I'm 28M. My ex 23F and I were long distance from the start for about five months, roughly 3,000 km apart, seeing each other every four to six weeks.
The emotional side was great. We talked for hours and she told me more than once that I'd set a new standard for communication and thoughtfulness. She said she could see it working long term, that apart from the sex it would be perfect, and that she thinks it would work if it had the chance to grow.
The physical side never settled. Early on we had a couple of bad moments. One time my dick didn't stay hard and she reacted badly. Another time her own sexual insecurities came up and she got upset. After that I was nervous and held back, and she read that as me not wanting her. We never got to the point of having sex. The last time we saw each other was different. On the day she left we had a spontaneous sexual encounter, and she told me the pull was there in a way it maybe hadn't been before. We both said it gave us a lot of hope.
She told me she'd get anxious in the week before every visit because it felt like starting from week one again. Things would build over the trip, and then the distance would reset it.
A few weeks ago we had three trips planned over the following two months, including one with her family. She arranged a week for us alone at her place, booked a flight so she "couldn't change her mind", and told me that no matter what, we'd work it out. Then my work wouldn't approve the days. I offered to quit early and come anyway, and we agreed I'd come the week after. Around then her friends told her a relationship can't work without sex, and she agreed.
A few days later she raised ending it. Her reason was that the sexual pull wasn't there for her and she couldn't see it growing with the stop-start nature of long distance. In the same conversation she proposed trying again when, or if, she moves to my city, which she'd been planning for early next year.
Two weeks of back and forth followed. I tried hard to save it. I sent roses, organised a dinner night, and wrote her a proposal for how we could make it work. She told me she would have ended it without the proposal. Later she said the gestures were beautiful but she just wasn't feeling it, and that my trying to convince her was confusing when she'd asked for time. During that fortnight she also told me I had no sexual pull for her, commented on my hygiene, joked about me being out of work, and said in an argument that she didn't even like me that much. She agreed to my visit, but on a day-by-day "trial" basis. We argued on the phone the day before I was due to fly, and she cancelled. I sent a long angry message that I partly regret.
Some context. She's told me she cancelled on flights with two previous partners, so I wasn't the first. A psychologist in my family thinks the pattern is fear of abandonment, where she leaves before she can be left. When I repeated that to her, she said it wasn't fair, because her concern about the sex was real.
On our last call I told her I loved her. She said it could still work if we were in the same place, and that she'd probably be questioning her decision. Her final message said it was the right decision for her, that she hopes we speak again, and that it's up to me.
We're no contact because in initiated it, she’d prefer not. I still love her. My honest belief is that if we had met once more and the physical side went well, everything else would be fine, because that was her only real concern. And the fact that the last time we met we did have that sexual pull (in her own words) makes it hard to question why she wouldn’t try.
Has anyone been through something like this and had it work the second time around? I'd love to hear your stories, good or bad.
TL;DR: Five months long distance with a strong emotional connection. The physical side kept resetting between visits. She ended it but said it could still work if we're in the same city. Has that worked for anyone?