I'm a 34-year-old man who has never experienced a serious, mutually loving adult relationship. What makes this particularly painful is that I had numerous opportunities throughout my life. I wasn't necessarily unattractive, incapable of flirting or unsuccessful with women. Yet, somehow, everything went wrong.
My childhood and teenage years
There was a girl I had known since kindergarten. I always found her particularly beautiful, and although we eventually attended different schools, there was always something about her in the back of my mind.
Throughout my teenage years, several girls showed interest in me. I remember one girl even writing "Je t'aime" with a heart on my desk at school. However, I either failed to recognize their interest or ignored it because I was infatuated with another girl who was in my class from seventh grade until graduation.
Looking back, I regret not having been more sexually and romantically adventurous during those years. I might have developed the experience and confidence I desperately needed later.
When I was around 18 or 19, I started seeing the girl from my childhood more frequently again. I found her incredibly beautiful and desperately wanted to get closer to her.
However, several things prevented me from approaching her:
- I was sexually inexperienced and insecure about it. I felt intimidated by women who might have been more experienced than I was.
- I had recently been rejected by the girl from my class, which reinforced my insecurities.
- I had recently expressed feelings for that other girl and somehow felt that pursuing someone else so shortly afterwards would make those feelings seem insincere. I had some rather naive ideas about love and dating back then.
- I was planning to go to Australia in a few months and wondered whether starting a relationship before leaving would even make sense.
- Above all, I was terrified of being rejected by the one girl whose rejection would have mattered most to me. It would have reinforced my belief that I wasn't good enough for her.
In retrospect, I sometimes wonder whether pursuing the girl from my class was simply a way of avoiding the emotional risk of approaching the girl I wanted most. Perhaps she seemed like the safer option.
I overthought absolutely everything instead of simply allowing myself to get to know someone.
Today, none of those reasons seem sufficient to justify what I missed out on. But back then, they felt overwhelming.
The irony is that my silence and inaction weren't indications of how little I wanted her. They were indications of how much I wanted her.
I never approached her.
2012ā2014: The happiest years of my life
After school, I spent two years travelling around Australia. I became confident, spontaneous, adventurous and sexually experienced. I had numerous encounters with women and genuinely felt attractive and desirable.
I didn't consciously think about how to flirt or behave around women. I was simply happy, and everything came naturally.
I could tease women, make them laugh, flirt, initiate physical contact and create romantic or sexual tension without consciously thinking about any of it.
However, I also noticed that whenever I genuinely wanted something serious with a woman, rather than something casual, much of that confidence disappeared. Suddenly, I had something to lose.
While I was in Australia, the girl from my childhood met someone else. When I returned, she was already in a relationship.
By then, I had acquired much of the confidence and experience I wished I'd had when I was 19.
When I had the opportunity, I wasn't ready. When I was ready, the opportunity was gone.
2014ā2020: Betrayal and emotional deterioration
When I returned from Australia, I felt ready for a serious relationship. I met a woman who I perhaps hoped would fill the emotional void in my heart.
In retrospect, I sometimes wonder whether I was genuinely as much in love with her as I believed, or whether I was simply so desperate to finally experience love and a committed relationship that I attached enormous emotional significance to her.
Instead, I experienced what I can only describe as severe emotional manipulation, dishonesty and betrayal. Something similar happened with the same woman again approximately three years later.
I sometimes describe these experiences as emotional rape, metaphorically speaking, because of how profoundly violated I felt.
What devastated me wasn't rejection. I've been rejected plenty of times and can accept an honest rejection. What I couldn't cope with was being deliberately misled and having my feelings and trust played with.
I would have preferred an immediate, brutally honest rejection to any of what subsequently happened.
After the first experience, I met several attractive women who were genuinely interested in me, including women I had known from school. I even became intimate with some of them. However, I couldn't emotionally let them in.
I remember driving home after sleeping with one woman, hearing a song and suddenly crying because of what had happened to me previously. Something similar happened with another woman.
There were women who I might have been able to build a genuine relationship with had I met them under different emotional circumstances.
After the second betrayal, there was a period of approximately three years during which I barely pursued women. Sometimes, I even experienced panic attacks at the mere thought of meeting one.
