The only person Franzese actually testified against was Norby Walters, regarding Mafia connections in the music industry. Walters' conviction was eventually overturned.
The rest of Franzese's cooperation was reportedly focused on his own criminal activities. He never gave prosecutors information about what other Colombo family members were doing and refused to testify against his former associates.
He could have potentially helped the government put a lot of his former associates away, but he chose not to. He also did his time in prison and never went into witness protection.
Compare that to Sammy Gravano, who testified against dozens of former associates and helped put around 50 mobsters behind bars.
I'm not saying Franzese was innocent or that he didn't cooperate with the government. He clearly did. But there's a pretty big difference between cooperating on your own crimes and turning on your entire crime family.
What's funny is seeing guys like Joey Merlino constantly going after Franzese when, compared to actual Mafia informants, his cooperation seems pretty limited. By Merlino's own definition, Franzese followed the code: he never hurt anybody through his cooperation. He just used the government to his own advantage.
Merlino is a bit of a hypocrite here, too. He says it's acceptable to plead out, but back in the day, taking a plea deal was often viewed as being just as bad as being a rat. And when he was facing his RICO cases, he admitted in court that he was part of the Mafia, which is another thing that could get you labeled a rat back in the day.
I wish Merlino would actually explain on his podcast who Franzese supposedly hurt through his cooperation with the government. Who did he put away? Who did he testify against besides Walters?
If he's going to keep calling him a rat, I'd like to hear some specifics.