r/LanguageTechnology • • 7h ago

How Is Novelty Judged When Two Papers Have Overlapping Findings?

2 Upvotes

Consider this hypothetical scenario:

- August: Researcher A submits a paper to a journal.

- October 8: A uploads the paper to arXiv.

- October 18: Researcher B uploads a paper with substantially overlapping findings, already accepted at a workshop.

- Later: A's paper gets rejected, and they plan to resubmit to ICML, TMLR, or ARR in January.

Assume both groups worked independently, with different experimental designs but similar major findings.

My questions:

  1. Can A still claim novelty since their findings appeared on arXiv first?
  2. Would B's paper count as concurrent work, even when A resubmits months later?
  3. Do reviewers consider the original submission date, arXiv date, or acceptance date when judging novelty?
  4. Can A retain the overlapping findings as contributions, or would reviewers consider them no longer novel?
  5. How do ICML, TMLR, and ACL/ARR handle such cases officially versus in practice?

A broader concern: If the first public disclosure doesn't establish priority, isn't there a potential loophole?

With tools like Claude and Codex, someone could potentially reproduce an existing arXiv paper's findings within 1–2 months using different experimental designs and submit them elsewhere.

How would reviewers distinguish genuine independent discovery from research derived from an earlier preprint? What protects the original researcher's contribution?

I'd appreciate perspectives from experienced researchers, reviewers, and area chairs.