I’ve been waiting for GTA VI for a long time; probably since somewhere around the release of the Oppressor Mk II. Deluxe version pre-ordered, pre-loaded and now sitting on my console ready to go.
And yet, when I get home tonight, the first thing I’m going to do is play Madden. Why? Because I have a Jordyn Tyson breakout in our league of course. My immediate next thought was, how mentally ill am I to still be prioritizing a game (with no hesitation mind you) that does not deserve it.
I consider myself a washed gamer. I run a small Madden league, and if not for GTA now being out, it would essentially be a 1-game rotation for me.
And that’s what bothers me.
I love Madden. I love Franchise Mode. I love the camaraderie, the competition, the roster building, the development, and everything that goes into running an online league. I’ve put an absurd number of hours into franchise mode over the years. At some point, though, you have to wonder if you care more about the game than the studio putting it out, and when it comes to Madden, that answer is a resounding “yes”.
I think one of the most frustrating aspects of Madden right now is how little transparency there is surrounding the actual game.
Take Camp Counselor, for example. It was the best coaching ability in Madden 26. EA brought it back in Madden 27, but changed some of its functionality without fully communicating what was different. Some of what the ability actually does doesn’t even align with what its description suggests. Why are players having to figure these things out through their own testing? Why isn’t this information clearly communicated in the game? Bonus question: Why not leave it up to players to set how effective these abilities are?
The same goes for coaching abilities that promise an increased chance of something happening. Increased by how much? What are the actual odds? We’re making decisions about our teams and coaching staffs based on descriptions that often tell us very little about what we’re actually getting.
How about needing to leave the franchise and come back when you’re on the clock in the draft? That’s another fun feature that has survived multiple title updates. Maybe it was patched in the ‘97 update though, wouldn’t be the first time a change in the game didn’t make the patch notes.
Custom playbook organization remains unnecessarily frustrating. Breakouts have been mangled. Season goals have lost meaningful XP rewards. Franchise Mode received a contract negotiation minigame, which was a nice addition, but beyond that, where are the substantial improvements?
Too much of what we’re getting feels recycled, reskinned, or simply carried over, while some of the changes that actually affect the experience have been steps backward.
Are there any franchise updates planned this cycle? Any ability updates? QoL improvements? Anything?
I don’t expect Madden to reinvent itself every year. I understand the realities of an annual sports title. But I do expect the experience to evolve. I expect basic information about the mechanics to be available to players. I expect features that have been part of the game for years to be refined rather than continually compromised.
I’ve even found myself building external tools to track and manage things within our franchise that you’d think would have been standard features by now. There are countless other commissioners and franchise players that have done the same in their own way.
I say all that to say: I’m part of the problem. I’m still going to buy Madden next year. I’ll still spend hundreds of hours playing it. I’ll still invest time into my franchise and continue doing the things that make this game enjoyable. And that’s despite knowing that EA hasn’t necessarily earned another dollar from me, much less the thousands of hours I’ve already given this franchise over my lifetime.
I have met lifelong friends playing Madden. It’s hard to imagine my life without Madden in the periphery. I would argue that Madden has as loyal a fanbase as any game, even if it’s in a cult classic kind of way.
Madden has a community of people who genuinely love this game. People who spend countless hours building franchises, managing leagues, learning mechanics, developing players, and finding ways to make the experience better. That kind of investment should be something EA wants to cultivate, not something it can simply assume will always be there.
We’re not asking for anything unreasonable. We want meaningful improvements. We want transparency. We want communication about the mechanics we’re expected to understand and the changes that affect how we play. We want Franchise Mode to feel like a priority rather than an obligation. We don’t want cuckish “Don’t Delete” graphics when we’ve already obviously loaded into your game!
EA should be thankful I was indoctrinated as a kid and fell in love with this game young, because I’ll be tougher to alienate than most. I would imagine most people still loading this game up regularly are in a similar boat.
I’m still going to play Madden tonight. That’s probably not changing anytime soon. But I do think it’s time EA gave its players a reason to feel as good about their loyalty as the company seems to feel about having it.
tl;dr Jordyn Tyson’s future takes precedent over GTA release. Stop taking that for granted, EA.
Thank you for reading if you made it this far.