A machine can transfer its existing value into what it produces and also contribute to creating new value. I think Marx’s refusal to allow the second possibility puts too much weight on labour being the exclusive source of value.
The distinction matters. Marx recognises that machines increase output and make workers more productive. His further claim is that machinery only transfers its existing value, while living labour creates the new value. That is the claim I disagree with.
Suppose workers and a mill produce something that sells for enough to cover materials, energy, wages and the mill’s wear, with a surplus left over. Why must that entire surplus be attributed to labour? The workers helped produce it. So did the mill. Knowing that workers originally built the mill does not, by itself, settle what the mill can contribute once it exists.
The existence of a surplus alone does not identify its cause. But neither does calling the machine “past labour” establish that its own contribution to new value must be zero.
Here is why this matters for the rate of profit.
In Marx’s simplified account:
r = s / (c + v)
Here:
- c = capital advanced in machinery, materials and other means of production.
- v = capital advanced for wages.
- s = surplus value.
- r = rate of profit.
The denominator is the capital advanced, including the machinery’s value, rather than just the depreciation charged during the period. Keep the period and turnover assumptions consistent throughout.
Write a = s/v and x = c/v. Then:
r = a / (1 + x)
Holding a fixed, increasing x lowers r. More capital stands beneath the same surplus per unit of wage capital.
Marx also discusses counteracting influences, including an increase in the rate of surplus value and cheaper means of production. So the claim is a tendency, not that every new machine must lower every firm’s profit rate.
Now allow both labour and capital to contribute to net surplus:
s = s_L + s_C
s_L = a × v
s_C = b × c
Here a is the net surplus attributed to labour per unit of wage capital, and b is the net surplus attributed to capital per unit of capital advanced. These are net contributions: wages and the replacement of used-up inputs have already been accounted for. We are not counting the machine’s original value twice.
Then:
r = (a × v + b × c) / (v + c)
Dividing by v gives:
r = (a + b × x) / (1 + x)
Holding a and b fixed:
dr/dx = (b - a) / (1 + x)^2
That gives three possibilities:
- If b < a, increasing the capital-to-wage ratio lowers the profit rate.
- If b = a, it leaves the rate unchanged.
- If b > a, it raises the profit rate.
For example, let a = 20%, and increase c/v from 1 to 3:
- With b = 0%, the profit rate falls from 10% to 5%.
- With b = 10%, the profit rate falls from 15% to 12.5%.
- With b = 40%, the profit rate rises from 30% to 35%.
This simple model exposes the disputed assumption. Marx’s labour-only source of new surplus corresponds to b = 0. Machinery can still affect a in his account; what he excludes is a direct capital contribution to new value. Allowing b to be positive changes the result. Capital accumulation can lower the rate, leave it unchanged or raise it, depending on the relative contributions.
The equation does not identify a and b for us. Production is joint, and the proposed split needs an economic justification. But the question is exactly whether capital’s contribution must be excluded. Likewise, a and b can change with technology, wages and market conditions; the calculation isolates the effect of changing x while holding them fixed.
My argument is that capital accumulation alone does not establish the direction. The restriction on what can create surplus is doing essential work. If capital also creates surplus, a falling tendency needs an additional argument about how these contributions develop.
The same alternative accommodates better performance from labour. At a fixed capital ratio, an increase in a raises the rate. It accommodates improved capital performance through an increase in b. It can therefore represent gains from either source without deciding in advance that all new value must be credited to one of them.
What changes if this account of capital is right?
- Labour loses its status as the exclusive source of new value.
- Profit can no longer be identified in its entirety with unpaid labour simply from the fact that it is profit.
- Returns to invested or lent capital need not all be explained as portions of labour-generated surplus originating elsewhere.
- The particular falling-profit-rate mechanism based on replacing the sole source of new surplus loses its exclusive foundation.
These are connected consequences of one disputed premise. Exploitative conditions and unequal bargaining power can still exist. The stronger claim I am challenging is that profit necessarily comes entirely from unpaid labour.
Take financing. Marx treats interest on a business loan as a share of the profit generated through the use of that capital, ultimately explained through surplus labour. My alternative allows the supplied productive resources to contribute to the creation of the surplus itself. The payment of interest is still a transfer; the disagreement concerns what created the surplus being divided. Receiving interest is not proof of creating value, but calling it a transfer does not settle its productive origin either.
There is an obvious Marxist response: more useful output does not necessarily mean more value. Better machinery can make commodities cheaper.
I agree that producing twice as many objects does not guarantee twice the sales revenue, let alone twice the surplus. But that does not establish that machinery creates no new value. Additional labour can also increase supply and depress prices. Price effects alone do not establish the exclusive productive status of labour.
And if “value” is being used specifically for socially necessary abstract human labour, I understand that definition. My disagreement concerns whether that labour-based account adequately explains economic surplus. A definition cannot, by itself, establish that every profit must originate in unpaid labour.
There is an interesting history behind this. After working through the argument, I found Jean-Baptiste Say making a very similar point long before Marx wrote Capital. Discussing a mill, Say accepts for argument’s sake that its original value represents the labour used to build it, but says:
“the value daily produced by the mill is a new value altogether”
He explicitly separates the productive capacity of capital from the labour that originally created it.
Source: Say, A Treatise on Political Economy, Book I, chapter IV, note 64:
https://www.econlib.org/library/Say/sayT.html?chapter_num=6
Marx knew this argument. In Capital I, chapter 8, footnote 3, he discusses Roscher’s presentation of Say’s oil-mill example and replies sarcastically:
“the oil produced by the oil mill is indeed something very different from the labour expended in constructing the mill!”
His objection is that Say and Roscher confuse producing useful things with producing value. But that reply relies on the distinction under dispute. Demonstrating that oil and value are different does not establish that the machine contributes only to one of them.
Marx’s reply:
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch08.htm
For the profit-rate argument and counteracting influences, see Capital III, chapters 13 and 14:
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1894-c3/ch13.htm
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1894-c3/ch14.htm
The point I keep returning to is the difference between the cost of creating a productive capacity and what that capacity can subsequently produce.
Marx himself makes that distinction for labour-power. In Capital I, chapter 7, he explains that the cost of maintaining the worker and the value created through the worker’s activity are different magnitudes. That difference is central to his account of surplus value. I accept that a productive capacity can yield more than its reproduction costs. What requires justification is why that possibility belongs exclusively to labour.
Source:
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch07.htm
My mother gave birth to me. Food keeps me alive. Farmers, teachers, doctors and previous generations helped make my productive activity possible. Yet we still recognise me as someone capable of creating new value. We do not conclude that everything I will ever produce is merely a transfer of the value of those earlier inputs.
That analogy challenges the inference from origins. If being produced through earlier labour were enough to rule out becoming a new source of value, the same reasoning would undermine the worker’s claim too.
An organised system of flesh and blood and an organised system of nuts and bolts can both transform inputs into useful outputs. Their differences matter, but pointing to their materials or tracing their origins does not establish that only one can contribute new economic value.
Having inputs from labour does not mean something cannot become a source of new value itself. What is the economic argument that establishes that limit for machines while allowing workers to exceed it?