I was ashamed of having allowed someone to hurt me so profoundly. I hated myself for having been so naive, for having trusted someone and for not having walked away sooner.
I promised myself that I would never let another woman do that to me again.
Unfortunately, in trying to protect myself from emotional pain, I also seem to have shut myself off from the possibility of experiencing love.
One of the things that still makes me incredibly angry is that I wasn't without romantic opportunities. Rather, by the time those opportunities presented themselves, I was often no longer emotionally capable of pursuing them.
2020: My last experience of falling in love
At 27, I met an incredibly beautiful woman from Colombia who was the first person in years to make me feel like my old self again.
Her physical appearance absolutely captivated me. Her face, her body, everything about her appearance. I hadn't experienced that degree of attraction in a very long time.
I was excited, hopeful and genuinely in love. I could even imagine having a family with her. She was the only woman who had ever come close to the girl from my childhood in terms of how strongly I was attracted to her.
For a brief period, I felt like I had regained my former self.
I knew even then that this might be my last opportunity to begin a meaningful relationship in my twenties.
Unfortunately, this experience also ended in what I experienced as dishonesty, manipulation and betrayal.
The heartbreak was accompanied by overwhelming anger and shame. After everything I had already experienced, I had allowed myself to become vulnerable again, only to be deeply hurt once more.
I didn't just lose another woman I wanted. I lost the renewed belief that my life could still turn out the way I had hoped.
Something changed in me after that.
My frustration with dating and romantic attraction
Another thing I've increasingly struggled with is the very nature of romantic attraction and dating.
When I was younger, I had a rather romantic and perhaps naive understanding of love. I believed that genuinely loving someone, having sincere intentions and caring deeply about them would somehow count for more than it actually does when it comes to creating attraction.
But just because you feel an extraordinary amount of love for someone doesn't mean that person will experience anything remotely similar towards you.
Your feelings alone cannot create reciprocity.
As a man, I often feel that dating requires me to perform a complicated balancing act:
- Be confident, but not arrogant.
- Show interest, but not too much.
- Be attentive, but not overly available.
- Be flirtatious and playful rather than overly serious.
- Tease a woman and create romantic tension.
- Take the initiative, including approaching her, arranging dates and initiating physical intimacy at the appropriate moment.
- Express desire without appearing desperate or needy.
- Maintain an appropriate balance between emotional availability and independence.
Sometimes, it even seems as though being slightly unavailable or indifferent is more conducive to attraction than openly expressing how much you like someone.
I'm not suggesting that women consciously demand manipulation or that every woman responds identically. But I find the apparent contradiction between being genuinely in love and having to carefully regulate the expression of those feelings incredibly frustrating.
It feels like walking a tightrope.
After dates, I've often found myself analysing everything I did. Should I have kissed her earlier? Should I have been more playful? Did I text her too much? Was I too reserved? Did I fail to initiate something at the right moment?
What makes this particularly frustrating is that I used to do many of these things naturally.
In Australia, I wasn't consciously following dating advice or executing some elaborate strategy. I was naturally playful, flirtatious and spontaneous because I was genuinely happy and emotionally unburdened.
Whenever I seriously wanted a woman, however, things became complicated.
And now, after years of negative experiences, I feel too emotionally exhausted and indifferent to participate in this whole process.
I don't want to manipulate someone into liking me. Nor do I want to constantly perform or feel as though my chances of being loved depend on my ability to behave correctly.
I understand that attraction and relationships require initiative, social skills and mutual effort. I simply wish that the process felt more natural and reciprocal.
Perhaps what I really want is to experience a relationship in which I don't constantly feel that I have to earn someone's affection through perfectly calibrated behavior.
Where I am today
I'm now 34. I have never had a serious adult relationship. I have never had a committed girlfriend with whom I've experienced both sexual and emotional intimacy.
I know what it feels like to be sexually desired, but I don't know what it feels like to be chosen, loved and accepted by a woman who genuinely wants to share her life with me.
Meanwhile, the girl from my childhood is still with the man she met while I was in Australia. They got married and had a child.
For years, somewhere in the back of my mind, I had hoped that their relationship might eventually end and that I would get another opportunity. Almost every relationship from that age that I knew of ended eventually. But theirs didn't.
Of all the relationships that could have ended, the one whose ending I secretly hoped for was the one that lasted.
