r/MeidasTouch • u/JimCripe • 11h ago
Legal AF Red State FIGHTS DARK MONEY in Major MOVE!!!
Montana, a state that voted for Donald Trump by nearly 20 points, has told corporations to stay out of its elections, and Attorneys Brian Kabateck and Shant Karnikian give their legal take. Initiative 194, known as the Montana Plan, passed with 65% of the vote and takes effect January 1, 2027. It bars corporations, nonprofits and other artificial entities from spending to support or oppose candidates, parties or ballot measures, while individuals and political committees are exempt. The Frontier Institute, the Montana Family Foundation and the Montana Republican State Central Committee have sued in federal court in Helena, arguing the measure violates the First Amendment. The hosts first explain Citizens United v. FEC (2010), which allows unlimited independent expenditures by corporations, and why they call it a disaster that opened the door to dark money. They then explain the theory behind the Montana Plan: because states create corporations and define their powers, the argument goes, a state can decline to give them the power to spend on elections, an idea tracing to Dartmouth College v. Woodward (1819). The hosts credit Hawaii, whose S.B. 2471, signed in May 2026, takes effect July 1, 2027, and note Reuters reports roughly 32 states are weighing similar measures. Montana's own history includes a 1912 anti-corruption law, aimed at the copper industry, which the Supreme Court struck down in 2012. Brian says he is unsure the measure survives constitutional scrutiny, expects the Roberts Court's conservative majority to resist it, and believes a constitutional amendment is the real fix; legal experts quoted by Reuters are divided. Brian's bottom line: he hopes the Montana Plan survives, but with Citizens United intact, he doesn't expect the Supreme Court to scale it back.