I have a planet X huntsman in an XL with a wb of 1257 and ett of 663 with a 35mm stem (65' ht 75' st). My day-ly driver is a gravely/road bike 1062wb 590ett with a 90mm stem (plus 105mm from stem center to roughly where i hold the hoods) (72' ht 73.5' st).
I was happy with the huntsman when i bought it but moved to the gravel bike predominantly since. I've just invested in new wheels (with a view to convert it to an e bike) but after a test ride it feels ridiculously short and cramped in the cockpit when it felt fine when i used it before.
I'm not hot on mtb, i rode observed trials for 17 years (where the bikes had absurd geo and leave me clueless with 'fit and ergonomics') and flirted with mtb briefly 10 years ago, but have been predominantly using road bikes for the last 5 years and found them comfortable and fine.
The planet x is a down country bike, which meant to me it would be a slacker xc geo that took big tires, but wasn't as slack and as burly as a hardcore ht but would afford me some confidence in demanding trails. Would a racier xc bike have felt more like 'home' having eaten road bikes for years. (My hope would be that it was a jack of all trades/winter tool that would be second fiddle to a full sus bike which was aligned to the type of off roading i enjoyed the most)
In theory its bigger and longer than my roady. (Unless i increase the headtube length with the stem and further extension from drop bars, then the reach is greater on my gravel bike) Is it intentional to improve handling to shorten the reach on my mtb?
I have an understanding that running a short stem to shorten the front end is preferable for aggressive riding. Should i consider owning longer stems for xc or 'long rides' and shorter stems for more aggressive and demanding rides, compromising comfort for performance?
Thanks for any input.