it makes sense why i have such a confusing relationship with the church and the Lord. i also have ocd which makes this a very difficult decision since it latches onto this.
my boyfriend is part of the lcms, and his dad is a pastor. we didn’t necessarily start off the best in terms of having a godly relationship, but we both want to do better.
for a few months now, we have been arguing about theology. it has gotten to the point where we are basically broken up because we cannot agree, but we both still have hope that we can make this work and we want to try again.
first it was arguing about young earth creationism. when we first brought up the topic, i was 100% against yec and believed in an old earth but now i take the stance of it could have been any way, and ultimately God knows the answer. he is somewhat fine with my view, but he wants his kids to believe in what he believes, which i am somewhat concerned about as science becomes more advanced. for me, it is still extremely hard to believe in a young earth when there is a lot of scientific evidence pointing to an old earth, but ultimately i feel like this is not a topic that deserves as much attention.
we are also arguing about our other theological differences. growing up, i was never really super catholic. for example, my mom was against going to confession, and i honestly haven’t went in years either. (i was thinking about going sometime soon so i can receive the eucharist at mass) purgatory, confession, and the pope have been big topics that we somewhat disagree on.
i say somewhat disagree on because when we first started talking about our differences, i didn’t really have a solid stance on most of these things, but i jsut went with them because i am catholic. for example, i disagreed with the idea of purgatory, but now finding out that it is a catholic teaching i feel like i have to agree with it.
there are a lot of things i love about being catholic. i love going to mass, there is something so comfort in about it, especially when i feel alone at college. i love the truth the catholic church brings, and i love how it goes along with science and doesn’t deny it. i am a first generation daughter of polish immigrants, and it is also strongly tied to my culture and my identity.
essentially he wants to agree more on core beliefs such as purgatory and salvation which is valid, but i don’t know what to do. i almost feel like im being pressured to covert since he can come off a little strong at times. i love him a lot and our relationship is great besides this disagreement. please help !!