Seeing a photograph of her with her child this year was devastating. It felt almost as though I was learning about the loss for the very first time.
Another man is living the life I would have loved to share with her. Neither of them has done anything wrong, but the circumstances feel like a particularly cruel twist of fate.
I still wonder whether she ever thought about me the way I thought about her. Whether she ever found me attractive. Whether she would have said yes if I had simply asked her out.
I will probably never know.
I'm aware that a relationship with her wouldn't necessarily have worked out. I'm also aware that I've never experienced the realities of being in a relationship with her.
But I never expected perfection. I would have loved to experience the beautiful moments, the mundane everyday life, the arguments, the difficulties and everything else that comes with sharing a life with someone.
I didn't just want to experience falling in love with her. I would have loved to spend my life beside her.
I regret not even trying. I feel as though I betrayed myself by allowing fear to prevent me from pursuing something I wanted so deeply.
What all of this has done to me psychologically
- I've become deeply distrustful of women and romantic relationships.
- I struggle to believe compliments about my appearance, even from women who have been physically attracted to me. My immediate reaction is often to assume that they're lying.
- I feel undesirable and increasingly unattractive despite evidence from my own past suggesting otherwise.
- I've lost much of my emotional curiosity, spontaneity and romantic excitement.
- I associate falling in love with vulnerability, humiliation and the possibility of betrayal.
- I find dating exhausting because it feels like a complicated balancing act in which I constantly have to behave correctly to maintain someone's attraction.
- I feel ashamed of my lack of relationship experience at my age.
- I feel increasingly bitter and resentful about the people who hurt me and the consequences their behavior had for my subsequent life.
- I struggle enormously with getting older and the opportunities that disappear with age.
- I have lost a considerable amount of my general enjoyment of life, motivation and sense of purpose.
When I see a beautiful woman nowadays, I often feel sadness rather than excitement. Something that once inspired hope and enthusiasm now reminds me of everything I've missed.
I also struggle with my age because I still find women in their early to mid-twenties particularly attractive, yet increasingly feel too old to approach them.
Seeing young couples can be incredibly painful because they remind me of the experiences I wanted to have at their age.
The women I truly wanted never became my partners, while I couldn't emotionally reciprocate the interest of many of the women who wanted me.
I've come to believe that I simply don't possess whatever it is that makes a woman genuinely fall in love with a man, even though I know rationally that I can be attractive, charming and desirable.
I've never been in a relationship with a woman I genuinely wanted. Casual sexual encounters don't compensate for that.
Sometimes, I feel as though if a happy relationship had ever been in the cards for me, it would have happened by now.
Grieving a life I never lived
Perhaps my biggest problem is that I'm not simply grieving individual women or missed relationships. I'm grieving an entire life that never materialized.
I wanted to fall in love in my early twenties. I wanted to grow older alongside someone, accumulate years of shared memories, get married and eventually have children.
I wanted to grow old with someone, not grow older trying to find someone.
Even if I met someone tomorrow, she couldn't give me back those years. And I think that's partly why I'm struggling to find motivation to move forward.
I also miss the person I used to be. I miss being happy, confident, adventurous, optimistic and excited about life. I miss looking at the future with anticipation rather than looking at the past with regret.
I sometimes feel as though I've already missed the best part of my life and am now simply drifting through the remainder of it.
Day in, day out, without much purpose, without much excitement and without anything that genuinely fills me with anticipation.
I understand rationally that my past doesn't necessarily determine my future, that not every woman is untrustworthy and that my emotional injuries may be responsible for many of the difficulties I experience today. But knowing these things intellectually hasn't changed how I feel emotionally.
I've spent years analysing my past. I understand many of the mistakes I made, the circumstances that influenced my decisions and the reasons why I became the person I am today.
I understand why I didn't approach the girl from my childhood. I understand why I became so attached to the women who subsequently hurt me. I understand why I became emotionally unavailable and why I now struggle to trust people.
But understanding it hasn't freed me from it.
If anything, understanding everything so clearly makes me desperately wish I could go back in time and do things differently.
Has anyone experienced something remotely similar? Has anyone recovered from years of romantic regret, betrayal, emotional numbness and grief over an unlived life?
How do you start enjoying the life you have when you are still grieving the life you wanted?